This has nothing to do with the food. Burgers are good, waitresses, bartenders, everyone was nice. It's about the Deceptive Advertising they do. There is a Huge A-frame on Jericho Turnpike stating "HAPPY HOUR ALL DAY LONG", and they have some decent prices and specials. Because of that sign, some friends and I decided to check the place out. We all had a drink at the bar before dinner and when some of us went to order another drink, (it was now after 6pm) we were informed that Happy Hour was over. What?, the sign out front says All Day Long. We were informed that on the sign (in very small print, which you don't notice) it says from Mon - Fri Until 6 pm. Now personally, that's fine. Happy Hour ending at 6pm. Just make the rules big enough so they can be seen on the sign. Don't sneak it in on the small print. It's just shady. read more

Tatum, thank you for the excellent service and professionalism. Does a lot of work as a one man band. Off peak hours. Kudos to Tatum she's a great professional. Myself, brother and father 2/3rds NYPD & USA military. Could not ask for better service. Thank you for the outstanding help. She deserves a raise. Place itself great for food quality, atmosphere, and drinks and do yourself a favor. Bring a sense of humor! Wish we did not eat so fast or I would add pictures. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Left to right non military , NYPD, then Nassau PD/Airborne USA Ranger - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

They charged me for for extra sauces I didn't order. I told them I didn't want that they said. Whatever it's only a dollar. They charged $1.75 for extra cheese. They made me wait 10 minutes to get an extra side of blue cheese. I asked a waiter after the host took several calls before getting my extra sauce and he said he couldn't help me. Hottest made a nasty comment on way out the door. Food wasn't good. Will never go back. read more

Absolutely love Prime Burger Bar, this time I had their Wednesday Special - a Farmhouse buttermilk fried chicken sandwich with french fries and included either 1 mixed drink or beer or milkshake and that's for dine in only, all for $11.95. Their regular menu is amazing, usually if I'm in the mood for a burger I have the Prime aged steak blend which is delicious to say the least and their Specials & Happy Hour are a must!!!! Be sure to check out their website online for their Lunch Specials, Monday Special, Wednesday Special & Happy Hour all day long M-F until 6pm. The staff are always friendly, attentive but not intrusive, will always explain the menu if needed with a smile. The overall Bar/Restaurant is really nice & clean. They do have a back room if the front room gets too crowded. Parking lot is big so there's no issue with parking at all. Be sure to check out their menu online, you'll get hungry just by reading it. Enjoy!!! read more

The burgers here are solid! A little pricey considering other options but for good reason. Have you seen those milk shakes? Will hopefully be back to try the meaty poutine fries read more

Prime Burger Bar - Loaded Fries, w burger - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Both were amazing, two of the best we got. Juicy Lucy was delicious, the house sauce is amazing and definitely juuuuicy meat! I also got blueberry cocktail, which was fantastic as well. French fries awesome too; we will be back for sure. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Jucy The Juicy Lucy Burger at front and North Shore in the back - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Prime has literally made me go out of my way, to tell other people to not eat there. Check my history - I want local businesses to succeed. These guys are serving people raw, unsafe meat. When they originally opened they were fantastic, but things quickly went downhill. Tonight was the 3rd time they've sent uncooked food out for delivery. You might wonder why I would order from them several times - it's because they were so damn good when they opened. ** I should note - this was "the drunken goat" and I asked for medium rare. read more

See all

Great customer service. Great beer selection. And great burgers! Very tasty, alongside the fries ! I enjoy coming here. I love the atmosphere and prices are reasonable as the quality of food is delicious. Service: 5/5 Food: 4/5 Price: 5/5 Atmosphere: 5/5 Overall: 4/5 read more

Prime Burger Bar - South Bay burger. Could've had a little more seasoning, but was still enjoyable. - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

I haven't been here for two years, and it was just as excellent as the last visit. We were shown to a table after a 10-minute wait, which is quick considering it was a Saturday night at 7pm. I was with a friend who was never here before and while we were eating, we were discussing which items we will try on the next visit! We started the meal with an order of Short Rib Poutine which was fabulous. My friend said he could've have eaten the whole order by himself, it's plenty for two it's just that wonderful. I had the Steak House Burger which comes on a pretzel bun with Truffle Fries. These fries are a little extra but so worth it. My friend had the Great South Bay Burger with Onion Rings, outstanding. Our burgers were cooked perfectly medium rare as we instructed. Our food was delicious, the service was super and we can't wait to visit again soon. read more

See all

Quality has gone down enormously. We got an appetizer, and burgers. Additionally, two chocolate milkshakes were ordered- they ran out of chocolate icecream and tried to make it with vanilla icecream. Wish they told us that before we spent $30 on milkshakes. Server also was overwhelmed. They don't have a large dining room either so be prepared to be on top of eachother. Overall, not what it used to be. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Menu - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

So glad we went! My wife and I came in thinking we would try the place out for hamburgers. Thanks to our superb waiter (I believe his name is Marty), he told us about the special that they had, and it was too good of a deal to pass up. The chicken sandwich was delicious, and truth be told would have been well worth it at the regular price, but as a special, it was a steal! For an app we decided to split the pretzel. It was quite large, had great dips to go along with it, and came out warm, fresh, and perfect. The chicken sandwich (we both ordered it) was flavorful and moist, and great sauces to accompany it, which we enjoyed with the French fries. We could not finish it all, but that did not stop us from enjoying the milk shakes at the end. I'm so grateful for the waiter telling us about the special, and he was extremely attentive and personable. I can honestly say he treated us as if we were dear friends, and could not have been better. Looking forward to going back and eventually trying the burgers, as they looked fantastic!! read more

My first time here this past weekend and the food was great! I Got a lobster roll and it was so delicious! The ambiance was nice and server Tasha was very sweet and attentive!! I would definitely recommend coming here the food and people are great! read more

We were a group of 9 people. Some had been there before some not. We had a great experience. We sat in the back room since we had a big party. The back room had a tv in with the football game on. The menu has many great items on it and not too overwhelming. We started with drinks 2 people had the Raspberry Long Island ice tea. Another person had a Bloody Mary. Everyone else had water. We shared 3 appetizers the Bavarian Pretzel, Fried Brussel Sprouts, and the onion rings. Everything came out hot and tasty. For dinner we all chose different things. Two did build your own burger. Someone did the black and blue burger. Another did the Ribeye Steak Sammie. Two people shared the Prime BLt and fries. Another person had the lamb burger and our last person had teriyaki wings. Make sure you get the sweet potato fries with marshmallow dipping sauce. It's like eating a dessert that should be made as an appetizer instead of side. Hope to come back on next visit to NY. The staff was so friendly and always came to check on us. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Inside private room - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Had a great time yesterday!! Food was delicious! Staff is very friendly and loved the manager Candace, who checked on people frequently Always with a smile. My girlfriends and I plan to return often. read more

First time visiting and we were served by Marty (he's awesome and made us feel welcomed) I had the Kobe beef burger on a pretzel bun, OMG, the flavor was amazing, very tender burger, the fries were seasoned perfectly and were nice and crunchy, definitely recommend. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Fries - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Outdoor Dining Review: Great selection of burgers, Top notch service, Great Shakes! My expectation was that this would be another gimmicky burger place with large shakes. My reality was this restaurant had AWESOME burgers and the shakes were the best! Located on Jericho in Commack, this was a very easy restaurant to get to. Because they are offering outdoor dining, there's a large tent set up in the parking lot so the restaurant will be easy to find. It is also located in the strip mall where Sobol is. Plenty of parking! Customers & staff are required to wear masks. Everything was very clean. Limited indoor seating, but plenty of outdoor. The tables are spaced far apart. The prices are comparable to other burger places but I feel like the quality here was better. The service was a large part of why this restaurant deserved 5 stars. Our server Nina S really made our first Prime Burger experience great. She was super friendly and attentive. Refills were always given (free soda refills btw) and she kept checking up on the table. She was awesome. The food was delicious! I will be reviewing what I tried: -PB&J Wings: Starting out with my favorite appetizer of the night. I needed to try wings that are tossed in a peanut butter and jelly sauce! I know some might think it's strange, but the combination just worked! Not to mention the wings were PERFECTLY cooked! Definitely had sweet and savory vibes on the taste buds. Comes with 8 wings so it's great for sharing. 5 out of 5 stars -Bavarian Pretzel: Yes this is giant and great for sharing. It was buttery and light, and comes with 3 different dipping sauces. A great appetizer for sharing. 5 out of 5 stars -Cheese Curds: If you've never had them and your not sure if you'd like them...you would so just get an order! Cheesy melted perfection and came with 2 dipping sauces. 5 out of 5 stars -Great South Bay Burger: I saw this on the News12 special with Elisa Distefano and I knew I had to get it. The burger was so juicy and cooked to perfection. The bun was so fresh and soaked up the juice. Any burger topped with short rib is a burger I need in my life! The Cabernet sauce drizzled on top set this burger over the edge! All the burgers come with freshly cut fries and a nice dipping sauce. 5 out of 5 stars -Ultimate Brownie Shake: A suggestion is to save room for dessert! If you can't, just share. Don't pass up on these shakes. My shake was decadent and perfect after my burger. The shake wasn't too thick and the brownie on top was to die for! 5 out of 5 stars I'm so happy with my first experience at Prime Burger Bar and can't wait to return! read more

