I regret not writing a review sooner. This review is a year late. My family enjoyed Prison Street Pizza in September 2022. We enjoyed it so much we couldn't stop thinking about it and came back a second time within the same week of our Maui vacation. Thin crust. Super fresh dough. Yummy cheesy goodness. Good tunes playing for indoor dining. Great, friendly service. The reason I'm finally writing a review is because a year later my family is still talking about Prison Street Pizza. This month we find ourselves in Lake Tahoe for vacation. We ate pizza at Jiffy's Pizza in North Tahoe and it reminded us of Prison Street Pizza in Lahaina. Fresh dough, crispy thin crust, and flavorful sauce and cheese. Pure yummy. I highly recommend Prison Street Pizza in Lahaina. I also highly recommend Jiffy's Pizza in North Lake Tahoe. LOL. ;) read more

Miss this place wish he would reopen somewhere in Lahaina. Since the fires we ha e lost so many awesome places to eat. read more

Nephew's birthday and pizza was his dinner choice. Prison Street Pizza is where we headed when we learned our original choice was already closed. We ordered: 1) Caesar salad - meh 2) Buffalo wings - I didn't try them but was told these had a kick. My mom can't take anything spicy and was only able to take a bite, but noted the flavor was good. 3) Grandma's - This one was noted to be the overall favorite for our party. Love the alfredo sauce and spinach. 4) S Turn - I liked the mozzarella and sausage combo 5) Pepperoni - nephew's choice and he enjoyed it. We liked the pizza crust and how the pizzas arrived piping hot. read more

See all

I would not have come to Prison Street Pizza if not for my friend randomly having a craving for pizza. I sure as hell don't come to Hawaii for pizza because all I want to eat here is local food or Japanese food. But since I wanted to adhere to his desires, I looked up pizza and found this spot. We ordered a medium pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and ricotta (because any pizza is automatically better with ricotta!). For being advertised as Jersey-style pizza, I was skeptical as to the quality of it since it is Maui after all. You know what, this was actually pretty good! Quality ingredients, I was pleasantly surprised. I literally had just went to New York two weeks before coming here, so I had a pretty good idea of how to compare pizza. At the very minimum, it's better than Joe's Pizza. Staff here are really friendly! You can definitely see how much work they put in their craft because the kitchen is right behind the register. They put in the work for sure. Prison Street Pizza is definitely more solid than spectacular. But you can't really go wrong with this. Pretty sure that good pizza options are probably fairly lacking in Maui. read more

See all

Disappointing pizza, ordered a pepperoni slice to go and got 3 pieces of pepperoni on my slice :( for $4 I expected a little better than that. I wish I took a picture of that sad looking pizza.... totally forgot. Save yourself a trip and disappointment and try another spot instead. Friendly staff but really salty pizza. Sauce was almost missing like what other reviewers said, thought I'd give it a shot with all the high reviews but definitely didn't have a good experience. The crust at the end was stale and so hard I threw it out without taking a bite there. Don't recommend it here. Go try something else! Maybe ordering a pie would be better, I'd still say go somewhere else. Added a star for friendly staff. read more

See all

I've been craving a Philly Cheesesteak sub for sometime and thought I'd try something new at Prison Street Pizza. They do good pizza,  so why not a good cheesesteak? The cheesesteak was topped with cheese, onions, and peppers you'd expect. There were a few pieces of steak that weren't chopped up and I couldn't bite through the steak, it was tough.  Also got the Grilled Chicken Parmesan sub. The chicken was dry and the sub would have been better with more sauce.  The best part of our lunch was that the order was ready upon pickup. Next time I'll stick to their pizza. read more

See all

We stopped into this fun pizza shop after being at the beach all morning. The service was kind and the lady upfront took orders and delivered food to all the patrons. She was quick, focused and consistently positive. The pizza can be ordered by the slice and we picked up a primavera, 2 calzone and a house salad. The bread/crust was prepared perfectly. The ricotta cheese and mozzarella were hot enough to pull but not burn. .this place was an absolute JOY! We will hit this place again and again! read more

