Shawn's Pizza Reviews REVIEW # 12 PICASSO'S PIZZA UNION RD. WEST SENECA, NY SCORE 8.4 "WE ARE BUFFALO PIZZA." First arriving in WNY in 1980, Picasso's has become a go-to for many. They also have locations in Lancaster, Blasdell, & Williamsville. Their pizza is top notch when it comes to ingredients. My only complaints were the bottom being a bit undercooked and the pepperonis a little burnt. Other than that, I could probably eat this pizza everyday if I needed to. Gold status! read more

Picasso's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Got a large cheese pepperoni and double hot wings for my grandson and his girlfriend who cant be here for Thanksgiving. It's been awhile since I had Picasso it was really good nice soft bites into the dough with spicy pepperoni and sprinkled with extra spice just the way I like it and plenty of sauce the crust was dark and crispy . Wings were good made crispy not too much sauce on it that makes the wings soggy. Glad they suggested Picasso 's even have leftovers read more

Picasso's Pizza - Hot wings - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Another solid lunch special. Was greeted immediately upon walking in, and my order was taken promptly. Within moments I had my pizza ready to go. Great pepperoni to bite ratio I just wish for a little less sauce... Highly advise against even attempting to eat a slice on the go. Will be back again sometime soon. read more

Picasso's Pizza - Pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I'll be honest- this has to be the absolute best pizza I've ever had. Picasso's used to be an eat in restaurant but after the pandemic, they're now take out only. So to make sure we had it at the perfect temp, we just ate in the car. It was everything I imagined Buffalo pizza to be- bready, saucy and the creamiest cheese! They sell by the slice, so we got a few each, especially because we wanted to have leftovers! This pizzeria is a gem! read more

Picasso's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Good pizza but SUPER inconsistent. Sometimes it's hot and crispy and sometimes it's soggy and cold. Sometimes it's on DoorDash and sometimes it's not. The last time I ordered the entire pizza part of my order was missing. read more

PIZZA HERE IS AMAZINGGG!!! I have never had a pizza that was as good as this one! It was so crispy on the outside, had the perfect amount of cheese, and the sauce was made perfectly! Filled with so much flavor! Definitely coming back if I ever get the chance to visit NY again! read more

Picasso's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

We order from Picasso's on Union almost every week. Today I ordered online for a specific time and got notified 45 min early. I went and picked up the order when I got the text and when I got home the pizza was cold. I can understand being a bit off with the timing, but it is usually 10 to 15 min. and the food is normally hot. Even with the Super Bowl they were not super busy. very disappointed with our order. read more

This pizza was amazing. We had it at work with wings and I was very impressed. I can't wait to order out from here!!!

Ordered online with a specific pickup time they made it almost and hour early and then got lied to by the manager on staff after was already told the food is ready. Due to poor service and being lied to this will be the last time we order from this pizza place. There are at least 6 in an 3 mile radius...taking my business elsewhere. Location West Seneca read more

Ordered pizza and chicken wings for Christmas eve for $120 wings where not good at all no flavor and not right. Pizza was ok but cheese was burnt. Sent them a message no call back. read more

Great pizza and sauce! Had some wings also nice and crispy! Would gladly order again!

Ordered LOADED fries. The fries came with nothing on them. Called and the manager, they said that's what we ordered. Asked who orders LOADED fries without any of the toppings. He asked "the highest person in the business" what to do. We were told sorry not our fault, bye. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE when ordering LOADED fries make sure the manager and "highest person in the business" know what that means! Zero customer service! (Is there no option for 0 stars??) read more

Picasso's Pizza - Picasso's please call Santora's and ask what Loaded Fries are. Thank you in advance! - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

The food is amazing the pizza the chicken wings. I also had a ham sub. I'm going to have a party now I want to price pizzas I cannot find their menu for that online whatsoever. I might get a party pizza. I'd like to know how much it is or due to large pizzas. It's aggravating. read more

Over cooked, pepperoni and crust were burnt. They did give us credit for a future order

