Ok first off.... They brought a warm, fresh baked chocolate chip cookie to me BEFORE I EVEN ORDERED MY APPETIZER. Never before have I felt so seen. So understood. So welcome. The rest of the meal could have been a disaster and I would still be giving it 5 stars. But - the meal, the service (Raphael in particular) was just as good. A few favorites were the lobster roll, the sea bass, and the banana cream pie. And did I mention the cookie? We will certainly be back! read more

Stopped in on a whim for dinner when visiting the city with the fam. We did not have a reservation but we're seated promptly in the bar area. Turns out they have a live musician playing jazz piano starting at 6:30 p.m. on Fridays, we arrived just in time! Jacob the musician was great, took requests. Just really great rep from Broadway to Sabrina Carpenter jazz covers. Food was varied sushi, seafood, steaks, salads, full bar. As a family we ordered filet which was perfectly prepared, salmon teriyaki bowl which was brimming with vegetables and just what I was in the mood for! Hubby ordered the dragon roll and tuna nigiri, also really great! We took our kids 9+11 no kids menu, but they eat like adults. Yes the description says touristy, but the food and service were top notch...also we are tourists, so hey, was really lovely. Felix took fantastic care of us. I recommend and would come again. read more

See all

I picked this place for lunch because I wanted something different then the restaurants I always frequent; AVRA, Del Frisco's, Oceana, HAMA, Ocean Prime, Cuervo, Limani etc. I haven't been to this restaurant in 20 years. So imagine my surprise when we ordered the from the lunch pre-fixe. Let's start with the appetizers didn't come out at the same time, which in my opinion if they waited for the Lump Crab Cake to be done the Calamari might not have to the table fried to obliteration. It was served with jalapeno peppers that were equally obliterated but were not spicy. My colleague gets her entree and appetizer at the same time (Cobb Salad with Chicken and Lump Crab Cake. The salmon entree was bland but cooked to perfection I will say that. So for me the Lunch pre-fixe menu a 2; Service 4, Ambience 4. Will try this place one more time and if no improvement I will be sure to take them off the list to eat with clients. read more

I don't normally write reviews but...Ambiance is a solid 5 Food is a solid 4 Service for 2.5 We will try it again next time we're in New York...maybe read more

Redeye Grill - New American Near Me - New York, New York

I am deepin with sadness that this Restaurant will be closing to my understanding in July 2026. I just love this restaurant the atmosphere and the food is so divine. You never get a bad mail. I will try to go there before it closes. If not, thank you for the memories. read more

See all

Very nice inside. Our food and drinks are very good and you gotta get the dancing shrimp. Service was just OK. read more

Redeye Grill - Inside - New American Near Me - New York, New York

I had a great experience at Redeye Grill. The food was okay overall, but the miso cod --which our server Jelena recommended-- was excellent, and the banana cream pie also she recommended, absolutely superb. What truly stood out was Jelena's service. She was sweet, funny, and went above and beyond, completely elevating the night. The reason for 4 stars instead of 5 is the unwelcoming host, lack of greeting, and incorrect info at the start. The food presentation could also use a bit more effort. Still, Jelena made up for almost everything. I'd come back just for her service and that banana cream pie! read more

See all

At first, we didn't think much of Redeye Grill. The menu appeared basic, like a fancy diner. We ordered the pork chops, skirt steak, crab cake, seafood risotto, and tuna tartare. Everything was great except for the seafood risotto. Surprisingly, it lacked seafood flavors. Our waiter was very nice, efficient, and professional. I don't remember his name but he had 1 dangly earring. The live pianist / singer also gave the atmosphere a very NY vibe. Other than the elevated midtown pricing, this place is fantastic. Honestly, a 4.5 star experience. read more

October 7th 2024 wife and I walked from our nearby West 57th Street timeshare to the red eye grill. Huge place although largely empty for lunch on Monday. Great ambiance with white tablecloths napkins and decent silverware .uniform waiters. Wife's miso glazed black COd cooked tender flaky and delicious over cooked spinach and mushrooms.$47 but that's on par with what we paid at Roy's in Hawaii. Serving size about 5 oz . Not for somebody who is hungry. My $44 lobster roll came with a roll of bread with the body of a lobster attached to the top. Awesome appearance for an entree. Unfortunately most of the lobster roll was either bread or the potato salad filling although the lobster itself was great. This was our last day of our week's stay in New York City and lunch was memorable. read more

