Amazing pizza! Every time I stop at Ians I get the macaroni and cheese pizza which never disappoints it is the prefect balance of creamy, salty and cheesy. The tomato basil was honestly better than I expected and a nice 2nd piece after the heavier mac & cheese. The location was great with lots of indoor and outdoor seating along with a few other shop and places to explore inside. One BIG drawback for us is that there is no available vegan options for a single slice - you need to order a whole pizza :( read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Garver Feed Mill - Mac & Cheese Pizza & Tomato Post Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

As someone thinking of moving to Madison, this microcosm of the town may have solidified my choice! A giant hall with Ian's pizza as the centerpiece for us all to partake in communion of cheese in pie form. The pizza: sometimes crazy pizza styles like ravioli, potato, or mac n cheese can be seen as gimmicks- not the case here. Each ingredient gets attention and is not simply dropped onto a pizza. The sauce changes accordingly. Even the marinara for the ravioli pizza tasted a little more hearty than the classic pepperoni sauce. The sauce and crust alone for the mac n cheese pizza was buttery and rich. ALL THIS FOR $5??(plus 50 cents). Everyone on staff was kind/welcoming and quick getting all of the orders. Seating was plentiful and eating amongst locals, you will feel the chill vibes emanate. Nobody was loud or boisterous, just enjoying their slice and soda. Do yourself a favor and visit this feed mill with many other delights (ice cream, beer, board games, coffee) to explore! Only note to ownership: writing out the different styles on the pizza partition glass could help people when selecting and save staff from being asked 'which one is that?' all day. read more

See all

Wow, what a cool Ian's pizza location! This mini food hall is really neat inside, they also have two large outside areas when it's nice. We ordered pizza from this location to-go and it was really easy to pick it up. I like Ian's because they have vegan options (I'm not vegan but I can't eat dairy). Their vegan cheese is the best I've had at almost any pizza place. I absolutely love their "vegan all the veg" pizza, which has a TON of vegetables on it. You can also get vegan cheese with meat; we also got a pepperoni with vegan cheese too. Our order was ready when promised and it was easy to park and run in. I would definitely eat here too; there's a fun bar, a beer wall, and ice cream too! read more

Yummy pizza! Only place I order from. Delivery always on time. Like being able to track my order.

Good pizza! Unique flavors. Service was a little slow given that it was always cooked but I prefer that to cold pizza. The location was fun and energetic too. Would stop again read more

See all

MAGNIFICENT experience! So i'm from italy.. and i'm italian 100%, just visiting the states and i can confidently say this pizza was wow. Not italian at all ok but so so so good in its own way. Briar helped me w the flavors and his endless patience, he deserves a raise y'all!! Anyway pretty much anyone here is super nice, which makes the experience even better. Love love love this pizza, even if it's really different from italy.. actually i think the dough is lighted and easier to digest.. italy don't ban me back home. Ian's pizza sponsor me read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Garver Feed Mill - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

This is one of my favorite pizza places in Madison! The location is fantastic, as it's inside Garver Feed Mill, with plenty of indoor seating and outdoor seating available when the weather is nice. Parking can be a little crowded, especially during peak hours, but we've been able to find a spot during each of our visits so far. We have a toddler, so we are always looking for places where we can grab a meal, eat comfortably, and leave whenever we need to. This place is perfect for that. The Smokey the Bandit is my favorite pizza, but other options, including the Mac & Cheese and Buffalo Chicken pizzas, are also delicious. When you place your order at the counter, they send you a text message when your food is ready, so you can find a seat and relax while you wait. Individual slices are usually available right away, while a whole pizza takes a little longer to prepare, but the wait is generally very reasonable. I highly recommend this place for families with toddlers. There's plenty of space to move around with a stroller, and the overall atmosphere is welcoming, relaxed, and family-friendly. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Garver Feed Mill - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Better timing. We pick up when our name is called. Pizza consistently served cold. Glsvir is good. Salad is pretty good. The chicken is consistently dry too. We'll find an alternative from now on. The staff is awesome. Perhaps better system processes and training. read more

Always so delicious and excellent customer service from the staff! We love Ian's and will always love them!!! We are frequently here and enjoy the space and the food and the service!! read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Garver Feed Mill - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

As someone who eats a lot of pizza, I was pleasantly surprised by the food at Ian's Pizza. This is two fold -- because of the tasty and fluffy dough which is evident in their delicious breadsticks and also because of the unique flavor options that include everything from Mac 'n Cheese to BBQ to Gyro to Cajun to Hawaiian -- often with a unique twist to them. The pizza itself is really fun to eat which huge slices and a thickness that provides just enough firmness but isn't overly salty or saucy. It's easy to eat a lot of pizza this way as it doesn't feel overly oily, but just satisfying enough to casually keep taking more and more bites. The prices here aren't too bad for the portion sizes as a 20" pizza is plenty to feed 4 ... or 3 people with huge appetites. For our table, we enjoyed the creations to much that there were no leftovers despite not being super hungry before we started eating. read more

