Cancel

Open app

Search

Pizza Extreme

3.0 (51 reviews)
Closed 11:00 am - 2:00 pm

Order Pizza Extreme Takeout or Delivery

Pizza Extreme Photos

Business Info

PIZZA EXTREME ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Happy hour specials
Outdoor seating
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Pizza Extreme

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Veggie EXTREME!
Stina T.

The newest addition to Pizza EXTREME (it's not really all-caps like that--I just like the emphasis) opened about a week ago on Monroe Street, just across from the stadium. I stopped in for a slice while I was running errands and wanted to check out their Grand Opening specials. Well, no specials to be found, at least not according to the counter help. EXTREME Pizza Dude was friendly, however, and told me about their regular lunch specials--for $4.99 you can get two slices and a soda, a sandwich + chips + soda, a small house salad + a slice + soda, etc. I just went with a standard slice to go and ordered the Veggie. It was a decent, thin crust pizza. Not greasy but, sadly, not warm either. I sat outside in the sunshine (they've got about four outdoor tables with umbrellas) hoping that might heat things up a bit. I'll check back again in a month or so when they've settled in to their new EXTREME digs and see how EXTREME things are going!

Rick H.

Possibly the best pizza in town, and they deliver. Lots of other stuff on the menu too. Pizza is plentiful in college towns (Gumby's, Papa John's, etc.), but good pizza is a rarity.

This is what you can expect.  Run.

See all

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

17 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of E. L.
0
29
0

15 years ago

Not a fan. Sorry. Greasy and flavorless. We fought over who had to take the leftovers... I'm sure they got thrown out. No thanks.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Pizza Extreme

Review Highlights - Pizza Extreme

Despite the fact that I have been a (practically) life-long Madisonian, this was my first time trying Pizza Pit Extreme.

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 3,806 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Wings Over - Madison - Tots

Wings Over - Madison

3.5(179 reviews)
1.2 miRegent
$

First, the good news: The food is great…read more However, I have been a customer of Wings Over Madison for about eight years, and over that time, the quality of service has steadily declined, particularly delivery, and the past two years have been especially bad. Deliveries have arrived over an hour late, orders have been deleted without notification, and I have had to drive to the store myself to resolve issues with delivery orders. These problems are recurring and point to breakdowns in the delivery process, not one-off mistakes. After last night's situation, I will no longer order delivery from this location. The current delivery operation is unreliable, and after years of patience, I am done rolling the dice.

I'm usually more of a Wing Stop guy but today I felt like giving this place a shot because I've…read moreheard it referenced positively in the past. I can't tell you how their food is. Before I could order while I was looking at their menu a guy in the back was yell something. Couldn't understand it and it didn't seem directed at me because he was in the back and i was at the counter. He pokes his head through the window to make eye contact with me and yells "IS YOU PICKING UP?" I said no and he said "ALRIGHT THEN YOU CAN ORDER RIGHT THERE" I turned and left then went to Q Doba next door. They have free gauc. And nobody yelled at me. Wing Stop it is next time.

Photos
Wings Over - Madison - Golden BBQ Wings

Golden BBQ Wings

Wings Over - Madison - Tots

Tots

Wings Over - Madison - Entrance

See all

Entrance

The Bar

The Bar

4.4(16 reviews)
1.5 miCapitol
$$

As someone also pointed out the huge plus to this hotel located place is it being competitive with…read moretheir prices when compared to other restaurants in the area. So if you are staying at the hotel you don't have to head outside if you wish for a drink or tavern food fare. It's right there and not costing the usual $5-$10 more for food per item. The menu is a little all over the map. It's Wisconsin so I get the commitment to cheese offerings but an Asian / American / cheese forward fusion seems a 'choice'. Someone looking for traditional will probably want to stick to the turkey sandwich or burger. I did very much enjoy the dumplings but just know it's 15 min to make. For me that was fine. I wasn't in a hurry. The service was great. Both bartenders work the tables also so just be patient with them if they are busy. When it's medium filled or empty the place is good for conversation. If the tables are all full be aware it will be loud as the space isn't very big. And if the hotel is hosting an event like a conference or wedding it's a bit of a zoo. Also note the room service menu matches what they serve.