See all

It's an ok tasting pizza, but the thing that blew me away was that the delivery driver was here within fifteen minutes of me placing the order. I was expecting to wait 45 minutes to an hour, but these guys were on their game tonight. Way to go guys, it was a jailbreak read more

Prison Street Pizza - Pepperoni, mushroom, onion and extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

On our third try, we finally found the right pizza place for us on Maui. Prison St. Pizza was really, really good. The real-deal. You can tell the difference when a pizza is made with quality ingredients and fresh dough. The thin crust is sturdy enough to support the lightly sauced, and appropriately cheesed pizza. We ordered Pepperoni & Sausage, and we were happy with the taste and quality of the sausage. The pepperoni was mild. It appeared that only mozzarella cheese was used but I'm not certain of that. Our server from the counter where you order was gracious and he checked and re-checked on us. Beers are all from cans. Nothing on tap. Pepsi products. Individual pizza slices are sold as well. read more

Prison Street Pizza - Menu front. - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

Was in town and my husband was gone so I didn't want to order a pizza since they only offer medium and large sizes which look quite large. I decided on a calzone with cheese and spinach filling, and it was amazing. Still too big to eat alone. Definitely big enough to share with one other person, but thoroughly enjoyed it. One glitch was, I tried to order it online and their online ordering does not allow you to order just a calzone. It's only considered an add-on to your pizza order? so I had to call and talk to someone in person. read more

Prison Street Pizza - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Jersey style pizza in Lahaina! A little bit hard to find, but the small local pizza shop had outdoor seating around a beautiful mango tree full with fruit (there was a falling mango sign for caution). Service was quick and efficient, the lines moved fast. I wish they offered slices of their signature pizzas because the options for slices were limited to cheese, pepperoni, sausage, and primavera. I had a slice of Primavera ($3.75) because my party wasn't quite hungry enough for a whole pizza. The pizza itself was delicious! It was fresh out of the oven and they did not skimp on the ricotta on top. The crust was light and crispy and the sauce paired well with the toppings. Overall, efficient service and good pizza thats very affordable too! Wish they had more options for slices. read more

Prison Street Pizza - Primavera slice - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Completely forgot to write a review for Prison street pizza!!!! I was in Hawaii back in august but boy do i remember this spot lol We actually ate here three times! Yes it was that good. After some good hikes we just craved pizza. The photos show different ones that we go through out the three times we went. What is not pictured are the wings we got. Those were eaten in .152 seconds as well as the salad. But!! One of the times we got a Veggie pizza and a Philly cheese steak pizza. Dammmm the Philly cheese steak was a game changer! Pleas try that one. Then a different time we got half pepperoni and half chicken Buffalo. Soo good! The Buffalo was a bit spicey but not over the top. The staff was very friendly and they were on GO! As in hustling to get orders done over the phone and in person. Gotta love a fast pace place. Truly recommend coming here if you want pizza while in Maui. read more

See all

My husband and I I miss Prison Street Pizza so much. If you make pizza elsewhere please let me know where it is.

This was by far the Best pizza on Maui. Now closed permanently due to fire. :( Very sad. We miss it as well as all the closed businesses due to the fire. read more

We were so hungry and found this prison street pizza.The pizza lacked a bit of salt due to which I rate 4 stars .They had slice options too.It's a nice place where they had outdoor and indoor seating. read more

Prison Street Pizza - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

Prison Street Pizza is a very good pizza! Make a break for this pizza! We had finished a long day in the sun, surf snorkeling, paddle boarding, sport fishing, whale watching and swimming. So we decided to order a pick up pizza tonight on April 2021 post COVID19 pandemic. We arrived at the Prison Street Pizza in Laihaina a small "hut" packed outside seating only and with pick up orders customers crowding the front entrance. They have three tables outside including a "sunken" table that seats 6 and two other tables with a couple and another . with 4 people. No street parking but par. king across the street and behind the hut. We ordered a combination pizza, half grilled chicken, mushrooms, black olives and other half a classic Margarita pizza. Also ordered a garden salad with red peppers, black olives, mozzarella cheese and romaine lettuce with ranch dressing. The Prison Street Pizza is a great place for pizza. read more

