That was surprisingly delicious! Tucked away in the New Hope Commons shopping center. The owners are nice and friendly. They took my order right away. The fries was quite delicious! I don't know what they put in it but it's tasty! It's almost has this buttery like flavor to it. Impressed for something as simple as fries. The white pizza was on point. The crispness of the edges paired well with the garlicky goodness, cheese, and white sauce. I miss ordering by the slice! It sure reminds me of New York style pizza in Manhattan. Honestly, I think it's as good. Happy to find this location! I've been to the other locations before too. read more

See all

Check your receipt, check the actual food order. I prefer to support businesses that have good vibes and aren't trying to trick you out of your money. They made several mistakes with my takeout order at a slow time of day. I find it suspicious since both of the mistakes were in their favor. 1) Ordered 3 pies, and they charged me for 4. As a customer, be sure to slow down and check the screen before you pay. They were definitely counting on me rushing through the order screen to tap my card. 2) Ordered 2 sides, they gave me 1. It was packaged up tight, so unless I slowed down to actually open the bag and check, I would not have seen they shortchanged me. They were counting on me being in a hurry to leave with the takeout and not checking. This was patently obvious once I came back to ask for the missing 2nd order. They hadn't even prepared it and didn't acknowledge their mistake. They really thought they were being sneaky. And frankly, that is the most insulting part!! I didn't eat the food (it was for a friend's big family), but the experience left enough of a bad taste in my mouth that I didn't need to. Not returning. read more

who can afford this price and why would i pay this price for just a cheese pizza with 3 more toppings i want read more

See all

*Don't let the negative reviews turn you away!* I read the first few recent reviews prior to going in and was somewhat hesitant but went in despite - some people just like to complain and be heard. I was greeted as soon as I got to the register and the gentleman helping me, Eduardo, was so patient with me and helpful and just seemed genuinely happy to be there and help me figure out what to order. I was planning on getting just a slice of cheese pizza and unfortunately they didn't have a pie made and I assume since it was close to closing time on a Monday night they were not planning on making any more pies which is fair enough. When he said they didn't have any slices (or pies to offer a slice from), Eduardo went above and beyond to help me get what I wanted with what they had to offer. They had one more cheese personal size pie left and he explained the meal special that I could get with that (I think it was up to 2 additional toppings, salad or fries and a drink for $11 something but don't quote me on that) and as someone that has worked multiple cashier/sales/customer service positions I can genuinely appreciate the effort he made to help me get what I wanted with what they had to offer. Also, I got a slice of cake and asked what his favorite flavor was and I can second that the Oreo cake slice is to die for!!!! Overall, it was a great experience- a very clean, welcoming establishment with employees that are kind, helpful and genuine. Definitely will have to return :) Thank you Eduardo and the other gentleman that made sure I had been helped and was so sweet to ask if I needed a hand or spare bag since my hands were full before I got my order !!! read more

I've been several times and service friendly however crust is tasteless but it is quick when you need a quick bite in the area. They also fall short on cleanliness, mens restroom was not clean and instead of buying soap for customers to use they added water to the old soap container. If a restaurant can't clean the bathroom when four people are working and only 4 customers are eating. That is purely lazy on behalf of ownership/management. It also makes me question the ability to clean the kitchen. Hopefully this will help them make a turn for the better so paying customers will come back and not feel like warning others about the experience. Happy to change the review if things are clean on my next stop through. read more

The food is amazing! the service is good. no it's not a romantic type Italian eatery, but for the quality and price of food I don't care! i ate lasagna at another place "with ambiance". It was $9 more per serving did not include anything. Here it included a salad other place had a mandatory 18% tip. not here. definitely try you will not be disappointed. we drove all the way from knightdale to eat here! read more

I Love Ny Pizza - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

absolutely awful service. These were genuinely the most rude workers I have ever encountered in my life. I WILL NEVER support this business again. read more

Very much a hole in the wall local spot. My two boys love the atmosphere and decorations. There is a diverse group of customers that flocked to this place during lunch hours. We went during a weekday so you have all sorts of clientele that come in from shopping in the strips center to weekday employees stopping by for lunch. there was plenty of seating in the booth and ample amount of space. Definitely wheelchair/stroller accessible. Restrooms are clean! Employees are polyglots, including English in Spanish. I got the 10 wings, they were absolutely wonderfully cooked. The chicken was juicy and tender, and the outside of the wings were almost air fried, very crispy and airy! The pizza is amazing, i'm not one to dictate the difference in pizza because I really can't tell. But this place had amazing Sicilian pizza. The crust was perfectly cooked and held its shape and the breading of the pizza was soft and moist and did not collapse with the sauce and cheese. Slices are huge! ranch is delicious. I think it's homemade. They also have homemade lemonade and strawberry lemonade next to the fountain drinks. 10/10 recommend! read more