Incredible little bar that exceeds all hotel bar expectations. Very reasonably priced for a hotel -…read more$2 PBRs! Can't complain about the drinks - highly recommend the Sconnie Old Fashioned! The drinks are great but the food stole the show. Everything we got was amazing, especially the spinach and artichoke dip. I don't say this lightly, but it is the best spinach and artichoke dip I have ever had! The staff was nice and attentive. Highly recommend making a visit, even if you aren't staying in the hotel!

Photos
The Bar
The Bar
The Bar

See all

Licari's Bar and Grill - Pull tab popper

Licari's Bar and Grill

4.1(68 reviews)
2.2 mi
$

So good and such great service we came back a second night!! Popped in on a super busy Sunday and…read morewere greeted by Alex with an acknowledgment that I see you and I will be with you in a minute or two. Dropped menus right away and let us know the wait on food. We were committed so we stuck it out and so glad we did!!! (Wait time was way less than anticipated!!) Lydia rocked the grill and I had one of the best shrimp salads and the husband is still raving about the grilled hotdog sandwich!! They were both getting their asses handed to them but they greeted every customer immediately, never complained and smiling. Being from the service industry to see those two work together was awesome and so was the food. Not your classic bar food but elevated and delicious. Highly recommend for the service, atmosphere, hospitality and delicious food!!!

I picked this dive bar thinking we'd have a really nice burger…read more Heard it won burger of the week last year. I hate to say it but we were totally disappointed. Sat outside and it took awhile to be waited on. The waiter said to another table it was his first day on job. Well I'm very okay with new people learning but this took it to another level. Very very inexperienced to say the least or they gave him no training. Said it would be 30 minutes for food if we ordered; okay fine! Over 1 hour later we still had no food. He was very forgetful, brought wrong drinks, was told to turn umbrellas down. He didn't know how to turn the handle to lose it, I helped him with that. Said he'd put brewer game on tv - not. Burger of the week was special 65rrr. So t thought I'd try it; finally when we were served our food by the cook herself ( who god bless her ) tired her best to make up for the mess. The burger had fried onions, bacon ( lots of bacon ) good bacon I must say. The burger was huge 1/3 lb they say but all the flavors blended into one so so burger. My wife's cheeseburger was better. They wanted you to vote for the 65rr for burger of the week. I just couldn't. I'm pretty forgiving but this was probably the worst diner/pub I've been to and I've been at a lot!

Photos
Licari's Bar and Grill - Bar and food prep

Bar and food prep

Licari's Bar and Grill
Licari's Bar and Grill

See all

Pizza Ranch - The great dessert pizza

Pizza Ranch

3.1(52 reviews)
7.3 mi
$$

Best service I had with pizza ranch and best work I ever run into Melinda matrick, very helpful and…read moreis very easy talking too and funny Never thought there is chill people like her , she is so dope people definitely need a Melina in there life fr

*HEALTH DEPARTMENT NEEDED*…read more MAtthew Reason, the man in charge of this place has an accountability problem. your kids threw up after eating warm ranch? He will claim not their fault. Serving people old food because someone in the back was too lazy. health department is desperately needed, not company inspectors. I talked with some of the workers who are disabled and they are getting bullied by their bosses. Telling a disabled person to do something that's past their limits or capabilities or claiming they are faking their disability. I try the sun Prairie location. Robert Figueroa, some kind of magician, has no issues opening a gas powered wallet torch right next to the buffet, leaving harsh fumes lingering around the food. He obviously doesn't know what he's doing. Both locations paint is peeling everywhere, carpet has disgusting stains, plates and silverware have stains, chairs and tables are never fully clean, no funzone, buffet is always empty or old and they're charging almost 20$ per person to eat. Kids over the age of 12 are full priced. The treachery here is CRAZY. Enforcements need to be called.

Photos
Pizza Ranch - Drinks, so many varieties. All self serve.

Drinks, so many varieties. All self serve.

Pizza Ranch - Pizza, they have tons of crust styles. And the chicken. Which was great.

Pizza, they have tons of crust styles. And the chicken. Which was great.

Pizza Ranch - Salad bar

See all

Salad bar

Pizza Extreme - pizza - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...