See all

If someone says they have Jersey pizza, we have to go taste what jersey pizza taste like in Hawaii but this was not what I was expecting. When they say cheese pizza, they mean legitimately just cheese on the pizza. Maybe a tablespoon of tomato sauce altogether on a medium pizza? However, the crust was well done. Thin crust and crunchy. Exactly the way thin crust should be~ But it was disappointing when I pulled back the mozzarella and there was literally nothing underneath. I saw other peoples pizza and it look absolutely delicious so I don't know if maybe this was a one off? read more

Prison Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

Good pizza, great sizing. We ordered the pepperoni pizza to go. Nice switch up after eating seafood and Hawaiian everyday. My husband and I treated ourself to a slice of the pie while waiting. He had the sausage and I had the pepperoni. Quaint spot with seating in and outdoors. We will be back. read more

Prison Street Pizza - Slice of Pepperoni pizza and Sausage pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

We don't normally eat veggie pizzas but wasn't in the mood for meat that night. We ordered the veggie and added pesto. While we expected red sauce, there wasn't any. In any case, the pizza was so good! It was satisfying and crispy. Crust wasn't too thin or thick, flavor was on point. With the pesto it was perfection. Im not sure if it would've been too plain without pesto, but it was perfect for us. Warmed leftovers next day and it still came out like it was fresh. read more

Prison Street Pizza - Veggie pizza with pesto added - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Can I say, I came in here with huge expectations and Prison Street Pizza exceeded them. My friend from mainland was recommending me places to eat with my family and he said " if you don't go to any other of my recommendations, YOU MUST HIT PRISON STREET.... We had the freight Train and a Calzone... AMAZING FOOD So happy we came; the pizza was airy and Crisp, the ingredients were fresh and complimented the SAUCE perfectly... Greg, Carolina and John Paul were very attentive to our needs and our questions !!! You can tell they take Pride in where they work and what they DO. we won't always be eating pizza in MAUI but when we do it will be here @ Prison Street Pizza read more

I'm giving this place 3 stars solely for the service. It was solid, friendly and helpful service. Also, I like the ambience of the place, what maybe was an old cottage converted to pizza restaurant. It was homey and friendly, with mango trees outside (the sign warning of falling mangoes was not kidding; one thumped itself almost on top of us before we scurried inside). But the pizza was the worst we've ever had. A medium cheese which could pass as a large size in any other place, so give them credit for that. But the crust was a thick and solid gluten disc, hard to cut or chew through. And no cheese or sauce was spared in the preparation. I guess we should have taken up the offer from the server of some ranch dressing on the side. Is ranch dressing on pizza a thing? Honestly have never heard of it. We ate half the pizza because we hadn't eaten for hours and didn't want to search around for openings at the crowded restaurants. But we left the other half behind. I don't know if we just didn't order right, if the yeast just hadn't taken in our batch of dough, if they were running low on cheese and sauce supply...who knows?! Others have left very good reviews, so we might have just not hit at the right time. But the people were very nice!!! read more

We tried the slices first, and loved the simple cheese one, but the primavera was my favorite. It was so good we ended up getting an entire veggie pizza which took longer than the slices but was freshly baked and out of the oven. The veggies on it were fresh and managed to eat half of it before packing away the rest for home. The insides were cozy and the people were very nice. read more

When on vacation it's always good to have a delivery food to fill in when you don't want to wait in line and deal with the crowds. Prison Pizza is more than that. They deliver piping hot pizza with a plethora of toppings. The crust was thin and they use plenty of cheese. We were very happy with the pizza. I also ordered a side salad but it was warm and not very tasty. I recommend the pizza they say the delivery time is 1.5 hours but they arrived in less than 45. Parking - on a side street across from a parking lot. Place- Small and limited seating. Full of happy faces Location- Down town Lahaina walking distance from baby beach and AninNalu rentals. Enjoy. I will order again l, why but when I can sit on the beach and enjoy a slice of pizza. read more

