We ordered takeout - so I can't comment on ambiance or servers - while in town visiting locals, at their recommendation. A good one! I appreciate the variety of crust options (including gluten free, which we did need for one member of our crew), and the high quality toppings. The meat and cheese suppliers were called out on the menu, which told me to expect good things. Everything was reasonably priced for the elevated quality involved. The order was ready when expected, and pickup was easy & trouble-free. The ride back to the Air BNB was excruciating while hotboxing pizza air - it smelled SO GOOD. The flavor delivered, as did the texture of each crust style we tried. The salads we ordered were also fresh and delicious, and the dressings totally topped out at max tastiness - my favorite was the Greek. Overall, I would be so ready to go again at any time! Fatpants are ready, let's do this. read more

First of all, we got here at 6 pm on a Saturday and were told for a table of 2 it would be a half an hour wait which we had no problem with. About 16 minutes later our table was ready which was great. Our waiter was in the top 5 for worst waiter I have ever had. He would literally point at things and never speak. At one point he pointed at my empty plate but he was asking if I needed water. When he brought our food out he handed me my plate instead of setting it down in front of me. He had the personality of a saltine cracker - I never saw him smile once. Not personable at all. Definitely needs some training in customer service. read more

See all

I've been visiting my sister for over a decade and have always noticed this pizza spot--but finally gave it a try, and I'm kicking myself for not going sooner. The pizza was absolutely delicious, with generous toppings and a perfectly made crust. We were torn between two specialty pizzas, and our server helpfully suggested we split them half and half--such a great option! We ended up trying the Mac Daddy and the Buffalo Chicken, and while both were solid, the Buffalo Chicken was the clear standout. Honestly, it's one of the best versions I've ever had. The dough was excellent, and even the leftovers held up beautifully the next day. On top of the great food, the service was friendly and welcoming. I'll definitely be back next time I'm in town. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Mac Daddy & Buffalo Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

Food was great. Sat at the bar on a very busy Sunday night. Bar seats full (16 stools?). Waitress station at bar was stacked up with back orders. Only one bartender... and on his second shift ever. Left all alone behind the bar and was DEEP in the weeds. He got very little help from management or servers. An off duty staff member came in to help for a second but wasn't there to work I don't think. Server stations helped first and bar patrons were an afterthought... if at all. 2+ hours from sit down to eat and leave. Bartender never said a word or acknowledged people. Good food... but not going back. read more

What a pleasant surprise I ordered the gouda bites nice tasty fried cheese. The Maple Bacon pizza hand tossed crust was recommended by Pearl the bartender and what a great tasting pizza it was unique from anything I had before Excellent service and a great beer selection I will return to try more read more

Sugar River Pizza - Maple bacon pizza hand tossed crust - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

Great pizza. We went for a weekday lunch. Our server was distracted but it may be due to him being the only one, but they weren't busy. That said, the pizza was really good. We customized ours so it was pricey but well worth it. Drinks were reasonably priced. We will dine here again. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

See all

Here's the good and the bad...the food must be made fresh because they were quite busy and it took a long time to get our food. Onion rings were excellent! My husband ordered quesadillas and claimed they were " ok" but rather bland. I had the southwest salad, which was very disappointing. The chicken was overcooked and they add LOTS of arugula...who ever heard of making a southwest salad with arugula??? It did not even taste good. On the other hand, service was good. Our waitress was attentive and was able to help us navigate the menu and make needed changes. Next time, I will order pizza. I haven't tasted it yet, but the pizzas I saw bright to there looked amazing! Give it a try...but skip that salad if you don't love arugula!!! read more

This is a great place for a large menu/ lots of different options. One of my favorite pizza places. This is my favorite place for hand tossed pizza. All of the pizzas have a perfect amount of toppings, and they were all well balanced. Overall there is never a miss on any pizza I've gotten here, and the appetizers are also delicious. The food is always served quickly, and the service is always friendly. I loved the sweet treat, cinnamon nuggets. Portions are huge and prices are inexpensive. There was live music tonight, and I appreciated how it wasn't too loud but just loud enough to enjoy. Lighting and seating are great, with many places to sit with large groups. read more

See all

This is the best pizza I have ever had, hands down. Meatlovers was my first experience and fell in love. I've had a few of the different specialty ones and their all yummy! I'm now addicted to the maple my bacon. Maui tropics is good too. Heck, they are all good! Pasta, salads, burgers are all yummy! I'm a fan. read more

