Absolutely loved this meal. Everything felt thoughtfully prepared and beautifully presented. The steak was cooked to a perfect medium-rare--tender, juicy, and full of rich flavor with a great sear on the outside. Each slice practically melted in my mouth. The fries were crispy and well-seasoned, elevated by fresh herbs and truffle. The crab cake was a standout too--golden on the outside, moist inside, and packed with flavor, finished with a smooth, buttery sauce that didn't overpower it. We did order cosmos and I will say they were way too strong so we switched to wine which was better. Also a man came up at gave us $100 towards our meal so that may speak to the type of crowd. Overall, the meal felt indulgent yet balanced, with every component done right. A truly satisfying dining experience that I'd happily order again. read more

Pietro's Prime - 8oz. Filet Mignon - Steakhouses Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

Great steaks with good value for the price! Sides are homestyle. Great creamed spinach. Au gratin potatoes were good, not great, with a little bacon. Very busy on a Saturday night. Our server did a good job balancing our party of 7. read more

A yuppie, middle-aged crowd very congested however, the food is fantastic. It takes a while to be served, but it's worth the wait. Don't expect a drink at the bar really fast. The old-fashioned was mediocre the bar service is overwhelmed. It's a local spot with good food, it's an established restaurant that lost its personal connection your a number it happens but over all steaks are still delicious. read more

Great waiter, very friendly and the service was attentive. Food was average, my steak was underdone, the lobster was ok but nothing I couldn't make at home. For the price i would expect far more, it just didn't do it for me or the party I was with. read more

Went to Pietro's last night for a drink. No seats at the bar, but the host gave us a high top and made sure we were taken care of. (Thank you!) Martinis are the go-to there because they're an appropriate size, good value, and a really good price at $15 ...and the happy hour price is $12, I think. Highly recommend the Pepperoncini Martini. Andrea, our server in the bar, was amazing. We had a great time! Will def be back. read more

The food and service here are top notch. Our server was very courteous and answered any questions we had and our meals were delicious! I had filet and my friend had crab cakes and we split Brussels sprouts and potatoes. We will definitely be going back! Very enjoyable night! read more

We have been going to Pietro's for years. Always enjoyed sitting at the bar and getting a drink and dinner. We have gone in twice in the last month and the service at the bar has been horrible. Both times the bartender was more interested in their phone than helping customers. Out of respect I will not put her name in this text. read more

Food and service excellent. Brian our waiter is what food servers should be striving for. He made it a great experience. If you haven't been here, go with your significant other on a date here. read more

My first bite of the filet was pure magic. I'm a total weirdo who wants a steak both moist and medium-well (yes, I know...rare people are rolling their eyes). But it was done perfectly! And Brian, our server, knew everything about every steak on that menu. He was fun and attentive. Our table was private, enjoying much needed quiet conversation time. read more

Pietro's Prime - Magical - Steakhouses Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

The best steak! Great customer service. Never have we been disappointed in years of dining there. read more

See all

The food. Service was great! Food Just okay , it wasn't anything special that day. The remolade sauce was really good. read more

See all

Yall know I'm a yelper, so I depend on reviews to choose new spots to try. Hubby wanted to go to West Chester for date night, so I looked through a few spots. Funny enough, we already tried the top three recommendations in West Chester. This place was on the list of top recommendations that we haven't tried. I liked through the reviews and and the pics of dishes, and was sold. I made resys for us and we arrived just in time. Although we were originally seated inside, our server was kind enough to sit us outside because the air conditioning was doing its job! lol. We started with apps- fried oysters, cheesesteak panzotti rolls, and I got the watermelon salad. For mains we had lamb chops and the 8oz strip. My strip steak was served with the Roquefort garlic butter (soooo good!), and the lamb chops came with a demi glacé and a white sauce. We had the creamed spinach to share. Everything tasted so good, the service from Isabelle was ON POINT, and we will definitely be back. read more

I thought this place was wonderful The food was very good, our waiter was excellent and it doesn't have an industrial feel like so many other steakhouses. It's a very comfortable little place. A quick warning, some of the sides are very large, as are the desserts . The server will probably warn you. One point to note ... if you're trying to go for a special meal, don't go on Friday night at 7:30! There is a risk that the place will be crowded, the kitchen overworked, and the dining room a little noisy. That's the case at every single restaurant. If you're looking to have a cozy dinner with your significant other, pretend that you're old and go early! Reservations are strongly recommended . read more

Horrible food! Raw lamb chops, microwaved bake potato, server very rude, seated in back corner. Christmas Eve dinner. Will never go back

We have been coming here yearly following our local golf outing for the last 5+ years. The service is always amazing. Knowledgeable staff. We have a quiet back room, but the entire restaurant looks great for a date night. The hors d'oeuvre plates were great, even with a large party. The bar does a great job too with an array of different spins on old Classics. The steak was cooked perfectly and the sides were delicious. Dessert is great too, if you have room! We've had the same server for all these years, so it must be a great place to work as well. Looking forward to next year already! read more

Christmas Eve 2025. A special time for us to dine with family and friends and each year we try out a restaurant we have never been to. This year we chose Pietro's Prime and frankly, we were quite disappointed. We had 6:00 reservations and upon arrival the very friendly owner told us our table was almost ready and it would have been perfect for us - in the main dining room near the bar and fireplace with ambience. I use a wheelchair so navigating a busy restaurant can sometimes be tricky, but this would have been no problem. Instead, the owner had a table in the back room that was ready and a Hostess took us to that room and our table. First Red Flag! We were shown to a table at the very back of the restaurant in a room that had ZERO ambiance - all of the HVAC commercial ductwork showing on the ceiling, our candle was never lit on the table (our table was a folding table with the leafs let out and the metal bars underneath hitting our legs if we moved to the left or the right. There was no problem navigating to that room and table. But, the room was bare, unassuming walls...just not good! We should have asked for another table but given it was Christmas Eve and they had an almost full restaurant, we decided not to make a fuss. Our server was polite and efficient. We ordered Calamari as well as a Jumbo Shrimp cocktail for starters which were very good. But, when it came to our main dishes, Red Flag 2! The lamb chops ($59) were ordered medium rare and came bloody in the center. The Cowboy Bone in ribeye was quite small for the $62 price and had a funny taste. The garnishing on the large white plate was a single 3 inch onion stick. The 8 ounce filet ($50) was ordered medium and was very good - although the filet looked lonely on a huge white plate, again with only a single small onion stick. Just an odd presentation for a pricey meal. The sides, all priced at $13 each, except for the Lobster Mac & Cheese ($25) were generous - huge potatoes that were described as baked but were instead steamed. The mushrooms seemed steamed and while a large portion, not very tasty. Instead of being served with carrots, the mushrooms would have been much better sauteed in butter and garlic to compliment the steaks. The dessert was delicious - an Italian Lemon Cream Cake. Overall, disappointing for our special, annual Christmas Eve dinner and our first time at Pietro's Prime. Maybe an off night for the chef. Each year, we have lots of $$$-$$$ restaurants to choose from with a great menu and a warm and inviting atmosphere. This year, we were expecting the same. Unfortunately, our first dining experience wasn't what we had expected. read more

Pietros prime I loved food and service. Came for lunch had the lobster bisque and Pietros prime salad which was delicious. Salad had Tenderloin tips, roasted red bliss potatoes, sauteed mushrooms, and veggies atop mixed green with a roquefort and balsamic vinaigrette. So glad I am working nearby this I think will be my favorite place. read more

Pietro's Prime - Steakhouses Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

First stop on our new monthly date night (married 31 years) and very much looking forward to a superb ribeye to go with a night alone with my beloved. Good memories of a magnificent Tomahawk steak there years ago. Unfortunately, the $56 Cowboy Ribeye was a huge disappointment. No sear. Not tender. Not as thick as I like, and no notable aging (wet or dry). Chunky and chewy. Ordered medium but came more rare and hard enough to cut that I wondered if my knife was dull. My wife's Cajun Delmonico was overwhelmed with seasoning and a bit dry. Our server was a delight but only offered to take back and cook a bit longer. Never a good option, IMO. Restaurant is VERY loud so we had to project to hear each other. It was still a good date night, but, as I said, disappointed it didn't include a memorable marbled masterpiece. read more

Stopped in on a beautiful Friday afternoon and had a great break from reality for a while. Great atmosphere. Excellent pours and wonderful steaks. Can't beat it. read more

See all

Service was excellent. Our server was kind and attentive. Started with rose and espresso martini - both yummy and cold! Calamari was yummy - loved the sauce. Warm bread (a big basket) and oil was great. Filet and aged strip (special) for dinner with Brussels sprouts (special) and steak fries for a la carte sides. Steaks were cooked to correct temp. Everything truly was good. However, this was our first visit and it was very very loud! We were sitting In the front room with about 7-8 other tables. My husband and I were screaming at each other for most of the dinner to communicate. Our reservation was 7pm, which while a busy time of night you'd still expect to be able to talk. We finished the night at the bar. Live music was nice and bartenders were friendly This should be 4 but due to how loud I am giving a 3. I'd suggest they work on the acoustics of this spot. When you're spending that kind of money. read more

Made a reservation for Sunday instead of Saturday and didn't realize it until they called to confirm. I spoke with a manager who was extremely kind and helpful making the change. Had an amazing meal and great service from Steven. We all had steaks cooked perfectly. Sides ( potatoes au gratin especially) were delicious and plentiful. Drinks were a generous pour. Went to celebrate our daughter's graduation and couldn't have been happier. read more

Came here for apps during Taps! Sat at the bar. Service was fast and drinks were flowing. It was a little loud but we still had a nice time. Apps were delicious! read more

See all

Came here during weekday lunch time. It wasn't crowded at all. We like the settings: they have both dining area and a bar. The place is pretty big. We had the shrimp Lejon and Crab cake as the appetizers. The shrimp was huge, wrapped with bacon. The crab cake was just okay - it tastes like it has too much stuffing instead of crab meat. I wouldn't order that again... the dipping for crab cake is also just okay. I'd prefer the dipping for the shrimp. For entrees, we had the scallops and half sandwich. The scallops are just great! Cooked to be perfect. It comes with a side and we got the onion rings, which are huge and delicious. My half sandwich is good. For the prime rib sandwich, they did not even ask how I want it cooked... but it turned out to be good. A little overdone, but okay. However, they did to make my soup order wrong. I wanted the soup of the day , which is chicken fajita, but they gave me lobster bisque, which I didn't say anything. One thing to notice is the speed of service is really slow... it took 20 minutes for the appetizers to be ready. Then another 30 minutes for the entrees. We were just waiting there all the time, given the fact that there weren't too many people... the waitress served us was also the one working at the front desk... read more

See all

Thoroughly enjoyed a dinner for 3 for Fathers Day. We tried one of the special salads and a seafood sampler as appetizers - both were great. Tow it f is had the filet mignon and one had the ribeye - delicious. We tried 2 martinis and a glass of red wine - all were very tasty. For sides, we had broccoli, spinach, mushrooms and onions - huge portions and all wonderful. And we now have lunch for tomorrow! Prices are not inexpensive but much lower than a similar meal at one of the large chain steakhouses. read more

Pietro's Prime - Salad (special for tonight) - Steakhouses Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

See all

Fantastic food I had the scallops Everyone said fantastic Lobster bisque soup Mashed potatoes Flies mignon .. just fantastic . I never give 5 stars read more

Pietro's Prime - Graduation lunch - Steakhouses Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

We stopped here for drinks and appetizers on the way to our actual dinner reservation. We sat towards the back of the restaurant in a very romantic, dimly lit space. We enjoyed mango martins which were very good. For appetizers we got the lobster bisque and the crab cake appetizer. The crab cake was average, a little mushy to be honest. The lobster bisque was very bad. We honestly couldn't even finish it. The dominant flavor was sweetness and it overpowered everything else. We finished off with a brownie sundae. It was the highlight of our meal. 10/10 on the dessert. read more

See all

Excellent food! Excellent service! And...the drinks were outstanding!! I would recommend for a date night, dinner with friends, or a special occasion with your family! read more

We had a reservation for 8:45 and got seated right away! Our waiter was Steven and he was excellent. Very attentive and educated about the menu. Boxed all our food for us! great atmosphere and food, sides were delicious. definitely coming back! read more

We frequent this steak house often and I am always very happy with the food and service. The seafood sampler is a must try...delicious (although I miss the fresh lobster meat that used to be a part of the dish). Their filets and steaks are always cooked perfectly and to our liking. The lobster Mac and cheese is rich and delicious. This place is definitely a favorite of mine. read more

Great service, but extremely loud. Food was good, but not quite as good as you'd expect from such an expensive place.

I came here with my girlfriend for valentine's day, as a nice treat to ourselves. And while the service was decent, it was most certainly not to the degree that I would expect from an expensive steakhouse such as this. The food also followed the same trend. My girlfriend and I split their cheesesteak pazzoti which has potential but certainly lacked filling and was very deceptive (the menu says you get six but you get six half pieces which was a tad irksome in the moment especially for 15 bucks). For our mains, we also split the porterhouse with their scampi butter sauce. We did ordered the steak medium rare but came out as rare in some parts and medium in the others (I do not know how that is possible), but it was tender (aside from annoying pieces of chewy gristle ) and well seasoned for the most part but I did expect more for a $60 steak (it was saved by the scampi butter sauce). For our sides we got their special lobster mac and cheese and their au gratin potatoes. The lobster mac and cheese might have been the star of the night being perfectly creamy with a nice lobster taste with decent chunks of lobster meat, but their potatoes were about average where all I tasted was cream and potatoes with very little seasoning or cheese (also I did slightly expect more for an $11 side). The ambiance is also very mid, and while it is the most spacious restaurant in West Chester, the dining room in the back where we were seated have back room dining room vibes and was not reflective of a fancy steakhouse, but it was different for the other dining rooms. All in all, it was not a horrible experience, having its pros and cons but there are certainly better places to get a fancy dinner in town that are actually worth the price. read more

Pietro's Prime - . Porterhouse, Au Gratin Potatoes, lobster mac and cheese - Steakhouses Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

See all

Great food and excellent service! Terrific place to celebrate a special occasion! Everyone in our party enjoyed their experience. We will be back to Pietro's ! read more

The food was amazing and very friendly staff I will be coming back for more the steak was delicious and very well made

There is lots of nearby street parking that you can pay for by downloading the Passport app to your phone, especially if you don't frequent West Chester. We visited on a Saturday at around 5PM with reservations and were surprised by how crowded it was at such an early time. Maybe it was that people were there for special events or for Valentine's Day, and/or maybe the place is just that popular. The reason I visited were the high marks that the restaurant received online. The New York Strip that I ordered looked like perfection, and it tasted excellent, too. Although I don't normally drink martinis, I tried one, specifically since this is a martini bar, and the drink was a pleasant experience of different flavors. Our server was pleasant and informative, too. My issues were the noise level and slowed service at the end of the meal. It was harder to hear each other after the room filled up, and it felt like the service slowed, taking a while to get our desserts and check. My espresso arrived after I was finished with my dessert, which wasn't ideal. Maybe that is just part of the experience when you have such a great reputation, and everyone wants to eat at your establishment, but it is why I am giving a four instead of five. I would definitely visit here again and recommend! read more

Stopped in the bar here for the first time with a girlfriend on a weeknight for cocktails. Our bartender was excellent and knowledgeable, he even gave us a little extra of our drinks at no extra charge! Both cocktails were amazing. 5 star experience. read more

Pietro's Prime - Cosmopolitan and Espresso martini (extra!) - Steakhouses Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

See all

This spot is pretty hit or miss and later we've been experiencing some misses. To start, everyone can appreciate a complimentary bread but they served flavorless rolls that would have been better left off the table. We ordered two 8oz fliets and those were good. I got mine marsala style and I loved that topping. But, the sides were really bad. We got lobster Mac and cheese. It tasted like velveeta and had almost no lobster. The Brussels sprouts were soggy instead of crispy. The service was OK but quite quirky. The room was uncomfortably hot. The highlight of the night was the chocolate lava cake dessert. I would give this place a try if you have never been but that might be one the last tries for us. read more

Pietro's Prime - Menu - Steakhouses Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

I was invited to celebrate a birthday dinner in a private suite at this place. It boasts a nice upscale vibe and a cozy ambiance. The food was excellent, and the service was amazing. read more

See all

Went here for the first time a special birthday dinner with my wife. It was never on my radar, but I am a fan now. We started at the bar for cocktails. Turns out it was happy hour, so we had to try a few of their appetizers, including the black and white tuna and the tuna skins. Both were delicious! As were the HUGE martinis we had. I have never seen such large cocktails, so be careful when ordering a second one. Dinner was equally delicious, albeit a bit pricey, but we knew that ahead of time. I had the Cajun Delmonico and it was cooked perfect. read more

Pietro's Prime - Awesome cocktails. Almost big enough to take a bath in g - Steakhouses Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

See all

Our usual Anniversary dinner. We order a porterhouse steak. Prepared medium. Cooked on the bone I get the strip and my wife the filet. Highly recommend! Also a great lunch. read more

Our experience was impeccable! Brian was the best server ever, making sure every detail was covered. Food was phenomenal as were the drinks. Brian made it a memorable 15 yr anniversary from start to finish. read more

See all