See all

The food was really good; the price is worth the vibes. The skirt steak was served with a sauce that really amplified the taste. The cheeseburger also came with a special sauce. It made the bun quite soggy and it was falling apart about 15 minutes into the meal. The fries were fresh as well and a really good addition. Service is polite and slow. The food didn't take too long but didn't come out too fast either. Everything seemed of quality and the decor is beautiful. read more

See all

Hubby and I stopped in for dinner before a show and we enjoyed absolutely everything we ate. Since the area is filled with mostly to-go lunch spots and some sit down overpriced restaurants-I wasn't sure if this restaurant would be good or just a large commercial-space with really expensive menu items. However, the food was delicious, the ambience was classically NY, and it was the perfect distance from Radio City to get to a show in ten minutes. Yes, the meals are pricey and so are the drinks-but literally everything we ate was delicious. Drinks: -pornstar martini 8/10-colorful, unique, and delicious -espresso martini 9/10-the depth of flavor was out of this world + it was pretty to look at Dinner: -dragon roll 7/10-basic, fresh, but not worth 24$ -salmon with mushrooms- 7.5/10-delicious but needed a bit more seasoning -lobster cob salad-8/10 unique take and super flavorful We seriously can't wait to come here again next time we're in the area. read more

See all

Restaurant Week menu, 3 course $60. Shrimp cocktail, seared halibut followed by strawberries. Very good. 4 stars is pushing it with respect to food quality but ambiance compensates for slightly overcooked fish. read more

Top notch service within a well established steak and seafood restaurant. Interior is warm, dark with a mix of classic and modern decor. Wine and spirit list were expansive. Signature cocktail list pretty good. I had the house old fashioned, pretty good, though I didn't taste the coffee / cocoa bitters. Appetizer selection for our table included garlic bread (fluffy dough, good seasoning, some what hard to cut in the provided cast iron dish); guacamole with lettuce slices (excellent); flat bread (also good). Menu was interesting, covering many interests (sushi, tacos, burgers, steaks and seafood entrees), which was surprising. I went for the lobster roll - well toasted roll, lined with potato salad, into which large pieces of lobster were placed - lobster was tasty, but the unusual presentation was not what I was expecting, which was a more mixed lobster; cole slaw and fries were good. Next visit I will probably go for a steak or more traditional seafood entree. All in all a good experience. read more

Redeye Grill - Lobster roll, playfully decorated with head and tail. - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Absolutely stellar service with very classic American decor! We had a fabulous lunch at Red-eye Grill, and the staff was amazing. They constantly checked to ensure that we had a good experience, and even offered some freshly baked cookies and cotton candy, on the house! Very unique experience indeed. The food itself was also wonderful. We all opted for the lunch set menu, and all the dishes were great. The crab cake was stuffed with crab, and the calamari was very crispy and well done! For entries, we all went for the fish dishes. Both the mahi mahi and teriyaki salmon were good, but the best was the salmon and wild mushrooms. The salmon was very well seasoned and delicate as well. The desserts were also good! Overall, a very amazing experience that I would highly recommend to try! read more

