There are lots of weird reviews for Spinners on here- I wouldn't base your decision on whether to eat here or not on them. No problems any time I have gotten pizza from here (ordered over the phone for pickup). It's always super solid and I think their thin crust is the best in town. Sauce is up there too (Yeti's sauce lowkey might be better but Spinners has the better crust and sauce/topping ratio imo). Not a place really to sit and eat, but it's a small town pizza place- what do you expect lol. I get the thin crust Skinny Veggie with red sauce and it's sooo good. Mac and cheese is also pretty good. I have always wanted to try the dessert pizzas (how fun?!) but haven't gotten the chance. Their signature pizza menu is huge and they've got pastas and other side items too. Yes it's usually kids working but you don't have to be a seasoned professional to make a tasty pizza. read more

Best breadsticks ever! Soft, buttery with Parmesan cheese sprinkles. Take out, deliver or dine-in. Ice cream too! Very friend staff. read more

Spinners Pizza - Breadsticks! - Pizza Near Me - Stoughton, Wisconsin

Thin crust held together good and nice crispy crust. Fresh topping. Some family member picked it up so unsure of the service. If in Stoughton I will get some hot and fresh. read more

Spinners Pizza - Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Stoughton, Wisconsin

Don't trust their online ordering pricing. In placed an order online and paid via Apple Pay. Showed up to get my food and told I owe another $3+ before I could get my food. The good old shakedown to grift for more money OR their web ordering sucks. Either way not my issue but I still had to pay for it read more

This pizza was sooo good, I would give it a 10+ I'm visiting from Atlanta and the pizza was delivered on time and hot. read more

Who doesn't love a good local pizza? I ate the Canadian Bacon and Pineapple pizza, which is a tried and true classic. My folks are a big fan of the chicken taco pizza, but wish it came with sour cream packets too. They also have some frozen yogurt, which wasn't too bad, but extremely expensive for what you get. The good part is that they offer military/veteran discounts, as well as police/first responder discounts. Definitely recommend bringing a coupon if you have one, they are quite pricey. read more

See all

Wednesday's are mac n cheese slice day and they will absolutely scam you out of your money by giving you the smallest slices possible. Instead go to Yeti's or Pizza pit for way better quality and prices. read more

Our new fave for variety, great pieces, quality ingredients, friendly service and fast delivery!!!! Wonderfully crusted, sauced, baked and piping hot delivered pizzas!!! There were so many good combinations and specialty pizzas that we couldn't try them all! We loved their gluten free crust and spicy sauces the most, but my kids are also a fan of their pepperoni (and they can be picky). We ordered 6 large/family sized pizzas around dinner time, on a Sunday evening, and expected out wait to be well over 1 hour, but they delivered (albeit nearby) within 40 minutes! We will DEFINITELY be repeat customers, and recommend others, to this pizza palace! read more

Pizza is fine. Sorta like a local Papa John's, so nothing to really brag about, but it gets the job done. Delivery can take a while, so you're better off going to pick it up if you can. They definitely have an America, F*ck Yeah! vibe in the store. I like me some America - don't get me wrong - but I don't need to get hit with it when I just want a thin crust sausage and pepperoni. I've been going to Luca's or Yeti's instead for better pizza and less nationalism. Both are also locally owned, so if you want to support local they fit the bill as well. I hope I don't end up on their watch list because of this review. read more

In and out of town for 30 years and there has never been a better Pizza Joint when it comes to unique selection, quality, and price! - Best and cheapest specialty pizzas in the area(TOPPLES ANY local Mac N Cheese style Pie) - Best Desert Pizzas around - Greatest Wings in town, fresh and VERY affordable($1) a wing. - Quality Crust -Huge Menu and very friendly staff. - Quick delivery in town Need I express more facts..? Their Taco Pizza slams, the best Taco Bell item in taste and quantity. My ONLY suggestions, start doing stuffed pies, and stuffed crust. Both options offered in specialty menu options also. BANG. COME HERE TODAY!! read more