See all

So impressed with all the vegan options!!! We felt the prices were extremely reasonable and we just ordered from our phone and went to pick it up, nice and easy! It tells you the sizes in inches but I was still shocked how big the 20 inch pizza was (in a good way!). Absolutely recommend ordering from here, especially if you want more than just cheese and pepperoni (delicious options like tomato pesto) or vegan pizza. read more

I just love this place! This is our go to pizza place located in downtown Madison. The crust is thin, tasty, and fresh! Their toppings range from fresh vegetables, meats, or even Mac and Cheese. Besides pizza, they also offer fresh salads. The restaurant has a fun atmosphere, and can be difficult to get a seat on the weekends. The staff is efficient, and the food is made to order so it may take a minutes to get your order. We enjoy Ian's so much that we also ordered gift cards from their website. Stop by for a slice or pie...it's a delicious choice! read more

Love the Garver Mill location. Great space to hang out and grab a slice. I attended an event and it was super busy but the staff at Ian's did a great job moving the line along quickly. I love that they also have salads as an option and opted for a side Caesar salad and a slice of lots of options to choose from. This time I checked out a taco/fiesta option. It had a nice spice to it and some toasted chips on top. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Garver Feed Mill - BBQ chicken bacon ranch - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Ian's Pizza Madison is in a shopping center that is far off the main road. But it's worth the journey to get there. You can order pizza by the slice or by the pie. We ordered the breadsticks. They had a great flavor and a great sauce. We were so impressed with the breadsticks that we went back with our friends to get a half sausage and pepperoni and half barbecue chicken pizza. It was delicious. Our friends were happy with it, too. I highly recommend Ian's Pizza Madison. read more

See all

Best pizza in Madison, with a large variety of specialty pizzas by the slice or whole pie. You can order online and pick up curbside. They also offer delivery according to a poster I saw in here. There is also ample seating inside Garver Feed Mill, cool place to hang out and a few quirky places around to check out while you're at it. My top two faves are the cheesy potato and the veggie. They also have a weekly special which is fun to try. read more

Great spot and pizza. I wish they got new slices of pizza like they do with the ice cream place that's connected to Ian's.

Food was pretty good, salad excellent, pizza burned on the bottom, but otherwise good. Disappointed in the amount of single-use plastic being used. Especially unnecessary for the in-house diners, but every table had plastic cups on it. Unfortunate.....can something be done? read more

Loved all the unique flavors the pork taco pizza with habanero and pickled peppers was amazing also the pizza with greens. I love the crust and sauces . Service is fast and they have so many options also there's a salad bar and kombucha if you're in a healthier mood read more

See all

I went there on a weekday evening. The place was not too busy. I got parking easily. There were a lot of pizza slice on display. I tried 3. All the veg was my favorite. Mac n cheese and chicken pasta were my other ones. I loved those as well. read more

See all

When in the Madison area, you have to do Ian's pizza. They have three convenient locations. Where else can you get crazy tasty pizza. Some concoctions are never thought of except by Ian's. My top 3 favorite is the cheeseburger, the mac & cheese, and the ravioli pizza. This new location is an awesome place. Scenery is the best with plenty of seating. read more

This is my 2nd time coming here. Ran into this place when going to RolePlay the first time I came.. They had a great selection of pizzas. I've tried the tomato pesto the last time and it was so delicious. This time around I tried the drunken ravioli and the penne Alfredo. Also very delicious!! Service is pretty quick. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Garver Feed Mill - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Solid food, fair price, kind and present humans who give you eye contact. What more does a human need?

After exploring the Olbrich Gardens, we came here for lunch. There was a lot of parking available on a Friday for lunch. We ordered up front and got a 12" pizza to share which was plenty of food for 2 people. We made our own pizza with vegan mozzarella, BBQ sauce, bacon, grilled chicken and the ranch sauce on top. We didn't love the ranch sauce, probably would have liked the pizza better without it. The staff were super friendly and I was personally bummed that they were out of the cauliflower. The 12" pizza plus some churro chow came out to around $24. The inside of the building is super nice and divided into several small business on the first and second floors. read more

See all

Ian's always hits! The pizza here is delicious & the staff is super friendly. I'm not a big pizza fan, but this is one of the few pizza places in Madison that I love. read more

I thought I had found a new pizza place for a good Supreme pizza. My previous three visits in the past month were near perfect. However, all that changed yesterday. I could tell that the person who put my order together on Saturday morning (10/04) was not the same person who made the previous orders. Ian's, please take note, $25.59 for a cheese pizza with sprinkled toppings is a little too expensive for a return visit read more

