It's been 9 years since my last review so time for an update. With Falbo's closed on Park St, I needed to satiate my stuffed pizza urge. While Extreme doesn't match, it does a decent job satisfying my urge. Perhaps a little over sauced and the pepperoni being waxy, the crust was nice with a fresh tomato sauce. A solid option in the sea of chain pizza places in the area. Would get again. read more

Pizza Extreme - Stuffed pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

You can literally get a pizza that is 10x better and cheaper up the street at Pizza Brutta. This was maybe the lowest quality pizza I had ever had. I would have rather had a Lunchable pizza than whatever this was. It was somehow almost 20 bucks for this small ass pie. The only thing keeping this from 1 star is that the pizza box itself was sweet, and the guy who took our order was a chiller. read more

Pizza Extreme - Tf is this - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Thes service was abysmal. No one addressed me after standing inside for 11 minutes. Guy walks in from the outside and doesn't speak nor washes his hands but he grabbed the phone. Man that was on the inside taking a call when I entered - hung up and disappeared in the back. Then, reappeared from outdoors. Young guy (I'm assuming took my phone order) walked from the back. Hung behind the counter then dipped to the restroom. That's when I started calling for any assistance. Left with squat. Here's to things getting better. read more

Despite the fact that I have been a (practically) life-long Madisonian, this was my first time trying Pizza Pit Extreme. I really enjoyed the pizza! The sauce is delicious, and definitely worth writing home about. We devoured the garlic breadsticks, and I may have had to fight my son over the last one! :) We will definitely be adding Pizza Pit Extreme to our rotation. read more

11/24/2023 - My husband left a review earlier outlining how Pizza Extreme, on Monroe Street in Madison, WI, didn't have the correct hours online. It said it would be open at 11a.m., when he arrived there was a note stating that they would be open at 4pm. My husband called at 4p.m. to see if they had our order. When my husband began telling him our order, he was told by the employee that he saw our order. HOWEVER, even with the order being correct online, the guy STILL messed up our order! They pizza taste good, but it wasn't what we ordered. There was no apology, no offer to discount the pizza and no offer to deliver them. Not a great experience. It'll be a while before we by pizza from Pizza Extreme, at least the one on Monroe Street. If you want a tip, get the order correct and value your customers time and money. read more

11/24/2023 - Today is my birthday, and my husband ordered two of my favorite pizzas for us all to eat. The website said the Pizza Extreme on Monroes Street in Madison would be open at 11:00 a.m. My husband placed the order online and it confirmed that the order would be ready at 11:33. He drove from the Warner Park area to Monroe Street only to find out that they would not open until 4p.m. This information should have been listed online. Other restaurants either indicate online that their hours are different (not a note on the door, wasting peoples time and gas), or disable their online ordering until the establishment is open for business. We LOVE the taste of the pizza, but were not pleased with having to make ANOTHER trip after they open at 4p.m. We would cancel the pizzas, but there's no way to do that online. They SHOULD deliver our pizza to us at 4p.m. today. Very annoyed. read more

The Chicago Deep Dish is THE BEST!!! There is no other pizza like it In Wisconsin. The cheese, the sauce, the crust...... So good.

I ordered this for delivery. I really wanted a gyro pizza. I suppose if you were really hungry, you could eat this. It's pretty meh. Especially when you have Glass Nickel, Ian's, etc. etc. available to you. The crust was undercooked, the toppings were sparse, and it was lukewarm upon delivery. Back to Glass Nickel. I guess I'll have to make my own gyro pizza. read more

Was craving for a Pizza Pit pizza. Guy said 45-1 hour for delivery. It was terrible. Hardly any beef, more mushroom than anything! Tasted like cardboard , hardly any good Wisconsin cheese. Pizza was cold after waiting 50 minutes. Never this place again! Sure wasn't a Pizza Pit pizza!! read more

I had been raving about the deep dish pizza, when we decided to order some while watching the Packer Game. WHAT A MISTAKE! Pizza came 45 minutes later but was NOT the deep dish variety that we had ordered/paid for. I called the store and they promised to deliver the proper order ASAP. 75 minutes later I call the store AGAIN only to be told whoever I spoke with never initiated the "reorder" - we were sitting, waiting for NOTHING!! 3 HOURS LATER we are STILL WAITING! read more

