A fucken joke of a place. Ordered a margarita pizza. They completely forgot to add the basil pesto and balsamic glaze. Went back inside to show the cook what he gave us and just gave us sauce in containers. Didn't even offer to fix it. Go spend money on overpriced pizza somewhere else. read more

Pizza Paradiso - Bullshit - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

I REALLY wanted to love this place - it had a lot going for it - super close to our hotel, some of our favorite cuisines (pizza for the keiki, kebab for the grownups), plus drinks and desserts, but it was just okay. This place does a lot, which I appreciate, but I was left wanting. The pizza had a good thin crust, but was SO greasy - it was dripping with grease, even after blotting some off. The kebab and rice platter was just fine, it lacked flavor. I liked that they used compostable leaves instead of paper to line the tray. Mai Tai was average. Truly, it probably deserves somewhere between 3 and 4 stars, especially for a local business. But it wasn't good enough for me to go back, so I rounded down. Busy on a weekend evening. It seemed they had a lot of takeaway pizza orders, too, because the line sometimes built up but the tables never filled. read more

I want to give this place 5 stars because the food is delicious, but the customer service was awful. My husband and I came here on Friday night to pick up pizza for the kids. While we waited for our food we ordered drinks at the Pineapple Robot bar and had a great time talking with the bartender. Like I said, the food was amazing, everyone was pleasantly surprised by how good the pizza was!! Back at our hotel room we did realize that the restaurant forgot to give us our roasted garlic bulbs, but figured we would return on Saturday, with the whole family, and they'd make it right. Fast forward to Saturday night and we are ordering more pizza, salad, fries, and a smash burger. We explain that they forgot to give us our roasted garlic the night before and the man behind the counter was acting as if we were lying and trying to cheat them out of a $3 side! Thankfully I had our receipt but that didn't change his attitude toward us. We also had a coupon for a free Dole Whip. I asked if we could put it on our check but come back after we ate the pizza to grab our dessert. He said yes, but I wish I had remembered to grab our receipt. After we ate we went back to get our Dole Whip. He had zero recollection of our conversation and said we had to pay for it because he gave us a free slice of pizza instead (while that was another option on the coupon, I remember seeing the transaction on his register when he had removed the dole whip. I was surprised that Dole Whip would cost $7). He made a comment about 'being busy and we can't expect him to remember every transaction' so I told my husband to just buy another Dole Whip. Unfortunately, we will not be returning to the Pizza Paradiso. Giving us our $3 garlic with a quick apology would have gone a long way in terms of customer service!! And honoring our coupon would have been also! We are talking about Pennie's on the dollar, and why would we try to 'steal' such small items on their menu? It was very short sided on their end. We are a family of 6 and ordered a ton of food each night. read more

Pizza Paradiso - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

I needed some carbs to get ready for a tennis tournament the next day so we found this place. One of the only places open in the area after 8pm! The prices were a little high for what you get, but the food was pretty good. The best part was they had karaoke and I got to sing for/with my teammates! They enjoyed their drinks and food as well. I got a slice of the day and a side of fries. The fries were normal, and the slice was pretty good. We got to try the pineapple soft serve which was very refreshing. Free parking and they're open late. I would come back to sing anytime! read more

Pizza Paradiso - Fries, pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

Excellent Pizza! We were in Maui for a few days and we arrived late the first day. We were just looking for a quick take-out spot to eat at our resort on the way in from the airport. This place was close by, open (after 10PM) and had decent ratings. We ordered two (2) Large Pizzas: Margherita Pizza and the Pizza Paradiso. So the Margherita was probably the best I have ever had, with fresh tomatoes, a thin garlic & oil crust and Pesto sauce on the side (yum!). The Paradiso is basically the Supreme. It came loaded with Pepperoni, Sausage, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms. One of my sons wanted a slice of the "Maui Wowie" (ham amd pineapple) and my other son had the Chicken Shawarma sandwich which he commented was 'OK'. Everyone loves the Pizza. Sorry about no pictures but we ate everything so fast! (Good sign right???). And we went back 3 nights later. About $28/pie so not the cheapest but good pizza and reasonable for Maui. read more

