I did a side by side by side comparison of three different pizza places for Christmas eve and got a medium combo and veggie (no cheese) at each of them all were about same price for the size of pizza. Pudge Bros pizza was average at best. They do give a nice amount of toppings. But it stops there. Crust is bland (even a little floury). Red sauce was nothing to special. Quality of toppings average. The guy there Christmas eve was very nice. The place was clean, za's were ready exactly on time. Sorry PB. I wont be back. To many other options. read more

Pudge Bros Pizza - Medium Veggie (no cheese) - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

I love Pudge Bros Pizza! It is my go-to pizza and the zesty red sauce is delicious. I also appreciate the amount of toppings and cheese.

This place looks like it's straight out of the 90's and I love it. Just a divey looking pizza joint that I've passed a bunch of times but walking back with my buddy from the nearby dispensary, we decided to drop in for some slices. Now I've criticized the pizza here in WA/Seattle. I still do, nothing has come close to pizza from back east (outside of chains) ... until now. I think I can confidently say this is the best Pizza I've had since moving here, from a non-chain place. Everything just hit - The cheese, the dough, the crust and the slices are big. About $4 a slice, it just tastes like good pizza. All these fancy artisan pizza places with their, wood fired this and fresh finest sauce that I see at all these places I've tried beat out by dumpy ol Pudge bros where it seems like their budget goes into the food and not the location and that is just what I like to see. read more

See all

Classic American pizza. Very nostalgic and cozy. Dudes in the shop were cool and it wasn't crazy expensive either

Ordered pizza delivery here and the large cheese pizza ($18) was awesome :) Simple, fresh, and good. ON Time. Even great the next day. read more

Pudge Bros Pizza - This is the only picture I took lol - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Stopped at Pudge Brothers again today. Purchases 2 big slices. The waiting area wa clean and staff was friendly and most importantly the pizza was great. If you're looking for a slice of Pizza this is one of the best places to get one. If your looking or a whole fresh made pizza as far as I'm concerned it doesn't get any better than here. The pizza is a thin crust with a zesty sauce and what ever topping you want. read more

There individual slices are the the best I've ever had. The motso they use is great, they don't go skimpy on the pizza and the best part. They make the crust crispy without burning the bottom! Great Flavor don't ever change. read more

Great Pizza, served its purpose for my time in Seattle. I will miss it. And the cool bros that work there always taking care of me.

Been there a few times. Slices are a bit inconsistent. Sometimes they're stacked with cheese and toppings and other times are a bit skimpy. Their cheesy bread is pretty delicious. I wish they would add pepperoni on it, because their normal pizza tends to be too thin for me and usually doesn't have as much cheese as I'd like. It's pretty standard for the area. read more

Really solid pizza. Esp given that seattle pizza can be a bit iffy. Fast delivery too.

*NO MASKS WORN BY STAFF DURING COVID-19* The staff at this location during COVID do not wear masks while interacting with each other and even when interacting with customers (plastic shield is deemed "good enough" by staff). Staff includes the cooking team. This issue builds on previous poor experiences with cleanliness from Pudge Bro's which includes broken plastic (from a utensil) in the pizza, hair in the pizza, and handling of cash transitioning directly to touching food with bare hands. The pizza itself is quite greasy, so if you like that type of pizza perhaps you can overlook the cleanliness issues. I cannot. read more

I was needing a pizza redemption after the horrible experience at Element Pizza the night before so I ordered the Isabella's Veg pizza on gluten free crust for lunch. It did not disappoint! I honestly could not tell it was a gluten free crust. It was really good!! Typical looking pizza joint. Not a lot of places to sit, which is fine since I took it to go, but don't expect to bring a large group and eat in. read more

Definitely my favorite pizza, hands down. Wish they had a location closer to me, but it's a treat whenever I go. Love getting their monster size pizza. read more

Solid pizza! We dropped in late at night and asked for a whole pie. They suggested we get a bigger one and save money -- and then they made it fresh right on the spot. It was tasty and warm and perfect. What a wonderful local spot. Don't miss out on a chance for fresh and cheesy goodness. And the drinks are ice cold! Woot! read more

Good service and good pizza. The pizza was delivered in a very timely manner and it was still very warm and delicious.

Ordered x2 pepperoni pizzas for kids soccer game. Friendly service. Pizza was ready on time. Our Caesar salad was fresh. I have always enjoyed their calzones. Simple food, Fresh and good. read more

It's pizza, but it's bland, greasy and boring as hell. This is pizza for undiscriminating high school or college students who are too hungry to care. Even Domino's puts more effort into their pizza. This is the same pizza you'll find at dozens of pizza shops who just don't give a hoot about their product. If you love good pizza, keep looking... read more

Worst customer service, EVER. I couldn't even get an order from the woman on the phone with me. She obviously hates working there. I just wanted to know prices for pizzas, since the prices on yelp weren't accurate. She obviously didn't want to help me. As I started to say I am no longer interested, she interrupted me and said yeah this isn't working and hung up on me. Get some employees that enjoy working costumer service, will ya? read more

the cheesy bread and bbq chicken pizza is my favorite. i would recommend everything from here tbh.

