Righteous Slice: A Divine Experience for Pizza Lovers If there's a heaven for pizza, it's located right here at Righteous Slice. Forget everything you know about those run-of-the-mill, cardboard-like pizzas. The moment you step in, you're greeted by the intoxicating aroma of fresh basil, garlic, and what I can only describe as pure happiness baked to perfection. Now, the pizza. Let me tell you, this isn't just food--this is an experience. Each slice is a harmonious medley of a perfectly crisp yet airy crust, rich tomato sauce that tastes like it was kissed by the sun itself, and melty cheese that stretches just enough to make you grin like a kid on Christmas morning. And the toppings? I don't know how they do it, but that pepperoni tastes like it has been blessed by the pizza gods. But it's not just about the food; Righteous Slice nails the full dining experience. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, complete with cozy booths that make you feel like you've found a home away from home. It's a place where you can bring your loudest, giggling kids or your chatty grandparents, and they'll all feel right at ease. Now, I have to mention the owner, because no review would be complete without giving a standing ovation to the maestro behind this culinary masterpiece. This person doesn't just run a pizza joint; they curate a community. Whether they're handing out free dough balls to excited kids or cracking jokes with patrons, their friendliness isn't just customer service--it's genuine human connection. You half-expect them to sit down, ask about your day, and then somehow give you life advice that turns your whole week around. So, do yourself a favor: go to Righteous Slice. Trust me, you'll leave with a full stomach, a full heart, and a firm belief that not all heroes wear capes--some make pizza. read more

If you're searching for the best pizza in Idaho, look no further than Righteous Slice! From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. The aroma of fresh dough and bubbling cheese immediately draws you in, making your mouth water in anticipation. Now, let's talk about the pizza. Righteous Slice truly lives up to its name! Each pie is crafted with precision, showcasing a perfect balance of crispy crust, rich sauce, and high-quality toppings. Whether you prefer classic pepperoni or adventurous gourmet combinations, there's something for everyone. The flavors are bold and fresh, making every bite a delight. What sets Righteous Slice apart is not just the food but the exceptional service. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about what they serve. They're eager to help you find the perfect slice and ensure your experience is nothing short of fantastic. You can tell they take pride in their work, and it makes all the difference. If you find yourself in Idaho, make sure to stop by Righteous Slice. It's more than just a pizza place; it's a culinary gem that will leave you craving more. Highly recommended! read more

3.5/5 stars. I've been here several times and I like their pizza. It does have that flamey brick oven flavor, and the dough is good, but maybe a little too soft or floppy at times. My biggest criticism is they are pretty skimpy on their ingredients, especially on the tomato sauce. The margherita I ordered had a very thin layer of sauce that hardly extended to the crust of the pizza. It was more of a garnish than a foundational ingredient. I imagine it would be a similar story with their white pizzas... if they had sauce at all. I really only have myself to blame, because up until now I hadn't realized that is the definition of a "white pizza" - sauceless. So for any of you out there with as little culinary knowledge as I, heads up, white pizza does NOT mean it has a white sauce (as opposed to a red pizza, which has - you guessed it - red sauce). Overall it's tasty pizza, I just wish they put a little more love into it. read more

This is a great New York style authentic Italian pizza place. I've lived and traveled in Italy and New York City. Righteous Slice is the real deal: fresh toppings, delicious Italian cheese, fresh, homemade tomato sauce, on authentic Italian flatbread, all baked in a brick oven. The Margherita pizza with fresh basil is just like what you get in the best pizzerias in Rome, and just as good, if not better. And the Figgata! Che deliziosa! When you go, forget everything you think you know about pizza. American pizza is not Italian. Righteous Slice is a unique experience in Rexburg. Just imagine you're in New York City or Rome or Cortona. It's a nice diversion from the usual Rexburg fare. Thank you, Righteous Slice! The service is great. Got our pizzas quickly. read more

Huckleberry cheesecake milkshake is literally the best milkshake I have ever had. EVER. Real cream cheese mixed in, whole berries, Graham cracker crusty stuff, and it took 3 of us to finish it off. Really I come here for the pizza, though. The Che Figata is the perfect combination of sweet (fig) and the flavor that is hard to describe broadly without using the words Gorgonzola or moldy cheese. You just gotta try it. My kids love the pizza with potatoes, sausage, and arugula. If you like cheap, greasy pizza this might not be your place. If you sometimes longingly think about a pizza you once ate in San Francisco or the one you grabbed near Central Park that was just unforgettable, this place might hit the spot. read more

Best pizza ON EARTH, and I mean that literally -- all of the Neapolitan style and New York style pizzas, the huge and incredible gourmet salads, the ridiculously good dessert pizzas, and insanely spectacular shakes -- it's all so crazy good. It's best experienced as a dine-in destination restaurant! The service is typically fast and always friendly. We love the atmosphere, the authentic imported Italian pizza oven, and cool vibe too. Over a span of four years since we moved to the area, we've eaten there and have experienced the full menu countless times. And if it continues to be as consistently good as it has been for us, we'll never stop. read more