Customer service was great! My husband and I came here on our last night and it was a great experience. It took about 29 minutes or so for our medium box pizza but it was worth the wait. We waited outside under a mango tree and just our luck we had a fallen mango land near us. It was delicious!!! The we ate the pizza the next morning too and it was tasted amazing. And we ate it cold!! This pizza place is located just at the end of Lahaina downtown area. read more

Prison Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

We were so looking forward to this pizza, but what a let down. The pepperoni was pretty scarce on one of our pizzas. The grandma pizza, although it had abundant toppings, I must say watch out for the pound of garlic! The crust is lacking in flavor and basically made for a mediocre pizza pie. read more

Great pizza, great service. Ordered a large pepperoni and a medium cheese for delivery to our hotel (Hyatt Regency Ka'anapali). Was told 45-60 minutes. Pizza was delivered in just under an hour. Ordering was easy and delivery was prompt as promised. The pizza was delicious. Right amount of cheese, pepperoni was perfect. Crust was the best part. Chewy and crispy at the same time. Will DEFINITELY order Prison St again, great job! read more

It was just ok. We tried the grandma pizza that had Alfredo sauce, chicken, spinach and garlic and my son got a big bite of garlic. I tried a calzone and it was just ok. We had a Hawaiian pizza and it was a hit even though my family does not typically choose pineapple over their pizza. Sorry no pictures. read more

Such a great little hole in the wall! The pizza was awesome, they have a great selection. We also had the house salad which was good too. They had lots of local beers, only downside is you can't drink on the patio and the inside is small. Plus one table was being used for folding pizza boxes and the other for an employee taking a personal phone call... but would still recommend! read more

Prison Street Pizza - half Philly Cheesesteak, half Windmills - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Excellent value, and very fresh! Got the pepperoni, primavera, and sausage pizza slices, piping hot from the oven! Flat crust with a gooey cheese topping. Prison St Pizza is no frills, old-fashioned pizza that isn't overpriced unlike most touristy restaurants around here. Would definitely go back for a slice! read more

Fancy having a pizza sitting under a mango tree!? For a lovely Lahaina moment, looking no further than Prison Street Pizza! Wonderful menu with pizzas named after all the local surf breaks! The people who work here are genuine in the Aloha spirit and really went the extra mile to make sure the food and experience were everything we hoped for! read more

Prison Street Pizza - Guardrails Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

We stopped by yesterday evening for dinner based on the reviews. My wife and I and our 4 kids came and sat outside on one of the side picnic tables. We ordered the kids a medium pizza (it was huge) and my wife ordered a slice of primavera and I ordered 2 sausage slices. This is where our experience took a change. The lady that checked me out told me to sign in 3 places on the receipt. One was the tip, one was the total, one was my signature. I'm not sure if it is an island custom or proper etiquette to tip in this situation, but unless I am waited on by a waiting staff I do not tip by just ordering at the counter. She was watching me carefully as I filled out and signed the receipt. Later, my wife went up to ask for a to-go box for the cheese slices we could not finish and told me the same woman that checked me out clearly ignored her (while doing nothing - not preparing an order or attending to a patron - simply standing at the counter fumbling around with items to make herself look busy) and when she finally acknowledged my wife, was very short and not courteous at all - not what you would expect from a well respected establishment or the feel of aloha. She finally reluctantly 'gave up' a to-go box to my wife, but my wife came back to the table to tell me the story, clearly upset and disappointed of how she was treated. I'm actually glad I didn't tip for a counter order, especially after knowing how patrons are treated for an optional tip. If it was 'standard' to tip in this situation, I wish gratuity was just built-in as opposed to allowing you to input your tip amount. The gentleman that brought out our pizza was very nice, I'd like the mention. It was the woman at the counter that put a sour taste in our mouth about the experience. Hope this is read and the service improved upon for future patrons. read more

While walking around, we were hungry and decided to get pizza. We ordered a large Serpico Special and Large Margherita. We ordered some beer while waiting for the pizza to come out. The Serpico special was ok. The Margherita pizza was delicious. I always enjoy the Margherita pizza. The weather was great and we were sitting underneath a mango tree. They have a sign that saids Caution Falling Mangos. One did fall onto the street. The inside of the restaurant has couple small tables and couple big picnic tables outdoors. Most of the customers that come here take it to go or have it delivered. read more

