Haven't been here for a while and received a text from a friend telling us they're donating 15% of your bill to St Anthony's HS and since we were in the mood for a burger we headed over. We weren't disappointed! The burgers were great and the sweet potato fries with marshmallow sauce is amazing. My hubby had wings and they also were just the way he likes like them. The bartenders Erin and Justin were so nice and we met one of the new owners Joe who came out and talked with us which is always a nice gesture. Definitely will go back . read more

"From the moment we walked in, everything was exceptional. The food was fresh, flavorful and delicious. The chef, bartender and staff made us feel genuinely welcome, and the atmosphere was warm and inviting. It's the kind of place you can't wait to return to. Top rated French dip and pulled pork! Can't wait to go back! read more

Just leaving: Prime Burger Bar! If you haven't been there, check it out! Food is luscious! The staff, Waiter Joe and the owner Joe, And me the customer Josephine~~ Are all wonderful! A lot of bang for the buck and drinks are not overly priced! So come on down! Build your own Burger. Or have their delicious fried Chicken toppings sides... all fabulous! Manga! read more

I am selective when offering 5 stars, has to be great food, service, value etc. I'd give 10 if I could here. The place is so welcoming and friendly from start to finish. The food is fantastic so much so I recently had lunch delivered via Uber Eats and it was like I was there eating that's how fresh it was. I highly recommend the Prime Burger Bar. They have also added live music which we love. read more

It was not busy, but we unfortunately waited over 10 minutes in the front by the door before someone greeted us. There was a bartender but she never even apologized or let us know what was going on. We were finally seated without menus and just sat there with our two toddlers waiting for service. Once our server came, he left to get us menus. We were ready to order but our server went to two other tables that were seated after us and took their orders. By this time our toddlers weren't happy. After we placed our order, we waited a while for our food. The burger was good but the fries were extremely over cooked. They were dried out and crispy like deformed potato chips. We immediately asked for the check when we got our food based on the service up to that point. I know every place can have an off day, but I will have a hard time going back to this place. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Terrible, overcooked fries. You know it's bad when your kids don't eat them. - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Another fantastic burger establishment on Long Island, Prime Burger Bar is just Fantastic, food and bar tenders are the best. Happy Hour should not be missed. Bar seating only for Happy Hour Mon-Fri. Service is professional and friendly . Their selection of burgers second to none.... they're as good and maybe even better than any steakhouse. Highly recommend and get there early if you want a seat at the bar. read more

See all

So I used to be a frequent visitor when they had the Plainview location. But unfortunately that shut down, so now whenever we're in the area we like to come back. Justin manning the bar and taking food orders was awesome. Very fast service, extremely friendly. The ambience throughout was incredible. Everyone was very friendly and we engaged in great sports talk. For my entree I had the buffalo buttermilk fried chicken sandwich, extra well done added bacon and made the chicken extra wet. Got it with a side of onion rings and all the sauces I asked for came right out. This sandwich has always been amazing. Perfectly cooked, perfect amount of kick with bleu cheese and pairs amazing with the pretzel bun. The onion rings are always crispy and delicious, I do wish they threw in some more onion rings lol but overall it was incredible. read more

See all

Love the burgers here. Typically I just get the sliders because it's enough for me. The kids love the shakes This time I had fried cheese curds, will def be having them again And for my fellow lushes, they offer happy hour all day at the bar ! Bonnie at the bar is very welcoming and was running the tables and bar alone and rocked it read more

Prime Burger Bar - Cheeseburger sliders - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

In a world of generic food, the meal we had was pretty gosh darn tasty. The menu is extensive and you can also build your own The bacon on bacon burger lived up to it's name with big thick cuts of bacon, tasty bacon jam, and bacon infused into the burger meat itself. I will say they should have let the burger rest a bit because it was super drippy. Fries were average but it's actually pretty rare to find a place that excels at burgers AND has amazing fries. Tex Mex salad was loaded with flavor and I added chicken for some extra protein. Service was speedy on a Saturday evening and everything was fresh. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Tex Mex salad with chicken - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Fantastic food, great service, friendly bar. Justin behind the bar was amazing. Great sports conversation with everyone at the bar, the vibe was perfect drinks flowing sports on tv great local conversations. The Bavarian pretzel is like butter and the sauces. The sliders were amazing and the fully loaded fries. Upset the Plainview location closed, will be returning when in the vicinity. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Bar Area - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Absolute best experience! The Chef Joe & Bartender Alissa are so welcoming with such great personalities. Makes you feel right at home! Can't wait to come back! read more

Prime Burger Bar - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Burgers were really yummy! Tried the Okie burgers on the recommendation of our server, Joe, and they were delicious! The fries were absolutely perfect. Joe was such a great server- friendly, intelligent, funny, and warm. Definitely a huge asset to the establishment. He didn't rush us even though we were still there sharing a brownie sundae, as closing time approached. TRY THE SUNDAE TOO! read more