See all

This place screams high class but the service was MID even with a manager walking the floor and handing out chocolate chip cookies how bizarre. First of all HOW in 2025 is there no ramp to get up the steps to get in?? 2 thumbs down bc I arrived in the pouring rain on a dark and cold Sunday evening to meet my father who flew in to NY to celebrate my sisters birthday. THEY had already pre chosen this based on proximity to the hotel even tho I sent a list of great options. Fine We approach and my first thought was what is this?? A huge booty sculpture met me at the door. They had a larger than life valentines heart balloon display in the windows an impressive bar and a hostess who DIDN'T even greet my son and I as we looked around for our party. I noticed the place was not small but more like a maze of ups and downs. Anyway crowd observation everyone was super buttoned up definitely a pricier area of town. My sister IMMEDIATELY complained about the fact that they had a hard time getting in with her 2 year old and his stroller. I was disappointed. Then the cauliflower soup left a Horrible bad taste in my mouth. So bad I had to send it back and it was presented as the ONLY option... But then they sent out a clam chowder instead. I was peeved they didn't offer that first and seemed to be limiting my options. I noticed that there was no bread given as a starter and as soon as I asked the table a man arrived with chocolate chip cookies and thrust the tray towards us. My thoughts... who else touched this and I just put the cookie down and went to wash my hands confused. The dancing shrimp were head on hard fried not juicy like I expected but so interesting that we just had to order one for the table. The salmon was supposed to be over a cauliflower purée did they exclude it bc I complained about the soup? That's is NOT the largest steak you serve IMPOSSIBLE. My son ordered the steak au jus and thru got that right. But our snooty little I know it all waiter for got the bernaise for the steak promised to bring it out and never did he kept making slight errors (no one is perfect) and everyone at the table was like don't say a word bc they didn't want him getting in trouble with the floor manager. Booo Anyway dessert looked awesome I did not partake, romantic ambiance and no no street parking. 2/5 invest in a ramp immediately how in the world are disabled folks supposed to get up the stairs? Hey some tongs and serve the cookies don't let ppl touch the tray. The dessert menu had everyone's eyes lit up like Xmas except the birthday girl. She said the huge slice of banana cream pie they served her didn't hit the mark. But my son's vanilla ice cream and my dad's blackout chocolate cake did look and taste amazing. I would not recommend that you split the steak for 2. read more

Redeye Grill - New American Near Me - New York, New York

The food was great! The service fabulous ...But the homemade cheesecake was absolutely amazing! Next trip to NYC? More cheesecake please read more

Redeye Grill - Cheesecake - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Quintessential New York feel, classy, fun music, and a fantastic meal! The service was top notch, too. I wanted to take my mom and my aunt somewhere where they could have a fun NYC experience, and I'm so glad I took them here! I ordered the crab cake burger, the buttermilk onion rings (in place of the fries), and we shared the Dancing Shrimp between us. No regrets! I will absolutely be eating here again! read more

Redeye Grill - Dancing Shrimp - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The food menu here is wonderful. The restaurant also participated in New York Restaurant Week which can be a real treat. The host answered questions and provided hospitable service. The vibe is somewhat upscale with a dozen to earth feel. Try it out! read more

See all

Redeye Grill, perched across from Carnegie Hall, is a restaurant that knows exactly who it's targeting. Tourists snapping photos before curtain call, business diners in for a corporate lunch, theatergoers looking for a convenient bite. If you don't fall into one of those categories, you may wonder why you're even here. The room itself has undeniable polish: plush banquettes, polished brass, and on weekends, live music that brings a gentle warmth to the space. It's easy to imagine why tourists find it appealing, it looks and sounds the part of "New York dining." Service, on my visit, was beyond careless. Dishes were forgotten (twice) and when reminded, our waiter brushed it off with a joke rather than a fix. It set the tone for an evening that hovered around irritation. The food? Adequate, but utterly forgettable. My steak frites arrived competently seared but without much character, the kind of plate you can find and often better executed at a dozen other brasseries. The much touted garlic loaf was very basic and frankly should be complimentary given its status. To its credit, the live music adds a certain charm, and for those in need of a pre-theater bite in the neighborhood, Redeye Grill may be serviceable. But for anyone seeking a destination meal, Manhattan offers far more compelling options. Redeye Grill, ultimately, is a restaurant of convenience, not conviction. read more

I stopped in on a Sunday night and sat at the bar. It was crowded which is always a good sign. I ordered the little gem Caesar salad with Portuguese anchovies and it was out of this world delicious. It was so crisp and the anchovies were so fresh. I also ordered the salmon as an entree. It was fresh and tasted great. I finished everything on my plate. The service at the bar was really good , too. The man who waited on me was friendly and nice. I liked this place and plan on returning... no complaints from me here. I want to go back for that amazing salad with those anchovies! read more

We celebrated our anniversary here with our two daughters. The entire staff from the host to all our waiters served us with high service, smiles, and great professionalism. The food was delicious but the staff went above and beyond to make our visit an exceptional experience!! The ambiance with the live piano music increased the experience. Thank you Redeye Grill for the amazing service! Bravo!!! read more

