Well well well....where to start. My beau picked this place (although I had eyeballed it at one time too but prefer places that aren't byob), and we came prepared with a nice bottle of wine. Before I start on the food, please note this restaurant backs up to a strip mall, so the parking is in the back where the mall stores are. Parking is competitive, but available.
Advice to the owners....when you do today's "specials," we expect to hear 2 maybe 3 dishes. The waiter (who's name escapes me right now) was very nice, and very thorough, but there were like 5 specials for appetizers and 5 for dinner. I am not a fan of mushrooms, so every time I heard it in the description, I kinda faded out the rest, but beau (who does like mushrooms) said he couldn't even remember half of the dishes the waiter said. Okay, not a crisis, we went with the menu.
The menu is very nice. Lots of choices for appys and for meals, and not your typical Italian food fare, so that was a pleasant surprise.
Sooo, I ordered clams on the half shell and calamari, and beau had the mozzarella, Tomato and Roasted Peppers. He loved his. The clams were good and fresh, the calamari? Not so much. If you look at my other reviews, I have a real dislike for gummy calamari, and although this is the not the worst I've had, it was definitely more on the gummy side.
For dinner, beau had the Tuscan Style Grilled Swordfish Steak. Huge piece of steak, very well cooked and very tasty. This was served over broccoli rabe with sun dried tomatoes in a garlic/lemon/olive oil sauce. It was really good--we give it 5 stars.
I had the Lump Crab Cake, and opted out of the veggies and potatos for a caesar salad. The crab cakes were pretty good (a little more lemony than I would have liked, but not bad), however, the caesar salad? Aside from looking less than fresh (lettuce was wilted, croutons were soggy), it was drenched in whatever dressing that was, which definitely did not taste like caesar, and was way too salty (and I LOVE salt).
We did not have dessert, but a party table next to us did and all the desserts looked delectable.
Would I go here again? Perhaps. I usually go to Ciro's in Jamesburg for Italian food, and I pretty much measure any other Italian establishments against their food because I have never had a bad dish there, and can get a Margherita at my table lol. I would have given Vecchio 3.5 stars, but I couldn't figure out how to do that here. read more