Pizza Paradiso - Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Was not expecting this place to be so good, so glad we gave it a shot! We came at the perfect time and didn't have to wait at all. The line got LONG very quickly. Very fresh and delicious food! We got a slice of the Maui Wowie pizza and a slice of pepperoni pizza. The Caesar salad had the best Caesar dressing I've ever had! 10/10 for the dole whip Will be back soon! read more

Pizza Paradiso - Maui Wowie - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

Good spot. Given we dined at 9:15pm and under 21 was getting kicked out (if not dining with a family) at 10p, perhaps I'm a little bit out of the demographic since it was loud (not simply "energetic". However, the family thought everything we ordered was great. Service lacking. Ordering reminded me of the Seinfeld soup ordering bit. Somewhat rude even when their menus aren't clear. How would someone know only certain pizzas can be ordered by the slice? I noticed afterwards that the online menu is clear. In restaurant, simply states slices are available. Karaoke was fun! read more

I'm not sure why this place isn't rated better. The food was great! We ordered a whole pizza and had a cup pineapple whip. Service was good. Atmosphere was chill! Queue line a little strange but no big deal. read more

See all

Don't waste your $. The AI ordering is a joke. I was about 45 min away and wanted them to hold off on making my order. I called back 5 times before anyone answered, at that point they already started preparing my food. I asked them to keep it warm if possible. When I picked it up there was an extra pizza added and none of my order was correct. The photos they show on their website is nothing like what you actually get. Pass on this pizza. Go to Round table or some other choice if possible. Extremely disappointed while paying over $100.00 for what went in the trash. read more

For a pizza parlor in the middle of a tourist area, this place ain't bad. I've been a couple times when visiting Maui and it's usually great. (Much better option than the sad food truck lot across the way.) Anyway, they offer a selection of salads and pizzas, and everything is made to order. You can also snag wine, beer, and Dole whip when visiting. The ambience is a little funny so I would opt to take it to go and enjoy it on the beach or at your timeshare. Service has always been kind! read more

This place should have 5 stars from everyone for the simple fact that they have affordable slices of some good Pizza. The maui wowi pizza was bomb. The place stayed open late and always seemed to have quite a few people in it every time I went. lol, I went to this pizza place like four times in ten days. Wasn't a fan of the cocktails, I tried two. So I can understand the 4 stars from some. The filet kabob was yummy, overall I appreciated this pizza place. read more

We usually get takeout but after watching the Lahaina Lights Christmas parade we decided to eat in this time and were surprised to find a new bar at the end of the restaurant! Wow! What a great place to hang out and eat, plus they have a fun range of cocktails all served in fancy containers....well, empty Spam containers...lol...this is Maui after all :) I decided to dive into cocktail land with a Pixelate my Pony, served in a unicorn head, a delicious blend of passionfruit and booze. Hubbs ordered a coke and it came in a foldable recyclable cardboard container, so they are definitely doing their bit to save the planet. The bar staff, a couple of Italian guys, were sooooo much fun, they really had a great vibe going. Total characters and great at their job. Their antics really made our night so much more enjoyable. Our order was our usual, a Margharita pizza, with balsamic drizzle and fresh basil. So classic and soooo tasty. I'm addicted to it. I really like their hot feta with pillowy white pita too. They offer a full range of snacks, mains and desserts as well as a full bar and prove very popular with locals as well as tourists. Plus they offer Kamaaina rates which means we can afford to eat out as locals too. Karaoke on Saturdays starts at 9pm and goes until early morning. Trivia night is Sunday. They seem to have something going on every night and are always full of diners. A/C dining inside, bar and restaurant seating, and tables outside too. If you are on the west side and looking for a place to eat at any time of day try this restaurant, it's da bomb! read more

The atmosphere is awesome and the staff is super friendly! The cutest Robot delivers your food! The pizza is delicious! The Fat Gyro is what you wanna have yum! And pineapple dole whip! Everything is one stop... just yummy! Oh and beer and Mai Tais read more

Pizza Paradiso - Pizza and pineapple whip - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

Pizza- Looked delicious, but didn't want to spend 32+ for a pie for the family. Got gelato for two kids instead, $8 per (almost) Dixie cup per kid. It was decent, but expensive. Coconut anything is never bad. Guy behind the counter. He kinda sucked, but he was half right. He said the chocolate gelato was bad and my son wouldn't like it (He might have said it ironically, but it didn't land well with my wife). Turns out the chocolate gelato was bad (I didn't like it. Tasted like cacao powder you use to bake and water in gelato form), but my son loved it and ate the whole thing. He also stuck his finger in the gelato as he was scooping with bare hands. So idk. The vibe inside was cool, but pricey for what it was. read more