Yelp removed my photo from the business page (?!) before I even opened the pizza box. Yes, it's porn... food porn. I felt filthy after having a cheese and pepperoni late afternoon delight. It was a greasy, cheesy, gooey guilty pleasure. Bite after bite, and I couldn't stop until my huge slice was gone. I was hungry and Picasso's satisfied me truly. Even though I wanted to take a shower right after this intense experience, I would do it again. read more

See all

Not sure but are you using less dough, seems like the crust is getting thinner and on top of that its not always cooked enough. Not sure if these changes were done on purpose but you typically have been the best pizza in the area. I hope that the last couple times we've ordered were just one offs. read more

Sox cc y uh cSry or wet c go in CT y by I by shh if f hi Sucks I'm not interested in having any other side effects for this one but I'm sure it's not the best read more

This was my first time having Picasso's and it was alright. I had the BLT and fries. We also ordered chicken tenders too. I felt like the bread although very tasty the seasoning comes off so easily, and the bacon was a tad too crunchy for me other than that it was good. Fries (not pictured) 0/10 not flavorful not crispy they were so bland. The chicken tenders my daughter and I loved they were perfect and hit the spot. I'm curious to try other items Picasso's offers like their pizza. read more

Picasso's Pizza - BLT Sub - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Uncontested best pizza in Western New York. No argument. They have perfected pizza. Their wings aren't too shabby either. Buffalo Bills and Picassos is the right combo. read more

Great regular Buffalo pizza. If you like sweeter sauce. Well, then...Picasso's is for you. Crispy on the edges cup pepperoni. A large is almost a sheet. You'll get it in the rectangular box. Cut in squares. Enough to feed a large family where a regular large won't cut it for more than four people. read more

Love the food the prices are crazy though. Cheese and pepperoni pizzas are done perfectly. They do have specials though.

Pizza- dough was not cooked all the way. Middle was still raw, not a pleasant taste or texture. Whatever spices they put on is a tad spicy in some bites. Wings- super soggy by the time they were delivered. Soggy wings are never good. We will not be ordering here again. But for your other loyal customers- Please do better. read more

This pizza is delicious. I ordered it from Gold Belly and had it delivered to CA. It was worth every penny. The sauce was sweet but still zesty. The cheese was perfect, had lots of flavor but not too greasy. The crust was buttery and crisp. The pepperoni was thicker cut and high quality. I've been craving a proper square cut pizza in a world of Neapolitan choices and this hit the spot. "Pizza understands, pizza will always be there for you" read more

See all

Ridiculous prices. Probably the most expensive pizzeria in Western New York. Asking over $15 for three slices.

Fluffy and crispy crust just the way to want it. The pizzanomics is perfect the right toppings are on the top and they're all perfectly cooked. I got a single slice which was actually a 7x7 square personal pizza. Then I got a split medium pie of the Stinger and Spaghetti meatball. Aand they were daaaaang good. 20/20 demolish that pizza like it ain't funny. Plus the staff was very nice. They're going through a renovation, but I'm sure the rest of the inside is gonna be clean and modern. read more

Picasso's Pizza - "Single" piece pretty big definitely worth it. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

i ordered 1 large pizza and 25 wings, received mostly chicken drums, very few wing. i went back the website to check the descriptio. the menu also said 25 wings and no mention any drums. very disappointe! read more

Picasso's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Ordered early on a bills Sunday. Never got pepperoni on our pizza- didn't realize till we served at 1/2 time. Very disappointing.

