This pizza joint is to die for. Hands-down one of the best pies I've ever had and I am definitely…read moregonna come back. The service was so fun - the employees are so great and friendly and super considerate, and it was so fast! Thank you again for having me team and I can't wait till next time

Yummy! Best pizza in the area , by far…read more We had the lasagna & a cheesy bread. Man, t ricotta was so good , there were 4 cheeses used . Top tier Italian in my opinion. Thank you See you next time!

This place never misses! Their pizza is so good!! We ordered pizzas Friday night, had a lot left…read moreover and ate it the rest of the weekend. They also have ice cream cones which is great . We were at an event last night that had pepinos catering. Chicken parm, eggplant parm, baked ziti, garlic knots, salad. All of it was fantastic! The garlic knots are drool worthy! Mmmm mmmm!

Delicious pizza and friendly staff/comfortable clean place to sit down and eat. I ordered a 14 inch…read morefor myself, ate half of the pizza in the restaurant and took the remainder back to my hotel in a small box which fit in the mini fridge and had it for dinner the next night after skiing all day - and I have a big appetite and it filled me up and was savory to the last bite. Next time I stay in Carbondale or nearby I will definitely go back to Peppino's. I wish I had taken a picture to share. I chose a pizza from the menu that had sausage, pepperoni, onions, peppers, olives, and garlic. Ingredients were fresh and the pizza was done to my liking.

This is our second review of an old friend. The Secret Stash is a must stop for us on every visit…read moreto Crested Butte and every dinner is a marvel of discovery. On this visit we ordered The Hamptons which is completely off piste (bada bing! for the skiing reference!) for a traditional pizza lover. With nary a drop of tomato in sight, The Hampton features an EVO sauce on a lemon pepper crust and is topped with a mix of mozz, parm and prosciutto and garnished with arugula and a lemon crown. We could not have been more delighted. These ingredients mesh into a piquant velvet run through culinary knee deep powder. As usual, we paired our meal with the Big Ass Marg and Gin and Tonics. Service was attentive and the decor is reminiscent of our visits to Thamel in Kathmandu. Bravo to The Secret Stash!

Terrible, if not rude, service Was with another person, was…read moresat without a word from the hostess. She then brought water it like we were annoying her. Sat for 10 minutes with no one speaking a word to us. Completely unprofessional

I've been to this place three times now, and each visit has delivered excellent service. The…read moreatmosphere is exactly what you'd hope for in a mountain setting--cozy, welcoming, and full of character. Everyone you encounter is friendly and seems genuinely happy to be there, which really adds to the overall vibe. The beer is exceptional, with one of the best varieties in town. Whether you're into classic styles or looking for something more adventurous, there's something for everyone on tap. I travel to this area for work, and this spot is always on my list. It's the kind of place you look forward to returning to--not just for the drinks and the atmosphere, but for the consistently great experience.

To be honest the food is good but overpriced for what you get. $25 for a 12" pizza and $18 for a 6"…read moremeatball sub? If you split these two items with another person you will not get full on the portion size. I don't think I will be going back in the future. But hey, if you want to overpay feel free. Limited menu items. Price a little better or increase the portions for REAL people. Go to Subway and Dominos.

May 24, 2025 review:…read more From the outside, it give you a house vibe than a restaurant. Parking is not concrete and gravel area. This place gets super crowded. Wait time for to-go was 45 mins. Pizza is good but if you're in hurry, I would say- go find another place. Like for pickup itself is like 15 mins wait time. They have 8 inch, 10 inch, 12 inch pizza sizes available. Most of menu items are common among all sizes but 10 inch is gluten free only. We got 10 inch gluten free pizza- get your goat. We were able to replace pear with spinach. It was Alfredo sauce base with olives, caramelized onion, goat cheese, mozzarella. Overall good experience.

Sweetest staff!! Pizza was delicious. Roomy area and nicely decorated. Quick service. Definitely…read morewould recommend:) we had 3 pizzas but I only got a photo of one. All were delicious!

Got a pizza while I was at the Amtrak station on our way back home from glenwood springs / Hotel…read moreColorado. The food: The pizza was delicious the best pizza I had on my 3 week trip across country! It was prepared correctly The service the staff were all very friendly and courteous. They all had smiles on and were in a good mood. Seemed like all the employees worked along together fine. The ambiance: The store was charming the aesthetic is perfect for the brand and the employees fit into that company identity perfectly. I wish I had more time so I could have hung out more. The place seemed a little small but that just makes it more intimate. Thanks Rocky Mountain pizza and glenwood springs, Colorado! Beautiful country friendly people great food. will be back!

Order a medium pizza, more than enough for 2 people. Pretty good, great service. Space is nice…read more. brought out water for my dog. Service was great, very friendly staff .

Fantastic pizza! Crust is not always my favorite, just fills me up, but this crust was excellent!…read more Keep in mind during colder days that their inside dining area is fairly small so go during their less bus hours. Great service. Everyone there went out of their way to make everyone comfortable and enjoy their food.

Only had a large Greek Salad. Not great but did have a few crumbles of feta…read more Service was very hospitable and fast. Dining area redefines "cozy." Small counter space and 5 little tables. Outdoors is a much larger dog friendly area. During summer, ordering ahead is the genius trick.

Fresh and hot thin crust new york style pizza to go!! $4 for cheese and $4.50 for exotic. Fast and…read moreeasy. They have a large menu to order from including pizza pies s/m/l, salads, and sandwiches and they even do 3 kinds of breakfast burritos until 11pm. We only were interestedin slices. This is not a sit down establishment. Definitely a grab and go relaxed kind of feel place, but they do have 2 stools if you want to sit for a few. Staff was very friendly, pizza was good, and service was fast. Definitely will come again for a quick grab.

We love Mikey's. Delicious pizza, easy to order and they sometimes deliver which is epic in CB…read more Great folks working there, too!

Ordered the Molte Carne w/peppercorns. Very good pizza. Please put more Marinara sauce on the…read morepizza. Bartender very attentive. Great beer recommendations.

Pretty good pizza at this local spot, they make smaller pies (6" or 11") to order, along with some…read morestarters/salads/sandwiches on the menu. The pizza was good, if not on the doughy side a bit. The special had some adventurous ingredients, including peach and a balsamic glaze. It worked really well! And the Salsicia was good, the goat cheese was a tart balance to the heavy sausage. They're a brewery too, and the beer selection seemed decent, though I didn't love my west coast lager. Seems like they brew to specific styles, not as much creativity as their pizza menu. All in all, a good option for a no frills meal that won't break the budget!

Joey from New York here. I vouch for this pizzeria. Just look at that crust!!! If you want pizza as…read moregood as they make in NYC and Brooklyn, give this spot a try. The staff is great, the ambience of the place is clean and comfortable. And unlike most NYC pizza parlors, you can have a pint of exotic beer with your meal! Great job people!

Mediocre, not great. The garlic bread went right into the garbage. There's a barstool right by the…read moreregister. Don't sit there, because they'll ask to move. If only there was a way to retract the gratuity. Which begs the question, why put a basketball hoop in the middle of the park if you don't want the local kids shooting baskets?