See all

If you're in Maui and have a taste for pizza, this no frills locally owned establishment serves up "Jersey style pizza" and does not disappoint! Located in the heart of Lahaina, it was super easy to find and accessible on foot. There was a minimal wait of roughly 5 minutes before we were seated. Outdoor seating is also available if you wish. The pizzas here are exactly what you would expect from a place paying homage to the Garden State! The slices are huge and there are a plethora of quality toppings (e.g., goat cheese, artichoke hearts, grilled chicken, garlic, mushrooms, and pepperoni). In addition to excellent pizza, they also have calzones, sandwiches, burgers, wings, an excellent beer selection, and even salads! Who says you can't eat healthy at a pizza joint? We settled on a large pizza with half mushroom and half grilled chicken. It was brought out on a pizza stand hot and with an enticing aroma. The crust was crisp but not over baked, the cheese was evenly distributed, and the toppings were perfect. If I ever find myself in Maui again, I'll be sure to stop by Prison Street! read more

See all

Very casual diner style pizzeria with friendly service. Parking was a little tough but there is a public parking lot nearby and if you're lucky some street parking too. Pizzas were delicious but HUGE! So beware when ordering. It's pretty thin crust but still pretty large. read more

Prison Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Really enjoyed this place for a casual bite to eat in Lahaina! The guy who took our order was extremely friendly and easy to talk to. You cannot beat the beer prices here!! Best I have encountered in all of Maui. Their pizza was top notch as well. Very awesome that they deliver to the resorts as well! Highly recommend checking them out! read more

Prison Street Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

Maybe my expectations were too high? I thought it was just okay. It wasn't bad by any means, but it wasn't anything to write home about. We ordered the garlic bread and split a large margarita pizza, based on the dude's recommendation. I appreciated the way it was cooked - crispy crust with easy-to-eat, chewy "middle." However, there just wasn't any flavor. The pesto didn't pop at all. The cheese was just meh. Sauce was very sub-par. As for the garlic bread, it just didn't have the buttery, crispy, garlicy mix that you'd want. It was pretty dry and appeared to have a bunch of italian spice dumped on it. Based on the reviews, I may come back in the future, but I certainly wouldn't go out of my way for it. read more

I'm from New York City (I've had the prince street pizzas and the like), and this is a SOLID place to go. Obviously, it's not the best in the world, hence the 4 stars, but I had it two days in a row, and it hit the spot so far from home. Both times I've ordered (a Thursday and Friday night), and it only took 15 minutes to make 2 pies. If u leave the top open a little while you travel for about 15 minutes, the middle won't be soggy. I'd happily go again if I was here. read more

Update: Somehow between now and the last time we were here in 2019; the pizza seemed different. The crust was not thin like before, and didn't have that Jersey pizza flavor. However, the staff very kindly brought out my take out order to my car when I couldn't find a parking space! So A+ for that. read more

This place is a little gem in Lahaina. It's a small shack/house looking shop across from the parking lot for Front street. Don't let the understated, almost shabby curb appeal fool you, their pizzas and wings are pretty yum. There are a few tables inside to sit and a couple out front, but it looks like most people either order for delivery or carry out. They were pretty busy when we were there so so couldn't get through on the phone and ended up driving there to place an order. It took about 20 mins for the pies to be ready. We got the Serpico Special, cheese and olives and a side of Buffalo wings. Everything was delish and disappeared before I could even snap a photo. I highly recommend this place if you're in the area and are looking to feed a large party or lots of kids. read more

Prison Street Pizza - Inside the shop. - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

Wanted: 5-7" 120lbs Female Stole my last slice of the best Pepperoni pizza on the island. Last seen near Banyan Tree in Lahaina casually consuming said pizza. Locals warned me of her presence. Highly recommend purchasing at least two slices, one for you and the for safe passage through the Banyan forest should you encounter the Banyan Pizza Woman. Approach with caution. If encountered, place the single slice on the park bench and walk away slowly with your hands on the air to illustrate you have no more pizza. read more

Prison Street Pizza - The banyan Pizza thief - Pizza Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii