tl;dr - one of the best pizzas in Maui, at a proper sit down pizza parlor with excellent service! I have been coming here for years, I dont know how I never wrote a review for it before! It's the first place I think of to eat at anytime I am in Kihei around mealtime. The pizza is so good. You can tell the ingredients are high quality, especially the cheese. It's a thicker crust style, which may not be everyone's favorite, but they do really well. Another bright spot here is the antipasto salad. It's a must for us, although I am vegetarian so we get the meats on the side which they ate happy to accommodate. The house vinaigrette is great, but the ranch here is home made and absolutely amazing on both salad and pizza! I specifically came here to write a review today because of the service. It's so good. All the servers are nice and professional, but the bartender (sorry man, I don't know your name!) is absolutely exceptional. He's attentive, proactive with his service, and really friendly. It's not hard to be good at service, but this guy clearly takes pride in his work and puts in the extra work to make his service truly great. You are very appreciated! The only downside to this place is that it is in Kihei and I live upcountry so I cant go as much as I'd like to. read more

Can someone message me the recipe for their homemade ranch? It's SO good! Better than Wingstop ranch & Wingstop ranch is my favorite! The pizza here is so fresh, I've been in Maui for 6 days & have gotten pizza, wings & salad twice already. I love their specialty pizza (basically combination pizza) with fresh tomatoes on top. It's sooo tasty & flavorful. I also love their antipasto salad - such a simple salad but the homemade RANCH dressing is what amps it up. The wings are crispy & battered to perfection. I like to dip it with their buffalo sauce & ranch at the same time. Service is nice, came for pick up twice & was greeted & thanked, so no complaints there. Overall 10/10 recommend! read more

Pizza Madness Maui - Special pizza with fresh tomato added on top, antipasto salad & 2 orders of wings - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

We ordered a small, sausage, mushroom, red onion pizza to go. The online ordering and pick-up process went smoothly and our order was ready exactly as promised. Our basic impression is that this was a solid 3-star, rather generic, pizza crust with a 5-star, absolutely delicious, tangy, well-crafted sauce! The toppings were okay, but not particularly generous and unevenly dispersed. Some pieces were loaded, others had practically zero. And since everything was basically cut into tiny bits, we really couldn't reapportion anything. We also ordered a Caesar salad to share and neither of us had much appreciation for all the dry, crunchy bacon bits but I can see why someone might like this addition. read more

It was madness! Excellent pizza and great service. It has a very family friendly and local atmosphere. Everyone was nice read more

Pizza Madness Maui - Delicious beer - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

When there's a big storm brewing offshore, that means there is a good chance there will be flooding on South Kihei Road and you'll want to stay home for the next few days. And, there's a good chance that the power will go out for a few days. So, instead of stocking up on cans of spam and tuna fish, we decided to live it up, with the help of Pizza Madness. We ordered a large meat lovers pizza. It comes with pepperoni, bacon, ham, and sausage. Plenty of cheese and loaded with flavor. We also got a large antipasto salad, with lots of deli meat (ham, turkey and salami), mushrooms, bell pepper, olives, tomatoes and cheese. Oh, and a few pepperoncini. We asked for the bleu cheese dressing (it comes on the side). Oh, man, our car smelled so good on the way home! The wind was howling and the rain was pouring. Four branches were ripped off of our royal palm, but we ate like kings. And, yes, the power went out for 14 hours but we got by just fine. Didn't have to reach for the spam. read more

See all

This is a lively place with a sports bar vibe located near Maui Dive Shop in Kihei. There is plenty of parking in front. There are lots of picnic style tables inside to accommodate larger parties as well as smaller tables and bar seating. They are known for their pizza, but they also serve wings, pasta, sandwiches, and salads. Beer is on tap and they also have a small selection of hard liquor at the bar. The service is fast and friendly. We ordered the spaghetti meal and salt & vinegar wings. The spaghetti came with a small salad and garlic bread. It was a perfect meal. The salt & vinegar wings were too salty for me. Next time I would order the wings plain with sauce on the side. This is a fun place to come with a group. read more

See all

A solid choice to end our week here in Maui. We just wanted a good pizza pie before we headed back to the airport to end our trip, so happy we stoped here! Great service, tasty pie and crispy crust. Definitely keeping this place in the radar for future trips. read more

Pizza Madness Maui - Meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

The pizza is good but the toppings were all over the place. 3 pieces had no toppings at all, 2 pieces had the perfect amount of toppings, the rest of the pizza had scattered toppings mostly cheese. (it was the most expensive pizza I have ever bought and it was only ham and pineapple) read more

Love the pizza from this place. It is easy to find off s kihei road, has a pretty big parking lot. We ordered a meat lovers pizza an large salad to go. Said be ready in 15 min. We arrived and only had to wait a few minutes for it. Place was crowded and lots of tv's being watched. Staff was friendly and helpful. Don't do their punch cards any more use your phone number now to keep track of your purchases. If you like great pizza this is your place to go to. read more

See all

One star when we pay $73 tip included for a small pizza and eight wings!!! Wings were salty, and the pizza did not show the extras we added!!! read more

Pizza Madness Maui - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

I can't remember the last time we went to pizza madness and now i don't know why we waited so long to come back!!!! Well truthfully, i can tell you why, we don't get out to the south side very often. But when i saw that the they were helping out the Maui humane society, you KNOW we had to come support! I believe this special is running until the end of the month (July 2025) so you should really take advantage of this amaaaaazing deal: purchase a $25 coupon which gets you 1 medium pizza with 2 toppings AND 2 non-alcoholic drinks....and wait, this gets better...$5 of this coupon goes to the support all the animals at the humane society! Update. We also went back the next weekend. Seriously best pizza ever, they do not skimp on the toppings!!!! It's loooooaded! Today is the 31st so if you can make it for some pizza and saving animals, go for it!! But if not, support this amazing business who also supports wonderful causes! read more

See all

Great pizza Great service Love the cheese and pepperoni pizza. Highly recommended. Jordan read more

Ordered delivery and it was amazing. Only 30 minutes total and it tasted so fresh. Got half meat, half veggie with jalapeños and fresh tomatoes. I love how you can specify fresh vs cooked tomatoes when ordering online. When delivered, the cheese was fresh and the pizza was not greasy. Highly recommend! read more

The ambiance is very cozy, I was told it used to be the warehouse where my friends work. The server was very nice and friendly, and I can hear a guy calling our server manager, I'm not sure if he was. I'm not a pizza person, but their pizza was so good, even the chicken wings. Over all I can't say other than I recommend this place. read more

Pizza Madness Maui - The pizza I get to like - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

Amazing place to have a local pizza , pizza was amazing customer service was amazing and the atmosphere vibrant

The folks at the dive shop next door recommended we check out the pizza place nearby, and we're glad they did. Trixie provided excellent service, and the Hawaiian pizza was especially delicious. read more

Pizza Madness Maui - 1/2 of a small Hawaiian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

It's a beautiful night in Maui. What sounds good right now? How about a delicious hoagie. Let's give Pizza Madness a try. . .One of the worst sandwiches I can remember. Hard to wash the taste of this one out. I would say the pizza might be delicious. I'm sure that's what they're known for. Next time, just stick to what works. read more

We ate here a couple of weeks ago while vacationing in Maui and have brought up our experience here several times since being home. The pepperoni pizza was awesome, but the main item of our affection was the pineapple BBQ wings...perfect in every way. I need to know the recipe to this sauce! Don't leave without trying them. For reference- we ordered the 14" pizza for 2 people plus the wings and the pizza ended up being enough for two meals (which was fine since our condo had a kitchen). If you are avoiding leftovers, you may want to get a 10" especially if getting other menu items. read more

Ordered over the phone and had a friendly and helpful gal, I told her lots of ranch and she offered a mason jar, lol I said that was a bit too much. We had a large half meat, half combo pizza with 2 large ranch sides. It was ready in 25 minutes when I called around 5pm. Pick up was easy. Total came to $50 with tax and tip Very delicious pizza! Just what you want after a beach day when you are hungrrryy read more

Pizza Madness Maui - Half Meat Lover & half Special - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Pizza here is still some of da best on da Island. Tonight our Head Official on Maui treated da crew with a large all meat with pineapple & extra cheese and a large double pepperoni with extra cheese please! Outstanding! read more

See all

Our favorite pizza spot on Maui! Keno and the crew are always so welcoming and go above and beyond to make our family feel welcomed every time we come down. our 4 year old daughter loves the pizza, I love the wings and my wife loves the sandwiches - something for everyone! Great draft beer selection and a cozy bar that I even swing by just to grab a quick beer and watch some of the game. 5 out of 5 for sure - we are so lucky to have this awesome spot so close to our home here in Maui! PS: They have added some fun arcades, kids games, and even a magician on Thursday & Friday evenings - now every time we ask our daughter where she wants to go out for dinner it's always Pizza Madness! read more

I'm from Chicago where nothing beats tavern style pizza. I've been on O'ahu, Kaua'i and Maui. Pizza Madness is the best pizza I've had while on all my visits to the islands. If you're a pizza lover, like me, and are looking to satisfy a craving, I think you'll really enjoy this place! read more

Great service and awesome Pizza. Our waitress was the best ever and has been with Pizza Maddness for years.

Place was nice Food was delicious Staff very friendly They had some arcade machines that my boys liked read more

Pizza Madness Maui - Place was very nice. Food was delicious and staff very friendly - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Pizza Madness is one of our favorite places to grab pizza in Maui! Their pizzas are always delicious, and I'm obsessed with their mozzarella sticks--they're perfectly gooey with the best cheesy pull. We always order one of their special pizzas, and this time, we went for a 14-inch since my husband was extra hungry. We also got an order of hot wings. I love the heavy vinegar flavor in their hot sauce, but we always get it on the side so we can dip as much (or as little) as we want. I think my husband loves this spot because there's always a sports game on, and beer, pizza, and sports just go hand in hand. The staff here is awesome, and if you're looking for a great pizza spot in Maui, I highly recommend Pizza Madness! read more

Pizza Madness Maui - 14" special - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

Pizza Madness is a great pizza parlor in Maui. It is open seating, so when you get there, just find a table. The service was great. One of the servers helped my parents get a flight of beer with his favorite picks, and they really enjoyed it. The pizza is delicious. We got the special and a pepperoni! Very good! We also got a Cesar salad, a couple of beers, and for dessert the cookie coffee ice cream. If you are in the mood for pizza, this is the place to go. read more

Pizza Madness Maui - Pepperoni and the special. Half n half. - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

The pizza was really good. Liked the sauce and crust a lot. I did not appreciate the raw underripe tomato on the margherita pizza, that was my only dislike. We ordered 4 large pizzas, 2 side salads, a basket of fries, jalapeno poppers, and 3 or 4 sodas, and 2 beer. The bill was $270 (insert eyes popping out of my head here). $40 of it was gratuity to be fair. Long gone are the days of going out for pizza being an affordable family affair read more

BEST SOUTH MAUI PIZZA You heard it here folks. Easily! Their pineapple pepperoni is my favorite. To die for. We are frequents here. Typically take out but I do like their dining area as well. read more

Pizza Madness Maui - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

BRAAAAAAH. $71 for a pizza and wings. Meh pizza and madness price. Getting pizza for the family used to be easy. Now as a local it's completely unaffordable. Only pizza we can get now is this Dominos and Little Caesars junk. Sad. read more

Easy five stars! I regularly go here for dinner, or a beer and a bite while running Kihei errands. As far as food goes, their pizza is FANTASTIC; reminds me of my childhood pizza place I'd go to growing up. I've also had their philly cheese steaks and wings which are awesome. Plus they make their own ranch! I put it on everything. Staff is always friendly and personable, and the atmosphere is warm and welcoming! Highly recommend read more

