Got a Large Pepperoni Pizza with extra cheese, boy was it cheesy!! Fast Service!! Great please to…read moretry if you're in Custer!

Over 4 stars on Yelp and Google? Unbelievable! I hope I caught them on a bad day. The pizzas looked…read moregood when they came out, but the second you picked up a slice the toppings and cheese slid completely off. No cheese pull, no structure, just a soggy undercooked mess in the middle. The crust was the biggest issue. What looked like a stuffed crust was really just thick undercooked dough that never fully baked through. It made the pizza feel heavy and gummy instead of crispy or chewy. The pepperoni pizza was honestly ridiculous. It had maybe four giant pepperoni slices on the entire pie, so every other bite was just plain cheese and undercooked dough. For almost $45 a pizza, this was a huge disappointment.

We came here because we saw bloggers and road trip videos recommending it as the best burger joint…read more However, upon arrival, we discovered that it had changed ownership and was now exclusively serving pizza under the same owner which is a bit disapppointing. Despite the unexpected change, the pizza options were surprisingly delicious. It's a self-service setup. If you're open to trying pizza instead of a burger, I would recommend giving it a try.

Great pizza, some of the best I've ever had. Just perfect. I confess I was disappointed to discover…read morethis was no longer a burger joint, but the delicious pizza made up for it. Lots of interesting menu items (including burger wrap and salad). Service was great. You walk up and order your meal. There is a counter with utensils, water, etc so you can self-serve. The food came out rather quickly. Overall, one of my favorite meals of this road trip. Highly recommend!!!

Great beer and amazing service. We loved enjoying a couple beers on the patio. Large beer menu with…read moreall types of options. Food menu looked pretty good too.

Just off the Main Street of downtown Custer, this hidden gem is not just the great brewery on the…read morelower floor, but the dining room upstairs is amazing. Open only later in the day, the dining room offers a very sophisticated menu that's not readily available in the downstairs brewery. The dining room has a full bar, and of course all their wonderful beers, and a menu that will just blow your mind! An extensive selection of appetizers, entrées, and sides to satisfy any taste and diet. The salads are phenomenal and the staff will accommodate just about any request, including shared salads, substitutions, etc. This was such a hit that we tried it twice in one week. Entrées like bison, Oso Buco, Cornish Hen, Quail, an array of beef selection, as well as vegetarian options that includes pastas, etc. Yum! The service is just outstanding! Super friendly, eager to please, and really professional. Touting itself as the "pounding father's brewery", the names does not necessarily portray the sophistication of the dining room experience. This is a must stop! Check out the mount Rushmore brewing company, and in particular their dining room upstairs

There are limited options in Custer. We would choose here to eat again and again…read more The food was great and the prices were too. The wait staff were local and all friends. This added a great vibe. Highly recommend.

Be wary of the service here. Our server, a blonde, middle age woman, was noticeably cold to my wife…read moreand I when comparing how she treated us compared to other tables. Frequently coming back to other tables to check if anything was needed, striking up conversation, mentioning the specials of the day (which i would've gotten if i had been offered them and hadn't heard after already ordering). We got none of that. As for the food, it's okay. Nothing to write home about for $50 dollars between a drink, an appetizer, and two mid size entrees. I'm assuming the issue is that my partner and I are both in our mid 20s and have the stereotype of not tipping, which is understandable. This dining experience we definitely did hold up the stereotype based on the complete lack of decent service. If you're anywhere below mid 30s, I'd take your money elsewhere. There's a Pizza Hut a block away that's tasty, friendly, and 1/5 of the price.

Went and had a regular cheeseburger and an elk burger.Super good. the fries were the amazing. The…read moreservice was great. Food came out fast. Great price. Highly recommend.

Food was good, not great, messed up an order but fixed it. Waitress we had was terrible, but the 2…read moreother waiters were busting their tails doing a great job. So probably won't go back it hit or miss but maybe worth a try.

Food was great, I had the elk bolognese and my wife had the salmon . Both were excellently…read moreprepared. We also got side salads, which were delicious and we got the Graceland pie or cake. Whatever it was which was divine. We truly enjoyed our meal. I would highly recommend this place. The weight staff that evening was excellent all the guys working there that evening were hustling and doing a great job.

Tried this place at the last minute and am glad I did. The service was terrific and the place is…read morecute. Food came out hot and tasty Thr potroast melted in your mouth.

Dropped in for lunch and had the Calamity Jane veggie pizza. They make their own quick bread…read morecracker crust. Very generous with the toppings. The owners were very cordial. Good vibes although $20 for a 13 inch pizza is pricey.

My family stopped in for a late lunch during our stay nearby. The staff were very friendly and…read moreknowledgeable. The selection of apparel, home goods and gifts were nice. We ordered the wagyu burger, hot dog, and a pizza. The burger and the hot dog were average 3/5. The pizza was a 4/5. Overall 4 stars.

We rolled in right before close but the staff was still very friendly. The restaurant is cute &…read moreclean. The pies....amazing. I'm pretty picky about rhubarb pie, and theirs gets two thumbs up from me. My husband got the raspberry rhubarb jalapeño pie & it's now his new favorite. It just works. The crusts are crisp and flaky. We'll be back the next time we're in Custer!

Coming from Wisconsin where we pride ourselves to having the best ice cream/custard, when a place…read moresays home made ice cream they better make it real good. This place outsources their ice cream. I think it's by kemps, but the ice cream we got looked and tasted old. Like it's been sitting there for a few weeks. I say this cause you can tell it's more ice, than cream. It has a weird sweetness to it. It doesn't taste like real dairy or at all fresh made like they advertised. The pie was ok. The crust was fine, but the filling seemed like store bought pudding with some coconut mixed into it. Not enough coconut. Not something I would come back for. Over all they say everything is home made. They're not.

The sandwiches were great and the service was fast and friendly. Their prices are also more…read morereasonable than other places in town. Not sure why the so-so reviews! The place was pretty busy, so I guess not many customers are posting reviews.

This is good and fast and healthy food as well. To travel…read moreinterstate you no need to spend to much time in food that so great food as well