Got a Large Pepperoni Pizza with extra cheese, boy was it cheesy!! Fast Service!! Great please to try if you're in Custer!

Over 4 stars on Yelp and Google? Unbelievable! I hope I caught them on a bad day. The pizzas looked good when they came out, but the second you picked up a slice the toppings and cheese slid completely off. No cheese pull, no structure, just a soggy undercooked mess in the middle. The crust was the biggest issue. What looked like a stuffed crust was really just thick undercooked dough that never fully baked through. It made the pizza feel heavy and gummy instead of crispy or chewy. The pepperoni pizza was honestly ridiculous. It had maybe four giant pepperoni slices on the entire pie, so every other bite was just plain cheese and undercooked dough. For almost $45 a pizza, this was a huge disappointment. read more

Pizza Mill - Chicken Alfredo pizza - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

See all

Everything was delicious! The pizza, the cheesy garlic bread, the chicken Alfredo and the calzone were all Devoured by our group of 5. Ordered a large pizza. Probably could have got away with a medium and not need to get a take-home box. The cheese to thick and tasty! Next time I would specifically request that our cheesy bread arrive as an appetizer and to serve the Alfredo when the pizza and calzone were ready. Even so, they all came out rather quickly, just not all at the same time. It was a warm, sunny day and we found enough shade under the big table umbrellas that no one was melting in the sunshine. We were just visiting the area. If going back again I wouldn't hesitate to eat here again. read more

See all

The pizza was ok...but the pick up process was definitely problamatic Unsure if it's related to staff issue or organizational issue. Had to wait 20 minutes after their order time per online order. Place was busy and backed ? due to inability to process the take out orders. Hopefully things get better, we did not use them again thus trip read more

Amazing pizza and great service. The pizza crust is thin the way I like it with a thicker crust at the end. Service is quick. You order at the counter, and they bring you your order. I love this pizza place in Custard while visiting. read more

Food was mediocre. Our family of 2 adults and 2 children stopped for dinner on our way through town. We had a personal pizza, chicken mean green salad, pasta and meatballs, and chicken tenders. Go a place that specializes is pizza, it seems like the pizza would have been better. My daughter's pasta was so watered down that we had to dab it with napkins to soak up the water that made the red sauce extremely runny. My chicken on my salad was supposed to be roasted chicken, however it was processed. Overall, I would not return. Our $70 dinner was not worth that cost. The girl working was friendly, that's the one positive. read more

Nice to sit outside when weather permits. Order at the counter, get a number, then fill your own fountain drinks and enjoy a huge calzone or pizza. Sauce is on sweet side, fillings in canzone were still chilly and the chicken was deli fake grill marked meat that was not good. read more

Pizza Mill - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

Wow! Best calzone we've ever had. We sat outside on the patio during a beautiful late summer sunset and had an incredible meal. The staff was very helpful and friendly. The food was incredible. After a long vacation and having pizza a few times, I was ready to be done but our kids insisted on pizza. We ordered the personal cheese pizza for them, the slash pile sandwich and ponderosa calzone for my husband and I to share. And wow- this was much better than any pizza I've had for a while. Sandwich was very flavorful and I kept eating the calzone past being full because It tasted so great. In the area? You must try the calzone here! read more

See all

Pizza crust was thick and cooked Perfectly ! We had three different kinds of pizza and everyone enjoyed theirs. We ordered a green salad -not the side salad- and there was enough for four people as a side dish. Delicious food after a long day in the Black Hills. read more

Pizza Mill - Cheeseburger pizza. DELICIOUS !! - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

Very delicious pizza. Friendly staff. Restaurant & bathrooms were clean. We enjoyed their nice patio area out front. read more

Pizza Mill - Hungry Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

If you're visiting the beautiful and charming town of Custer, it is a must to try Pizza Mill! One of the best pizzas I have ever had. My husband and I ordered a medium pepperoni pizza and half with pickles. If you're a pickle fan, pickles on your pizza is a perfect combination and a great way to restore some electrolytes after doing a 7 mile hike. They don't hold back on the cheese! Perfect cheesy amount! The pepperoni was like hidden treasure underneath the cheese. The dough was excellent! I don't eat the crust most times but this one I devoured it. Nice and fluffy in the inside and just slightly crispy on the outside. If we were staying longer we definitely would have eaten there again but if we ever return, we know where to find the best pizza. :) read more

Pizza Mill - Medium pizza with pepperoni and the other half with pickles! Absolutely delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

Food was average. Order from counter. Sat outside, inside looked nice. Bathroom was clean. Soda was flat.

Food was fresh and made to order. Service was fairly quick. Cute decorations and ambiance. Would definitely return. read more

Pizza Mill - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

See all

Great calzone, we had the Towering Timber. The timber is loaded, and we ordered one calzone for two people. Plenty to eat and more to take home. Great service, great everything! read more

Pizza was delicious! The space was small for 11 of us, but with the additional outside seating, which we chose, it was perfect. There was a steady stream of customers the entire time we were there. Everyone said it was delicious, and all 11 (8 adults and 3 kids) in our group said it was some of the best pizza we'd had in a long time! read more

The food was amazing. We had two pizzas and ate them both. Perfect for small groups. Did notice that the pick up process or having lots of people was very problematic and clumsy. read more

Dang so good. Meat pizza with a side drizzle of honey and hot pepper flakes. Chefs kiss. Yum.

Pizza was delicious crust was perfect and the staff great as well! Come support this awesome place!

Great pizza, chicken alfredo & even better service! Wish we had one in our home town!

Cute little pizza shop with a decent variety of pizzas. Their crust is difficult to describe, the base is thinner, but the outside edge is like a stuffed crust--big and puffy and delicious. The service was prompt and friendly, they were helpful with suggestions and checked in to make sure we were enjoying our meal. They do provide take-out, but if you can get a seat in the mill or out on the patio, it's quite charming. *Medium pizza 1/2 healthy logger, 1/2 hearty logger* read more

Pizza Mill - Medium pizza--1/2 healthy logger (veggie), 1/2 hearty logger (meat lovers) - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

Order: Chicken bacon ranch pizza, ponderosa pizza, towering timber (all XL) Cannot stress enough how much I HIGHLY HIGHLY recommend this place. Absolutely delicious and my favorite find from my visit to SD. The pizza was truly delicious - saucy, flavorful, well balanced and perfectly cooked. Crust was more Colorado style- braided and thick, with honey on the side for dipping with (a great and underrated combination). The chicken bacon ranch pizza was the absolute standout, and I'll be thinking about it for years to come. Service was excellent as well - they were heavily understaffed with only 2 people in the entire FOH+BOH and yet still happily and easily managed a hungry party of 7. Ambiance was homely and friendly, and felt very cozy and comfortable. Wish this was near my house!! read more

See all

Thick pizza with lots of cheese! It was wonderful. Ordered online and picked up to go - the restaurant has about 4-6 tables inside so glad we decided to eat it back at our hotel. Had the leftovers for lunch in the park the next day. Would get again. read more

What great surprise! This place was really good. Pizza crust was great, toppings fresh. The only thing that caught me off guard was that the sausage on the pizza tasted more like breakfast sausage and less like Italian sausage. It worked! But I probably would have preferred Italian. Well done Pizza Mill! Thanks read more

Pizza Mill - Gyro Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

See all

Cute spot to get some pizza. They have house specialty, or you can build your own. The pizza is thin crust but not crispy. It makes it hard to eat the pizza without a fork and knife. The crust is too thin for the toppings. The flavor of the pizza was still very good. My only complaint is how many flies were inside the restaurant. It made it an unpleasant eating experience. read more

Pizza Mill - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

See all

Delicious pizza, great service, welcoming atmosphere! We enjoyed the pizza after riding the 1880 train.

Busy Monday night but great service and excellent pizza! Great place to eat while at Custer State Park and you want a casual dinner.

The crust was incredible. They were also really flexible with making the pizza vegan for us and it was delicious. It was clean and cute as well! read more

10/10 pizza. We did takeout and the pizza was ready right when they said it would be. Our group got a pepperoni, cheese, and chicken artichoke pizza. They were all really good. I would recommend to anyone wanting pizza in the Custer area. read more

We were in Custer for a weekend and decided pizza was what we wanted. After reviewing menus at the different pizza joints, we selected Pizza Mill. It. Was. Fantastic. We got the all meat (forgive me for forgetting the name) with jalapeños on half. The jalapeños were lackluster. The pizza itself was not. The crust is made by hand with little twists/tucks/pinches around the edges. Tons of cheese. We opted for the dine in. The location is small and tight but there is patio seating available. I noticed honey on the table's condiments. Not sure why but I did add some to my pizza and it was pretty good. Also, the Pizza Mill appears to be good stewards for events held in the community as they were listed as a sponsor for the Mount Rushmore HRC hunt test we were in town attending. Had I known that when we were at the restaurant, I would have thanked them personally. Anyway, if you're like us and try to eat at local establishments when traveling, stop here. You won't regret it. read more

Pizza Mill - All meat pizza with 1/2 jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

What a gem! This place is amazing great staff. She was helpful and gave a great recommendation. The pizza itself is good handmade and yummy! We got the chicken bacon ranch, spinach artichoke and the Hawaiian pizzas. Great all the way we also ordered the mango habanero wings.. kinda lame they charge for ranch but it's silly to complain about .50 cents Really cute and dainty place! read more

Called our pizza in, they told us 15 to 20 minutes. I got there in 25 and the pizza was ready. Carried it back to our campsite and are so surprised at how good the pizza is! We got the Supreme,. This is one of the best pizzas we have ordered anywhere. Highly recommend pizza Mill! read more

I need to begin this review by saying that the food here is really good. The crust on the pizza is especially unique and flavorful. That's the reason I'm giving this place two stars rather than one. Unfortunately, the service we received was horrendous. Based on all the fantastic reviews, I don't know what to make of our experience. Nonetheless, I think people need to be aware of what happened when my family dined here. When we walked in, there were two people ahead of us, and it took about 10 minutes for anyone to come to the counter to take the first order. Then, the girl at the counter left for another 10 minutes to serve food. It took around half an hour for us to even place our order. I should also add that each additional topping on a pizza costs $2.50. $2.50!!! I've paid up to $1.50 for each extra topping, but this was ridiculous. Next, we grabbed an empty table that needed to be bussed. No one ever came to clean the table despite us asking a few times, so we cleaned it ourselves. Despite some of the worst service I've ever had, I don't fault the young lady working there. She clearly needed help and couldn't do the work alone, but she was the only person working in the front of the restaurant. Staffing is a problem at many establishments, and Pizza Mill is no exception. The food is excellent, but if you decide to eat here, bring your patience. read more

Beware - hours of operation are not accurate. We went there on 9/13 at 5pm and the place was closed. That stated, when it's open the food is delicious. read more

Yum! Friendly, clean, kind and quick! Does it get better? Nope! Got the Hearty Choice/All Meat, loved the puffy crust too. Friendly staff recommended some honey with the crust--the perfect end to a great meal. read more

See all

Short and to the point: Undercooked. Wayyyyyyy too much cheese. Not enough sauce. Pretty terrible pizza to be honest. read more

As a local, we try to help local businesses when we can. In a quest for calzones, found them on their menu. Ordered two: pepperoni, sausage, black olives, extra cheese. Seriously overdone, seemed more cheesy and less pepperoni and other toppings. Sad to say I didn't check the order before I left. I'll count this as an "off-day" (December 28) and will try again. We know they've done better and haven't been disappointed in the past. Honestly, nothing else we've tried comes close in our little town, when it comes to pizza. read more

Pizza Mill - a burnt piece of bread on a cutting board - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

See all

Stopped by after a long afternoon hike and found the pizza to be fantastic! Give it a try

This little pizza place is the best around! While in the RV and from out of town, we love trying the local places! One, it supports the small businesses and not the chains. Two, you're likely to get a great surprise and try something you've never had! The pizza here was fabulous! Lots of options and all is fresh and homemade! Best crust ever!!!! And a Greek Gyro pizza? Yup. Amazing. It's so much worth spending a little extra- you get extra! And the staff was polite, friendly, helpful, and funny! If e are ever back in Custer, SD, we will eat here! Go. You won't be sorry! read more

Pizza Mill - This camper loved his personal cheese pizza! And he's a picky pizza person! - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

We only got a half cheese/ half pepperoni pizza because it was expensive at Pizza Mill in Custer, SD. It was okay. I think it would be better if there were more toppings or if it was hot when we got it back to the campground. They don't deliver on Tuesday or Wednesday. We were going to eat there, but the dining room is very small and there was nowhere to sleep. read more

Pizza Mill - Cheese pizza at the Tee Pee in Custer - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

Read about this place and man it didn't disappoint. If you like hand tossed crust, then look no further. We ordered our usual ch,s,m,o,bl olive and the kids got the Reuben. Order of cheese bread to boot. Mediums for both and still had leftovers. Definitely satisfied the pizza craving read more

Pizza Mill - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota