Only 4 starts because Nino's goes through phases. Sometimes they're on point for months and then suddenly, everything is just "meh" for awhile so we take a break. But when they're good, they're really good. Like one of the best Buffalo-style pizza joints around good. Also LOVE their blue cheese. I will say, for the longest time, the foil they were using would stick to the chicken fingers and tiny bits would peel off, making the fingers inedible, bit somehow not the wings? We haven't ordered their fingers in a couple years because of this so I can't say if this is still an issue. But for years we would occasionally order forgetting about the foil problem and then regretting it every time. read more

They use to be one of the very best pizzas around. If I could give them " 9 " Stars.., I would. Now small slices more expensive but the pizza itself...., " TERRIBLE ". Sauce..., Cheese..., Dough.... read more

Ninos is definitely one of the best pizza places in the Southtowns! Every time I'm at my in laws we tend to get pizza from here and they never disappoint! I love a traditional cheese and pepperoni pizza, but I do also love ninos peppers and onions pizza! It has a ton of flavor and is a nice vegetarian option! The service is always fast and the pizza and super warm like it just came out of the oven even by the time we get it back home! This is a great little pizza place if you're looking for a good local option in the southtowns that has amazing wings and pizza! read more

Nino's Pizzeria - Bbq wings - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

Another pizza and wings night from Ninos - our favorite! Pizza was amazing, wings were good but some of them were just very small. read more

See all

I used to like Ninos.. was craving the char broiled chicken sub.. asked for oil, toasted hot peppers, onions, lettuce, tomatoe... got no oil, no roasted hot peppers, no lettuce.. they have gone down hill. Last time going there. read more

Pizza is delicious. I have going there for many years and the pizza has never changed. Highly recommended.

Just picked up a Royal sub and pizza slices from Ninos in West Seneca . The sub was the best I've had and service was amazing. Will be tasting the pizza later. Fast friendly service on a day that the Bills won! read more

spent $47 on a half sub, one full sub, two drinks and garlic sticks. and this was half of the one sub. So sad and disappointing. read more

Nino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Ordered delivery tonight. Gave them another shot. Ordered a special. Large pizza 20 wings. Wings were food. Ordered a small pizza cheese pepperoni and hot peppers. Got it delivered. The small pizza had no sauce at all. Never again will we order Ninos again read more

Crust was excellent. The crust edges were a little crispy but not burnt. The rest of the dough was tasty and chewy. Just enough cheese and pepperoni. Not greasy at all for having pepperoni. I don't like a ton of gooey cheese. Was just enough for my taste. The sauce was thick and a bit sweet but perhaps a little too much. Overall, excellent and highly recommend. read more

Been using Nino's as my go to place since 1981, last 2 times, they forgot blue cheese and the little tables to keep pizza from sticking to box. This last time pizza crust was undercooked. Both times it was a party pizza and bucket of wings! Didn't realize till I got home... They lost me as a customer! read more

Ordered two subs for pickup in the early evening. Waited a short period of time beyond the pick up time, they were moderately busy. One sub was ordered as a stinger and was labeled as such upon pickup. When I unwrapped the sub I realized they had not put in the chicken fingers. The steak portion was still tasty, I just ate the sub and did not contact the establishment. Within the last six months we had another issue with barbecue wings which were burned beyond being edible. I think they need to improve their quality control. read more

Nino's Pizzeria - Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Call and stated I was ordering the daily special for $26.99 to the person taking my order. They took my order and when I got to the restaurant I was charge $30, claiming that was the price even though the official Nino website citing $26.99. No restitution were made even though that was false advertising. I will not be coming back. Ninos should take responsibility for errors on their website Or the employee should have informed me of the additional cost. read more

I ordered 2 large pizzas from this place for the first time time. Friendly on the phone, lots of good manners. Unfortunately my order was not put in as I showed up.. BUT! The way it was handled was phenomenal! The young man at the counter not only was respectful but polite and did everything in his power to make my order right. Unfortunately they only had made one of my pizzas but he immediately made it right. He took full responsibility like a true gentleman. The pizza was amazing by the way and it was made well. Respect and professionalism goes a long way and this young man nailed it. I understand mistakes happen but it was handled perfectly. I will be a regular for sure! read more

Nino's is one of my favorite pizzerias in WNY. While their pizza is solid, it's not the shining star of their menu. Their subs are where it's at! They also happen to have some of the best homemade blue cheese in Buffalo. You won't find much blue cheese better than theirs. Recently had a simple ham sub with a side of fries. While it's hard to mess up a sub like that, it's also equally as difficult to perfect it. But Nino's managed to get the job done! Perfect balance of each topping and the sub roll was toasted just how I like it. The fries were pretty standard, too. Their prices can be hit or miss. Their chicken finger dinners are much more than I'd feel comfortable paying. But the subs and pizza aren't priced too outrageously! If you're looking for a solid option for pizza, subs, and the best blue cheese you've ever had in the Southtowns, look no further than Nino's. read more