See all

It's a great place. I had an awesome conversation with several staff members there. Keno, the GM, is incredible. Thank you and Semper Fi. Dan / Project NAGA. read more

The service was 5 star, but the pizza was "meh." I can't put my finger on why it was disappointing, but I left frustrated. I had been eating gluten-free for two months and had been anxiously awaiting my first bite of pizza. I thought maybe I had just overhyped my expectations, but the rest of my party felt similarly. The pizza is just "okay." read more

Pizza Madness Maui - Pepperoni pizza - medium. A small would have been enough for 2. - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

Let me start by saying that we visit Pizza Madness as often as humanly possible. The pizza is amazing! The service is also typically good. With that said, it is SUCH a turnoff to walk into a restaurant 45 min before they close and be met with eye rolls and frustrated looks, clearly annoyed that we have walked in. We almost turned around and walked out BUT considering we made the HOUR drive to come to our favorite pizza place and I had starving children, we decided to stay. As we sat down a server came over immediately and said "Ok so you have to order right now because the kitchen is closing." While there, we saw several others walk through the doors and observed the same unwelcoming body language from employees in the dining room. We ordered very quickly but felt like we were having to choke down our food as body language continued and we were feeling like an inconvenience. My kids actually said they wanted to just put the pizza in a box and go eat in the car. (Mind you, this was all still prior to official closing time). A server even came with a broom and dustpan sweeping under the table behind us before they had finished eating. VERY disappointed by this experience and not the Pizza Madness standard we expected. read more

The food came out so quickly! I would post pictures of the food but we were all so hungry, the camera did not eat first that's for sure! Keno was our server and he was so amazing! This was our first time, we ordered the cheese bread, chicken alfredo, and their version of a supreme pizza and everything was a 10/10! Also, everyone was so nice that worked there, we felt so welcome! read more

We are always looking for a great pizza joint when we travel and we finally found one in Kehei. We ordered on DoorDash and the pizza was delivered still hot and tasted amazing. Got the 10-inch BBQ Chicken Pizza and the a pepperoni and both were fabulous and tasted fresh. Sorry for the missing slices in the photos but the pizza looked and smelled so good we had to try it first before snapping a photo. If you are a pizza snob you will definitely be more than satisfied with Pizza Madness even when delivered. We shall be back! read more

Pizza Madness Maui - BBQ Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

Great pizza, ready fast and great service. We ordered the meat lovers and it was insanely good!

Very good pizza, we got the large special with all the good toppings. Not overly greasy like some pizzas with pepperoni and sausage. Mushroom and peppers tasted fresh. The bottom of the crust a bit damp but we got to go and lots of toppings. read more

I've been to this place many times and have always enjoyed the food and atmosphere, which is why this visit was so disappointing. When we arrived, we were told we couldn't sit at the regular tables and were directed to the small tables instead. These tables were extremely close together--so close that I could literally reach back and touch the people behind me with my elbow. It felt like we were packed in there like sardines. What made it more frustrating was that there were about eight regular tables sitting completely empty. I politely asked if we could move to one of them and the waitress said no. There didn't seem to be any reason for forcing everyone into the cramped seating area. On top of that, the chairs were wobbly and uncomfortable. I even tried switching chairs, but they were all the same. It's unfortunate because I used to enjoy coming here, but the uncomfortable seating and refusal to accommodate a simple request really ruined the experience. Not a place I want to spend my money if I can't even sit comfortably. read more

Delicious pizza and fast service. We ordered out twice from here during our recent trip. Each time we brought the pizza back to our condo so we could enjoy the view. read more

Pizza Madness Maui - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Server was kind and chill, music playing was totally my jam, baseball game was on, love the decor and ambiance. This pizza place is AMAZING! cheese was stretchy and crust was crispy- toppings loaded! Tasted so yummy! Would come here again and again! Best pizza in Maui! read more

Pizza Madness Maui - Pepperoni, ham, green pepper, mushroom pizza - medium - Pizza Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all