We ordered takeout from Pizza Plus last night, and it turned out to be a really good choice for an easy dinner at home. The pizza had a nice balance of sauce and cheese -- not overloaded, but definitely not skimpy either. The crust was lightly crisp on the outside with a soft, chewy inside. You can tell it was freshly made and not just sitting around. The toppings were evenly spread, and every slice actually had what it was supposed to (which isn't always the case with some places). Overall, it was a dependable, satisfying pizza night. If you're in Newman and want a straightforward, tasty takeout option, Pizza Plus definitely delivers. read more

Pizza Plus - Pizza Near Me - Newman, California

Pizza is pretty good. We ordered large 1/2 meat combo and 1/2 Canadian bacon. My kids liked the cheese bread the best. It came out after the pizza. The wait didn't take long and staff are friendly. They don't have utensils to serve the pizza so you have to use your hands and with meat combo the pizza is greasy. We would stop by again if in the area. read more

Pizza Plus - 1/2 meat 1/2 Canadian bacon - Pizza Near Me - Newman, California

See all

Decor was super cool with all the sports memorabilia. They were very friendly. We placed our order and chose a table. There were 7 of us drinks rolled out to our table within 5 minutes, pizzas within 10. The order was correct, freshly made, and delicious, 3 different types of pizza and everyone loved them. They checked on us and made sure we were all good. Our first time there and not our last. read more

Great pizza, great service. Highly recommend. Exactly what you expect from this place.

My family loves Pizza Plus everything is Delicious excellent service delicious delicious

Always great pizza and even when we call during dinner rush they're still pretty quick.

We ordered the all meat combo and wings. The pizza was great! The wings were great! The price was much more affordable than the other pizza place in town and the delivery was on time. This is the go to pizza place in Newman. read more

Best pizza in town, hands down. Even on the busiest of nights, when the staff is jumping table to table to clean, take orders, fulfill customers needs, the food is consistently good. They have plenty of room inside for the local baseball teams to gather. This business gives back to the community and is a huge benefit to our town. read more

Great pizza and it's always are go to. Marinated veggie pizza and the heart attack is so good.

Great service and a welcoming atmosphere every time. The staff is friendly, the place is always clean, and everything is well run. Joey, the owner, goes above and beyond and it shows. He truly cares about the business and the people who come in. On top of that, the pizza is consistently excellent and easily the best around. read more

I've continued to order from pizza plus and have not had any further issues. Service and food have been great!!

Reasonable , far price. You can possibly custom your order to. That's what I do when I order

After so many years of coming here for pizza I will not be anymore disappointed by far ordered pizza tonight for the kids and the pizza was extremely raw I don't understand why they wouldn't check before sending them out yuk please retrain your employees on proper food handling before someone gets extremely ill read more

Pizza is good, some days better than others, so it's hit or miss. Wednesday 11/26 pizza was great, today Thursday 12/11 pizza was okay and seemed to have very little sauce. Wonder if it's different cooks depending on the day of the week. read more

Best pizza in this area most delicious pizza with good deals every day and friendly staff.

What a little gem in the heart of Newman! We were visiting our Lola who lives here and she mentioned this pizza spot was REALLY good. Of course we took her word for it and came by for dinner.. There's plenty of parking outside on the street. This is your typical pizza restaurant, sports decorations on the wall, few arcade games on the side, plenty of tables around. They have specials everyday depending on what day it is. We came on a Wednesday so it was 2 medium pizzas, ANY toppings for $30, plus a 2 liter soda. That's a great deal, especially as many toppings as you want. We went with pepperoni and sausage for 1, and mushroom/sausage with white sauce on the other. We also asked for extra crispy crust, A MUST! The pizza came out fairly quick, and it was delicious! I wasn't expecting too much but I was blown away by how good it was. The crust was crispy, lots of cheese and it just tasted like a great overall pizza. We were all happy with our food! And we'll definitely be back next time we're in town! read more

They are overcharging for the salad bar!!! Cheaper in gustine at pizza places there. Plus no heat at their store. Cold. Embarrassing cold inside. read more

I had one of the best combination piazzas I hav had in a long while. Great crust and generous toppings contributed a memorable pizza. It was part of the two pizza Saturday special. read more

By far the best tasting pizza in town! Service is cheerful and food delicious! The owners support the community big time! For every event, you'll see them mentioned as sponsors. read more

After a long day of softball all I wanted to do was have a nice slice of pizza with breadsticks. But that wasn't the case. My breadsticks were undercooked, pizza had almost no pepperoni. When I called they said the breadsticks looked cooked. I'm sorry, they looked cooked from the outside but the inside was still not fully cooked. Pizza plus has lost its touch! read more

Pizza Plus - Pepperoni much - Pizza Near Me - Newman, California

Always great pizza!! The pepperoni, the combination and chicken veggie with cream sauce are the best. read more

Pizza plus has always been our go to, but yesterday, our combination pizza looked very sad, they forgot/or ran out of some veggies and didn't bother to inform us about it. I hope its not turning like the patterson pizza plus, because that how they started, running out of ingredients! Update: owner looked up our order after she saw the review and offered her help to make it right. It turns out there was a mistake in orders and we got some one else's combo pizza and she made it right and made sure I was happy and confident in continuing to enjoy their business. Thank you! read more

Pizza Plus - Our sad combination pizza/forgot/ran out of veggies? - Pizza Near Me - Newman, California

Everyone says the ripon pizza plus is the best one, but I personally prefer the Newman location! Great service and the pizza taste is always consistent and so good. Take a cruise out to Newman and get a pizza. read more

Pizza Plus - Large pepperoni with white sauce , half garlic and an order of cheese sticks . - Pizza Near Me - Newman, California

This is a hidden little gem! We had low expectations and were very pleasantly surprised. Plain cheese pizza is our go to order. The cheese is very flavorful and has a nice melt to it. We did try some wings and fries and they were meh but the ranch was really really good. read more

First time going to this Pizza plus. The combo pizza was perfecto...loved it. Is was worth driving 20 miles and on top of it they gave us a free sandwich read more

Pizza Plus - Bomb pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newman, California

False prices. Lady told me on the phone a person pizza was $11 when I get there my total comes out to $18?????? What is this out of tower tax???? read more

I have been ordering Pizza there for quite some time and it is always delivered hot and just the way I ordered. This evening I called to order a pizza at 7:50 pm and was told they do not deliver at this time. I am pretty sure Ive ordered up until 8 for delivery. I do not drive so I could not place my order and will question whether I want to order from them again. Dusappointed. read more

Best Pizza in the valley by far! Their supreme is the best, it's always so tasty. Hard to beat!

I've been loving this Pizza since they were in Patterson and then I follow them to Newman Pizza is great but customer service sucks especially the manager LINDA she's rude. Screaming at customers in front of all employees and all the people. I hope she leaves her problems at home not bring them to work. F U , Linda. read more

Best pizza in Newman! Also great wings and cheesy bread. Doesn't break the bank and can deliver!

Best pizza around! The owners are great! everything is always fresh and delivery drivers are always friendly and professional. Doing a great job during this pandemic to keep their staff and the community safe. Thank you! read more

It is SO GOOD the only bad thing is that the lines do get a little to long and you're wait is a little long

Best tasting Pizza and great family atmosphere! Local owners who really care about and support this community.

Best pizza in town always enjoy fresh pizza nice and hot. I travel to get the best best pizza in town

I ordered 2 medium pizza extra crispy last night they came cold and raw, the cheese wasn't even melted all the way and the dough was raw. Worst pizza I've ever had, sad when best pizza in our town is Little Caesars. I would recommend stay away from pizza plus they are wildly inconsistent read more

Newman Pizza Plus makes great pizza And the staff is always friendly. I go out of my way to travel to Newman to get my pizza. read more

You need to work on some things. First of all, you took away the one trip salad bar. You only have the $10 salad bar! what? I only want a small one trip! I don't want to pay $10 for it! Come on! It's not costing you that much to provide the beans, spinach and produce items! Also, your online ordering is not working anymore!!!! That was a huge, easy way to order. Fix the issues, please! read more

My husband and I got their Saturday special and some wings. Food is really fresh and my in laws, who live Newman, really like the pizzas. The employees are nice and friendly as well. read more

Best pizza in town always enjoy fresh pizza nice and hot. I travel to get the best pizza

Excellent. Came in for lunch. Had a meatball sandwich that was awesome. Beer prices are great. read more

See all