This is a cute neighborhood spot that my friend loves. We shared the sushi and lobster mac and cheese while the live music played. The bar area is right in front, so it is hard to miss the grand piano. The service was top-notch and attentive. I felt like we had great treatment. The Lobster Mac and Cheese meal was very generous. I had enough to take home for seconds. It is a nice place to drop in and get dinner or just relax at the bar while live music plays. read more

Redeye Grill - Dragon roll - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great food, adequate service. This was the first time we didn't feel like we mattered as customers. Sorry (not sorry) if being there was a bother to our server (blonde with tattoos). It's my associate's birthday! "mmmm... happy birthday then" in a muttered, muffled tone. We had the prix fixe menu for restaurant week. Starting with an additional sushi roll (which was tasty) we each had the house salad - a complex mix of lettuce, cheese, candied walnuts, and more. Then we each had the salmon, cooked perfectly with a sear on the skin and a moist, pink middle. Delicious. Food = Great Service = mmmm, adequate, I guess. Ambiance = it wasn't busy, so it was surprisingly quiet. I've been here before and I'll certainly be back. But not feeling welcomed actually has put me off a bit (and that's why it's a four-star vs. five-star review). read more

As soon as we walked in, we were greeted like we were old friends & felt welcome. The oysters on the half shell were so fresh & looked so good, the diners next to me complimented them - the spicy margarita DID NOT disappoint, & when it was time to go our waitress brought us a flute of champagne, and another waiter was passing out chocolate chip cookie bites fresh out of the oven. Whole dining experience was like eating with family, & I will definitely be back the next time I'm in NYC read more

Food and service were very good. We enjoyed our dinner. Our waiter was informative and efficient. Roasted chicken was moist.

Shoutout to Alton for going above and beyond. Super welcoming, great energy, and very attentive without hovering. He gave fantastic recommendations and made the whole night feel special - Thank you Alton! read more

WOW, we had the best experience here for my friend's birthday dinner. The staff were incredible, sweet attentive and even brought out cotton candy for my friend's birthday. All of the food was incredible aside from the truffle mashed potatoes. The lobster mac and cheese was INCREDIBLE. The burger was delicious and my friend got the steak which she loved. They had live music and the performer was phenomenal. All around fantastic experience, beautiful restaurant, amazing staff and great food. What more can you ask for? read more

See all

Simple put staff at the Redeye Grill lack maturity and certainty not the maturity expected at a venerable place like this. Not reading the requests for reservation. Not asking if we have a show...we did. Not knowing the difference between balsamic vinegar vs a vinaigrette dressing. Not offering salt/pepper with a salad. Not following up on if chef could make a modification to an entree. Food runner did know who had which entree having to "go fishing. Having to be reminded to bring a desert menu or refill teas (twice). Wasn't expecting customer service perfection but would have appreciated service better than a fast food restaurant. Beet salad, seafood pasta (wine butter sauce instead of tomato base) and lobster roll were okay. Shrimp overcooked in pasta and it was light on lobster and lobster in roll was anemic and adding potato salad as a filler is a sin. Banana cream pie was very, very good. Btw, ambiance is great with a lot to see and generally a great vibe with tablec cloths, lots of rework and the classic sculpture of the woman opening the wine bottles. read more

See all

After a walk in Central City park we couldn't have had a better spot to people watch in very comfortable outdoor seating for a few beverages before heading out for dinner. Prosecco was priced reasonable. Tip: make sure you ask for the happy hour menu, they don't advertise it. Service was top notch! read more

Redeye Grill - Menu - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We had dinner here for our anniversary. Our server Andrew was very professional and friendly. The food was very good, I highly recommend the French dip sandwich and the chocolate cake. The piece of cake was enormous and delicious, we couldn't finish it and we shared a piece! Highly recommend if you are staying near Broadway. read more

Redeye Grill - My beautiful wife, on our anniversary - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Brunch was the perfect mix of sweet and savory. Everything had low salt but was still flavorful and fresh. We especially loved the crab cakes and the pancake--fluffy and enormous like a Dutch baby! Friendly service and a calm ambiance made for an excellent late brunch. read more

Redeye Grill - Beautiful restaurant - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Food was ok, once we were finally brought some. Waiter was mostly absent while 3 adjacent tables were loudly complaining about him, something I've never experienced in many years of dining out. When waiter was nearby, he was engaging in arguments with the complaining customers! WHAT?! Service took WAY too long, bread never appeared despite our asking twice, while waiter hung out across the room with apparently nothing to do! Amazing! Who's in charge here? It was my first time at the Redeye Grill. I'd perused the menu beforehand, so knew the prices were a little higher, but expected attentive service for the extra price. NOPE! Never coming back. read more