Wings - 10pc I guess homie either can't count or just doesn't respect anyone. Because why is there always 8 or 9 and never 10? and very little sauce? Sugar River Pretzel Bites same person counting? I either get way toooo much or literally 10 pieces. Lets not get how I also run into someone who mistakes cheese for Au Jus. Smoked Gouda Mac Bites seriously? who is counting. Mac N' Cheese Pizza look you never get this wrong. HURRAYY Asian Chicken Pizza i swear this pizza ISN'T FOR YOU. the same person who cant count, makes food as if it were for THEM. ZERO Sauce!?! ALL pineapple? its an ASIAN Chicken Pizza dependant ON SAUCE not a HAWAIIAN. Im just disappointed because why does it seem the SAME person cooks whenever the pizza is sauceless, there are apps with improper counts, mix ups and more. either this person is SLOW and has difficulty cooking and shouldn't be there. Or they deliberately dont care and need to be FIRED. because there's days GOOD and days like today-BAD. Just quit if you hate cooking bro. You seriously suck at this. 9/3/25 read more

We got a garden salad with ranch and a BYO pizza with sausage, onion, mushroom. Loved the fresh, local ingredients! Seemed it was some sort of trivia night (busy!!) but we got a table without a wait & food came out quick & fresh. Will stop again! read more

Sugar River Pizza - BYO pizza sausage, mush, onion - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

See all

Finally went to the delicious Sugar River Pizza! It was a surprisingly calm night with few people, and we enjoyed our food, drinks, and desserts. Our server was very nice and welcoming, the pizza and salads were excellent and oh my goodness, get the peanut butter pie and roll yourself out the door -- holy goodness that dessert is a top 10 for me. We had pretzel bites which were amazing, although they kind of sit in the butter pooled under them. The Hawaiian pizza was delicious, pineapple does in fact belong on pizza. I had the Asian chicken salad and was very happy with the portions and quality. The peanut butter pie was absolutely outstanding. I would drive the 25 minutes from my apartment just to order that dessert. It is incredible, I'm still thinking about it days later. Get one for the table! The ambiance isn't much to speak of, there's not a ton of decor or a theme going. The bathrooms were nice, but watch out, the foamy soap comes directly at you! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Peanut Butter Pie - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

Ordered fried ravioli, pulled pork nachos, lasagna, Goat Cheese Alfredo. Portions were huge, and everything was absolutely delicious. We had our order delivered (no delivery fee is charged), delivery time was great & everything was hot. The person who took my order was polite and knowledgeable about the menu, was patient and answered all my questions. The delivery driver was great too. 10 out of 10 from start to finish read more

After hearing some decent reviews, my better half and I decided to stop in when we were in the area. The location is definitely built for a crowd as it spacious but lacks any real charm. A very expansive tap list (probably close to 50) is notable. We were in the witching hour between lunch and dinner and our waitstaff was a little brusque. We ordered the stuffed cheese bread along with an amazon deluxe pizza. They were fine. Definitely not noteworthy or something we would purposefully come back for. An option if you were hungry and needed a quick bite or a few beers. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Stuffed cheesebread - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

if I could leave a a negative star review I would, took us in the far back of the restaurant and then wait's 30 mins for them to Still look at us and not help us We ended leaving while they waited on people that arrived way after us, prolly won't be going there again read more

We came on a trivia night but wouldn't know. Immediately greeted and sat. Our drinks were slowly served and our food took a while (20+ minutes) my food order was incorrect and had to be sent back. The server was very apologetic. My drink couldn't be made because they were out of a key ingredient. Not a big deal but an inconvenience. Overall the food was good and worth the wait. Would come back to try more things on the menu. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Beers on tap - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

See all

Stop by this place for dinner with family. What a cute sit down restaurant. Our server was very attentive but I didn't catch her name. We had a party of 7 and it was easy to get a table since it wasn't that full for a Thursday night. We ended up ordering onion rings and spinach and artichoke dip as our appetizers and 3 different kinds of pizza--Mediterranean, Garden Bella with added pineapples, and Amazon deluxe on a gluten free crust. Everything was so delicious. Would definitely come back again for their pizza and to try other things on the menu. read more

See all

I have Alpha Gal Syndrome (allergy to mammal). They were wonderful about making me a pizza with fresh ingredients. It was delicious.

A good pizza joint when you want variety of specialty type pizzas at a decent price. We ordered a specialty pizza with some custom toppings split between the halves & it was great! We did a take-out so not sure of in store service, but place looked busy for a regular weekday evening. Plenty of parking spots nearby which is a plus. The portions of toppings are on higher side and it tasted really good. read more

We love Sugar River. Our order is always accurate and they have a ton of options for those with dietary restrictions.