Best pizza in town-for real! The crust...I'll leave it at that You can't compare this place to any other restaurant here because it's totally unique. It kills the competition. Haven't been disappointed with anything on the menu, and trust me, we've tried almost everything. Salads are fantastic and filling. Had never tried a pizza dessert, didn't know that was a thing. They're ridiculously good. Aside from the food though, the environment is great, and the staff are really nice. I love the live music, definitely a cool vibe. If you're in Rexburg you'll want to try this place. read more

Took my family to Righteous Slice this weekend. It was busy when we got there, but our food came out hot and fast. My teenage boys are still talking about how much they loved the food! The crust was thin, perfectly cooked, and the toppings were amazing. Our favorites were the Bee Sting, Sunshine in my Soul, and the Star Witness. We loved watching them make the Star Witness pizza in front of us. So fun. SO DELICIOUS! I'm not usually a pizza fan, but I (we) can't wait to go back and try a few more things on their menu! :-) read more

Easily the best pizza in Rexburg. I wouldn't doubt it if it were the best pizza within 100 miles radius. It's that good. The owner and staff are incredibly friendly. The amount of different pizza options they have while maintaining to keep their pizza to the same standard blows my mind. The prices are fairly high, but they are completely fair. Pizzas would be flying off the shelves and quality would go down if prices were any lower. They run a smart business over there. Go. You won't regret it. read more

We have eaten at righteous slice twice and plan to return many more times! The dough they used for the pizza's is incredibly tasty and cooked well in an authentic brick oven. The sauce, fresh ingredients, and speed of service was incredible. I mentioned to the management that I would have like to have red pepper shakers at each table instead of just downstairs and they listened! This is a great small business that cares and should be supported. You have to try it! read more

Wow. This pizza is legit Neapolitan pizza. It's a bit more expensive than most places, and I can polish off one pizza by myself. However, if you are looking for authentic pizza this is the place. I am a pizza maker myself. It takes me all morning to get my own dough to this level of quality, and my oven can't bring the heat to get the same results as a real pizzeria oven. These guys have the gear, the ingredients, and the talent. This place has my respect. read more

I love Righteous Slice pizzas and dessert pizzas. The atmosphere is fun with lots of college students mixed with locals. They have a good selection of different pizzas and they are all delicious. The dessert pizza with Nutella is awesome. The sauces and crusts are so good. I thought about only giving them 4 stars because they are priced a little high for Rexburg, but I gave them 5 stars because of the friendly staff, extra tasty food, and fun atmosphere. read more

I don't go here often 'cause it's a bit expensive, but I like it a real lot. Everyone who works here is super chill. And the pizzas are good! I'd compare it to MOD. Me of my favorite things is that you can put pretty much whatever toppings you want on your pie. It's your masterpiece to create! The sky's the freaking limit! No one's gonna tell you how you can or can't style your pie! Freestyle that sucker! Follow your dreams! read more

The Food and ownership are what really make this place unique. All their pizza is made from the clay oven which essentially centerpieces the middle of the restaurant. I got the pizza with honey and Ricotta cheese? (I forgot the name) and it was very delicious. The owners there seem to genuinely care and enjoy the food that is served there. Amazing spot to go to on a date or a night out with friends. Would Recommend! read more

Love the Pizza, Ive eaten there for many times now and I have never been disappointed. I heard that some people didn't like it in the past - it is not a food chain and it is brand new so expect improvement. Every time I went the workers were nice and really fast. I like the authentic pizza, much better than anything else you can find... unless you like soggy 5$ pizza. You pay for quality, but it is worth it. read more

Great pizza, great service, 10/10 would marry this pizza. Its a great place to relax, pretty cool and stylish. The wait wasnt too bad. Their flavors are freaking good. Love it love it LOVE IT. I dont know what else to say im just speechless. They have organic options and vegeterian options for my vegan ass. They're so considerate, they make me feel at home. Thanks righteous slice! read more

Rexburg is in need of more places like this! Super cool atmosphere. So fresh and delicious. They use ingredients that are high quality and top notch. We got the Praise the Lard pizza and the hail Caesar salad both were awesome. I've had pizza all over the US - NYC, Chicago, Boston and this is right there at the top with some of the best places. Will definitely be returning! read more

When they brought out my first pizza, they said it was slightly below their standards and they'd make me another one. Now I'm walking home with one and a half large pizzas. Honestly wouldn't have noticed there was anything wrong with the first one if they hadn't said anything. (It came out slightly oblong; taste-wise it was perfect.) The commitment to quality is remarkable. read more

place was friendly , very clean very organized and the pizza is phenomenal, all hand made fresh ingredients and the pizza is all so perfect ide have to say it is the best pizza place in Idaho rexburg area , nothing better then a good ride day on the dunes and then to a great restaurant for a hand tossed pizza hands down the best service is great read more