I called an audible to order from here on Super Bowl Sunday and I won the pregame for my Mom! I was welcomed with a smile by the friendly and pleasant young lady at the counter. I ordered take out but the atmosphere is cozy and welcoming with a few tables and a TV. I ordered a medium pizza with cheese, pepperoni, hot cherry peppers and a sesame crust and a single order of hot bbq chicken wings from the pit extra crispy, extra saucey and all flats. Simply put Just Pizza was Just Delicious! Highly recommended for game day or any day! read more

Just Pizza - Medium pizza with cheese, pepperoni, hot cherry peppers and a sesame crust - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

I'm Not really sure why people are rating this place so low. The pizza is solid, especially if you get it freshly made. Not always a fan of the pizza that sits in the turner all day so purchase that with caution- most times it's dried out. That's why I prefer ordering the pizza hot and fresh. Today's choice was the stuffed hot pepper pizza. Totally delicious but I rated 4/5 because I do wish it had more sausage. Flavor was amazing though. Their pizza is on the thinner side but I personally like it that way. Overall just pizza is clearing doing something right with the number of locations they have all over Buffalo. They offer so many different crust flavors, pizza toppings, sauce options, etc. I can't wait to try something new! read more

Just Pizza - Stuffed Hot Pepper pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

I typically don't order pizza on game days but this one was delicious! Nice and cheesy. Placed my order online and it was ready when I got there. Staff here is great. Very welcoming. read more

Just Pizza - Cheese and pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

The Holiday pizza with honey sesame crust is to die for!! Wings were cooked perfectly and the bleu cheese is delicious! read more

Shawn's Pizza Reviews REVIEW # 28 JUST PIZZA CENTER RD. WEST SENECA, NY SCORE 6.4 A whopping 11 locations all in WNY. I walked in and the cashier opens up the custom box and asked how it looked before I paid for it. Similar to a barber when they're done cutting your hair, I thought that was cool. But who would be rude enough to say "Remake it." Ok, on to the pie. I wasn't a huge fan. This pizza reminds me of what you would get from a Crosby's or 711. I would say slightly better than that though. The sauce had a good taste and the crust was nice & crispy. There's always a Just Pizza nearby, so give it a shot! read more

Just Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

I didn't try Just pizza until last year, this pizza is excellent and well worth the hefty price. This location is the best, you get friendly welcoming service with a smile. When you pick up your order they open up the box to make sure it is up to your expectations, I have never had a problem with the service or the quality of the food. I mentioned hefty price because everything has gone up since covid. The New York thin style crust that I always order it just excellent, I find myself eating more pizza slices, I usually order about once a month, convenient location and great service this place definitely has my vote read more

See all

Ordered a double wings. They gave me 1 tiny blue cheese 2 ounces of celery and 2 pieces of carrots. They should be ashamed of themselves read more

It feels weird typing this but Just Pizza seems like the underrated & forgotten pizzeria in the area. They have the best selection of specialty pizzas around. A standard cheese and pep is great. I love how you can get their amazing crust flavored too. Might I recommend garlic & hot pepper? Subs are solid. The seeded roll is a nice touch. read more

Boneless wings are terrible. Half of the wings in my order are literally the size of a quarter. And they forgot my sauce. The Tyson popcorn chicken in my freezer is larger than the "boneless wings" I purchased. Pizza is usually good though so I'll give a 3 star rating. read more

Nothing about this order will have me going back. Three items ordered: 1 the Hollywood pizza - which is like a meat lover's: undercooked and not very good taste to the toppings. 2. white pizza with mozzarella, broccoli and ricotta... it was the best of the three but just OK. Chicken fingers - you really can't mess these up and they were satisfactory ... all for $75. For that kind of money it better be spot on. It wasn't even close. I'm really starting to hate take out all together ... who wants like warm food EVER? When it was reasonable you would do it, know it's just not a value - I'll eat at the restaurant and get table service to a warm meal. Just Pizza was just disappointing. read more

