Cute little shop right across the street from the beach and attracts a lot of attention. Customer service is quick, easy and nice enough. Lobster rolls here are cheap compared to ones in other states especially CA. $19 per roll is pretty good. Each roll is pretty small you can say like average size pretty much just like everywhere else with this economy (all lobster rolls shrunk after Covid). They are generous with the chunks of lobster though and it's so juicy and fresh! I also ordered the lobster bisque and that was great too. Bisque had lots of big chunks of lobster and it was creamy how I like it. The fries were big slices of fries and also fresh and yummy. The only thing I can say I wasn't happy about was no Tabasco no hot sauce of any kind! What???!!! I love my Tabasco with all my seafood and it was a disappointment to not be able to enjoy my seafood the way I always do. read more

See all

You want really, really, really, really good lobster rolls???? Here it is! Prior to visiting Cape May, I did a little research on the food scene and Quincy's immediately came up. At first, we were targeting their Washington Street Mall location, but we realized it wasn't their original spot as the original location was on Beach Ave, just a few blocks away. With Washington Street Mall being so busy and packed, we figured we'd give the original location a try instead since it was away from the buzz of the Mall area. This location was right across from the Cape May convention center, but the strip that the shop was part of was pretty dingy. The tables and chairs outside were all very dirty so make sure to give them a good wipe down first. When we arrived for an early dinner at 5PM on the Friday before Labor Day, we were surprised to see quite a few families sitting at the outdoor tables. How could that be???? It was ONLY 5PM! Luckily, they all finished quickly and we were able to snag a table outside. But there were other tables belonging to other establishments there that were free though. This location of Quincy's was as no frills as it got. It was slightly bigger than a hole in the wall with no indoor seating what so ever. All of the tables and seats were outside and there were only a few. After taking a gander at the menu, we ordered 1 Classic Roll, 1 Connecticut Roll, 1 Lobster Mac and Cheese and 1 Lobster Bisque. Let me just say, I haven't had a lobster roll in a longgggg time, but it was well worth the wait and more. All of the lobster in the rolls were so fresh and delicious. I easily could have eaten 3 of them by myself, but, unfortunately I only had 1. The Lobster Bisque and Lobster Mac & Cheese were very good too, but the Lobster rolls definitely had me wanting much, much more. One thing to note when dining outside is BEWARE OF THE SEAGULLS. Yes, they love lobster too (who or what doesn't????) and they will occasionally fly and land in the vicinity looking for food, so just keep a close eye on your food. As for parking, unfortunately, it's all street parking as Quincy's doesn't have a lot like so many of the Beach Ave establishments. However, if you decide to walk away from the Mall area, Quincy's is an excellent option. read more

See all

Wanted to get some take out to eat on the beach with my family and got some lobster rolls + fries here. It was delish! I liked the whole lobster pieces and not the shredded part, it was a little dry. But the fries were incredible! read more

Haven't eaten here in a while and I recently enjoyed lunch, yes with my dog. We ordered and ate outside at the tables. Lobster was so juicy and sweet. Yes I shared some with my fur baby too. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Delicious lobster roll with a great ratio of bread to meat. For context, my boyfriend had never had a lobster roll he liked until this one and I'm so happy he did! I was happy as a clam with it. We also got the lobster bisque - of the 3 lobster bisques we had in the area, we ranked it 2/3 (all were good). It was very tasty with a high sherry flavor. Overall the lobster roll is a must, but a better lobster bisque is at the Lobster House. Friendly, prompt service and the seating is all outdoor. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Was it the best lobster roll I've ever had? No but it was very tasty. Small but yummy. I got the "classic", which was served cold and warm butter. I meant to order "Lobster Salad" which is made with mayo, which I thought was "classic". Still yummy and I would recommend. Not pricey for lobster roll but appropriately pricing for the size of for lobster roll. Someone hungry could eat two. I still recommend. Good service. read more

Really good lobster roll place in Cape May! It seems like it's been around for a long time. The lobster tasted fresh and they give you a lot of it on the lobster roll. It definitely hits the spot if you're in the mood for a lobster roll! read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

this was our first time trying a lobster roll and it did not disappoint! we ordered the classic roll which is served cold. it was small in size but very delicious. the fries came out piping hot, so they were definitely fresh! the pickles and lemon were a nice touch to add some acidity and freshness. service was good, nothing to complain about. there wasn't a line when we got there but it took about 20 minutes for our food to come out. the roll was about $20 and the fries were $6. there is no indoor seating and it is located in a little plaza with other food shops. whether or not you get a table just depends on how busy it is that day. we managed to get one right out front and we were not bothered by any seagulls! read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - classic lobster roll and fries - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Great lobster rolls at a decent price! No frills ambiance right in the beach. Tried both hot and cold with a slight preference for cold. Give them a try. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

I completely understand why the line for Quincy's is out of the door when you're passing by. The los get rolls are stacked, flavorful, and delicious. The price also can't be beat. If you're in the area, definitely stop by to try one of their many roll options that comes with the perfect plain bag of lays chips. I promise you won't be disappointed ! read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

We tried Quincy's Original Lobster Roll in Cape May and left pretty disappointed. The lobster roll didn't live up to the hype, and the atmosphere wasn't great either. If you're after a really good lobster roll, check out Paramount Diner in Manasquan -- by far the best we've had! read more

Went here for lunch with my family and was excited to try the place out. As soon as we walked in, we said hello how are you with a smile and were returned with a straight face of the cashier who just looked at us and ignored us. We asked questions about what is good to eat and we were ignored while being dully stared 99% of the time. Started off with poor service to say the least. It was a simple space, just for ordering on the go. The food was very disappointing and was nothing special. I ordered the shrimp roll and there was plastic left on top of my roll. Out of 5 people, not a single one of us really enjoyed our food or would return back for more. The food looked nice and the colors presented it well but it also was not worth the price. $18 for a lobster roll thats not good and a $11 shrimp roll that wasn't anything special. The food was not filling, small portions. While it's location is convenient and near the beach, I would take the extra 5 minutes to reach a different spot with better food nearby. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - shrimp roll - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Want for lunch did take out was so good worth it they were good got go of season when not busy read more

See all

My family and I loved this place! Such delicious and abundant lobster rolls. Served with chips and pickles. Delish! Also got the crab salad which was delicious and fresh as well. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

This was my first visit to Cape May, and it was my birthday. We had a different dinner planned but had to return home earlier than expected, so stopped here for a bite before leaving, which we hoped would be fun and tasty. I ordered the crab roll and was disappointed. The crab "lumps" were minced and the portion small. It tasted forgettable. The fries were coated and overdone. I would recommend skipping the crab roll and the fries. We certainly won't repeat this experience. read more

Lobster rolls is what Quincy's is all about and that's all they do. Cold, warm, with butter, plain or with mayonnaise they are all just perfect! Note that this is a take-out stand, but easy to enjoy at one of the several sidewalk tables just outside. It's a perfect lunch stop! read more

Ohh, ohh, ohh how I wanted to love this place. It got great reviews.... but the lobster rolls were TINY ... I even ordered the 50% More for $6 more.... so I expected a couple of good bites. Maybe it was the fact that it cost so much that I was not satisfied. It's in the main busy area on Washington Mall. The outdoor seating wasn't bad. The order taker was very nice. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Lobster Roll , half eaten - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Absolutely loved the good! Very quick and easy pickup. The shrimp roll and clam chowder were delicious!! read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Shrimp Roll and clam chowder - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Chains can always be hit or miss, but this one is a hit. We ordered the crab roll, and the price could not be beat. The crab meat tasted very fresh, and there was a generous amount of it. As far as service and ambiance, the employee who served us was very friendly, and the location is perfectly situated near all of the shops, which makes for an easy grab and go between stores. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Crab roll - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

1000% recommend. Everything about the lobster roll was perfection. The buttery roll and lump jumbo lobster pieces were the perfect combination. Service was quick and the outdoor seating was quaint. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Finally made it to The Original location and had the classic Lobster Roll. Very Fresh, beautifully chilled with just the right amount of mayo on a soft bun for under $20 can't go wrong. They have other rolls as well and I'm sure equally tasty. Great vibe and excellent location right across from promenade and beach. read more

See all

Dry lobster & roll. No butter. Would not eat again. Had enough lobster but wasn't very good

Not super impressed with the experience. No one eating here on a Sunday at noon should have been an indication. Service was pretty blah and the roll itself was mainly claw meat. Roll is tiny for just under $20. If you've ever enjoyed a roll in Maine, I would suggest you pass. Cole slaw was so bland too. Best thing about the meal was the frozen chicken fingers and thick cut fries. Bummer. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Very good and a decent price point. Lobster was spot on. Roll was spot on. Service was spot on! read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Overrated for the price. Lobster bisque had very little lobster....mostly cream. Lobster roll was ok but bread was clearly sitting out for hours and almost stale. Very little butter and cold. Delaneys has a way better sandwich. read more

I can't believe I walked by this hole in the wall so many times and never tried a lobster roll here before today. Quincy's Original Beach Ave is in the middle of a small row of vendors across the street from the convention center on Beach Ave, Cape May; The atmosphere was buzzing with tourists shopping and beachgoers. They served my roll in a paper bag with a bag of chips. This Lobster Roll was not cheap; it cost $18.75 + Tax, $19.99 total. I thought it a bit pricey; when I opened it up, a seagull swooped down and helped himself to a big chunk of fresh lobster meat! I was shocked, not knowing why I would be with all the signs that warned to "watch your food from Seagulls" half my sandwich was gone! Luckily, they were nice enough to make a new one; now, for the best part: the first bite, my taste buds started to dance!! All the flavors of a fresh lobster tail at a fine dining restaurant were there. It's a shame I only got one roll; I could have eaten five. It was delicious and a pleasant surprise from a little hole in the wall! Try if you're ever in beautiful Cape May, NJ. I highly recommend it! Wheelchair friendly, they talk cash or card, outside dining only, kid-friendly, restrooms across the street. Quincy's Original Beach Ave 709 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204 609-600-3571 Open 11:30 am - 8:00 pm read more

See all

The rolls were delicious, but definitely smaller than you'd expect. However, the serving of lobster if you added extra was generous. Definitely small rolls though. Similar to hotdog rolls. It also is a shame they close so early in the off season but to be expected. Food was easy to order online and kept at appropriate temps. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Food amazing. Well worth it and I would definitely eat here again. However the service was so awful. The cashier had no idea they had a lobster grilled cheese, she kept saying lobster Mac and cheese. They also didn't know how to apply a coupon so we had to wait for them to call someone. We are outside which has very limited seating but nice if you get the chance to grab a table. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Lobster grilled cheese - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Fresh lobster in a buttered roll with chips for $15.99 and if you go during happy hour it's only $13.99 What a deal, and perfect for smaller folks. Larger people will need 2 rolls. The 4 roll deal $49.99 for 2 people is probably the way to go if you are really hungry. Try to avoid peak hours as the seating area is fairly small but we often do takeout and eat back on our Victorian wrap around porch when staying at a vrbo Or on the lawn at congress hall No alcohol for sale here, but lunch is time to hydrate anyway read more

See all

FRESH!!! The lobsta was so very fresh! This little lobster roll shop pushes out some very good lobster rolls. My friend and I passed one other lobster roll shop before we came upon Quincy's and I guess we came to the right place. QUESTION: Why are lobster rolls always so small and leaving you wanting more? Anyway, it was GREAT. I also ordered lobster mac & cheese. That was GREAT as well. What else can I say. Good Stuff. read more

See all

[1123] 7/2020 This place is located in Cape May NJ. Plenty of street parking. We stopped by the walk up window to try the lobster roll. It was just "ok". I was expecting a bit more lobster. The staff was just ok and got my order wrong. There were tables shared with other businesses. They were dirty. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

My husband and I went down to Cape May on a whim for a date night. Everything down in the town center was booked but this little gem was open and serving amazing sandwiches. Everything looked great but we settle on 2 sandwiches. The crab roll and the lobster roll. Both were fresh, light and delicious. My favorite was the crab roll because the horseradish sauce was awesome. The sauce was not heavy and let the crab shine through. The lobster roll had lemon butter and again not over powering. There were no fillers. The bun is a split top brioche. Fries were surprisingly good too. We will be back. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Fries - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

What is there not to like? The food was awesome, but I do have to complain that Quincy's is (too) small and seating was scarce, outside, and although under cover it was hot as heck. Sigh, lobster prices with beach bum accommodations--except this was at an outside mall. Kind of felt ripped off. read more

See all

For all the ratings that said amazing things I was a little disappointed but happy that this place was open when everything else was closed. My friend and I decided to take a day trip to Cape May and we decided to get crab rolls and lobster rolls and a couple other menu choices I have to say the lobster roll and the crab rolls were not what I expected it was like a sad excuse for a seafood salad and the mayonnaise was not even mixed up I guess when you visit Cape May you have a certain caliber that comes to mind. I don't mind paying more expensive prices as long as it's a decent meal but this barely hold us over it was like a really sad excuse for a sandwich and also served on a hotdog bun I'm not quite sure if I will ever revisit but for two people spending $40 on lunch, Left us starving and disappointed. Edit/Update: Shortly after posting review, manager gave feedback, which is appreciated! We understand that these are crazy and hectic times with many Changes. We won't hold this against you and we will come back for lunch at a later date! Thanks for reaching out! Stay safe! read more

See all

We tried the Classic with extra lobster meat for $5 more. It was definitely worth it. The rolls were jam packed with fresh lobster meat. They use very very little mayo which was great. They give you two dill pickle slices and a wedge of lemon with each roll. We also got some lobster mac n cheese which was decent. They sprinkle Old Bay on top. We love Old Bay so that was a bonus. The pasta wasn't overdone which was nice. We liked the food here. They were open until 8pm on Sat. read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Classic Roll with Extra Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Absolutely delicious. Truly one of the best lobster rolls I have ever had! The buttered bun was exceptional and the amount of lobster you are given is totally worth the price. A+ and will definitely be back! read more

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Arrived right before the doors opened and YUM! The lobster rolls were fresh, and as a purist I appreciated being allowed to to skip the Mayo and butter. The fries were crispy and all in all it was a perfect simple lunch. They have a few outdoor seats with umbrellas. read more

Overall good lobster rolls. We ordered 2. One of them with extra lobster, the other just regular portion lobster roll. Although we paid about $6-$7 for extra lobster, it didn't seem like they added more because it had the same portion as the regular one. There wasn't a line, but took about 20 mins or so to get my order. Still recommend! read more

This is a no frills place to get a deliciously prepared lobster roll that tastes fresh! I've been here several times and it is never any drama. Lobster rolls served with Cape Cod chips and a smile. I like that there are lots of other options on the menu that are non seafood based thus making them good for kiddos. read more

Not bad. The rolls are pretty small but definitely tasty. My husband had the warm lobster roll with butter & I had the lobster salad on a salad. I would say the portions are more of a snack than a meal. If you have had lobster rolls in New England these will definitely not be that size, but the taste was good. read more