I Love Ny Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

See all

Having started coming back when I'm in the area after all these years, each time, I was pleased with the service. The food is some of the best within public transportation distance in the area. I showed a former Google Review from the Summer to one of the employees Junior and they gave me a complimentary slice of tuxedo cake. I hope Ali and/or Junior are my/our servers in the future. Since I have started going back, I have only had good experiences here. read more

I Love Ny Pizza - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Best pizza in the area. I highly recommend this pizza place. Good service. And friendly staff read more

See all

I was doing some errands on Durham and had dined at this place, pizza was okay not the best one i ever had but it was fine for what i paid. I don't think I'm coming back any time soon. read more

I Love Ny Pizza - Hawaiian Pizza and Veggie Pizza - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Absolutely incredible pizza. While I'm not from NY, the restaurants namesake affinity with the Big Apple is thankfully spot on. The flavors are distinct and true to what you'd think of a slice. Perfect crust- something I've not had here in NC. Very personable owner.... I can't say enough about how much we enjoyed our 8 slices. Whatever you do, their white pizza is a must for all garlic lovers! read more

I almost didn't come here because some of you teabags gave it one stars and a bunch of petty criticism. But I'm from New York City and I'm gonna give these guys a shout because the pizzas about 80% New York City and undoubtedly the best you're going to get in this rural area if you're looking for true New York City by the slice pizza. I'm so glad I came in here despite some of the negative reviews and encourage others to come in as well. Legit read more

See all

My cousin and I were visiting from out of town and found this place near our hotel tonight. What a find! Cozy atmosphere, good friendly quick service, decent prices. We had the chicken Alfredo and chicken broccoli Alfredo. Served hot and more than enough on the plates. And the buttery garlic knots could be a meal alone. Melt in your mouth. Rest assured when we're back in Durham this is our go to place. read more

As a resident of NYC "ILNP" is passable. Slices are generous but that's about it. Please pay more attention to how pie looks and it's uniformity - we eat with our eyes first! read more

the place needs to be sprayed , shut down , torn down , and built back up again . also the owner i believe should be replaced . you tell him about a roach , he responds as if he has them at home . I went in the beginning of 2024 , found a roach in my ice cup , and haven't been back since read more

I arrived to pick up an order I placed through Yelp, which I think is GrubHub, they did not have the order. They quickly made it, were super apologetic and friendly! I wasn't in a hurry and appreciated the team moving quickly to make my pizza. Cool people. read more

I can't make this stuff up. Third place in a row and no customer service!! No greeting no hello, just staring dumbfounded. I was standing behind a group of guys who seemed like they were waiting but they were just waiting for food. A lady walks past me and goes up to the person at the register and asks him for something. And still nothing was said to me. I've never been here before! How the hell am I suppose to know where to go or that I have to hunt someone down and make you take my order. If you don't want business then fine. I left. Third place in one day. Clearly this area doesn't want business at all read more

Love this place. It's so good that I make a point to come eat here every time I visit the area. Even if I've already had dinner

I ordered a large sausage, mushroom, onions and cheese pizza. I received a pizza loaded with mostly onions and VERY LITTLE sausage. First time visiting there and I will not be back. The customer service wasn't all that great either. Not a delectable experience! read more

Vegetarian: I had a slice of cheese pizza, it was solid but nothing to write home about. My sister had their cheese calzone and the ricotta cheese was cold. She had to dig the ricotta out of the calzone to enjoy it. Not anywhere near as good as the location on Hillsborough street in Raleigh. They had several vegetarian options that you would expect at any pizza place like this, such as mozzarella sticks, and white pizza. Vegan: They only have fries and a salad. I thought they might have more because they do have Greek food, but sadly no. Glute-free: They made no mention on their menu. Service: order at the counter and pick it up when it's ready. The cashier was polite. They heat the pizza up in the oven when you order it so there is a little bit of a wait. Recommendations: I would come back but I would stop short of recommending it to anyone. read more

I Love Ny Pizza - Menu - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Positives: You get a lot of bang for your buck, and the employees are great! I could also eat appropriate 900 of their garlic knots, honestly. Negatives: Honestly, I would best describe their food as "okay". I've been here a few times and gotten pizza and pasta. Overall, it's not bad but not great. Bland is really the word for it. read more

I've been ordering weekly through DoorDash. The pizza is decent and has the potential to be great. The ingredients are first rate. However, the pizza is consistently under cooked. So, after the first few orders, I decided to order the pie "well done." Three orders later, my request is still ignored. Tonight, I thought I'd try again. Not only was it NOT well done but it was practically raw dough. Shame. So, if I were you, I'd skip it. read more