I ordered a Debris Pizza a long with a straight mushroom. Pizza. I picked up the pizzas and brought them home to find out the Debris was a Deluxe pizza. I called to complain and was told I was wrong even though I heard my wife say Debris with extra cheese.the lady was kinda rude and said it was my wife's fault cus she read the order back and my wife didn't catch the error from her and it a as all our fault. We have gone there atleast 3 times a month and never had any problems before. I was hoping they would make things right especially when I came to get the pizza I said I had a Debris and a Mushroom pizza to pick up. They didn't say anything g when the handed me the pizzas. So much for them checking the order before handing the out.since they were rude and blamed us, we will no longer be eating at that Spinners again.we are VERY VERY DISSAPOINTED!!!!!! read more

Great hand tossed pizza is the best!! Only downside is that they have limited delivery service and sometimes they are not able to deliver outside of Stoughton city limits when they are busy or have limited drivers read more

Quick. Simple. Solid Service. Would not recommend eating in, perfect for take out. Only current issue is all the construction around the place. Makes it real tricky to get to door. read more

We just moved to Stoughton and were told that Spinners had some of the best pizza in town, so of course we tried it out one of our first nights here! We come from a military family, so a huge bonus to me was that they are so veteran oriented. red, White & Blue decor, tips go to a veterans organization, employee shirts say "freedom isn't free," and they offer a veterans discount! They not only have pizza, but they offer a frozen yogurt station too! The great thing about that is they charge for the size of your cup and NOT the weight of it. Their pizzas may seem expensive, but completely worth it for what you get. We got the 10" garlic cheese bread and it was the best we've ever had! It also fed four people comfortably. We tried the hand tossed and the thin crust on our pizzas and both were to die for. Their sausage is top notch, and I am really picky on the sausage that goes on my pizza. They were super fast at getting the piZzas out even though they said 35 minutes. They also offer 10 ish dessert pizza options! We tried the cinnamon breadsticks with glaze, those were delicious and you a ton for 6.99! We are regulars now. read more

Spinners is super! We have been ordering from them for about a year or so. Outstanding menu, with lots of unique and interesting pizzas to try. The "deluxe" is our favorite and the crew is consistently fast and skilled at cooking a perfect pizza. I think their pizzas are some of the best in the Madison area! Great food, good prices, nice folks! Thanks, Spinners! read more

This is by far my favorite pizza in the Madison area. Pizza sauce is what will make or break a pizza and there's is great. Toppings are generous and the price is good too. Try their garlic break sticks!! So many of them and they have a great flavor. We love Spinners! Bonus, they're local! They offer military discounts and also have frozen yogurt read more

Delicious food and fast delivery! They always deliver to our camper and I really appreciate it!

First time for trying Spinners, and most certainly won't be the last. We had a deluxe hand tossed pizza and a chef salad to share. Both were great, but the crazy fast delivery to Oregon was outstanding. 36 minutes from time of order to delivery at our front door on Eisenhower St., simply Amazing!! Pizza washreat and hot out of the box. Awesome job Spinners! read more

Spinners Pizza - Deluxe hand tossed pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stoughton, Wisconsin

See all

Good flavor, great sausage, tough crust. Too tough. Maybe I should say : "well done "

Pizza was great! Delivery was quick and correct, staff was friendly. Highly recommend!

Great pizza and awesome service! We always get delivery and their drivers are always prompt, courteous, and show up with a smile on their face. Not over priced at all. We order often and it would be awesome if we could order online. Hint hint. read more

Huge fan. Very cheesy and delicious. Highly recommended. Try the Chicken Bacon Ranch. read more

Spinners Pizza - 16" Chicken Bacon Ranch - Pizza Near Me - Stoughton, Wisconsin

Got pizza and wings. Very mediocre and expensive for what it is. Wings barely had any sauce. Pizza had no flavor. Will not be getting this again. read more

Pizza is good but don't get your hopes up when you decide to order delivery. Told one night that they wouldn't deliver because it was too far but only because they had a driver who didn't want to drive that far and our address wasn't outside the delivery area. Disappointing customer service and I will stick with a local that provides better customer service. read more

Pizza ready on time. Just wanted some indication they appreciated my business. Pizza fine but there are other pizza places in town. Picked up 4 Fri. Dec. 12/28 so not busy? Businesses have to set themselves apart. read more