Best kept happy hour! Monday - Friday 2:30-5:30 all apps (excluding wings and tenders) are half off. I will never turn down a pizza here though, try the creamy pesto...it's the best I've had! As much as love SRP, the service is hit or miss, which is why the 4 stars. Sometimes things are fast and well-oiled, other times you could wait an hour to get an appetizer. Today our waitress never checked back after our food and we both needed refills on our sodas. I've had several meals made wrong, or even forgotten, and not given a comp, offered to make right, or much of an apology. I've eaten here a lot in the last two years and the food outweighs the potentially bad service. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Fried ravoli over a bed of creamy pesto - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

See all

The food was absolutely amazing !!! Went in on Saturday night and were immediately seated. The server was quick to get to us and get our orders in. We always go to the Verona location and this was our first time at the Sun Prairie one. The food and service did not disappoint. They have a lot of options for pizza and pasta lovers.The Buffalo chicken pizza was delicious and I highly recommend the appetizer platter. The chicken Alfredo pasta was really good. The portions sizes are huge so prepare to share. The drinks were good too. Please make sure to order the Bruschetta, I want it now. Go checkout Sugar River Pizza for some amazing specialty pizzas, you will not be disappointed. read more

See all

My wife made reservations for 15 people for 1 table/tables seated together for 7/20/25 for a birthday celebration, they did not set up as such and made people use 2 tables, which alienated some of the guests, who then left early, while they still had plenty of empty tables in the area that they could have made it happen but they refused to do, after once again saying they could do this when the original reservation was made, asked for the owner to call me after the event which never happened, this was at the Sun PRAIRIE LOCATION SO DO NOT TRUST THAT THEY WILL DO, WHAT THEY SAY THEY WILL DO.............wkg.................... read more

Friends were craving pizza, so we decided to grab dinner here. All around delicious pizza and friendly service. We ordered the Rio Grande BBQ Chicken, Kickapoo Taco, and Kicking Horse 4-Alarm specialty pizzas. The Kickapoo Taco pizza is served with salsa, sour cream, lettuce, and homemade chips on the side, so it's up to you to determine how you want to go about creating that full flavor profile. For our group, it seemed like a 14" pizza was an ample amount to share with 1 friend. Some of us ordered the Daytona Stinger, a fruited sour - this is not fruity in the slightest. The beer is slightly green in color due to the "healthy dose of mojito extract" and it did not look appetizing. BUT if you are a mojito fan, you might enjoy it as it tasted like a listerine mojito infused beer. read more

See all

First off, this was a very nice resterait and had a very good staff. Our waitress was very nice and friendly. I had recently sprained my finger before going and I had it taped. She asked what happened and I said I sprained it. She then said that she was a EMT trained and would gladly take a look at it. She looked at it and gave me ice for it and even offered to splint it for me and I said it was fine. There was one problem. We ordered a meat pizza and it had an issue, we told staff and they quickly resolved it and took care of us.I give this restaurant a 5/5 and the waitress should get a raise. read more

Great place and great food plus the portions are huge! Wanted to try the avocado ranch but unfortunately they don't serve it anymore, went with the sriracha mayo instead and was very good! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Goat cheese alfredo highly recommend!! - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

I ordered a side salad and shared a Margherita pizza with a friend. The salad had a long hair in it, which the waitress was kind to get a new salad and remove from the bill. I lost my appetite for the salad but it was mostly lettuce with a few cucumbers and tomatoes on top. The pizza was greasy (not typical pizza grease) and you could only taste the cheese which for Wisconsin I'd expect to be flavorful. The tomato, basil, and balsamic had zero flavor as well. The best part of this restaurant was the views and ambiance to spend time with friends. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

It has been two years since I've been to Sugar River Sun Prairie! I loved the service and hospitality. Sam and Kyle were the sweetest and helped me pick delicious selections of drinks! I've missed Sugar River Sun Prairie!!! The Gouda bites were immaculate and the steak sandwich was so filing that I had leftovers! Kyle is an A1 bartender! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Gouda cheese bites and steak sandwich with waffle fries - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

See all

First off this place is much bigger inside than I would have guessed. We arrived on a very buy Saturday evening but were able to get a table for five with about a 25 minute wait. The staff was really hustling but the place was jammed so there were a number of times we were waiting for service or the actual food. We started with their small Caesar salad which was actually quite big as the waitress said it was. Three of us shared a 14" Italian meat pizza - the thin and crispy crust. It was pretty good, not great. You could tell the crust was a pre-made crust. It actually tasted like a something you'd get in a store bought frozen pizza. There was plenty of meat and that part was good. One other got a flatbread item and thought it was good. The other got a chicken wrap of some sort and it was huge - he liked it. OK experience, OK food - not sure I would rush back since there are better pizza places in town. read more