Parking Plentiful and close. They could do a better job with salting it in winter but other than that it's fine Food They make a saucy pie. I like it. A little on the sweet side and they don't skimp on the portions or ingredients. Large is like a mini sheet pizza. You get more for your buck then say ... just pizza IMO Vibe It's an old school pizzeria. I only get take out. From what I can tell it's never been remodeled and it's fine in someways I guess. read more

Allways consistent product, and if you love pepperoni, it comes loaded! Wings are always perfection. We order "hot" , but it is not too spicy. Not very saucy and sloppy, the way we like it. We always ask for extra crispy. Service is always professional, and they also have a coupon for a free chef salad with your order. We always do take out. We are hooked! read more

First time trying out Picasso's, ordered online through doordash. I got their 1/2 medium bold pies / specialty pizza, steak in the grass and mozzarella cheese sticks. I really like the pie / pizza it's a good quantity for the price and size wise too, perfect for 1-2 people! The taste also was very fresh and the pizza came hot, so the cheese pull was amazing! But only thing I didn't like how oily the pizza was it leaked so much oil. I didn't either like the mozzarella cheese sticks they were so small for the price of 3, like they should make them a little longer if they are selling 3 for $4.78, they were not that great. I'll hopefully order more pizza from here and try their other items on the menu! read more

Picasso's Pizza - Mozzarella sticks and Steak In The Grass - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Super pizza, consistent, hot , fresh! It's our weekly no-cook nite treat and will continue to be as long as we are lucky enough to have them nearby! read more

Worst food ever! Tried to give them a chance a couple times. Everything is terrible. Undercooked dough, never order loaded frys. read more

Picasso's Pizza - This is what your loaded frys look like. Mushy frys with a jar of jalapeños dumped on them! Gross - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I've always thought I would make a good competitive eater but after having a sub from Picasso's I'm having second thoughts. I ordered a stinger sub which is chicken fingers & steak along with all the essential sub items, never had one before. Even though I ordered the smaller of the two sizes available this thing weighed about 3 lb give or take, and was wrapped up in wax paper then put into a box, that's a first for me. Needless to say I could only eat half of it which is extremely rare for me, the sub itself was delicious, the chicken fingers were hot as I ordered and the steak was tender and juicy, the order was ready for pickup when I was told it was going to be and the counter staff was pleasant. Good job! read more

Picasso's Pizza - Sub in a box - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Perfect cup & char pizza and the wings are large! A must for when I return back to Western New York!

Always consistent. Always delicious. Picasso's Pizza never disappoints. Today's order was a simple medium cheese and pepperoni pizza. I ordered it extra saucy and I was certainly satisfied. They are quick with their orders and I never have to wait when I pick up orders. There are generally others in the shops for pick ups too but I feel like they get the orders out quick. I never order much else besides the pizza because, again, they are consistent with the pizza. The calzones have been good in the past when I've ordered. I frequent this place about 2x per month for pizza and I'm always happy. read more

Picasso's Pizza - Cheese and pepperoni pizza; extra saucy - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

We ordered the gluten free pizza with double pepperoni. Lots of amazing charred pepperoni. The gluten free crust was tasty. Salty , spicy , lots of flavor ! There are a lot of GF pizza options , I will try GF stinger next! read more

Picasso's Pizza - Gluten Free double pep pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

If I could leave zero stars I would-I ordered 10 wings and received 1 flat and 9 drums. Most pizzerias will make sure there is at least a reasonable ratio. I would have been happy w/ 6 drums 4 flats. I never complain about food but if you could give me 9 drums and 1 flat why couldn't you give me 9 flats and 1 drum? Especially since I specifically asked for all flats and they said they don't do all flats/drums even if I paid extra. Which leads me to believe they purposely gave me 9 drums and 1 flat to "make a point". I just won't be ordering from here again since I paid $50 for my pizza and 10 wings to be delivered and got jipped on the one specification I asked for while willing to pay extra. read more

Picasso's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I ordered a pizza through door dash and paid for it and they couldn't find it. I went home, called, and waited on hold for 10 minutes. I called back and they found it. I drove back to get it. No compensation offered. This was last night. Food is good. Service was not. read more

This was my last hope with their large pizzas. Lately every time we order a large cheese and pep the dough is under cooked. No way to hold a slice. Always need a fork and knife because it's so soggy and doughy. The amount of grease was ridiculous. So sad because the pizzas used to be delish! read more

Love their food. Pizza is the greatest. Have been going to the one on Unon Road forever. Service is great too