We came here because we saw bloggers and road trip videos recommending it as the best burger joint. However, upon arrival, we discovered that it had changed ownership and was now exclusively serving pizza under the same owner which is a bit disapppointing. Despite the unexpected change, the pizza options were surprisingly delicious. It's a self-service setup. If you're open to trying pizza instead of a burger, I would recommend giving it a try. read more

Black Hills Sauce & Dough - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

Great pizza, some of the best I've ever had. Just perfect. I confess I was disappointed to discover this was no longer a burger joint, but the delicious pizza made up for it. Lots of interesting menu items (including burger wrap and salad). Service was great. You walk up and order your meal. There is a counter with utensils, water, etc so you can self-serve. The food came out rather quickly. Overall, one of my favorite meals of this road trip. Highly recommend!!! read more

Black Hills Sauce & Dough - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

This is our absolute favorite place in Custer!!! The staff girls were both so sweet and amazing and made our experience WONDERFUL! The pizza was absolutely delicious and we were fat kid full!! The atmosphere is fun and catchy! Would 100% recommend this place when you come through Custer!!!! read more

See all

Hidden gem in the black hills! Custer is such a cool town, busy and happening! We stumbled across Sauce & Dough from Yelp and so glad we did! Their pizzas are amazing, and the selection all over the place. We tried the Cheeseburger Pizza and the Cheese Curds appetizer. Both were amazing! The curds had a nice light breading and light on the grease dipped in your choice of sauces (ranch for us). The pizza crust was the same light, puffy, crunchiness! The food came out lightning fast and hot! Every table was full so I assume it always is with the product they serve. The servers were attentive and genuinely nice. Even with a packed house they gave every table proper attention. Decently loud in there, but the whole town is load :) One note, you order at the counter but they wait on you after seated, so make sure to tip up front or leave some cash on the table. Wish this was communicated a bit better, but thanks for a great lunch!! read more

Black Hills Sauce & Dough - Cheese Curds and Ranch - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

See all

Truly one of the best pizzas I have had. Fantastic quality ingredients including the dough!! This isn't just good for a small town in South Dakota, but fantastic for pizza in a large city! It came highly recommended to us and we will definitely be back! Staff was very friendly and helpful. Restaurant is small but they have some outdoor seating in their sister market next door. read more

Black Hills Sauce & Dough - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

Tasty pizza with light, delicious dough. It's a pretty straightforward gourmet pizza experience: good toppings, good crust, good portion sizes. They've got it dialed in. The standout was honestly the service - extremely friendly! Like we were all hometown best friends somehow. We'd go almost anywhere for service like that. Luckily here you'll get great food to go along with it. One more little note: the seating is conducive to conversations and date nights. Despite being part of an open restaurant, the way the tables and booths are set up offers a surprising amount of privacy for those who want it. read more

Awesome food! THE BEST burgers! Friendliest servers! Perfect Hill Country ambiance! Don't miss the chance for deliciousness! read more

I came from Southern California to visit my sister, who lives in Rapid City. We went to go to see the Bison in Custer State Park. Every restaurant we went to on the main drag of Custer was closed for Thanksgiving. Black Hills burger and pizza was our only choice. And boy, was I glad. Their food is excellent. My sister ordered a customized pizza with their homemade Italian sausage, mushrooms and peppers. It was excellent. Their crust is just perfect. I ordered the Cheeseburger with bacon salad. Don't knock it until you've tried it! It was so good!!!!! Not sure why they changed their name. Oh! I know. People don't do internet searches for Sauce and Dough! We were lucky the other restaurants were closed! I can't recommend highly enough. read more

Stopped in and had a veggie pizza. The staff is very friendly and courteous. The crust is a dense artisan style baked at 575 dF in a gas deck oven. Sauce and dough are made in house. read more

Black Hills Sauce & Dough - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Custer, South Dakota

See all

We were there in 2024, sorry late review. What a great pizza! quant little place, it does get busy, so be prepared, but the food is worth it!!! read more

Prices too high for the quality of food. Rather mediocre at best. Ate there once maybe twice when it was a burger place. Same owners but different name and menu now. It got a little too noisy and crowded for us. Probably not going back. As far as the Business Owners response to my review it was my opinion. The fact remains for me is still the same regardless of her sales pitch. The food was mediocre and the prices out of touch. read more

This restaurant used to be the Black Hills Burger & Bun; however, over the winter they closed and re-opened as BH Sauce & Dough. They serve Pizza, Hoagies, Wraps & Salads along with Shakes. My husband and I enjoyed the pizza on our 1st visit, the hoagies on the 2nd and pizza again on the 3rd visit. The dough for the pizzas and the hoagies is all fresh baked and we'll definitely be returning. read more

Food was delicious, service was excellent, price was reasonable. Clean and neat place. read more

We loved this place! Many creative pizzas or you can create your own. My husband and I shared one and had two pieces left. The service was excellent! read more

I ate here previously when it was under a different name and served primarily burgers. It was so delicious that I intentionally drove out of my way to eat there. Since then, food choices have changed. My dietary needs have not. I am still gluten-free, dairy-free. I requested help with the new menu. I ordered a make-your-own pizza on a gluten-free crust and was assured that everything was gluten-free and dairy-free. The toppings I had were chicken, bacon, red onions, and mushrooms. That did not turn out. There was gluten in something. Unfortunately, once you've digested the food, you aren't left to deal with the consequences. So, I believe this is where we part ways. I cannot take that risk with my dietary needs again. Staff were kind and professional and attempted their best to be accommodating. It didn't really work out this time. In response to what Jessica posted as the business owner, I can appreciate her perspective and due diligence. I also know that I have been gluten-free for 10 years and cross contamination is not generally an issue. read more

To start off the ambiance is nice and relaxed. It's a casual environment with nice seating arrangements. The service was good and the staff was kind, welcoming, and friendly. They were very active and made sure we had everything we needed. The pizza was good, but not anything overwhelmingly delightful - although you could tell it was homemade so I'll definitely support it! They offered sweet tea - my favorite - but there were no free refills for the sweet tea which was disappointing. But overall, a good pizza place to stop. They didn't offer much for picky eaters other than the pizza, so be sure if you are bringing a picky eater to double check the menu items! read more

Yes. Yes. Yes. The atmosphere. The people. The food. One of the best places to eat in the Black Hills. Edit- call to verify their hours as they change with the season. They're not always up to date online. read more

The pizza was great; highly recommend Mr and Mrs Smith. A bit noisy but worth it. It was difficult to find because we were looking for its prior incarnation at the same time location, read more

Looking for a great local pizza place. Saw the pictures of their pizza and had to try it. Couldn't have been any happier. It was exactly what I was wanting. The online ordering for pickup was easy. read more

Amazing pizza. I had high hopes from all the great reviews but was still impressed. The service was fast and super friendly. We had the fried cheese curds- delicious. All 4 of us were impressed by the pizza. So delicious! We saw a few salads come out that looked amazing as well. If we were staying longer we would definitely be back! read more