We went to this location for the first time when friends were in town and the food was just as good as the Sun Prairie spot, which is where we usually go, so major points for consistency. I ordered the calzone and I'm sad to report, this was not really a calzone, as the dough was only on one side and the other was a pile of cheese that was mega greasy. I won't order that again, but the pizza and appetizers for the table were great as always. Our server didn't smile or seem to enjoy their job, but maybe it was an off day. I will still come back for sure. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

Great place to come by for a hot dinner on a snowy winter night. Wild State Cider Strawberry Punch: Very bubbly had more of a cider flavor than strawberry. I couldn't taste much of the fruity scents. Specialty Pizza - Amazon Deluxe: Basically a combo pizza. Crust was fluffy and lightly buttered. Pizza is more fluffy than thin. Shrimp Ravioli with Red Pepper Cream: There's more the pasta than shrimp, bit underwhelming on seafood stuffing. To me, the red pepper cream wasn't spicy but flavorful. Garden Side Salad: Red tomato was juicy and salad was light and refreshing. Cheese wasn't too powerful and it provided a nice savory flavor. read more

See all

While visiting a friend in nearby Madison, we wanted pizza for an evening in and he recommended Sugar River, and it turned out to be a solid rec! Sugar River is located adjacent to the Costco in Verona and is a good sized spot with standard dining and a bar area with seating. We did an online order and in store pick-up, but the space was nicely laid out and clean from what we could see. Upon entry you are greeted by the pickup/order counter and host(ess) stand. Things can get a bit packed here, as this where folks are waiting to be sat, just walking in, exiting, picking up and ordering. We ordered online and pickup was about 20 minutes from order to collection. We got a 14" pepperoni and mushroom pan tossed pizza and a small cheese bread. Both were tasty, nothing wildly wrong or to the opposite, nothing mind blowing. Both were a bit too bready in places, but it wasn't all the sticks or slices, so I enjoyed some more than others. The pizza and cheese bread ran me around $24, which wasn't bad for the size and quality. Sugar River is a go to for local buddy, and after enjoying it, I can see why he keeps it on his list. Overall, solid pizza and cheese sticks, cool spot, easy ordering and pick up. read more

Sugar River Pizza - 14" Pepperoni an Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

See all

Our waiter was fantastic and funny too! Best spinach artichoke dip I've had in a really long time. The calzones are amazing and huge enough for lunch the next day! Crust is perfect and the sauce - you could just drink it lol! All of the pizzas were scrumptious too. Cute environment and clean. read more

See all

Fair prices, well cooked pizzas, and intriguing specialties. I find it interesting that they replace tomato sauce with whatever the base of the specialty calls for. For example, we got the Rio Grande bbq chicken, and typically I'd see the bbq sauce drizzled on top, but here it's fully incorporated within. My friend said it made the pizza too sauce-y, and I would agree (though I like bbq sauce so I didn't mind as much). Overall though, this is a great place with friendly service and I would definitely come back again to try some of their other flavors! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Rio Grande BBQ Chicken* - A close-up of a pizza slice featuring melted cheese, green peppers, onions, and other toppings on a white plate. In the background, a whole pizza with similar toppings is visible on a tray, with a person and utensils nearby, indicating a dining setting. - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

I haven't had pizza in forever (dieting-you know how it is). Glad I cheated here. The 10" pie is perfect for 1 person and depending how much leftovers you want, 12". They have several crusts to choose from, from variations of cracker thin to deep dish. I got the 10" Amazon on the thinnest option they had. Fantastic. Also, what a great beer selection. I also like that they do 4oz pours. Ended up tasting a few that way and one pint. Staff was very nice. We made reservations about an hour before online and glad we did, place was packed and had to park in Cabela's parking lot. Inside, it's booths, tables and high tops. Bar atmosphere. Will eat here again. read more

I'm new to Madison and this place was recommended. What a quality feast. Fresh and delicious. This pizza even heated up next day very nicely. Staff was kind and attentive too. All around very satisfying. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - A close-up of a pepperoni pizza with a golden-brown crust, melted cheese, and slices of pepperoni. The pizza is in a cardboard box, showing a mix of slightly crispy and bubbly cheese with pepperoni toppings evenly distributed. - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

Stopped here for a late lunch and we were not disappointed. We ordered the typical garlic cheese bread along with a pepperoni and olive pizza. Both items were done to perfection and came out hot like they were just pulled from the oven. The service was amazing, attentive and she made some great suggestions from the menu. The atmosphere was family friendly with kids running around having a good time. I would recommend stopping here if you are in the Madison/Verona area. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Hand tossed olive & pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

See all

The service was amazing, the food was delicious and everything we ordered was made quickly. We ordered- Bbq pizza 10inch , pesto sandwich, pepperoni pizza and cinnamon nuggets- everything was good read more

if you want pizza delivery... don't do it here... I've never ever tasted WET pizza. We got a sausage pizza but it seemed to be more of tomato pizza. I can manage some veggies but let me tell ya.. a whole tomato garden resided on EACH slice. Like I said, the pizza seemed wet... floppy with premade crust. All the toppings took a dive right off the slice when you picked it up.. really disappointing. only ate like 4 slices between the 2 of us. read more

I tried this restaurant for the first time and it is fairly priced! The pizzas were delicious and had plenty of toppings. I got the Amazon Deluxe and I added pineapples. Quick service and good pizza. I would recommend! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Amazon Deluxe* + pineapple - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

Wow! What a fantastic pizza place. Everything was sooooooo good. The service, the portions, the food! Not one single complaint. Nothing could have been better. It is worth driving 2 hours away for their pizza and salad. I had their gluten free pizza and will definitely get the taco again. The chicken bacon ranch salad was huge...and I only had a half portion. I repeat, what is shown is a HALF chicken bacon ranch salad. Go. You. Will. Not. Regret. It. Lastly, they have coke products! read more

See all

I dined in on a weekend for lunch. There was a good number of people, but still I got a seat right away. The pizzas were very innovative. Asian chicken pizza was my favorite. It had nice flavor punch. The elote pizza was another excellent pizza. Kids chicken strips was good. read more

See all

Picked up some food here while on a trip after hearing good things. Shouldn't have gotten the "stuffed" pizza. It was extremely doughy, not particularly flavorful, and overall pretty disappointing. Salad was fine. Kids enjoyed their spaghetti. I doubt I'll be back in the area anytime soon, but this was overhyped. read more

Probably one of the best pizzas in Dane County. Try the Amazon pizza if you like meat and veggies, you won't be disappointed. Excellent beer list mainly with local breweries on tap and Paulaner Pilsner from Germany which goes great with the pizzas ! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Pizza and Pauliner Pilsner from Germany - A pizza with different toppings, including meat and cheese, is placed on a metal tray on a wooden table. A glass of beer with foam is in the foreground. There are salt and pepper shakers, and other plates and utensils visible on the table. The setting appears to be a casual dining restaurant. - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

We ate dinner at Sugar River Pizza on a Friday and it was great! They have a huge menu with a lot of different options. We got a 14in pizza- half Rio Grande BBQ Chicken and half The Tropics. The restaurant was busy but we didn't have to wait too long for our food. Service was great and our meal was very affordable! We will be back! *I highly recommend a reservation, we tired to go the Friday before and it was an hour wait. But we returned the next Friday with a reservation made earlier in the day and we were sat right away! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Rio Grande BBQ Chicken* The Tropics* - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

Really good pizza and appetizers! Recommend the spinach and artichoke dip...delicious!

We ate outside in a nice little seating area. The waiter was attentive and the pizzas were delicious.

Great pizza. Awesome for larger groups. The bar is decent but not huge. Much more table seating. Great beer selection. Service has always been hospitable and efficient. Love myself a Mac daddy pizza. read more

I've been to Sugar River Pizza in New Glarus, WI and had a totally enjoyable experience. While visiting family in Wisconsin we had the opportunity to stop in at this Verona, WI. location. It in located in a nice plaza and ample parking. We had a group of 6 and the place was busy but there were open tables; so we had our choice of watching football or no tvs directly by us. We choose the later! We were greeted nicely and directed to our booth. A waiter Ethan soon addressed us and took our drink orders along with waters. We got a few appetizers of breadsticks, fried cheese curds, fried pickles, waffle fries and onion rings. Ethan was very engaged in taking good of us. Our drink arrived and shortly after the appetizers I only sampled the waffle fries and onion rings; both very good. Others sampled the rest of appetizers; all was very good and tasty. I especially liked the onion rings, nicely lightly breaded and crispy but juicy and the waffle fries were crisp and seasoned just right. Our piazzas were a kid's 6" with 1 topping carrots; a Missy Figgy small; an Amazon Deluxe and a Elote pizza. The pizza didn't take too long to arrive; every pizza seemed to be done just right and each had their distinct flavors. Yes; we ordered too much but what could be boxed was taken home for future meals. ( yum pizza for breakfast ). Ethan did a great job in taking excellent service; attending to our needs and checking on us occasionally to make sure all was good. This being my second time at a Sugar River Puzza Co. I was not disappointed. My favorite was the Amazon; the Elote too much corn and the Missy Figgy I didn't try; not a big fan of fruit on pizza unless an all fruit pizza, fresh and chilled. Highly recommend taking time out to visit this location. read more

See all

This is definitely one of my favorite pizza joints in the Madison area, and this location always gives a consistent flavor and style of pizza. The crust is always crispy and the ingredients always fresh. I've only ever done dine-in once, but it was a pleasant experience and their outdoor patio is great in nice weather! Ordering to-go is pretty simple and their online ordering website is pretty easy to navigate. I like to load the toppings on my thin crust pizza, and the crust still comes out crunchy and not overly soggy. The rest of their menu also looks very good, I've just never been able to pull myself away from the delicious pizza. Definitely something for everyone here, and always see groups of all ages. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Build your own - onions, red pepper, goat cheese, extra sauce. YUMMMM - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

After many visits I've become a fan. Their basic pizzas are good and their traditional Italian entrees are big enough for two meals. When we dine in the service is constantly good. read more

Came in for the steak sandwich. Waitress seemed to not be in a good mood. No smile. Ended up not getting the sandwich as it was out and waitress said it's hard to come by. Ended up getting the pulled pork sandwich. Not very good. After I got my food, she asked if I'd like anything else, I asked for ketchup. Come to find out I got charged 50cents for ketchup after I got my bill. I would have not asked for it if I knew I would be charged for that. Ridiculous. I told the waitress that as a suggestion, she should let people know that it is a charge so people are not surprised by it. She said, ok. Not a thanks for the tip or sorry for the misunderstanding or anything. Never going back here. read more

After a long day, we decided to stop here for dinner. The wait was about 45 minutes but somewhat understandable on a Friday night. They have a decent sized menu with a lot of options and a great tap list. Our server was friendly and stopped by a few times at the start but the visits fell off as the night progressed. We ordered the amazon pizza - pepperoni, sausage, pepper, onion and mushroom. We got the traditional hand tossed crust and it had a tough time holding up the toppings but it did its best! The sauce had a great flavor and the crust was perfect. Next time, we will probably just do 1-2 toppings but it was good. It's kind of pricey for a pie but considering the amount of toppings, it makes sense. We will probably try it again if we are in the area. read more

See all

Great pizza but can be very busy with long wait times. Highly recommended though so do takeout if there is a line

Came here after a long day of training for take out. I genuinely enjoyed how quick and easy it was to order here! I got a chicken cordon bleu sandwich, and loaded fries. Both portion sizes were gigantic! The chicken was a little overcooked but otherwise, it was great! read more

I rarely eat the crust on pizza, but I love pizza. Some brilliant chef came up with the pizza bowl at Sugar River Pizza. It doesn't seem like it would be good, but I was in an adventurous mood. I picked sausage, black olives, artichokes & mushrooms. What a taste delight!!! The service was the best. I now have my very own pizza! read more

It's good Went for lunch on a busy Sat. Wait was not too long, staff was pleasant. Good selection of options other than pizza - the ones passing buy looked like large servings and delicious. They have a huge beer selection, unfortunate I am not drinking right now otherwise I would have been tempted. An by huge I mean a four page list. We had cheese bread and a peperoni pizza, with soda. Cheese bread was great. Great enough to eat by itself for lunch or with a salad. Not sure how it is made but seemed like bread made in the restaurant, although I cannot say that for sure. We ordered the thin crust, and it as very thin.and reasonably crispy. Unfortunately the toppings like to slide off and made a knife and fork required. As it was crispy, you could not fold it like a NY slice and eat it that way - however, no points off - it is not sold as a NY style pie. I probably would of appreciated it sliced into squares rather than pie shaped. That way the pieces probably would of been small enough to eat by hand. The pizza was good, just not five stars good. Definitely good and definitely worth going back to for the food, and especially for the beer selection if I am drinking again. There are some one star reviews. Ignore them. I have had pizza from NY to San Fran, including Detroit and Chicago, and this is good pizza. Perhaps not great pizza, but certainly very good pizza. read more

Sugar River is consistently good. Pizza is tasty and I love their goat cheese marinara appetizer. They have an excellent happy hour as well. Great outdoor space. Service is friendly and welcoming. read more

Typical pizza place. We got beef pizza, Italian creek meatlovers, and Kicking Horse 4-Alarm. The crust was nice. They all just tasted like regular pizza from any pizza chain. Would say they were better than glass nickels for sure. We also go cheese curds, fried pickles and soups. Cheese curds were ok. My boyfriend liked their fried pickles. The soup was alright. Overall, very average pizza place. read more

This is an adorable little local pizza spot. They have tons of yummy creations on the menu or you can make your own. We chose to sit at the bar because they have TVs and you could watch the game while eating and drinking. The food is delicious and the staff are all incredibly happy to be there. It's definitely gonna be one of those spots. I find myself frequenting! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Elote pizza - A pizza with a golden-brown crust, topped with sliced jalapeños and melted cheese, is placed on a metal tray. The pizza appears to be freshly baked and is cut into slices. The setting includes a wooden table, a glass of beverage, and a restaurant environment with menus and other food items visible in the background. - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

This is my 2nd review for SRP. My first was over 6 years ago after they had recently opened. At that time, I stopped in for a hard to find IPA and they had such a great selection of beer. I noted at that time that I would have to try their pizza next time. Well, 6 years later and they still have an amazing selection of great beers. And I can now say after probably 50 pizzas, that their pizza is amazing! And their sandwiches, and their pasta. There really isn't anything bad on the menu. SRP has now been for many years our go to place for our family. The kids meals are so affordable, at $4/$5 each and the kids meals are awesome. REAL Mac and cheese. A grilled cheese made from the adult sliced fresh bread! And big servings for the kids. They rarely don't have extra Mac the next day. The prices are amazing for the level of service and quality of food. A side salad for $2.50? Is this 2005? Oh, did I mention the side salad is NOT iceberg! It's Spring mix with tomatoes, cucumbers, and cheese! And don't forget their homemade ranch dressing. Today I had something new, the chicken parmigiana. I would say it's not the typical red sauce and chicken on spaghetti, it's a bit different. It's fettuccini Alfredo, with a breaded chicken breast topped with marinara, and cheese. It was super tasty and I would definitely order it again. I can go on and on about Sugar River Pizza as others have as well. It's nearly 5 stars on Yelp for a reason. They source and support our local farmers and we're happy to support this locally owned restaurant as well. Congrats to the owners for continuing to run a great restaurant, with great food, happy staff, and reasonable prices! Our family will continue our patronage for years to come I'm sure. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Chicken Parmigiana - A plate features chicken parmesan topped with melted cheese, served over pasta with a creamy white sauce. A bread roll is placed on the side. The dish is on a white plate, with a glass of water and other table items visible in the background. The setting appears to be a casual dining restaurant, Sugar River Pizza, in Verona, Wisconsin. - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

This place is great!!! There was a busy crowd when I arrived with my friends but we still got seated quickly since I was with a smaller party. I ordered the Amazon pizza to share with a friend, we switched out the pepperonis and got tomatoes instead, and we shared fried cheese curds with marinara with the whole table. The food was great-- this is some good pizza!!! The cheese curds with their amazing marinara was a fun treat while waiting for the pizzas too. My other friend got the asian chicken pizza and he enjoyed it as well. We did have to wait quite a while but it was packed so it wasn't bad since we had apps to snack on. The service is incredible here!! I spoke to multiple staff there including our server, all of them were polite, courteous, and the server we had specifically was attentive and helpful with refilling our drinks and checking up on us as we ate. I'll definitely be coming back some time soon! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Fried cheese curds and marinara - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

See all

This used to be an affordable family-oriented restaurant in Verona. Most recent visit, the men's room floor looked like it was from a bus station stop. The price for my daughter and me was a shock at $36. And the nerve to ask for a tip. Chicken was good, but the sides were a disappointment. Soggy corn and green beans, soggy mashed potatoes, uninspiring salad bar, one soup offered in a paper cup. Long wait to remove soiled plates. Place seemed staffed by zombies. Not one smiling face. This is the last visit for me. I can spend $36 more wisely at a clean, friendly, good service restaurant. read more

Nice atmosphere. Very nice outdoor seating, even a fire pit for those autumn nights. The Crunch Chicken was just that: crunchy bacon and breaded chicken surrounded by a slightly spicy sauce and cheese. And I am always pleased with their pizzas! Definitely a place to take the family or just hang out. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Crunchy Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

I have been wanting to try Sugar River Pizza for years now, and I'm so glad I finally did! We went to the Verona location for Sunday night supper to celebrate my mom's birthday. They take reservations so try to make one in advance to avoid a wait. We did not have reservations and waited about 30 minutes during the supper rush, but this gave us extra time to read their large menu. To our pleasant surprise, Sugar River Pizza has way more than just pizza. Because it was our first time trying them, we decided to stick with appetizers and pizza, but we can't wait to go back to try the pasta, salads, and sandwiches too! For apps we got the fried pickles and the beer cheese dippers. Both were delicious, but the beer cheese dip stood out for how good it was. We all said we could have eaten it by the spoon! For pizza we ordered the Kickapoo beef taco pizza and the Mediterranean pizza, both with their signature hand-tossed crust. The crust was good, but next time we want to try their thin crust. Altogether, they have cracker thin, regular thin, hand-tossed, and thick. The best part about the taco pizza was that the lettuce, chips, salsa, and sour cream all came on the side (see pictures). This is ideal for leftovers and keeping it fresh! Between the delicious food and the awesome service, we had a great first experience at Sugar River Pizza and cannot wait to go back this summer and sit on the patio! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Kickapoo Taco Pizza - A cheese pizza topped with sliced tomatoes is displayed on a round metal tray. The pizza has a golden-brown crust and melted cheese. A pizza cutter is partially inserted into one slice, lifting it slightly from the tray. The setting appears to be a casual dining environment, with a wooden table visible underneath the tray and a glass of water nearby. - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

See all

The food was absolutely delicious and the service was quick. Loved the large booths and all the windows which made the restaurant so bright and welcoming. Had a ton of gluten free options. read more

See all

A classic Madison pizza stop! I always bring visiting friends and family to SRP! They have an awesome happy hour with half priced apps! I have tried many pizzas, but nothing beats the Mac n Cheese with pulled pork and bbq drizzled on top. Oh! And they have the BEST ranch ever- i would buy it by the bottle if they sold it that way. I can't wait to try their brunch sometime! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Mac n Cheese pizza topped with pulled pork and bbq drizzle - A close-up image of a pizza slice featuring melted cheese, smoked pork, and barbecue drizzle. The pizza is in a cardboard box, with part of the box visible in the background. The caption indicates it is from Sugar River Pizza in Verona, WI, and describes the toppings as Mac and Cheese pizza with pulled pork and barbecue drizzle. - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

I've been to this establishment two days back to back. Ordered pizza and salad the first go. The pizza is great and they didn't disappoint with the wings the following day. Service is great around the bar area. They are attentive and friendly. Good possibility I'll be going back again in the next few days. read more

Firstly, the food is always good here. That's not the issue. This time, the issue was the service and handling an incorrect pick up order. I'm currently sick, and my wife was bringing me a pizza after her lunch date. She was getting an Asian Chicken pizza with no onion. I'm extremely allergic to onion. She brings the pizza home for me and goes back to work. I open the box....onions. I call to let them know the news. The only thing they do is remake the pizza. I had to get my sick butt in the car and drive from Oregon to Verona to get this pizza and then drive back home. So I could enjoy my meal without getting super sick. I just feel like compensation should be a given in this situation. I don't like confrontation, so I never bring it up (except passive-aggressively on Yelp...I know, sorry). Sometimes it should just be standard practice if someone has to go out of their way to pick up an incorrect order. I don't know...maybe I'm wrong. Either way, it ruined the experience. read more