new to Madison but these guys absolutely rock! no matter how busy they are they treat each of their customers like family. food is amazing! the place is very clean and very comfortable! read more

Could not miss this place on a visit to Madison! Buffalo Chicken Pizza was 10/10 (Crème Sauce, Mozzarella, Dry Rubbed Chicken, Buffalo Sauce, and Bleu Cheese Sauce) I was ready skeptical with the blue cheese and the strong buffalo flavor. But oh my goodness what a lovely lovely Pizza! Those flavors went so well together and neither of them was too overpowering. I had it with the Drunken Ravioli pizza (vodka Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, Cheese Ravioli, Butter, & Asiago). I was genuinely not expecting this pizza to be so good. Such a nice balance of the ravioli and the cheese and the sauce and everything else going on. Love the build your own salad as well! Portion size on here is massive and is definitely value for money. It was big enough for two meals! Love the grilled chicken that they put in the salad too. Well cooked and nice flavor. read more

See all

I felt like a senior citizen with all the UW college students inside. We got three slices, chicken barbecue, the mac and cheese pizza, and the ravioli pizza. Additionally, we got the Wisco salad. Whole place is kind of novelty. Flavors OK, but nothing too scream about. I think the lure is the price and the affordability versus the flavor. Service was mediocre. There were only 2 workers that I could see and they seem frazzled. There was some issue with some other person's order. The lines get long during meal times so plan accordingly. read more

See all

We've been to the other two Ian's in town and this one like the one in Garver Feedmill does have beer - though I did not get any on this visit. We were grabbing an early dinner before a volleyball game so the place was not busy. I know they are known for their oddball pizza combos but most are just not for me. I did get their barbecue chicken pizza but I really just wanted something more traditional in addition like a pepperoni slice. They had nothing like it at this time. So I opted for just the one slice which was good but... My wife got a slice they described as chicken cordon blue. She thought it was just OK. Not a favorite. I will stick with Glass Nickel as our "go to" for pizza in town. read more

Pizza is fine. Dude in panty hose just carries out several slices and announces slices are up and about five guys try to find which one is theirs. It leads to confusion and one guy brought back a slice after he handled it because he realized it wasn't what he picked. This method is stupid. Have a number or name to go with the order. I imagine a bunch of weekend drunks would make it quite a spectacle if your slice wasn't the one glommed on to. read more

This IS the place for late night eats when finishing up at bars... (esp Ivory Room Piano Bar!) We love the hot & ready to eat slices (HUGE) and that they offer gluten free crusts! The cheeseburger pizza legit tastes like the best burger I've had... without a bun! read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Frances Street - Gluten Free! Cheeseburger pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Service at this establishment is wonderful and it's an easy place to walk to down town or if you're staying in a hotel near by. Pizza was good and we ended our night full and happy! read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Frances Street - Buffalo chicken pizza and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

These slices are gigantic! Two is more than enough for one person. I tried the mac and cheese and the bbq chicken. Both were fantastic, but I made a sandwich and it was even better with a little ranch on top. Cheap prices, thoroughly enjoyed their pizza. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Frances Street - Bbq chicken and Mac N' Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Cool place to visit when visiting Madison basically by college ave. Good deals by getting $5 a slice they have some different combinations some good some questioning ones. I got the Penne Alfredo 6/10, could have gone for a regular tomato and basil. Would have tasted better. There was no sauce really, some flavor from the parmesan I added but nothing crazy about the pizza. I liked the crust though. Will be back for different combinations read more

See all

Surprisingly, my husband never tried Ian's, so we had to stop by when we were in town recently. Happy we did! We stopped on a Sunday afternoon while walking around and grabbed a slice of pepperoni before we ventured out. The space was fairly clean, including the bathroom. Plenty of space to sit and even space to look out at the sidewalks and watch pedestrians meander. There's not much to the menu but they have some good options (pizza, salad, sticks). You choose your par baked slice and they pop it in the oven to finish it up for you. They also have plenty of drink options, including tap beer/cider if you need more than soda. Our server did a good job - took a little long for our slice but not too bad. read more

See all

My dearest Ians Pizza, I am forever gracious to you for your incredible service and pizza! My stay was perfection and I shall return quickly! read more

I was there on the Lent week to have their fish fry pizza. They introduce this pizza only for the week of Lent every year. It was just ok. I think it was tilapia fish. It would have been better, if it was beer battered fried cod. I would skip it next year. Taco pizza was my favorite this time. Mac n cheese pizza was good. read more

See all

You can't beat the late night pizza. We grabbed two pizzas for four people (we were ravenous). I have found this Ian's Pizza to be a little less reliable than its companion down State Street. These pizzas took an HOUR to get out to us. I may be spoiled with their usual freaky fast service but that seems crazy! They did compensate with a bag of puppy chow, but alas it take more than that to satiate my tummy grumbles. It's a lot smaller and maybe less family friendly oriented than the State street location. Definitely mostly college goers here I think. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Frances Street - Ravioli pizza and Smokey The Bandit Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

The inside of the pizza place was really cool and had cool artwork and slogans. The guy taking my order was also very nice and quick. The pizza was okay. The Penne Alfredo was a bit dry and needed a bit more sauce. Also the pizzas were just sitting out and they were reheated so it wasn't very fresh. The mushrooms on the pizza also seemed like they were out for a bit. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Frances Street - Pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Loved the crust, the nice variety of toppings, service was fast & friendly. A must try in Madison! read more

See all

The pizza here is to die for. I would recommend getting a hole pizza because you can't just have one slice. The pizza is more like New York style pizza. They also deliver. So what are you waiting for try them today read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Frances Street - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Iconic. This is not just for after the bars. This is excellent for strolling the streets of Madison in the middle of the day. I have been waiting years for this moment and I finally got my bite of the mac n cheese pizza. It was everything I was hoping it would be. Ooh the cheese, the noodles, the love. I would have ordered an entire pizza of this if I could. I also tried the bacon, ranch, and potato slice and it was a strong contender for best slice. I wish I could have tried every kind they have. Ian's, I will be back and I will try it all. I love you, I miss you. read more

Ian's Pizza. Very awesome while drunk and good enough to enjoy while sober. That should probably be their slogan. Stays open late. Sells pizza by the slice (can buy a whole as well). That sums it up for the most part. The pizza is very solid New York style pizza. The crust is flavorful and chewy. What more could one ask for. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Frances Street - Mac and Cheese Slice. Ravioli Slice. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Great pizza! Open late. Different types of pizza Mac and cheese pizza is better than I thought it would be! Large slices! read more

I need to give a shout out to a particular speciality flavor -- the CRAB RANGOON! Crab Rangoons are my guilty pleasure appetizer and placed on a pizza -- absolutely delicious! Ian's Pizza got this flavor to a T! The crust is consistent every time - perfect thickness and toasted to a nice crunch. I usually don't eat the crust, but Ian's is an exception for me, especially when I have the ranch! The cream cheese sauce mixture with some green onions and chunks of crab -- just yum! I devour the slice in minutes. The crunchiness of the wonton crisps is the real star. Whatever flavor slice you get, the ranch always compliments it. When I can wait to eat the slice for me to get home, I'll add some sweet & sour drizzle and voila! Exact resemblance of a crab rangoon. I also want to give Ian's a shoutout for trying to reduce waste on their pizza boxes. I never knew you could bring it back to reuse and get a sticker on your pizza card. Just amazing! read more

See all

We ordered 3 slices of pizza to go this afternoon. When we got home, we found that it was so soggy, greasy, and burnt black on the bottom that it was inedible. Granted, it was busy when we were there, but the server totally forgot our pizza order. We had to call it to her attention after waiting 10 minutes. We used to love the place, but we won't be going back. Sad. read more

Great late night spot Fast and efficient service Crispy crust Pizza by the slice Great variety of toppings read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Frances Street - Some kind of veggie pizza and buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

I've o Lu come here late at night after having a few drinks out on the town! They keep the pizzas rotating! You go in and there are a bunch of different pizza slices to choose from. This time around I went with cheese! The as Dave would say, it's a little floppy! No cheese pull, but still tastes great! They have some other great pizzas to choose from. The BBQ chicken is amazing and classic pepperoni. They have a Mac and cheese one that I am too afraid to try! They are quick and have great service. Defenitely a great stop for a quick slice of good pizza! read more

I am a very picky when it comes to pizza, I am very biased and love Ian's pizza because it reminds me of the pizza back home on the East Coast. The staff at the Lake Street is amazing, the only issue I have is the order system. I ordered my pizza and went to pick it up but the ticket never printed. But I can't complain because the lady gave me money off my order. I do wish there was delivery but I am still ok with driving there. If you want pizza that will remind of you the East Coast go try Ian's. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Frances Street - Yummy to my tummy... Pepperoni Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

If you're downtown and near the Capitol then this place is going to be your go to for pizza. Their pizza are pretty unique and it's hard to find another pizzeria that have mac and cheese as their toping. The very cheap prices is also a huge plus. If you do not know what to get because of their variety then the staff will gladly help you pick out a slice of pizza to your preferences. If you do go here then expect it to be loud compared to other pizzerias. It's a known college hangout so many students come here for a quick bite or chill with friends so it's almost always lively, except on academic holidays of course. Great place to grab pizza from. Everyone is super friendly and almost always lively to hang out at. read more

I highly recommend any type of pizza here. The crust is the best I've had here in Madison multiple varieties to choose from & a nice cool beer to add to your choice of pizza. Service was excellent, fast, & best of all friendly. To go or eat in is your choice. Either way, you will not be disappointed. read more

Pizza was amazing. So crispy and yummy flavors. Very fast friendly service and good prices. Everything sold is from local businesses. Very cool. Nice sitting area inside makes for good ppl watching! read more

See all

5+ stars for their catering! I worked with Staci on a large catering order out of the Frances St. store. She was helpful, decisive, and suggestive. She calmed my fears about feeding a crowd. The pizzas were just as she promised, and ready for me to finish baking at home. I can't recommend them enough for your next large pizza order. read more

What's the difference between the superficial owner of this place, and a night when girls pretend to be scary but actually just wear almost nothing? One is Halloween, the other is Shallowian. What to get: Spinach Feta slice What not ot get: Feta and feta because you ate too much pizza I had heard all about Ian's Pizza and had been told about it, but in the end it's really just a good standard College Pizza. Not spectacular by any means. The chicken barbecue slice was nothing special at all - although it wasn't bad. The pepperoni slice was better, although it had nothing on the pepperoni available in places like Buffalo and Detroit. And it was really really really really greasy. Which isn't usually a bad thing, but the taste needs to at least match the grease level to make it worth it. However the winner was the feta and spinach sliced. It was the one which the cute girl working here told me to get - although it's not as popular as the others, she said it was her personal favourite. Well she has good taste because this slice was excellent. In fact good enough for me to give it 5 Stars except for the rather ridiculous pricing of $4 for a slice. Which is the reason I'm keeping it at 4. It's just about 5-star pizza if you get the right slice. Most slices are 4-star or less. And the pricing is just too much. Buffalo and Detroit slices are 10x as good and half the price. A couple of bonus things are that the crust is really hard and delicious, which really makes the pizza, rather the basic crap bread. It's cooked well and to perfection unlike a lot of the soggy bread you find around the country. A second point is that a lot of pretty girls come here for slices. It's an awesome place to flirt and people watch. But if someone stares deep into your eyes and won't stop, they're not people watching. They're "Pupil watching." And you should remind them to retina sense of decency and not do that anymore. Iris people would listen to advice, but they don't. read more

See all

I've heard of Ian's pizza so much so I had high expectations; it just didn't live up to the hype. I like the unique pizza combos but that was it. Really nice workers too. Just wouldn't come here again for pizza. read more

Ian’s Pizza Madison | Frances Street - Chicken bacon ranch & classic Mac n cheese - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

The last two times I attended Ian's pizza by the Slice the bottom of my mac and cheese pizza was burnt to a crisp. It was black and charred and not golden brown like a pizza should be. When I went to take my first bite the sound that was emitted was loud and crunchy. Although I still did enjoy the pizza. This morning when I awoke I realized I did not finish the crust and I decided to take a small bite but it was quite difficult because it was rock solid. Pizza crust should last for at least two days. I love my morning after pizza crust. In conclusion, I would still visit Ian's pizza again but if my mac and cheese pizza is burnt one more time it's the last straw. read more

See all

Worst day of my life. Ian's Pizza Sunday night manager was a complete dipshit. First, I ask for a small cup and fill it with Peach Powerade, to my chagrin when I was forced to pay $3 for a 4 oz cup of juice. Behind us in the restaurant was a unhoused fella who sat without food and drank from the soda machine as well without being charged. The gall of this guy. Upon getting home I realize my 3 breadstick deal did not have the 2 sauces it comes with, and my coupon card was hole punched for one slice, and not the two slices ordered plus breadsticks. Now, sitting here, writing this, I hope Ian's can figure it out and hire a competent worker who looks out for the customer and doesn't penny, nickel, dime them. 0/5 stars. read more

I used to work across the street from this location and was there the first day it opened. I have been back to Ian's many times since. There isn't much seating inside but the place is clean and their pizza travels well to-go. It's easy to pop in, get a quick slice and bring it back to my work. Plus, when you can buy by the slice it's quite affordable! My favorite thing about Ian's is the unique flavors of pizza. Nowadays most pizza places offer "unusual" toppings but that has always been the standard at Ian's. My favorite pizza there is the Macaroni and Cheese pizza which is packed with flavor. Crab Rangoon flavor, Buffalo Chicken, and many other flavors are so good I bet I could eat a whole pizza. Often I'd go and get a few slices to go, so I could have something different for dinner, too. read more

I always come to this ian's location and normally it is amazing. This time however, I got a salad that was not even halfway filled compared to their normal size. I still paid $13 for it. read more

Mac and cheese pizza was good, crisp and fresh even at midnight. Other slices were alright

Got two pies and they were both great. The crust was a nice crunch, cheese was melted perfectly and toppings were good. This was a good pre-race meal and the service was good too. read more

Welp. There is nothing else to say about this place, if you don't try this you are weird. It absolutely has everything, vegan, veg. By the slice full pie, quick- beer. Jeesh, just everything. I'm glad they don't have these by me, because I would just live inside of it. This is an amazing place read more

College town Pizzeria joint... ... I should end my review right there. But no, it's a bit better than that. Yes it might be where drunk young students stumble in at night after a rowdy time at the bar to fill their bellies with some decent pizza. Maybe a can of soda to help it go down in the most delightful way. On the way here all I heard about from my friends was their ever so popular "Mac&Cheese" pizza. I mean with this much reputation sitting on a slice of pizza. I was a bit skeptical, but sure enough, the Mac&Cheese pizza is the truth. I would most definitely order that again next time I'm here. Anyways, the place is really cool,, all open concept with the cafeteria style system. The staff is very nice, even the hot chic on the check out counter is a nice touch. I'm all about spot like this. I order, I pay, I get food, I eat, no frills, no gimmicks. Just good honest food to share with friends on a good super day. Thank you Ian's. I love you!! read more

See all

I came here for dinner last week with a bunch of sorority sisters as we were in town for our national convention. I would rank this higher if I had been able to try the pizza but in order to get a gluten free pizza slice, you had to order an entire pizza which was more then I was hungry for. There are a bunch of huge salads that you can either customize or have made per the recipe. These for the most part are gluten free. I went with a salad because I was able to get it gluten free. I had the southwestern chicken salad. It was quite good though there was a bit much of the corn in it. The pizza slices that my sisters had looked really good. I can definitely see why you only order a slice or tek when coming here. The flavor combinations sounded quite good. It would have been nice to have this option in the gluten free variety but I can understand that they probably don't sell enough gluten free to make it worth their while. I'm also not entirely sure that the gluten free pizzas are premade or made as you order as I did not order one or see anyone else order one. The posted menu barely had anything stating that they had gluten free pizza. I was in town for travel so I will most likely not be back. There are other options out there to fill my gluten free pizza cravings. read more

One thing always to be expected is that Ian's is solidly consistent in all locations, that is, great and unique flavor profiles on pizza served by a warm staff. Always will be a frequent and fan read more

See all