I've been going here for decades and this is by far my favorite take out pizza in Seattle. No Betta Feta is amazing! Small space, large slices. The sauce has just the right amount of spicy kick. Everyone is always friendly. Kids love Pudge Brothers Pizza. Highly recommend this place. read more

Best pizza, biggest pies, great seattle toppings, not shy about putting cheese on, cooked right, and that NYC style floppiness/greasy factor that nearly everyone else in Seattle lacks. Lovely delivery times. High value + great food. Pudge for the Win. read more

Terrible pizza. Ordered a pizza delivery. Large. It tastes rubbery and was cold. We ordered 10 chicken wings. They came breaded (bone in)... they were cold and not cooked through. Never ordering from here again. Don't waste your money. I spent $40 on this shit. Dominos is better than this place. Gross read more

Pudge Bros Pizza - a piece of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I love the giant 18 in pizza and cheese bread the guy was so kind to me. He worked tonight Sep 12 thank you hunny read more

Pudge Bros Pizza - 18 in Meat Eater Pie - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

So this place has to be By far the best pizza I've had in Seattle maybe because this is the type of group on hole in the wall Family owned or leased one guy on Which I talk to is pretty cool guy Really laid back any makes a really good pizza pizza dough light and fluffy just enough crispnest Cheese tasted really good It had great Texture their sauce was great too And this was all from one slice To me this is the best pizza in Seattle for share read more

Pudge Bros Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Pudge bros is the best pizza in Seattle. Their excellence starts with the dough. The crust is perfect and the toppings are all high-quality. Check out Vincenzo's Favorite and Isabella's Veggie. If you pick your 18" pizza up using the pickup special it's a great deal. read more

Cool spot near the U District. I made use of a coupon which made the experience even better! ;) Pizza was delish, price was excellent and the service was quick, easy and above and beyond the call. Thanks! read more

Sometimes you want a certain kind of pizza to match your mood. There are times where I may want artisanal pizza with local ingredients. There times when I want to cut into a deep dish. And then there are time when I want cartoon pizza You know what I mean, strings of cheese between slices, perfect round pepperonis, button mushrooms that are just the perfect shape. It's a certain mood, but when that mood strikes, there's no beating Pudge Bros. Perfect pizza that meets cartoon aesthetic. It's not thin crust, it's not deep dish. The toppings are generous, the cheese is stringy but doesn't smother or overwhelm the other toppings. It's not overly fancy, but boy is it satisfying. read more

Amazing pizza! Don't order through Postmates. My order took two hours- it was not the restaurant's fault. I also got charged twice by Postmates. After an hour of waiting (my bad), I called the restaurant to ask what was taking so long. The restaurant never received my initial Postmates order. The gentleman on the phone was super nice and told me he would get my order started and would call me if I still don't hear back in 20 minutes. Use a different app to order- great pizza! My friend and I shared a pepperoni and garlic pizza. read more

Pudge Bros Pizza - Using Postmates to order at 6:52 pm - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

These guys rock! Normally, I hate pizza. Not anymore. After having Pudge Bros. I've decided to legally rename my child, "Pepperoni Pudge Peter." The triple P! Best pizza in town. read more

With so many great pizza places in the neighborhood, I didn't know if this place would even have a chance, but was I wrong. They have THE best meat lovers pizza. This is definitely our go to when we're looking for a bit of a thicker crust and all the delicious meats. Great service. Quick and always friendly. read more

I ordered from this place a couple of times as my colleague did for a late student get together at UW using Door Dash. Last week I called Pudge Bros. beforehand to let them know we needed extra paper plates and cheese packets. The person who answered berated me for calling then as my order was not even until after 3pm when they receive the Door Dash orders. I waited outside for delivery at 3:30 only to find out from Door Dash that Pudge Bros. had cancelled as they closed early!! Make of this what you will, but I will never use Pudge Bros. again. Terrible inconvenience. read more

Why are you wasting time reading this review when you should be ordering their pizza... hurry!!! They have the BEST crust around... so don't forget to order a side (or two) of the zesty red sauce for dunking!!! Salads are huge (Greek) and FULL off lots of veggies and cheeses... get one! I always order "Vincenzo's Fav Pizza" with the garlic base... it's amazing... especially with the zesty red sauce! Go. Now. Get this pizza and ENJOY!!! read more

Pudge Bros Pizza - Vincenzo's Fav Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Ordered Pudge Boris late at night and it was delivered fast! Very tasty as well! Their pizza is New York style. Would definitely order from them again. read more

I love this place! I work next door and I swear I've gained 10 pounds just cause I can't stop eating their pizza everyday. Can't stop, won't stop. Yummmm read more

Love their pizza (the Combo is perfect), and their Greek salad is terrific. Plus they're very close-by (to the U district).

Went in just now to grab a couple slices (90 minutes before closing time) and I thought the old timer behind the counter was gonna have a full blown geriatric meltdown. Apparently he was angry at me for not wanting to order a whole pizza? I honestly couldn't believe his immediate blowup when I told him I just needed a couple slices. Between that and how damn filthy it is in the food prep area (check through the window), I think I'm good on ever going back to Pudge Bros. Good job, gramps! read more

The Pudge Brothers really love their Valpak coupons. They might even hand you one from the stack conveniently located next to the cash register while you're trying to study the menu because they think the coupon menu is super easy to read! I've gotten pizza from them a couple of times, and it's been pretty good. For about $20 you can get a giant (by my standards, apparently not by Pullman standards) pizza and they did skip the cheese and meat when I requested it, so that worked out really well. (Some companies seem to not realize that some people mean it when they say "no cheese" or assume that we want vegan cheese.... bad assumption!) Not the Best Pizza Ever, but definitely a solid pizza joint and great for plenty of people because they offer (cheesey) slices. I hope they get some gluten free crust soon, so eating their pizza won't make my favorite guy sleepy and irritable shortly after eating... read more

I ordered a pizza from Uber eats. for some reason my pizza came with no marinara sauce on the base of the pizza.

Their regular cheese pizza is better than anything else on the menu. This place makes no sense. read more

I ordered Hawaiian pizza I waited an hour and it was very mediocre and over priced especially for the quality. Cold and rubbery, reminded me of cafeteria pizza from middle school. Also the ranch they charged $1 tasted like it was straight from Sysco. Def won't be wasting my money here again. read more