See all

They don't take reservations, annoying, but even on a Friday night which was obviously busy, we only waited 15 minutes for a party of 7. So far so good. Our server couldnt have been more attentive. He was fantastic. Not sure what's going on in the kitchen though. Two members of our party received their food a solid 10 minutes before the rest of us did. Three of us ordered the cobb salad with grilled chicken. The ingredients were super fresh, with the lone exception being the chicken which was horribly dry and obviously cooked well in advance of our order. Thank G-d for salad dressing! The worst part however was that one salad was ordered without cheese. When the salad arrived at our table it was obvious that someone in fact did not prepare it without cheese, and a half-hearted attempt was made to remove said cheese, with many small bits remaining behind. The good news is that it was noticed, sent back and corrected. The troubling thing is that if it wasn't noticed and this person had a food allergy..... well let's just say that Prime Burger Bar would have new owners. Yes, this is a burger place and you might be saying "you're in a burger place, why are you ordering a salad"? and to that i say, "because that's what i wanted and its on the menu." Someone needs to get ahold of the kitchen staff and straighten them out, they are a disaster. The party seated near us had small kids that were out of control, luck of the draw i guess, but nevertheless this is not a quiet place, so dont come here looking to engage in conversation with your party. Probably a great spot to watch a game though. read more

Here's the scoop: I wanted to try Prime Burger Bar for lunch after seeing a commercial. Ooooh my goodness!!! It was delivered hot and bagged perfectly. The food looked as delicious as it tasted (check my pics). I'm smacking my lips as I write. I will definitely order again because the menu is chock full of goodies like: lobster rolls hot and cold., juicy Lucy, Mac & cheese burger and phenomenal looking shakes. My gosh it's so good. My fellow Yelpers give em a try, you won't regret it, yummylicious!!!! read more

See all

The wings here are delicious! They're huge and they were juicy and crispy even with the sauce. My partner and I got mild wings and they were mild, if it was up to me I would do hot. I got the steak sandwich and it was really good. I asked for it rare and it was cooked to rare with a good amount of cheese. The truffle fries were pretty good, but steak fries are just my least favorite type of fry. My partner got a burger with the usual lettuce tomato and American cheese topping with regular fries and he said it was a really good burger. We definitely plan on coming back. read more

UPDATE - the manager Ed reached out to me and apologized for my experience. I understand that with these delivery services the restaurant loses control once it gets into the drivers hands. There was only 8 fries but they were delicious and the burger was very tasty. I would not use the delivery service again due to the surcharges it's just not worth it. I will definitely give them another try but eat in the restaurant or pick up myself next time. Thank you again to Ed for being so kind as to reach out to me. I just ordered delivery for the first time through DoorDash from Prime Burger. I have never ate in the restaurant. My food arrived cold and I also paid extra for truffle fries that turned up greasy and for 2.50 more I had 8 fries!!!! Seriously 8 fries!! My total order through doordash was 33.00 for a burger and 8 fries. Not Impressed at my first experience. read more

Prime Burger Bar - 8 truffle fries for an extra 2.50!!! You have to be kidding me - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

We came to Prime Burger after a childs birthday party in the area. It is located in strip mall off a busy road. As you walk in, there is a long bar area with flat screens playing mostly sporting events. We ordered wings of all kinds, and some spicy. I ordered a Belgium beer called Delirium. The wings seem to be good, and I thought the spicy ones were not so spicy. The service was very attentive and pleasant. read more

See all

Ordered a burger and they gave me this when I ordered medium well!!! This is completely raw and not edible!!!!!! read more

Prime Burger Bar - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Love the burgers here. The breakfast burger is my fav. Serious food here. The server was very nice.