Large open space with comfortable seating. We had a larger group and we were able to spread out and enjoy talking with each other. Service wasn't great, they didn't bring out the dishes at one time and getting refills on drinks took longer than expected. The food sandwiches portions were too large and nothing to write home about. If you decide to go here I recommend the pizza it's pretty good. read more

My husband & I decided to try to new pizza spot in Sun Prairie and it was amazing. We love pizza but who doesn't. We tried the Kicking Horse 4-Alarm Pizza and the spicy blend of cheese is a perfect combination! We also tried the Amazon Deluxe which was also good but once you try the cheese blend on the Kicking Horse it just doesn't hit the spot the same way. We had family visiting from out of town and ordered some and everyone loved it! We still need to go back to explore more items. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Kicking Horse - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

See all

We went the week between Christmas and New Year's around lunch time. They were definitely busy so there was a wait but all of the staff were clearly hustling. We sat at the bar to avoid the wait. I had one of the Young Blood beers on tap and the crispy chicken sandwich with waffle fries. The sandwich was very large but had pretty good flavor. It would have been better with some lettuce to add something fresh and crisp. I would probably go back again but try something else. Good place to go if you need a quick bite--just maybe not at lunch time during a holiday week. read more

The food is excellent here. Waitstaff is very professional, and a bar that does not skimp. I highly recommend this place, if you are totally bored with other establishments. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

Good place to grab a pizza & beer with friends! My friend & I sat at at the enormous & comfy bar (seriously, the bar chairs were soooo squishy & comfortable!) and tried a flight of beer. Their tap selection is very impressive, plus they offer a variety of cocktails. I also tried their purple margarita which was very good. We ended up ordering a pizza as well, which came out nice and delicious looking. I don't think the thin crust is homemade but it still tasted good enough. Decent pizza, but not my favorite (I'm big on a brick oven type pizza). The service was great, very personable :) I'll definitely go back. read more

See all

Was super excited to finally try this place out and we were not disappointed !!! We got appetizers. Pizza. Dessert. And all of it was amazing ! The cinnamon nuggets could have had a tad more cinnamon on them but we love cinnamon. The waitress was really nice and attentive. Brought refills on sodas without us having to ask. The pizza came out way quicker than we anticipated. I actually wish it would have taken a few more minutes because we were only half way through the appetizers. The restaurant was nice and clean and open feeling. Not a lot of people at 5 o'clock on a Saturday night. Prices are reasonable compared to other similar places. Will definitely come back ! There's a lot more on the menu then I thought there would be and I definitely want to try more ! read more

See all

Still just as delicious a year after my initial review. Service was excellent. Here is a picture of a few of their pastas. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Shrimp ravioli in red pepper cream sauce - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

See all

We're new to the area and have been trying to find our new base for restaurants, especially for our favorite of pizza. After trying several different area pizza places, we've found that Sugar River Sun Prairie keeps popping up as our choice of where to eat. We enjoy several of their specialty recipes. Our only "disappointment" with the pizza menu has been the meat lover's, which we find to be very salty. Otherwise, the flavor mix and choices are solid. We've done both eat in and carry-out. Our eat in experience has range from good to very good. Unfortunately, I've had some disappointing experiences with carry-out, mostly with the attitude and attentiveness of the register team. For instance, on one occasion, I waited for just under 10 minutes for someone to come to the register when I came into the carryout counter, even though I could hear and see people in the kitchen area and they didn't respond to my requests for attention. When they finally recognized my presence, they just pulled my order off of the warmer with no comment when I mentioned the extended wait. read more

This was my first visit to this location.. the place is beautiful! Big, open and new which is always nice. We sat in a room overlooking the wetlands, with the glass wall wide open. Super cool. First and foremost... the food came out HOT! Which is my #1 requirement. The server was super nice and very attentive. Food was good, nothing spectacular, but what ai expected. Done correctly, presented well, and huge portions. Couldn't even finish my reuben and waffle fries. read more

The pizza was amazing didn't think it would be as good as NY pizza. Loved it and the service was definitely the best. The staff was very friendly and helpful when it came to helping me and my friend pick a beer. read more

Sugar River Pizza - BBQ pulled pork pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

Well to start I would give this a negative star review. Where to begin. Went in and got food. While waiting to get food I witnessed a server getting yelled at and screamed at by another server. This individual is named Noah that did the screaming and yelling at a co worker. Screaming and yelling and swearing at this person. Not to mention kids are present and you're swearing in front of them. Asked to speak with a manager. And this managers name is dani. Dani thought it would be a good idea to stay in her office and do absolutely nothing. This shows how worthless this individual is. I guess it pays to be the daughter of the owner. I would rather eat a frozen pizza than ever give business to this place. Why is it that as a manager you can't hold somebody responsible for their actions and fire somebody that's swearing in front of kids, but not only kids customers. read more