"NY Style Pizza on MLK & University in Durham" I've actually been coming here on and off for 20 years, so I was surprised to see that I'd never reviewed it. It's solid NY-style pizza in a strip mall. You can order online or in the store at a counter, and they'll fix your pizza (or slices). I will say they always seem to overestimate how long it'll take to prepare, which is better than underestimating. Service is good and friendly. There's some seating inside, but not a lot, and not very inviting-- the place is definitely made for takeout. Quality is good. Some don't like the crust (it's a bit "tough"), but the advantage to it is it's easy to fold and eat without falling apart, like some other pizzas do. Toppings seem fresh. And prize is reasonable-- just under $20 before tax and tip for a 16-inch. They do have a vegan cheese option for a slightly higher price, too, but I've never tried it. Also a gluten-free option. Not the best pizza in the world, but solid if you are looking for some NY-style pizza, fast, easy, and relatively cheap. read more

The original Randy's in Durham. I remember when it first opened, and Randy himself made the fantastic pizzas and calzones. Oddly, this location has, over time, become the weakest of what is now a local chain of pizzerias. When I visited, a few years ago, it was extremely bad -- the dough was badly undercooked, and raw in places, among other issues. It's somewhat better than that, now, at least (all different employees -- all of whom were nice and also efficient). My slice was a bit under-reheated (a typical issue in the Carolinas). It was also under-seasoned and needed a lot of salt/pepper/parmesan help to get it to a passable state. For now, you're much better going to the other Randy's locations (the Miami Blvd one has been top notch for a few years). And, if you're really lucky, if you go to a location and Randy himself, or his son, is making the pizza (or has visited recently), it will be excellent. A little unfortunate that the original location is now a weak link. Still better than any national chains, though! read more

This is my go to spot near by now when I want a steak and cheese. Nice prices, good portion, and always tasty. We have ordered a white pizza here before as well and we enjoyed it, just your classic NY style pizza. I recommend ordering ahead to skip the wait. read more

Randy's Pizza - Steak & Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

See all

The pizza was fresh and had a great taste to it. The service was also friendly. I felt like the price versus what I got was great value.

Love the flavor and the service was top notch! Can't wait to go back while we are working in Durham!

Love this place! Delicious and huge slices! My daughter insisted I leave this! Out of things to say!

Pizza is the best and steak n cheese subs are amazing plus service is friendly. Reminds me of the small pizza places from up north in the Boston area. A+++++++ read more

Randy's on MLK Jr Blvd is the best of 3 Randy's I have frequented more than once. The Pizza's we ordered were one with Pepperoni & Cheese, the other was with peppers, onions & meat with olives, etc. The Pepperoni revealed a good sauce, not bitter, not sweet but real perfect for pizza. The pepperoni was fresh, the crust to the pizza tasted like real pizza crust not uncooked flour dough. The delivery service was on point & fast. The vegetable & meat pizza, I found the meat a little salty, & the vegetables made the pizza a little soggy, but still okay to eat. We also ordered a Steak & Cheese, which was very good. This had nice flavor, wasn't soggy with grease, you don't find this much. I do indeed intend to order from them again, and I do recommend trying them over the others. Keep up the good work guys. read more

Favorite pizza spot in Durham since growing up so now every time I come home to see my family, we have to order Randy's at least once!! Always great customer service, can't beat the NY style pizza and the sauce is just right - not too heavy but tasty however not over powering the toppings even with a good ol' plain cheese pizza which is what we ordered tonight! This location is right in the shopping center on MLK with plenty of parking and easy access stop right after going to the grocery store or even the movie theater next door! May not look too fancy on the outside or inside but it's your local pizza place, what matters is the food, speed of readiness and the overall quality experience from the staff!! Check it out, I've never been disappointed and have been going here for 20 plus years!! read more