This place had lots of tourists inside, all ordering greek food and pizza, however I will be frank and say I only came in for the dole whip. While staying nearby, my family came in everyday to get 1-2 dole whips to enjoy. The lines could get long, so just be wary of that! There was plenty of seating and lighting inside the restaurant and overall the customer service was good even when it was very busy. read more

Pizza Paradiso - Dole whip - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Absolutely delicious! Wish I would have taken a picture of our pizza before we devoured it. Hit the spot, and fed my husband and I for $34 which is pretty good considering Maui prices. Will definitely return! read more

Delish! We called ahead for pick up and ordered 2 Paradiso, 1 bbq chicken, 1 pesto veggie pizzas and the Greek salad with a side of ranch dressing. Our food was ready within 25 minutes. We pulled in for pick up, paid and avoided the line that was almost out the door. The pizzas fed our family of 7 adults with a few extra leftovers. Pizza was made to perfection. Let's talk Ranch dressing.....I'm picky about ranch dressing, but I could drink a gallon of this. So yummy. Friendly service, decent prices, plentiful parking in a strip mall, next to Times grocery store. Everything was just perfect. We will be back. read more

Delicious pizza, excellent service, and a cool, laid-back ambiance. We tried the Hawaiian and mushroom pizzas, and both were incredibly flavorful! The staff was warm and welcoming. read more

See all

I really like their pizza. Easy and cheap (for Maui) dinner option after a long day at the beach. We had the Maui Wowee twice this week - don't believe what they say about pineapple on pizza! Pizza snobs might not like it but the kids will! Grab a six pack at the Times market and have dinner on the lanai! read more

The food was amazing! We ordered one of each pizza, gyros, cheese steak, and salads. We loved it all and were ordering again tonight with other guests. Thank you for enhancing our March's in Maui!!! read more

Ordered dine in PARADISO pizza. LOVELY! Tasted great and only took about 20 mins to get our pizza. Staff was very friendly and the pizza tasted phenomenal. Loved it and would recommend to anyone!! Pretty nice inside with a bar attached, and a little robot that delivers pizza slices. read more

Pizza Paradiso - Our Famous 12" Garlic Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

Ordered a normal Margherita Pizza. They forgot the basil pesto and balsamic vinegar. So it just had tomato and cheese *sigh*. We ordered a pepperoni pizza with sausage; which came out as ordered. However, the sausage was dry and didn't have the spice/herbs we expected. At least my toddler ate it; hence the 2 stars. read more

Pizza Paradiso - Margherita- they forgot some stuff - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Pizza sucked!!! No sauce on most of it. Wrong onions no peppers or parm which i specifically asked for. No pineapple on 2 pieces isnt this Hawaii??? Had their pizza before it was good this one was battling a Dijorno read more

Had great pizza here about 4 nights ago so went back tonight for 3 large pizzas. Got back to my hotel to find out my margarita pizza was just a cheese pizza w tomatoes. Had to wait for a while my car (staying at a resort) returned only to have the employee say oh sorry I forgot to give you the sauces, handing me two tiny sauce containers for a $34 large pizza. I was so frustrated I took the tiny sauces and left and am not eating the pizza, but didn't feel like talking to the guy any longer. I doubt I'll be back. read more

Delicious pizza! Fast service. My husband and I grabbed pizza after we landed and this was great!

I'm here for the dole whip. It didn't disappoint! Don't miss it! I'll be back for items, the bar is beautiful and the menu has salads, pizza and more read more

Pizza Paradiso - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Usually good smash Burgers but today they were dry and tasteless. No veggies or sauce. Very disappointing !