I Love Ny Pizza - Raw and completely under cooked. - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Came in for a fast lunch. I got the lunch special - 2 slices of pizza and a drink for $6.99. The pizza was good, would have been better if it had been fresh. They have 10 different pizzas made already. When you order they just heat up your slices. I had the chicken bbq and Hawaiian pizza. The subs and pasta dishes looked good as well. Not bad for lunch and if you want thin crust pizza. read more

I Love Ny Pizza - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

I'm almost 20 now I've been eating here since I had my first job in new hope commons at old navy when I was 16, I love their food. My favorite is their chicken fajita wrap combo. So good never disappoints. The service is amazing as well! read more

I've Been eating here since 13 or 12 years old and I go here on every special occasion. The food is great and the butter pecan ice cream there is really good. read more

I'll start by stating I'm originally from NY - born and raised. Pizza is a huge deal and the hype is justified. You really can't get that anywhere else. I was super excited to see the familiar BIG slices, and everything inside brought on nostalgia. All the pies were beautifully displayed and there were great options. We kept it simple, ordered 2 huge slices and a slice of cheesecake to share. I wasn't overly hungry, but the sauce and cheese was a throwback to old school pizzerias. The crust, that was where it differed. It lacked that doughy, greasiness that I longed for. It wasn't terrible, but it wasn't what I expected. The cheesecake (sigh!).... super yummy!! Can't wait to go back and try the Sicilian slice!!! read more

Ok.... So I am very critical when it comes to spots because I am from NJ so expectations are high. I have a 3 star because the pizza crust was doughy, the taste was decent though. The garlic knots was a disappointment because I've seen all the top ratings of people loving the knots. When I tasted them it was SUPER greasy and taste under baked. This location gives me nostalgia because I miss the Jersey/NY pizza but I've been here twice in about 8 months and I haven't left feeling satisfied. read more

See all

This place is great! Gyro platter and pizza are delicious. My husband loves the steak and cheese! I don't get a chance to eat here much but the owner and his son always remember our orders. Impressive!! This place is a hidden gem! read more

This spot typically is decent but my visit today was a complete waste of money. The texture of the pizza was not to my expectations as it was paper thin and extremely flabby and soggy like. Beef patty was definitely from the previous day. If you want reheated food this is your place to go . Price was good just the effort put in the quality wasn't there. read more

Stale, over priced pizza ... That's about it. Went her for a late night bite after the bar. First the guy behind the counter immediately attempts to up-sell on everything thinking that we're intoxicated which was kind of annoying. I got 4 slices at $18 and all the slices were stale. The crust was hard and close to inedible. I would suggest saving your money and taste-buds, find grub else where. read more

I love this place.... typically I do a carryout order of a single slice paired with a salad with grilled chicken for dinner when I'm done shopping nearby. In my experience, the service has always been friendly and prompt. The quality of the food and the service have always been great.... you can't go wrong at this place if you're looking for pizza or an Italian dinner . read more

The pizza is gone down hill since change of ownership. They are skimming on toppings and using cheaper products

If I could give 10 stars I would! This place is great. Service, ambiance, food, all excellent. Yhe veggie pizza is spectacular! I one hundred percent recommend this place, and I'll be back. They even have hand made desserts. read more

This is the second time to this pizza place and both time the customer service has been AMAZING!!! The pizza is pretty good too!

First time trying this pizza and it was ok kinda doughy and wasn't crazy about the flavor. Decided to try it again and I like a thin crisper pizza better at Fat Daddys Pizzarea This is just my opinion you may love it and that is great Just not my taste read more

I have stopped in I love NY pizza a few times for lunch. They have a pretty good manager's special deal with two slices any kind + a drink for $6.99 + tax. Located in a bustling shopping area with a lot of frustrating traffic, this place seems to do a healthy business. The slices are pretty big. I like the pizza here, but would rank it slightly below Randy's. I love NY pizza heats up pre-made slices. I think most places do this, but some taste fresher than others and the pizza I have had here didn't always taste like it was just made. This location has Greek dishes like Gyros as well as Italian (spaghetti, lasagna etc.), and also serves ice cream, which seems a bit odd, but I am sure the children (and some adults) like to finish off their pizza meal with some ice cream. read more

White Pizza pictured. Sort of hidden near the Dick's sporting good. Slices are very large, lunch special is great. $9 for 2 specialty slices and a drink. read more

I Love Ny Pizza - White Pizza - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Pizza was delicious and came to the table quick! The only reason for 4 stars not 5 is the garlic knots were a little hard read more

I Love Ny Pizza - Italian Near Me - Durham, North Carolina

Granted, it's a chain. But it's a good one. As close to NY Pizza as you're ever going to get without actually being in NY. The food was tasty, staff was very gregarious, and everything was served piping hot. I'll have to see if we have one of these back home... read more