See all

There are 6 entries in Yelp for Randy's Pizza. I am writing specifically about location on GUESS ROAD, on the edge of the defunct Northgate Mall. The Northgate store is a lot cleaner and cheerier than the last time I was there in 2021. The sit-down area is newish but still basic and boring. The menu board is electronic which means you have to wait for screens to flip in order to see the whole menu (or ask multiple questions of the cashier). Menu has expanded to include more pasta, salad, and dessert items. Sicilian thick crust is listed right up with the thin NY crust, no longer hidden as a footnote. True to online advertising, this location did serve the largest slices in town (photo). Crust was chewy but did not have that fine crackle that arises when coated generously with olive oil before baking. The sauce and cheese topping was rather bland for my taste, but at least it was low-salt and not excessively greasy. For the price, the slices were good value. Good neighborhood joint for bringing kids or coworkers for a quick bite. [ An employee there told me that 2 Durham locations are not part of the Randy's chain, even though they use the Randy's name (??). In the past, I had noticed a difference in recipes and pricing depending on the location. ] read more

Randy's Pizza - a slice of cheese pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

They have really big slices which I love and just a solid pizza slice. Nice crust nice flavor sauce isnt sweet and if you get your pizza hit you'll always have a cheese pull. I made the mistake of ordering a pie in one of the lower sizes and won't do that again. Unless it's a specialty pizza only order 16" and above so you can get those big slices. Love the overall standard pizza joint feel from this place and in being in NC for 2 years I only have 2 pizza restaurants menus and they are one of them. read more

While visiting my aunt in Durahm/Duke, NC, my aunt brought us to this cute, little, pizza restaurant. She wanted to share one of her favorite pizza spots, that come close enough to remind her of home (NY). She says (It's the closest thing to NY style pizza out here). After devouring a large slice of the cheesy, pepperoni, and sausage, I agree. It comes remarkay close to the famous NY pizza's. All the ingredients including the spices are freshly cut, and never frozen. The freshness of the ingredients really does make a big difference, on how delicious the pizza turns out. I'm saddened that we only bought one, because after we got back to her place, the three of us ate the entire box in about thirty minutes. read more

See all

Local chain - this store seems to be well-loved in the neighborhood. People entering were sometimes greeted by name. I ordered a calzone and two pies for a family event. Found the crust to be very limp and the sauce to be almost nonexistent. Toppings were mostly clumped in the center, so there was a full inch or more of crust with no cheese or sauce around the outer rim. Meh. read more

First had this on a late night . I'm not sure why I ordered one slice but I was dying for more so much that I went back the next day for two slices ! I love the large thin cheese slices ! So good , so much flavor ! Thank you for being open right now ! We greatly appreciate it ! read more

Randy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

I'll start positive. Pizza looks good, nice and hot, great presentation. I won't go back though because The pizza was tasteless. Barely any sauce if any. Waaaaay too cheesy. Customer service was horrible. read more

Randy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

So glad we ordered our Friday night pizza from Randy's - it was delicious! The sausage they use on the Supreme was a bit spicy, which we liked. We're in the area often for medical visits, so you can count on us being back. read more

Randy's Pizza - 16" Supreme minus 2 pieces - Pizza Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Randy's is my go to pizza place! Everything is amazing. The pizza, wings, garlic knots, and salads are all great. The employees are super friendly, and everything is done quickly whether I order for pickup or delivery. Their rewards program is also really great. I feel like I always have a reward for free garlic knots! read more

Our family loves Randy's! They are always super quick but quality, and you can tell they use fresh ingredients. Since we're regulars we've gotten to know the staff a bit and they are really sweet and welcoming. Our go to pizza place, we wouldn't have it any other way! read more

I am originally from NY, and nothing comes close to authentic NY Style pizza like Randy's! The food is excellent-- my go-to order is an 18 inch (yes, 18 inch!!) Elia's Classic Greek pizza, garlic knots, and a Caesar salad with grilled chicken! The friendliness of the staff, fresh food, and consistency of the food quality makes Randy's the best pizza you can find in the Triangle. During the weekend evenings in the summer, you can sit out on the Randy's patio and enjoy live music performances while enjoying your dinner-- perfect for small get-together's with friends and family. Be sure to call in your order in advance! Randy's is a popular spot, and you may need to wait a while if you walk in during the dinner rush. read more

I went to Randy's in the middle of a Sunday afternoon. There was plenty of table space. I ordered 1 slice of cheese pizza and 1 slice of pizza with bacon chicken pineapple. The bill came to slightly over $9 with taxes. The pizza came out fast. They were perfect massive thin crust New York style slices. I couldn't finish both slices. They were absolutely delicious- probably my favorite New York style pizza spot. read more

Randy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

See all

Randy's is a Durham gem and this specific location is The Original. I've been coming to this Randys since they opened and the consistency of the food and familiarity of the staff says a lot about Randy as the owner. We typically get a combination of pizza, boneless wings and their subs. Love them all and it's a weekly staple for our family. read more

Randy's is the best pizza I've found done here that even resembles North pizza. (I'm from PA) I would give it 5 stars, but I'm not a fan of their gluten free pizza. I've recently been gluten free and was happy they had that option, but the crust just isn't where it's at. It has a weird grit like texture to it when you get pieces that aren't crispy. Additionally, their website was a little misleading. It had shown a pizza that looked similar to regular pizza but obviously smaller, and that is not what I got. I ended up dealing with the future consequences and eating the regular pizza that we also bought. Sorry stomach. read more

Randy's Pizza - What I thought I was getting - Pizza Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

See all

Best pizza in Durham!!! Love love love their pizza Their wings are also very good and they are consistent.

I stop in here every year or so, and most recently a month or so ago. A lot of folks from the area love this place, and I agree that it's definitely best fresh - like in the shop fresh. I normally get carry-out, and it's a solid pizza but not amazing. Lasagna pizza is good, with the meatballs and ricotta being quite tasty. Often grab some pepperoni (really recommend doing a double as single is pretty scant) and kalamata olive pizza as well, which is also a winner here. The garlic knots are a bit variable quality-wise. Sometimes super flavorful, sometimes rather dry and tasteless. When they're good, they're incredible, but I think I've given up on these after my last trip in. read more

The pizza is delicious! Very well made! Crust, cheese, toppings all very very good! Their cannolis are also delicious!! Very happy with this particular location!! Keep up the great work. The staff was very nice as well! read more

Charged me for a salad I didn't get. I saw receipt in email. When I tried to tell them what happened when I called, they first hung up on me 'by accident', then the guy who never gave me his name or position kept interrupting me when I tried to tell them. They said they couldn't see the charge in their system and wouldn't accept my offer to email the proof of the receipt that I had been charged. They said the receipt I got by email was just a mistake--I have NEVER received a 'mistaken' receipt for a 'nonexistent' charge that when I checked was also showing up on my credit card. The manager kept interrupting me and wouldn't let me finish my explanations. I will definitely use a different Randy's moving forward because these people are rude and unhelpful. I hope I can get my money back disputing the charge with my credit card company because otherwise I paid $45 for an 18" pizza. So ridiculous. Especially considering too that the pizza was given to me 10 minutes after the pick up time when it was supposed to be ready. Such poor customer service. read more

What the heck has changed about this location? We got an XL pepperoni pie tonight. The crust was so tough it was difficult to chew. It hurt our teeth! My 2 year-old is pizza obsessed and she couldn't even eat it. A complete waste of money. read more

Yummy! In town for the weekend and watching the playoffs so we were looking for some good pizza. We got half NY White with spinach and chicken and the other half pepperoni. Pizza was good but pepperoni side could've had a little more sauce for my husband and my side tasted a little bland. Like there wasn't enough garlic sauce. Nonetheless, it was good. read more

Randy's Pizza - Half NY white with spinach and chicken and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Randy's has the best pizza in the area in my opinion. The only thing I don't like is they have veal on the menu (at least the online menu). Do me a favor Randy's manager/owner- go spend time at a slaughterhouse and watch a baby calf getting slaughtered. Make sure you pet the calf too bc they like affection. I am just hoping more restaurants will actually go see what their flippant choice of serving it actually mean. Thank you. read more

I don't know what it is about their huge, greasy, floppy slices of pepperoni pizza, but I can't get enough. The restaurant itself is really casual and small with only a few tables, but it's great if you just want a quick slice or a to-go order. read more

Very average pizza. Crust and cheese were too chewy and was not flavorful. Not a friendly staff. They seem like they hate their jobs. I love going to places with a little enthusiasm because it's contagious. Prices were reasonable but still a bit too much given the quality. Most places are $2 or $2.50 a slice but this place is $3+ a slice for very mediocre pizza. Now, I'm a ranch with my pizza kind of person and so I really appreciate a place that will give you ranch with your pizza upon request free of charge so it really rubbed me the wrong way when I asked for ranch and they told it would be a $.50 charge for a little cup of ranch...after I had already paid. At that point, just satisfy the customer and give them what they want instead of making them go through the haste of swiping their card for fifty cents...no thanks. Only come here if you're desperate. There are better options. read more

Great NY style pizza, hot and cold subs, pasta as well as other Italian cuisine, being calzones, my favorite ham and cheese. Salads and garlic knots round out menu. Their NY cheesecake with or without real strawberry topping is SOO good, without question some of best in Durham. Voted Best of the Traingle by the Indy in 14, 15 and 2016! Small but cozy dining room is always bustling with a crowd, including a small outdoor dining area. Fast, friendly service makes Randys one of our favorite, pick up or delivery, pizza joints in town!!! Free parking and wheel chair accessible as well as restrooms read more

See all

I would avoid this place. Their prices are unreasonable and the quality of the food is not very good. I have been here a few times previously and have had mixed experiences. I tried to order a large two-topping pizza last year. They had to repeat my order multiple times over the phone before getting it correct. They hung up the phone before I could ask the total price. When I went to pick up, they wanted $38 (after a discount). I ended up walking out of the store. The quality of their pizza is not worth near $40. This year: I thought I would give them a second shot and ordered wings and a Gyro. The chicken wings clearly had freezer burn on them and they were soaked in runny hot sauce. Rubbery, soggy, and horrible outside texture. I ended up throwing them in the garbage. read more

Randy's Pizza - Freezer burned wings soaked in hot sauce. Soggy, rubbery, and bad texture. - Pizza Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

I liked this place. Pizza was good. Little on the greasy side for the cheese. Super thin as I like it. Little bit of a flop. Would go back read more

Randy's Pizza - Cheese and supreme slice - Pizza Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Had a vegetarian pizza w extra cheese delivered and it was superb. The pizza did not disappoint at all! Loved that it truly did remind me of NY style pizza. The Great: The food is always delivered on time by very friendly people. I would give Randys the entire 5 stars except for the bread on the chicken philly being burned so I couldn't enjoy or recognize the flavor to give it any kind of review. But honestly everything else I've ordered has been superb. On time and rad people bringing food with a smile and personality. I will still order from them! Idk about the Philly, tho (I love that sandwich too much, lol) read more

Pizza and calzone were very delicious...hot wings were ok but could have been hotter they weren't even tangy at all but other than that everything was good! read more

So so bad... the woman taking our order with the "mike" neck tattoo was taking personal phone calls the whole time yelling at Mike on the phone ... food was terrible and the whole restaurant was so disgusting and dirty... never coming back read more

I know there is a wing shortage but over $16 for 10 wings is a RIP OFF! If I had known the price before ordering over the phone, I definitely would not have bought them. read more

I have been the Durham location on MLK multiple times and they are awesome. Wonderful customer service and food. My fave is their white pizza. They typically have a special going on (look at the online menu). Some of the best pizza I've ever had! read more

Would give 3.5 stars. We picked up takeout from here but they also deliver. We got the meat lovers pizza, garlic knots, and chicken Parmesan. Food was great and reasonably priced. We enjoyed the pizza and were pleasantly surprised the chicken parm was better than we were expecting from a pizza shop. read more

Randy's Pizza - Chicken Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

See all