Service: Great! I always sit at the bar because Justin is the best person there! He is so attentive and can anticipate what you need! Food: North Shore Burger - Favorite! From the sauce to the mushrooms, this burger is always well seasoned and well cooked! I always ask for a side of the cabernet sauce to make the burger extra saucy. Breakfast Burger - Well cooked. The egg on the burger makes it extra saucy. It is a bit messy to eat with the yolk dripping for the burger but it was well worth it! Fried Cheese Curds - Fried cheese! What's not to love? Hot Classic Wings - Delicious! Their wings are temperature hot and the classic hot was not too spicy! There was some heat and a lot of flavor! On to my next adventure.... read more

Prime Burger Bar - Hot Classic Wings - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Good choice of burgers and everywhere is crazy pricing for burgers now, however, they have a great deal that makes regular burgers extremely reasonable. The food is very good. The atmosphere is pure neighborhood pub. Located in a shopping center that is always relatively empty, there is great availability of parking spots. Come for lunch. Very good burger spot, especially lamb burger. read more

Very good food and enjoyed this spot. Came here with my fiancé , her sister, and sister's husband for a quick lunch. Service was great and they do a great job and expedited food for a busy burger spot. I went crispy chicken sandwich and fries. Chicken sandwich was very flavorful and cooked to perfection. The French fries were very good and for a side I got fried cheese curds and they were out of this world. First time seeing them on a menu and I'm happy I tried them. Great beer selection & cocktails. Bartender here was not shy on her pour game and drinks were very strong lol! My fiancé sister Long Island ice tea was very strong and not over bearing where you couldn't enjoy it. All around solid burger spot with great food. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Buttermilk fried chicken sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

This was our second time visiting this lovely spot on Jericho Tpke in Commack, after work, close to 5 pm. Once there, the crowd was light, talkative and not loud. We were met by Joe, our waiter. He was very knowledgeable, attentive and not intrusive. He took time to explain a menu item, wings. I know this is apart of his job, but it was nice to hear and see. My FIRE ISLAND BURGER was delicious. The bacon added to its flavor. The accompanying fries could have been seasoned with a tad more salt. And I wanted more of them. Parking is plenty. The bathroom stalls are small, however. The menu also includes thick shakes and sandwiches. read more

Prime Burger Bar - FIRE ISLAND BURGER - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Came here with my wife and grandson for dinner. We were seated very quickly. Daniela was our waiter. She was excellent. My grandson had the kids burger with fries. Boy did he get a lot of fries. My wife had the Buttermilk Chicken sandwich which was really good. A very large sandwich which she took home half. I had the Bbq Burger which was cooked to perfection. I asked for medium with well done bacon which came out just like I asked. The burger was delicious. I felt like Guy Fieri doing the burger hunch to get the burger into my mouth. Onion straws were great and the bbq sauce was good. Well definitely be back read more

Love this place! Got the Po Boy special- holy smokes!!! Don't miss that... wow. Great drinks and great service. Highly recommend.

Solid burgers with dry aged and Kobe offerings for meat. Good range of toppings choices but the meat is a bit plain so factor that in. The regular bun is chewy and hard so I recommend getting a different type. Onion rings stole the show, they are crispy and delicious 5/5. Fries are anemic and floppy. Overall this isn't my favorite burger place but it's not a disaster either, 3.5 stars. read more

See all

7 months later & I'm still appliance shopping LMAO! Soooo of course I had to stop back in for a delicious burger. Not realizing it was happy hour my bartender gave me the lowdown on the specials. $17 or $8 for the same burger different toppings. I gave it a shot. And I was very pleased. My $8 burger was cooked perfectly medium rare. Juicy & seasoned just enough. Nice crowd at the bar & the bartender was on point. Thanks Prime! Keep doing what you do best! 10-17-2023 read more

See all

Burger was delicious. Fries and onion rings were on point. Great service. Definitely will be back.

Good service bartender/ server was great it was only 1pm so place wasn't crowded so everything came out on time food was good so was the drink. No complaints here read more

See all

This place is nice. The servers are always kind and attentive. The service is fast and efficient. There's lots of food options, both healthy and indulgent. I ordered a greek salad here and it was great! I wish there was more seating here because it's a slightly small place if you don't plan to sit at the bar, but it's still great. read more

We always have a great experience here, especially because Alissa always brings great service to any night out.

Stopped in as sign on street said $10 burgers all day. Apparently that goes only to 6 and if you sit at the bar not a table as our very nice waitress told us. Clearly disappointed as thought we were getting a deal and had already ordered our drinks we decided to stay. From menu posting you can see the cheapest hamburger is $15.99 with lots of up charges. We opted to order other menu items. I got the New England clam chowder which was a special- it was flavorful with lots of clams. Thinner/Creamer consistency than I normally prefer but still delicious. Also ordered was wings. They were meaty and tasty but note you only get 7. Not a very big order. And lastly the bacon Mac and cheese - creamy and great cheese pull. Overall nice decor and tasty food. Not sure we will be back though as the hamburger deal was misleading and felt the menu was a bit overpriced. Maybe we should have tried the hamburgers and just paid the extra money. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Menu - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Everytime I come here to dine or take out, there's some sort of issue. I come in one night it's dead and they still mess up my order. No joke. Either that or I order it well done and it comes out severely under cooked. Save your money and time and go else where. read more