I have not historically been a big fan of Ian's. But. This past week I came across news of how they offer a Lenten special on Fridays and it sounded weird enough to give it a try. Fish. Fry. Pizza. Battered cod, tartar sauce in lieu of marinara, mozzarella, French fries and topped with coleslaw. Weird? Yup. Different? Yup. For everyone? Probably not. But it was AMAZING. Preordered. Delivered on time (actually early) and a super friendly delivery guy. Loved it. Only available til April 15th but so good I am going to try the other menu items again afterwards. read more

Every single aspect of this night out was superb. The entire ambiance of the Garver Feed Mill space is perfect. The blend of events, yoga traffic, parents and kiddos, it's a perfect storm. Food is excellent and the staff are in point! I am in love with their Wisco salad with chicken added. They have these unique calendar pizza flavors I always look forward to trying. Love This location! & yes they offer Chocolate Shoppe Ice cream as well! read more

See all

This location is fantastic.Tucked into beautiful Garver Feed Mill, Ian's Pizza is one of the major focal points in the large space. Very open-spaced area with plenty of seating surrounding the kitchen. Similar to the other Ian's Pizza, you can see the display of pizzas they have available, you choose your slices, and then you walk to the other side of the kitchen to pick up your slice(s) after they've been heated up. Ian's Pizza is known for their flavor combinations and I'm all here for it. I love the fusionist mentality! I liked the BBQ Ranch ones or the taco one. I love their ranch! It is so good, thick, creamy, flavorful, just amazing. I also did not know until now you can get nacho cheese as well! What I've been dying to try the breakfast one with yogurt and berries -- only available Saturday brunch so need to make a stop then! What's also unique about this particular location is not family oriented/kid friendly it is. There are bags of games.toys lined up on the side for kids to enjoy - how fun is that! This would definitely be the spot come summer as there is outdoor seating as well. They're offering carryout and delivery at this location, I believe during this time of social distancing! Thankful to be able to getting my Ian's Pizza fix during this time. read more

See all

A pizza with a bullseyes or ranch, bacon, barbecue sauce, barbecue chicken and cheese. The Smokey and the Bandit pizza will leave you surprised and coming back for more. How could you go wrong? I mean obviously if you are vegan this is the wrong choice....but if you like meat, stop and try this. It was such a bold choice for a pizza joint. We ordered three different pizzas and all had adequate toppings and were hot when delivered to the house. The pepperoni pizza was good. But everyone was fighting over the last piece of the Smokey and the Bandit. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Garver Feed Mill - Smokey the Bandit Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

This location of Ian's Pizza is located directly inside Garver Feed Mill. Garver Feed Mill is an event space that has several businesses inside, including Ian's. When you get to Ian's, you can order pizza by the slice. They also have beer taps, salads, and bread sticks. They have several different types of pizzas to choose from. They rotate these pizzas throughout the day. When my family and I went, they had Mac N' Cheese, Taco, Buffalo Chicken, Penne Alfredo, Chicago Dog, Vegan, Veggie, Smoky and the Bandit, and more. I ordered pepperoni and Mac n cheese. We also ordered a Wisconsin' Salad. All the food was devious! The pizzas were brick oven style. The crust was crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. You can eat your pizza inside Graver Feed Mill or you can go outside. They have a beautiful outdoor patio which also has live music some night. It's a really fun option if you're looking to enjoy some fun pizzas! read more

See all

After 10 minutes of waiting I went to the counter to see where my pizza was. During that 10 minutes they called out each pizza that was placed in the window, in one case even brought it to the table. I went to the counter and the person behind the counter checked the oven and found it way in the back of the oven. Later I was told it was because I didn't wait in front of the window, and they try to "teach" people to wait at the window. read more

Delicious food, fun space but takeout experience leaves something to be desired. Pick-up wait times are wrong, (too short) and salads come predressed (= soggy greens). read more

Last two visits were awesome! Staff was super friendly, and wearing masks (which is a plus for me). Lots of pizza choices at lunch time, and I learned about flipping the all-cheese slice upside down in the oven to toast the cheese a bit... it was great! We selected to sit outdoors at one of the many tables in the sun and enjoyed the day. Also I was able to use a Madison Originals gift card that I had on my phone app. Thank you! read more