The newest addition to Pizza EXTREME (it's not really all-caps like that--I just like the emphasis) opened about a week ago on Monroe Street, just across from the stadium. I stopped in for a slice while I was running errands and wanted to check out their Grand Opening specials. Well, no specials to be found, at least not according to the counter help. EXTREME Pizza Dude was friendly, however, and told me about their regular lunch specials--for $4.99 you can get two slices and a soda, a sandwich + chips + soda, a small house salad + a slice + soda, etc. I just went with a standard slice to go and ordered the Veggie. It was a decent, thin crust pizza. Not greasy but, sadly, not warm either. I sat outside in the sunshine (they've got about four outdoor tables with umbrellas) hoping that might heat things up a bit. I'll check back again in a month or so when they've settled in to their new EXTREME digs and see how EXTREME things are going! read more

See all

This spot was super busy tonight so our food was late, But I will have to say, when we called to check what was going on, the person that answered was very nice about it and helped resolve the situation very quickly. It was about 2 hours before we got our food and it still was hot when the driver got here, It was very obvious the driver was working his butt off because he was very apologetic and was extremely kind. When we tried the pizza, Let me tell you.. it was WORTH the 2 hours. Even while being crammed with orders, they still followed my special instructions (well done). whoever made that pizza, made it with love cause it was BUSSIN. It was the best pizza i've had from a chain pizza place. Will definitely be ordering again, but for pickup next time! Thank you to the workers on (05/30/21). We can tell you were working extra hard! read more

Not a fancy spot. Kind of small with six or seven tables. I ordered a small pizza to carry out. I was quoted a twenty minute period for cooking. I arrived after 15 minutes as I was driving when I called the order in. I paid and the pizza was out within minutes. Pizza was hot and cooked well. I have not been impressed with the delivery service in the past. But I would order/pick up again. read more

The crust is absolutely amazing. I would highly recommend getting the pepperoni I love the way that it curls up and it tastes with a light crisp as well. We also tried the chicken wings and they were fantastic. Definitely going to go back again. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful as well. read more

A few weeks ago, I ordered delivery from a different Pizza Pit further west, a mega pepperoni, and it was perhaps the best delivery pizza I've ever had -- hot, fresh, doughy, crispy. With this in mind, I recently placed a large order for a party from this Pizza Pit on Monroe, which was the closest one to our venue. Sadly, the pizzas came lukewarm and left much to be desired. This may have been because the delivery person couldn't figure out how to walk into the building and so there was about a 10-15 minute delay from the time he first called our phone to the time we received our pizzas. However, the taco pizza looked nothing like the menu picture, bright with toppings. Instead, it was pieces of chicken, cheese, and slightly soggy tortilla chips. The buffalo chicken pizza was also unimpressive, more cheese and chicken, and the macaroni pizza was slightly dry, leaving me longing for Ian's instead. I couldn't bring myself to try the fourth pizza. If I find myself having to order from here again, I guess I'd stick with the basics like pepperoni, and pick it up myself if possible. While ordering, customer service on the phone was great, and they were willing to deliver slightly outside of their zone for such a large order. Ragret. I should have taken that as a hint to go elsewhere. Unfortunately, the helpful and polite phone service just can't cover the price of a subpar food experience for our large group. read more

Possibly the best pizza in town, and they deliver. Lots of other stuff on the menu too. Pizza is plentiful in college towns (Gumby's, Papa John's, etc.), but good pizza is a rarity. read more

Pizza Extreme - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

PIZZA EXTREME has RC Cola. PIZZA EXTREME does not have recycling bins. read more

My friends and I recently discovered pizza pit extreme during the pandemic. I highly recommend it. Prices are reasonable, delivery is super reliable and fast, pizza ingredients are fresh and pizza taste and quality are great!! read more

So, we've ordered a few times from this location. Not really great overall but edible. This last time however was just terrible. As the picture "This is what you can expect" shows it was as if someone spilled a pot of grease all over the pizza and breadsticks. Both were soggy beyond any excuse. The name Pizza Pit used to mean something 30 years ago. Now it's just a name people use to brand what loosely passes for pizza. Not sure anywhere in this town has good pizza anymore, but I can say don't order from this location. Unless you enjoy a pizza that looks like it should have been in National Lampoons Vacation. "The dog pi$$ed on the picnic basket.." read more

Pizza Extreme - This is what you can expect. Run. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

My fiance and I order from Pizza Extreme fairly frequently. They always deliver in a timely fashion, the cheese is amazing, and they have RC Cola! One time, after a night of drinking, my fiance called and ordered "two of the biggest pizzas they have" for delivery. Well, twenty minutes and fifty dollars later, we had two of the biggest pizzas I have ever seen sitting in my kitchen. We were eating pizza for days. And it was delicious. read more

Great environment, great food. The bartender Travis was very helpful and easy to carry an conversation with. Will be coming back 10/10.

For a Chicago pizza fix, Pizza Pit is an OK cure. Decent crust, plenty of toppings, and a very sweet sauce to balance the saltiness of the pepperoni, sausage, and cheese. The prices are very reasonable for deep-dish pizza, and the delivery fee is just $1. I opted for the sausage and pepperoni small deep dish-- it ran me $13, which I thought was pretty reasonable. Lots of sausage and pepperoni, as well as sauce (I requested extra), though I felt that the amount of cheese was somewhat lacking for a deep dish pie. Not the best I've had, but it'll do in Madison when I want to meet a craving for Chicago-style deep dish. read more

Location is everything. Located on my usual stumble home, Pizza Extreme is quickly becoming my 3 AM stop of choice. Bring a couple of friends, randomly select 5 items (ranging from chicken drummies to pizza of decent quality), and head home to play some Tekken. If you're a couple 7&7's into your night, you will not be disappointed. read more

Pizza Pit feels like a whole new restaurant. A huge revamp to the place and brought a great energy to the entire restaurant. Travis Meyer, the General Manager, took care of us all night and we all had a great time. Certainly a great place for food and drink. Would definitely go again and would definitely recommend checking out read more

With all the talk of Rocky's, Toppers and Ian's, this place has in my opinion the best pizza... I've not tried their regular pizza, but their Chicago stuffed style is the best I've had in Madison. And their sandwiches are very good as well. They have a fantastic selection for a pizza delivery place, and they deliver quickly. read more

Really nice gyro. Soft, fresh pita bread, warmed and nicely browned. Spicy and plentiful meat. Tangy yogurt sauce and quick service. Great, quick and inexpensive late night snack. So good I'd return for lunch. At a place clearly in business for its' pizza prowess, don't overlook the fantastic gyro. read more

This is by far one of my favorite places to eat in, great staff and don't even get me started with the food.

Most certainly earned the "Pit" in their name. Won't order from here again! I used to like Pizza Extreme, but that was before I left for NJ. They had great sauce, quality ingredients and great consistency of product. No longer. Placed order on a Thursday night during a non-football time and no significant events. (Which might reasonably delay delivery.) Positives: 1. The cheese/Extreme pizza met with favorable remarks. 2. They took off the cost of a pizza we neither ordered nor desired. 3. They did call to ask us if we still wanted the pizza after 2 hours of waiting. Negatives: 1. 2.5 hours before pizza arrived. We were told 45 min to 1 hour. 2. Charged us for a pizza we did not order nor want. 3. One of the two pizzas we ordered was still doughy. About 1/3 of this pizza stuck to the box. 4. Pizza arrived warm, but not hot. Other Thoughts: In my home area in NJ, I have ordered pizza from a little over a half dozen different businesses. None have delivered an undercooked pizza, and the worst of the pizzas I have had were significantly superior in taste to the pizza here. That two of my positive remarks are backhanded compliments, I really have very little respect for what this small franchise has done since I left Madison. read more

UPDATE: And they delivered 14" pizzas, ugh. I paid for 16" pizzas. I shouldn't have to argue with the manager for 10 mins to get the pizza I ordered for the price I paid. I didn't order one 1 topping pizza & one 2 topping pizza, I ordered the XL two topping pizza twins. All you have to do is fix it. Not spend 10 minutes telling me I'm wrong. Why would I order pizza I didn't intend to. I'll start off with, this is cheap pizza. Ordering the "pizza twins" 2 16" 2 topping pizza's for $24.99, $25.99 at some locations, you shouldn't be expecting gourmet pizza. I like Pizza Pit pizza, the sauce is good, not too sweet, they have crispy thin crust, and good portions on the pizzas but, they have the worst coupon system on the planet! The coupons & deals, like "pizza twins" all come out on the same flyers & magazines. You basically have to call each store to see if they offer that particular coupon, like BOGO13 which only 2 out of the 6 stores apparently offer it, yet all within 10 mils of each other. Then there are different "brands" like pit or extreme, so they offer different foods & specialty pizzas at each brand, like the "5 Cheese". Some coupons are good for some stores in town but not others, Some work online or over the phone, some are good for pickup or delivery only. or I could buy cheap $3 frozen pizza, yech. They used to have the best ribs, of course they stopped serving them. The wings are good, too many sauces to decide on. The gyros are ok. But again, unless you know what store you are ordering from, ALL THE SAME COMPANY, you can only get some things at some locations for some prices, worst uniformity or continuity of any franchise ever. read more

Just had the "new" extreme pizza (Monroe st) They've destroyed what used to be the best pizza in town. It doesn't even compare to a Dominos pizza now. Fake crust, fake cheese, fake sausage... etc.. Really bad. Will never buy another. Very sad... (look at the dates of the other reviews...) read more

This is our usual go-to for delivery. Employees have always been good to us, even adding coupons we didn't know existed when we call in our order. Delivery is always fast, and the pizza is good. Both their hand-tossed and Chicago-style pizza get high marks, and they're great reheated. read more

While visiting Madison for a few days we decided to order pizza. This was tricky because most all the pizza places near us had bad reviews. So we picked PPE...we only had interaction with one of the employees and he was nice. The actual restaurant and dining area itself clearly needs an update/overhaul. Okay, now let's talk pizza.... We ordered the special which consisted of 2 medium pizzas with 2 toppings great deal but for what we saved in costs the Pizza Pit did not make up for in flavor and quality. The overuse of the oil made the pizza super greasy and therefor the crust was soggy and limp. I like to be able to taste the crust otherwise I should just put pizza toppings on bread. We also ordered a side of garlic breadsticks and were pleased that those weren't too greasy. I don't mind the use of oil when making pizza crust but I do mind spending money on something that I could have made myself that won't clog my arteries (note to self). Actual order date 8/15/14 read more

I originally had a negative review based on the collective experience we'd had for many orders; the one prior to this, I removed after doing all the legwork to get a hold of the actual owner, despite his "manager's" outrageous behavior (I won't detail it again - suffice it to say it involved personal insults and a host of other crap, along with refusing to give me any way to get in touch with the owner). Only after seeing my review did the owner contact me. He assured me we'd have no more hiccups, and in good faith, we believed him. Ordered a couple nights ago, through grubhub. Would think it wasn't a toughie, a medium one-topping pizza, and an extra-large two topping pizza. Well - yep, it was, as usual, an apparent toughie. After over an hour, two....medium pizzas arrived, though we'd paid for one medium and one extra large. This happens all the time with these people, and I regret we gave them another shot. The original reasoning given was that the two medium pizza order was what they got from Grubhub, and so they can't help the error. As it turns out, em, yep, it was at the store end - on consulting THEIR OWN TICKET it said the right order. Screwed up order. Again. And again. And....well, yeah. I want to be clear, the driver wasn't at fault and he was a great guy. It was at the store level. Simply, they don't have their ^%$# together. At all. Additionally, and this is a warning on Grubhub - but though grubhub says they accept Paypal, they do NOT accept PP credit, and this policy isn't mentioned anywhere on the site. Though this is our default payment method, today we were surprised to find out it's coming from our checking account. This wasn't planned for, and it is going to screw us up with fees. Thanks so much. read more

I ordered delivery from here for a lot of people (4 pies). The service was good (fast and the pizzas were really hot when they got to us), and the price was low. The pizzas were not that great though. I'd order from here again for a big group, but if I'm just getting one pie, I'd go somewhere else. read more

I was over charged for pizza by $7 and management was terribly rude and refused to correct the mistake. The sad thing was that this was my first time trying this place and the pizza wasn't even good. Too many good restaurants in Madison to waste your time or money here. read more

Being the best pizza in Oregon is about the same prestige as being the best hockey player in Uganda, you don't get alot of bragging rights. The pizza and other menu items are decent , service good and the delivery is fast. read more

Worst customer service experience I've ever had with a restaurant. I called in, asked the guy about a coupon where you get two pizzas. It didn't work for the specialty pizzas so I ordered one pizza. The guy ordered me two pizzas. He didn't give me the total until after he ran my card so I got charged nearly $50 for what I thought was one pizza. I asked why it was so much and he repeated my order to me. And then he said it was too late, put me on hold, and five minutes later someone got on the phone and asked to take my order. And when I told him what had happened he said my pizzas were on the way and hung up. Ten minutes later another person called, said my pizza would be free and said my card would get refunded. It's been three weeks and there's been no refund. I've followed up on it five times. Never again. read more

Ok, maybe this isn't the best pizza. The one pie I had tried was the sausage mushroom melt, which was always delish! I tried another combination last time I ordered and it was cardboard-y and not so good. Meh. read more

The pizza is pretty good. It is one of my favorite places to order from because they usually have a $15 pizza/wings combo.

OK, I have been a fan of Pizza Pit since one of my first trips to Madison soon after getting my driver's license. Back then Pizza Pit was a mini-chain around Madison. Most are now owned by individuals. Oregon's Pizza Pit is one of those individually owned and luckily use the Pizza Pit formula. I just like their crust and sauce. The crust is thin, but not too thin and the sauce has that rich taste that I like for Pizza. A good mix of ingredients on the pizza. Their service is good. read more