Wife was in the mood for a hamburger and I saw an email for Monday night burger special at prime burger. We went and I ordered a rare hamburger and my wife ordered a regular hamburger no bun I don't know where they buy their meat from but this was far superior to any meat that I have ever purchased in a supermarket. She ordered the fries and I ordered the coleslaw. We could barely finish it. We asked the bartender Justin, who is very personable person how big was the hamburger? He answered 8 ounces. wow what a hamburger. We have been there one other time and Justin remembered that I like my Bluemoon with two oranges. We will be going back again. 5m read more

Best Turkey burger I have EVER had. My husband and I wanted a quick cheap date night, nothing fancy just good comfort food, this is now our go to spot whenever in the mood for a burger! I don't normally make bold claims but if it's that good and I take the time out to write it I would totally recommend giving them a try. My husband who says there isn't a better burger than McDonalds ( we have gone back and forth about this) looked up at me mid way eating his regular beef burger and was like .. well this is better than McDonald's! If I could buy them frozen I would eat them weekly, seriously. Yes they may be a little pricy but to take in account the price of meat these days and the quality it doesn't even phase me it's totally worth it! As I'm writing this I want another one ! also I want to mention our waiter bc he was super attentive and was concerned we were waiting a while and we were not. Usually the wait staff at any restaurant could care less if you have been waiting by the time they make it to your table but I thought it was super cool he wanted to make sure we were taken care of. Great food and good wait staff, sign me up! read more

Prime Burger Bar - Build your own Turkey burger! Totally recommended ! - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Today was a daddy-daughter day from swim lessons to play park to lunch. I always look to try something new and well recommended. Using my handy Yelp app, I found Prime even before I left the play indoor park where my daughter and some friends from school met up and the parents were lucky enough to get them out of the house for a little while because it was just too cold to hang outside. There is a large parking lot out front that makes that part of the experience a snap. Once inside, we were immediately seated and Gabby came straight away to introduce herself and offer us some drinks. After just a minute to peruse the kiddy menu and the promise of an ice cream afterwards, guaranteed that the burger and bowl of pasta would be eliminated without delay for my little girl. My burger was a little more involved- The thing is, you choose the meat/non meat protein, the bread or non bread, and the toppings. For me it was (and they have to name it after me if it ever appears on their menu) Lamb burger cooked medium on challah bread with caramelized onions and mushrooms with tzatziki sauce.. Wow - so good. Both my daughter's burger and mine were served with French fries but you can upgrade to other types if you prefer. I left fat and happy and she did as well because we made good on the promise of an ice cream with whipped cream and sprinkles- just like any good daddy would. Very excellent well-priced meal for us and I would definitely come back for a meal whenever in the area. read more

The burgers are awesome! Try the Juicy Lucy, yum! The drinks are top notch and tasty! Their short rib sandwich is so delicious with their sweet potato fries and onion rings. They also have these out of this world ice cream sundaes that you have to try. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Cookies and Ice Cream Sundae - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Not impressed. My husband brought me here after he had gone with his friend and really liked it. I was expecting a phenomenal burger, but not so much. I got a Wagyu burger with Burrata cheese and peppers and onions and after one bite, I actually spit it out-the burger meat just tasted "off ". I told our server and they politely took it off the menu, as they should. But I didn't order anything else, I just ate the burrata cheese with the peppers and onions. The fries were also nothing to talk about- won't be returning. read more

My boyfriend and I tried this place on a weekday since we heard about the hype from my coworkers in farmingdale ! We walked in and it was a cute atmosphere, we got seated right away and had the cutest waitress (I want to say her name was cecile, I'm sorry if I'm wrong) she was so helpful and made the first time experience unforgettable. We ordered for an appetizer prime rib Mac and cheese that was so good (the pictures below won't even do its justice) My boyfriend ordered the bacon on bacon burger and I ordered the steak burger so good !!! Parking is great also !! Only complaint is that tables are close together but that's okay the place was smaller and we sat next to a nasty couple who were super rude !! This place will see me again :) Also if you love bourbon KENTUCKY BURBON BEER IS A MUST TRY so yummy !!! read more

See all

Wow wow wow!!! We just picked up two burgers from Prime Burger Bar in Commack and it was an absolutely FANTASTIC dinner! To begin with the young girl that took my order over the phone was so sweet and nice. The order was ready in about 15 minutes and when we opened up the boxes at home we were really amazed. Such a huge burgers perfectly cooked and served with either french fries or very tasty and fresh coleslaw. Fresh lettuce, tomato, onion and a pickle slice as well as a choice of buns just added to the deliciousness. I give this place 5 stars!!! Keep up the great work. read more

Great spot! Kid friendly. Really creative food options too :) Wait service was quick ! We got the farmhouse chicken sandwich with sweet potatoes waffle fries and marshmallow sauce read more

Ok..... just stop in your tracks right now!!! My wife turned to me tonight and said, let's go to Prime Burger Bar. I want a great burger. Upon arriving, I could not have been greeted by a nicer staff. Everyone was the Mr. Rogers of hospitality. So amazingly pleasant. From hostess, to waiter, to manager. (OMG they got it right). Then came the food. This is where I stopped in my tracks...... really, you can make a simple burger taste like fine dining???it was truly as amazing as the staff. No Bullshit!!! This place is so real! They are great and food was great. (Do you think I was pleased?? Are you getting this?) I have absolutely no ties to this restaurant other than to say.... Thank you for making my evening special. You guys rock!!!! read more

Great food, service and atmosphere. The staff is really friendly and goes the extra mile. The food is fresh (homemade salad dressing !) and prices are good. All good. read more

Came here for the first time tonight. I personally wanted to keep it light so I ordered a chocolate milkshake ($7) and classic Poutine ($11.95), the other two people with me ordered burgers with fries and onion rings. Where do I begin... The chocolate milkshake was the most watery milkshake I've ever had...it tasted like water with whipped cream on top. It was not thick and icy at all or creamy. The poutine was served cold and the fries tasted like they were old. Both of my friends said their burgers were undercooked and cold in the middle and the bread wasn't toasted and the beers they ordered were warm. Among the few redeeming qualities of this experience was that our waiter was nice and welcoming. The girl expediting the food from the kitchen wore her hair down which was a little unsettling, as no one wants hair in their food. The atmosphere was dark and gave an old pub vibe which I didn't mind. Overall this place was disappointing and I wouldn't eat here again. I wish we went to Five Guys. *** the bill was $92 read more

Love the outdoor eating option. Would suggest getting here early especially for the weekend. You do have to first go in to see the hostess but it did look like they moved her outside since today was a nice hot day out. They have a pretty large menu and something for everyone. We started off with the Bavarian pretzel. It comes with a spicy mustard, honey mustard, and beer cheese. The cheese ceased up quickly but it was good! The pretzel can come unsalted if you ask. We made our own burger and then had the lobster Mac and cheese. The burger was good but careful with the bacon jam- it was much sweeter than anticipated and overtook the complete taste of the burger. We did love the garlic aoli that the French fries came with. The lobster Mac and cheese was good. A fair amount of Mac and cheese to lobster ratio. It seems like it would not be filling but trust me it is. We decided to top it off with a sweet and salty milkshake. Trust me- it was more than enough to share! I could not imagine getting my own unless it was the only thing I came for. There was even life music! Great experience. All servers are wearing masks and they have a sign that you must wear a mask indoors unless sitting read more

See all

Great menu, great happy hour prices, great food and nice employees Very friendly place, burgers are delicious Wings outrageous, great selection of beers n happy hour drink Worth a trip! read more

This is place is a great find. The burgers are the best I've had at any restaurant, better than the other local places like Jackson's and the service is helpful, friendly and attentive. My friends and I had the cheese burger and fries which were delicious on the luncheon menu also coleslaw and well priced. Don't forget to try their homemade coleslaw it's great. Also the price even gets more economical if you sit at the bar during happy hour. I'll definitely be going back. read more

See all

My kid's face lights up when we walk into this place- the burgers are excellent and the shakes are awesome! Great service, everyone was super nice. Tables are space far apart with dividers for covid safety. Will keep coming back read more

Prime Burger Bar - Sweet potato fries with marshmallow die - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

I've been doing outdoor dining here during COVID - and the food is just as good as ever! The Giant Bavarian Pretzel is great as an appetizer and the short rib poutine is great too especially if you're a fan of salty flavors. The fire island burger has a good amount of spice - not too mild and not too hot. My ultimate favorite from here is the Baja chicken sandwich! read more

See all

Sam was the quintessential hostess. Attentive and kind. The bar is quaint and comfortable. The food was delish! I enjoyed my Tex Mex burger since I'm a big avo fan! My hubs ordered the Great South Bay, which he thoroughly enjoyed with a side of onion rings. Onion rings had a 'kicked up' dip that was enjoyed by the whole family. Bacon on bacon and BBQ were the other favorites enjoyed by our two sons. No room for dessert! However, there's always next time! read more