Stopped in on Monday because I received an e-mail offer of 10.95 for a burger fries and milkshake didn't realize it was a bar but sat at the bar and the meal was great .... read more

Prime Burger Bar - Awesome - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Only giving four-star since I've only been there once, but it was a five star lunch. Met my husband on his lunch break there with our baby and got the bacon bacon burger, he got the tuna burger, and the baby got a hotdog (obviously she ate like a quarter of it lol). My burger was delicious, a a little bit more cook than I like, but my husband told me I said medium not medium rare so that's all my fault. However, even with that it was still juicy and delicious. My husband said the tuna burger was fantastic and I saw the steer on it was beautiful. French fries were definitely addicting. My only complaint, very minor, is that it was very dark for a lunchtime. Kind of wish the lighting was a little bit brighter. server was very friendly and helpful! read more

Boyfriend wanted burger night...Yelp brought us here. We opted to sit at the bar. Our bartender/server was fabulous. I wish I remembered his name. He was very attentive and checked on us often, all without being annoying. We started with fried sprouts. They were nice and crisp and had a maple bacon glaze. Every single bite was delicious and a party in my mouth. My boyfriend ordered the "Great South Bay" burger. It was a burger topped with braised short rib, caramelized onions, Swiss cheese and cabernet sauce. I had a bite and it was delish! He enjoyed it as well. He upgraded his side of fries to loaded fries which were equally as delish! The house cheese sauce was delicious! I had the Ahi Tuna sandwich without the bun. It was seared rare with a ponzu glaze, topped with red bell pepper and cabbage slaw with house ginger dressing. I also added avocado to it. It was yummy and fresh! Our sever was kind enough to ask if I preferred it cooked a little over it being seared rare. I upgraded my fries to sweet potato waffle fries. The fries came with a marshmallow dipping sauce. It was delicious! Drinks were good as well. Beer for me, vodka soda for him. Service and food were equally amazing! On our way home my boyfriend mentioned this is going to be our new spot. I'm not mad at it. I already know what I want next time! read more

See all

Prime is great for a Friday night out! Good selection of food and drinks. Sometimes it does get a bit slow with the service and take a little bit. However I don't recommend ordering DoorDash through this restaurant. It is always cold and the food is soggy. This may be a DoorDash issue but I don't think the food is meant for takeout! Restaurant is cozy and clean. Good ambience read more

Not super impressed with this meal and it smelled very heavily of chemicals when we walked in (at least it was clean though!). We started with the spinach artichoke dip, the chips were gross. I didn't love that the chips were so heavily dyed, and they were a bit greasy from being fried. We asked for another set because they were a bit stale, and the fresh ones they brought us were much better. The steak sandwiches were very fatty, but the sauce they came with and the buffalo chicken sandwich was very good. Ask for the fries well done, if not they are pretty soggy. The milkshakes were very not thick and not very cold either. However, the service was very good. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Buffalo Chicken Sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

The food here is great , service is top notch and a nice drink selection at the bar. I'd give 5 stars but the "All day Happy Hour " sign is a bit misleading. I've been to the bar 5 times and 3 times found out some stipulation depriving me of the entire reason I entered . Other than that. This place is ALL GOOD . I live in the Area and I go with my wife for the steak tip sandwich and the wings . Great atmosphere. read more

Ordered here many times but this time they were off their game. Burgers seemed old. Cole slaw very dry. Spent over $140 and no napkins or ketchup packets (7 of 8 of us had fries)? Sorry, but not giving them business again, they're past their prime. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Small portion of slaw - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Elite! Great food. Nice decor. Waitress was extremely friendly. Stopped here for a quick bite but would definitely add this to my arsenal whenever I'm in the area. 10/10 read more

Prime Burger Bar - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Came back to Prime for their great burgers, and delicious wings. Nice atmosphere and good service. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Menu - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Love love love this restaurant. These burgers are like none other. Huge and delicious! There's a large selection of menu items, and their milkshakes are also grand and tasty. Of the several times I have been here, I think most if not all the waiters have been great. Highly recommend this place if you're looking for a good burger. read more

See all

Great burgers, apps and sides. Good service too. My favorite burger spot. Fun ambience, not stuffy at all, very casual.

Food was great and bartenders were attentive and friendly. Wings were great and also had a good beer selection Have been back 2 weeks in a row. read more

The north shore Kobe burger is the best tasting burger on Long Island. But I've tried a couple burgers and have never been disappointed

First time here. Had a special promotion for a free appetizer, which our waitperson had a difficult time handling. He had to ask the manager. Then after he straightened that out, he forgot to bring it out with our meals. Again and again, he was asked. We were almost finished when he finally brought it out. Please keep in mind that although this place is a bar, it draws families in because it makes these special milkshakes. Bars are usually noisy. Add kids and it is way too loud. We were fine until four kids were seated right next to us. Then we moved to a wobbly table. The third time was fine but very close to the bar. We ordered two delicious burgers, which is what they are all about. read more

See all