What I expected before walking in here was not the reality of my visit. I was anticipating a classic diner, 1950s style. I was wrong. Like really wrong. It was much more upscale than I pictured. It was a pleasant surprise and experience. I started with the clam chowder. While it was delicious it was a small portion for the price. Out came my cashew brussel sprouts. They had an excellent flavor and sweet glaze. I enjoyed them and it was a nice sized portion. I would say that on my next visit I would ask them to be a little crispier but that is just my preference. Finally was the watermelon salad. What a perfect dish! Refreshing a with a mix of all the right components. A little sweet, salty ,crisp and balanced. The service was fine. They also gave our Hilton Grand Vacation discount with no issues. A little pricey but it was convenient to our hotel and we wanted something new. I would come back. read more

See all

New Loved this place. Super fun and lively, great music set the scene with a DJ who was awesome, spinning. And then there is the welcoming from the Host and staff. You feel wanted and appreciated for dining here. There are so many great food items on the menu, great seafood spot for sure. The salads rock from the little gem ceasar to the greek. Don't forget the baked loaf of garlic bread, and the main dishes are unique and really well prepared. The scallop crusted catch of the day was so so good, served with clams in a great broth. The crab cakes were really tasty and well prepared. Our server was great and super friendly and accommodating. overall a great place. read more

Didn't think much of it from outside but inside is a whole another story! This is an awesome restaurant. We were staying across the street and saw it from our window every day. Finally on our last night, we decided to try it out and so glad we did! First of all they have live music - this was Saturday night. This lady was singing beautifully and playing piano. Really nice! Secondly they have these murals on the wall although some of the depictions on there are quite interesting lol. Thirdly the cozy atmosphere because of the beautiful lighting and decor and comfortable seating really makes this a great space. We ordered a few dishes and shared between three of us - iceberg lettuce salad, spinach salad, flatbread and sushi. Everything was great. They even brought over a huge tray of fresh baked cookies and we could each take one - they went table to table. I asked for hot water and they brought a cute little kettle of it with a cup. Overall great experience here, definitely recommend! read more

See all

We stopped in for lunch after a morning in Central Park. There was no wait, which might have been our first clue, but reviews looked promising. I ordered the lobster roll. Nice presentation. The coleslaw was not very good and the side salad was basic. The lobster roll was okay. Bread was tough and kind of overtook the dish. My son ordered the brick chicken. Do not recommend. The chicken was bland, and the dish advertises truffle potatoes. He got maybe three small slices of fingerling potatoes at the bottom of the dish. Not worth it for a nearly $40 plate. My husband ordered the crab and avocado salad. The crab meat was minimal. The best thing at the table was the garlic bread or my youngest son's buttered noodles with Parmesan. Our server was kind and attentive, at least. And to be fair, we didn't voice our issues with the manager. For the quality of food compared to the price, we would not recommend. I get that it's midtown. I know it's expensive. But you'd find a better meal in one of the many cafes or hole-in-the-wall joints that crowd the corners. read more

Redeye Grill - Lobster roll, coleslaw, side salad in place of fries. Husband ordered the crab and avocado salad. - New American Near Me - New York, New York

10/10 great food, fabulous martinis, incredible staff. Vibe on point. Thanks for the great experience read more

Redeye Grill - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Enjoyed my first time experience here last week. We came early for a work related brunch. We were welcome warmly upon our arrival. Food is good, fresh & delicious. I had caesars salad, salmon, roasted veggies, & cheesecake for dessert. Servers are efficient & helpful. Clean bathrooms are clean. The venue is classy with flowers & interesting art on its walls. It is also spacious, compared to most places in midtown. Recommends this place especially for bigger groups & special occassions. read more

See all

The food can be tasty and pleasant, and the decor is fun but the prices are truly in keeping with Tines Square-a little on the rich side. Save it for a big family event read more

Delicious food! Excellent professional service! High quality! I highly recommend the Red Eye Grill! read more

Redeye Grill - The best lobster mac & cheese! - New American Near Me - New York, New York