I have been a customer for over 1 year or more. They have messed up my order about 2 times in the past. Today it happened again, I called to explain that they shorted me 4 wings on a 10 piece order. I asked if next time I order to add them at that time. I received a call back from one of the several 16 year olds he has working there. I was told I am on their "Watch List". My mind was blown! I called back to speak with the owner Tim. He was so arrogant he told me that there is NO WAY they would missed 4 WINGS 1 or 2 sure but 4! NO WAY He didnt believe me. If you need to put people on a watch list because you get so many complaints about orders being wrong....I wonder who is really wrong?? The food was great, but Tim needs to learn how to run a business with customers in mind. I hope it was worth losing a customer over 4 wings that probably at cost are worth$1.00! Buyer beware!! If they mess up on your order they put you on a "Watch list" pathetic way to operate a business! read more

If you want really good pizza with some pizzazz then Spinners is the place to go. I've had about four different pizzas and various chicken wings and have not been disappointed. I also love the fact that they have the credit card readers with the delivery person so you don't have to read your card information over the phone. read more

Love the pizza and breadsticks. We come from another town and do carry out. It's with the 10 minute drive.

We've had delivery twice and I'm a fan! The pizza is really pretty good and it's not greasy like some local pizzerias (ahem, Glass Nickel). The cheese bread is also really good. We also ordered spaghetti which was ho-hum, but I asked them to add meatballs to it and they did so that was a plus. Delivery drivers are really nice and I like that they carry a phone with a credit card swipe on it so I don't have to give out our card # over the phone. We'll definitely order again! read more

Love the garlic breadsticks! I could just sit and eat these for dinner. Each time I go in the staff are so nice. And the delivery drivers are great too! We usually get a deluxe pizza on thin crust. Just delicious. Tastes like it's made with quality ingredients. Great pizza addition to Stoughton. Also love that vets get a discount and tips go to charity. Being able to give back while eating delicious pizza when I'm too pooped to cook... it's a win win!!! read more

Pizza is okay....certainly not the worst in the world, but it is NOT worth anywhere near the price they charge. The kids in the kitchen were horsing around rather wait on the person who walked to the register. On top of it, owners are right-wingers...I think the decor is supposed to be patriotic (to give them the benifit of the doubt)...but it comes off as vapid and jingonistic. There are better, nicer places. read more

We love Spinners and since we tried it for the first time we haven't gone anywhere else. We've had delivery, carryout and eaten in the restaurant numerous times. Never a disappointment, always hot and delicious. service always good. They have always accommodated any special requests we've had without question, AND.....the breadsticks are to die for!! Most of the time we get so full on the breadsticks that the rest of the pizza becomes snacking for later or a second meal. So glad Spinners is in Stoughton so we don't have to drive to Madison for pizza that we LOVE. read more

I decided to give Spinners a try today. I ordered carry out because I wanted to see the place for myself first. The restaurant is very clean, has two really nice TVs, and is decorated in a patriotic theme. They offer a 15% discount to veterans, you just need to dig out your old ID. My wife and I both liked the overall flavors of the pizza. I particularly liked the sauce. We both felt the pizza should have been cooked a couple of minutes longer. It was done, but it was just barely done and that's the reason for 4 stars vs 5. I will definitely be ordering from Spinners again, I will just ask for my pizza to be a little more crispy. read more

was ok, was not overly impressed. just like a reg pizza. not sure if i would buy again ...

I couldn't tell you if the food was good or not because the family sized spaghetti that I ordered never came. Instead, almost an hour later (the girl on the phone originally told me 25 minutes) a family sized lasagne was delivered, and fyi- when you order for delivery if you pay by credit/debit card and your food is late AND WRONG, their system will even FORCE YOU TO TIP.So I called and was told I would get a refund for the lasagne I was charged for since it was wrong and then a few minutes later a manager called and said "our system doesn't work like that but we are going to put a credit on the books for you for a free spaghetti" and mind you, the spaghetti is almost $10 less than the lasagne so I'm glad THEY were getting a good deal. Because it was their mistake I've already filed a claim with my credit card to get refunded the difference since "their system doesn't work that way". Thinking it's ok to charge someone for the wrong, more expensive food and then not refund them the same way they paid, shame on them to think it's ok to do that to customers. It truly is disgusting when a business operates more to make a dollar anyway they can then to make their customers happy. read more