Nino's Pizzeria - Ham sub - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

After many years of enjoying Nino's pizza, the best ! I was very disappointed with my last two. The very last one is "for the books". The pizza was not baked through. It was actually wet beneath. we had to use a plate, it was too soggy to hold. . They didn't bother to cut it. There was an attempt to cut which left a four inch mark. The green peppers were CHUNKS spread more to one side. If this was my first experience. I wouldn't go back. I'm afraid to order a sheet pizza as we often do before a game hoping it will be as good as always. I'll give them one more chance. If it's as bad as the last one. I'm never coming back. They will have lost a customer and my recommendations. read more

Food was absolutely terrible! What was worse was walking in and having to wait to pay and pick up my food because the employees were either on their phone or standing around talking. It even looked like a couple employees were verbally arguing. So unprofessional. Will never return. Get it together management. Control your staff. read more

Hands down the best Pizza in WNY. Delicious thick crust, just the right amount of sauce and covered in lots of cheese!! It's the only place that we don't have to order double cheese to be satisfied with the amount of cheese on our pizza. They use slices instead of shredded and wow that makes all the difference! The inside area has tons of seating, I've never had bad service there and they have never messed up an order. read more

Wife still raves about our trip back home n to ninos. She says top pizza ever waitress was a nice girl and sub was ok.

Just paid over $19 for a Royal sub!!!! Last time I will order from this place again. Food is decent not great. Even Superior establishments like Imperial are $4 cheaper than what i paid tonight. Never again Nino's overpriced away a customer for good. CYA... read more

Pizza is great and the bleu cheese is amazing! They have a homemade bleu cheese and it's a must have with pizza and wings. On today's visit, I grabbed 2 slices to go with a side of bleu cheese and it did not disappoint. It's nice and convenient for when you're in the area. read more

Nino's Pizzeria - 2 slices and bleu cheese - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Ordered a large cheese pizza "slightly well done". Ordered at 5:00 ask for it to be ready at 6:00, no problem. Got there at 6:00 Pizza still wasn't ready. Finally took the pizza and went out to my car opened up the box and all the crust was burnt, took it back in showed the guy he said there's nothing I can do, you said well done and told me to have a nice day. Slightly well done means dark on top so the cheese doesn't slide off. Won't be coming back here. read more

Nino's Pizzeria - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

The pizzza was REALLY good I was SOOO impressed it tasted so good the pizza tasted fresh and it was warm temperatures. The service is ok they were pretty ok they weren't mean or anything. The ambiance was cute it was a small pizzeria which is just so cute. Over all I recommend going here for some good pizza! read more

If they sold environmentally friendly pizza, they'd be Greeno's. If they were owned by musician Brian, they'd be Eno's. And if they hosted bingo night, they'd be Keno's. What to get: A Slice! What not to get: Sluice! Go to a timber shop for that. If you're wondering whether God himself or herself (hi Ari) knows about this pizza, don't worry - Heknows/Sheknows. If Jay eats one too many of these slices (and he probably did), it's Leno's. And if it was located in Manila, it'd be Philippino's. Pretty spectacular pizza place in South Buffalo but there is just so much incredible competition when it comes to pizzerias in Buffalo that it's hard to imagine a pizzeria around here not being good, and if one wasn't good then it probably wouldn't really make the grade, because there are just so many amazing options such as Imperial Pizza and Bella Pizza and those are just within a mile of this place. If they gave away free pizza, they'd be Fee? No's. If they had no restroom, they'd be Pee? No's. But they have one, so that's good. And if they were in Northern Nevada, they'd be Reno's. And they'd have the biggest little slices in the world. I love the slices here - they're generous and tasty and warm and juicy and pretty much perfect. It's not one of my top 20 in the city but then there's a ton of competition. I definitely like it enough to come back, and I already have once since I took these pix. Buffalo pizza is thick and carpety, tomatoey and cheesy, hot and gooey, with pepperonis upturned holding pools of grease. Some hate it, but like Detroit pizza, it's otherworldly, and as yummy as it is unhealthy. Come and try some when you are in town. It makes Beef On Weck taste like a Week Of Work. And if their Pizza contained cancer drugs, they'd be Chemo's. Although if you eat too much pizza too often it definitely increases your risk of needing Chemo's. read more

See all

Nino's has never been my favorite pizza spot. With everything going on, I am trying so hard to support local so, I decided to try them again. $1.75 for banana peppers on my sub, there were maybe six or seven crushed up pieces. $19 for a pizza that was burned to s!$t on the bottom. The wings were never fantastic but $22 for some pigeon wings.. I understand the current circumstances- but increasing the costs for less than sub par food is what puts a business under. I hope they can do better, they're not bad but these costs are insane. :) read more

See all

The worst!!! super slow, ordered a slice to go. opened it up when I got home to a slice of pizza with half the cheese missing. the only reason I ever go there is because it's close. read more

Been living in west Seneca for 25 years and used to love Ninos Pizza. Now they over priced themselves out of this customer. I ordered two Subs. A sausage and greens with hot peppers and a steak and cheese with hot peppers. Two orders of curly fries and two small drinks. This cost me $48! Food came to the table and the girl said waiting on fries. I said no problem. We finished our two subs and no fries showed up. We took the bill up to the register and told him we never got our fries. Granted the subs come with fries we never got those either we wanted our money back and it took three people to get our money back for the fries. Never again will I go back to Nino's it's not the same as it used to be. Food was subpar service was horrible and for $50 I'll go to a nice restaurant. read more

Just paid $15.21 for 1/2 of a Royal sub. The roll on top was black, burned to a crisp, and the bottom of the roll was soaking wet, like it had literally been dunked in water. I didn't want the salami on it, so I was supposed to get a 50-cent credit on my card, which I did NOT!!! Nino's used to be the best around, not anymore! For $15.21 you'd think you'd be getting a great sandwich, NOT!! The worst sandwich for my money ever! read more

Great place to eat and delicious foods. But the menu "everyday specials" prices advertised here no longer apply. Large pizza and 10 wings is almost $50. They need to update their info, so you know what you're getting into before you order. read more

A childhood favorite! Thinking back to a free slice on Halloween in the 1980's and amazing after a party food in high school 1990's and family life every month or so in between ! Friends reunions when they come back to buffalo Nino's is it ! The pizza ! The blue cheese and the fingers !! Never a bad meal and never bad service ! This place hits all the buttons ! Great family friendly ambiance amazing food !! I love it there and it's part of the tapestry of my life! read more

Ninos has been offering really great pizza, wings, subs, etc. for decades. Reliable place...very unique bbq sauce

Delicious subs!!!!! in my opinion, the best around. My favorite is the Italian sausage sub. However, the meatball subs are delicious. Honestly, everything is delicious there. read more

I had pizza from Nino's yesterday. This and Blasdell were my favorite pizzerias 40 years ago since they both had a similar flavor. Unfortunately both places changed their recipes. It's still a good Buffalo pizza but not what it once was. Something is different with the flavor. I still recommend this place since their pizza will hold it's own against anyone's. Just not the flavor I remember. read more

Did you know if you want to dine in and get fountain water out of their soda machine it's $3.70? Now you know. The pizza was fine but the place is looking run down. I remember why I live 2 miles from Nino's, eat pizza once a week but went 10 years between visits. See ya in 2033. read more

Nino's has the typical thickish crust found in most pizza in Buffalo - hard to find a good thin crust pizza anywhere. However, Nino's does not pile on the cheese excessively as so many places tend to do. The ratio of cheeses to crust is about, so this pizza does not overwhelm you with the cheese. So I recommend giving this place a try. And the pizza tasted very good also. read more

I stopped by today for the first time and grabbed a slice of pizza, it will most likely be my last time here as I paid $3.80 for what looks like the smallest slice ever sold. read more

Nino's Pizzeria - I paid almost $4 for what may be the smallest slice of pizza ever. - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

I used to love Nino's but they have really gone downhill.Prices went up dramatically and when you order slices they make them really small.I'm taking my business to Imperial!!! read more

Good joint for some pizza and wings. The pepperoni pizza and sausage pizza are quite good, though I feel they could be more generous with the pepperoni and sausage. Some pieces only had a few on them. The medium wings are good and they have an excellent blue cheese with them. Good size dining room for eat in. read more

I picked up food from here for my coworkers and I at noon yesterday. (A coworker wanted to treat us for the holiday.) They have their own parking lot. I think you can sit in here but it's currently takeout only because of the COVID-19 pandemic. There is signage about the pandemic and they prefer it if you enter if the front door and exit through the side door. It wasn't very busy. I ordered half of a meatball sub and an order of garlic bread with mozzarella cheese. Both items were great. My coworkers enjoyed their food too. I've gotten takeout from here probably four other times over the years. The breadsticks are great. You get an order of those, if you order a salad. Sometimes the lettuce in the salad is a bit wilted. Their prices are a bit high. I haven't had their pizza in a long time so I can't recall whether I liked that or not but mostly everything I've had has been good. The staff is really nice here. I'll continue to come here occasionally. read more

See all

We're back...after a two (2) year hiatus, the Family was back in the Buffalo area for a much needed vacation and another great Erie County Fair experience. And of course a pilgrimage (or three) to Nino's Pizzeria...could they duplicate the magic yet again? My kids talked about the wings they were going to eat in Buffalo all the way to NY on the trip from Texas. Nino's was mentioned a few times. Once we got in town we soon made our way to Nino's for a sheet pizza and bucket of wings (20 medium and 30 hot) and toss a jar of that magical blue cheese they make...heaven... Within 5 minutes mouths full of wings were mumbling things like 'amazing', 'awesome' and 'the best'... On our 11 day stay in Buffalo we had bought 2 sheet pizzas and 130 wings from Nino's...my youngest even smuggled some wings in the cooler for the start of the trip back to the Lonestar State, needless to say they didn't last long. See you again in two years Nino's, we'll miss and dream about you. Sniffle. Sniffle. read more