Good local dive. (Support local Maui). Not fancy - but a good pie. The service was quick and friendly - and the place is simple, but clean. Overall experience was 4 stars - but the 5th star is for knowing what makes a great pizza. The crust! Great tasting crust - and crispy! We ordered a large - half mushroom/truffle and half Paradiso. The baclava was not made there - thus not as crispy as it should be - but still okay. They earned 5. read more

See all

Reading reviews we were excited to check out this place. It wasn't anything like the reviews. Pizza was sitting under hot lights and looked old. Gelato looked old and flavors weren't appealing. No one greeted us while we were there. We walked out & went to Java Jazz for a delicious dinner, great drinks & terrific live music. When we were leaving Java Jazz, Pizza Paradiso had Karaoke going & it was super loud & people singing were horribly off key. read more

Food was very tasty and reasonable prices. service is with a smile and timely. Restaurant is clean and well lit. Definitely going.

Went just after sunset on a Sunday. Very busy inside but the line moves fast and food comes out pretty quickly. Gyros were massive, I'm scared to think what the doubles look like. Spicy fries had an excellent flavor. Staff was very friendly, and held onto my raincoat when I forgot it overnight. read more

One of the worst pizza places I have ever been to. I was so excited about reading the good reviews. But it was horrible. The service was really bad. Our cashier was really grumpy. When I walked inside it smelled so good and I really wanted a slice of pizza. My order was a pepperoni pizza and a special pizza we also got fries and salad. The fries and salad were the only good things I ate there. THERE WAS NO SAUCE ON THE PIZZA . I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND THIS PIZZA PLACE IF YOUR IN MAUI. read more

Pizza Paradiso - PIZZA WITH NO SAUCE - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Such delicious and varied food options, open late. We went twice while we visited Maui and did karaoke the second night we were there. Super fun and good for all ages. Highly recommend checking it out! read more

Pizza Paradiso - Karaoke - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

What happens when you cross Mediterranean and Pizza? You get a terrific thin crust base to carry your favorite toppings, creating a delightful pie. I am almost sure they a Gyro based dough for their pizza crust which makes for a very pleasant surprise. This place is worth a try for late night vaycay grub. ProTip their online ordering does not allow for half and half pizzas but order in person to keep everyone happy, they are pretty quick getting pies out. read more

First Impression: 3/5 stars. I placed a pick-up order and found that the Yelp menu is outdated; they haven't had pasta in 12 years, and the online ordering system was also incorrect. I called to clarify and learned that ordering half a pizza isn't possible despite it being listed online. I'm glad I called, as this could have been a waste of time. Food: 5-Cheese Pizza: 4/5 - Solid and satisfying. The first time, we had the pizza cold because we didn't realize it would be ready in 15 minutes. The second time, it was warm and enjoyable. The kids liked it so much that we ordered it twice within a few days. Chicken Shawarma: 2/5 - While the chicken was tender, it was lacking in flavor and needed more salt and seasoning. The same issue applied to the Tzatziki sauce. I usually prefer less salty food, but even so, I found the dish lacking in flavor as others had mentioned. Service: 4/5. The pizza was ready quickly both times we ordered. read more

Pizza Paradiso - Ordering online options are wrong. I called and they said I can't order half a pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Been coming here for years everytime we come to island the owner is the coolest guy around, expanded to the next suite now has a full bar and open late with live music and karaoke nite as well. Always something happening here, check it out for great pizza and also Greek skewers as well read more

Pizza Paradiso - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

Dole Whip! French kiss. Everyone was very nice and the burger was pretty good. I will be back to tey the gyros.

Ate here twice. Visit #1: Ambiance-newly renovated, the place has ample seating and looks great. Took food to go though. Service-Staff friendly and attentive. Food-got two slices, surprisingly the Hawaiian didn't taste that great but the combo one was good, I think thinner crust was the difference. Visit #2: Ambiance-ate outside & there was plenty of seating with most tables clean. Service-same as visit #1 Food-had a pepperoni pizza made and it was excellent. Keep in mind, prices on the island are more expensive than the mainland but if you do eat out and eat here, consider having a pizza made. Good stuff. read more

Service was ok. It's an order at the counter, pay and tip before you get service or food. Hate that. And who am I tipping? The robot who brings me my food? Food was mediocre. It was hot and delivered slow. We ate mediterranean. read more

We ordered delivery via Uber Eats. The delivery was problematic but the real issue was the quality of the food. The chicken kebobs were a mix of half cooked and bone in pieces of chicken. The filet kebobs were grey and overcooked. It was very over priced, even for Maui standards, for barely edible food. read more