You can't really NOT like Ian's Pizza... pizza is delicious and their pizza is most certainly above average. While I don't like to be super adventurous in my pizza toppings (I like simple; cheese pizza is one of my favorites) and don't particularly appreciate wacky creations, I very much appreciate OTHER people's appreciation of their wild pizza concoctions. I think anyone who went to UW has at some point in their life eaten the mac and cheese pizza, which is certainly yummy. I certainly would not be upset if I had to eat a slice (mac and cheese and pizza are probably two of my favorite things), but I do kinda prefer to consume those two things separately. Ian's at Garver is very close to where I pick up my kombucha, so every now and then I like to get a bit crazy myself and order Ian's. Like mac and cheese, pasta is also one of my favorite things (theme: CARBS), so I could not say no to something called drunken ravioli pizza with vodka sauce. Another of my favorite things -- tomato sauce, so I usually order extra sauce on any and all pizza. I did that with the drunken ravioli pizza, and in hindsight it was a mistake. However, Ian's staff even called me to clarify what exactly I wanted for extra sauce (I think I chose a sauce through online ordering that didn't actually exist... oops) so I appreciate that. The drunken ravioli pizza is indeed DELICIOUS, but definitely doesn't need extra sauce (and I never say that!). It was soooo filling I actually had half for lunch and half for dinner... and I always eat the full pizza in one sitting. Most recently I ordered the vegan tomato penne or something of that sort. I'm no vegan, but it was the only pizza with penne and marinara instead of alfredo (tomato sauce, remember?). Recalling my previous error, I did not order extra sauce. The pizza was absolutely delicious once again. I ate the entire thing in one sitting, per my norm. The sauce ratio was quite lovely, but I don't think extra sauce would be as overwhelming as with the drunken ravioli. It also had some kind of charred/roasted greens on it, I think kale and spinach. Those are always risky on a pizza because they can be done so poorly, but these were some of the BEST I've ever had. Well done. The Old Garver Feed Mill is such a neat building, and I absolutely love that they restored it. Once we are in a somewhat free COVID world where restaurants open back up, I can't wait to go inside and actually see the place. For now, curbside pickup is easy enough. My pizza is delivered directly to my car and the employee is always wearing gloves and a mask. Hooray for safety. While Ian's is not somewhere I'd go for just a good old cheese pizza or two-topping pizza, it is delicious pizza and their creations are very creative -- definitely worth checking out. read more

See all

Speaking only of this location and only for 2 visits, 1 for a dinner and one for Saturday breakfast during the market. Both were good experiences even when slammed for business. The line moves fast and they keep clear what they need you to do to order pay and pick up your meal. Kind staff and very friendly people. I have gotten a BYO salad which was delicious and good sized and well priced. I also have gotten a super kick a$$ breakfast pizza slice called jam berry jam they do only on Saturdays and you should go try this as well. Thank me later. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Garver Feed Mill - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Great recommendation after touring the Olbrich Botanical Garden on a scorching day, which happens to be a 5 min walk away. I had the opportunity to try the mac and cheese pizza and the caesar salad that featured hard boiled eggs. Food is pretty good and there are plenty of seats for guests and their families. read more

The Garver feed mill location is superb with a huge outdoor courtyard. We can on the perfect night. I just wish we lived closer! We were able try a variety of their pizzas: mac n' cheese, tomato pesto, veggie, and the Smokey bandit. We also tried two of their salads (Greek and southwestern) and breadsticks with ranch, cheese or marinara dip. The Greek salad was delicious and my favorite pizza by far was the Smokey bandit. The drizzled sweet, creamy sauce on top (not sure what it was) really put it over the top for me. I really wanted to like the Mac n cheese but it was a bit dry for me- needed more cheese or sauce of some sort. Regardless I will definitely be back! read more

See all

Awesome find at Garver Feed Mill! We had the breakfast fruit pizza! Just the right combination of crunchy crust, sweet yogurt and tangy blueberries and rasberries. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Garver Feed Mill - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Heads up carryout takes an hour even for slices. Plan ahead!!! I have been obsessed with the Garver building since moving to Madison over 20 years ago and now it has one of my favorite pizza joints in it, what could be better!?! Like the other Ian's pizza location they make legit thin crust pizzas with really fun toppings toppings. My favorites are the Mac & cheese with a drizzle of their BBQ sauce on it as well as the bbq chicken. Granted I haven't met a slice from Ian's that I haven't liked! For a bit lighter fare, they have one of the best salad offerings in the area and I love to grab a slice and a salad to balance things out a bit. If you love Ian', this will probably be your favorite one read more

Tucked away on the north side of the Isthmus, Ian's pizza has everything you're looking for when it comes to a huge range of toppings and great service. The bread sticks were fluffy and have a wonderful seasoning on top and a choice of 3 different dipping sauces (marinara, cheese, and ranch)!!!! The southwestern salad was also delicious and a great compliment to any pizza dinner! The pizza was very good, I tried the Mac n' cheese which was tasty but for me could use a little more sauce. Smokey the bandit though hit it out of the park with flavors! The perfect amount of sauce to cheese to meat, hands down one of the best bbq style pizzas I have had in a long time. I will definitely be coming here to try some more of their pizza options. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Garver Feed Mill - Southwestern salad - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all