I've been here a few times over the years. Their subs and pizzas are great. I once bought a cute heart-shaped pizza. I came here four days ago to get takeout for lunch. I bought fries for a coworker. They were fresh cut and made well. She really enjoyed them. I ordered a double order of wings for myself. I got 10 wings as bourbon whiskey barbecue and 10 as blackberry barbecue. The blackberry were a bit better. All of the wings had a lot of meat on them. I added a slice of pizza, which I was being cashed out. They had four different kinds in the warmer near the register so I bought a stinger one. It wasn't bad. They were the biggest wings I've ever seen. This place is a bit pricy but it definitely worth it. read more

See all

The food is usually amazing. Their subs and pizza are fantastic and I love that I can have the pizza cut into squares for my daughters, sooo much easier. We ordered pizza and subs tonight and the pizza was delicious, but the crust was burned badly. Not crispy, full on burned and inedible. I will definitely order from them again but I wish they paid more attention to their pizzas- their name should demonstrate that. read more

Just Pizza - a half eaten pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

If you're looking for a local pizza and wing place, Just Pizza is definitely it! Located in the West Seneca area, it has the vibe of the local pizza shop. We ordered Monday (they have a great deal: one large on topping pizza and 20 wings for $24!) and we have a 40 minute wait. Y'all, worth it. They do simple things well. The pepperoni pizza had perfectly cupped little pieces of meat, and honey bbq wings we fantastic. Admittedly, customer service doesn't seem to be a priority, but they are not offensive or rude so don't let that stop you! But definitely expect a bit of a wait. read more

It's amazing that I've lived in the area for so many years and this is my first experience with this pizzeria. I had a simple order - cheese sub. Ordered online and had it delivered. My daughter had a steak sub along with loaded fries. My order - as simple as it is - is frequently screwed up. Not this time. The ordering process was easy. The product was really good, as were the loaded fries. I can't speak for the steak sub however my daughter is not complaining. I'm glad that I discovered this place. Next up - the pizza. read more

Pizza, wings (extra crispy) and subs are all good. However, they need to spend a few pennies and get their menus and website pricing updated! Amount other things, they have raised their pizza price by $3 and still use old menus. I actually think they continue to have them printed with old pricing. I would image this is false advertising and the BBB should hold them accountable. For See my photos. read more

Just Pizza - False advertising - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

Food was so good, must try wings, and pizza cut in squares, not too mention, service was exceptional.

Really good gluten free, the regular not so much. I'm an admitted pizza snob who grew up in eastern upstate NY, and I know there's a Buffalo style pizza, but surely there's some better than this. I had their regular pizza and it was bland, blah, just...there just isn't anything there. Just not good. Not terrible, mind you. It wasn't gross. It was just very blah. I had more flavorful pizza at Wegmans two days ago, and it was better in every respect: crust, sauce, cheese, toppings, all of it was better. This was just not good. My wife said the gluten free was really good, so if that's what you need, go for it. But if you can eat regular pizza, life's too short to eat pizza like this. Find someplace better. read more

We live up the street from this Just Pizza. The pizza is always delicious. My family will order the Monday special which is a great deal. One large cheese plus one ingredient pizza plus 20 wings $25. Just crazy good. They even let you sub boneless wings. Husband states teriyaki wings are great. Staff is always pleasant. I always look at yelp reviews and health score on yelp before ordering. This place has excellent scores from ECHD. Always good to know you won't end up with food poisoning. This staff is well trained and friendly. Owner/Owners should be proud ! read more

Just Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

With all the Just Pizza locations in the area, I finally had to chance to give them a try yesterday. I had ordered some for a church event. We had a variety: plain cheese, pepperoni, Italian sausage, and mushroom for the regular pizzas. We also had two gluten-free pizzas: one cheese and one pepperoni. Overall I thought the pizzas were very good. The crust was a decent thickness, thinner than typically Buffalo pizza. If you prefer a thinner pizza, as I do, you will like this pizza. The pizza is not quite as thin as New York or New Haven style, but it is pretty good. Because the pizza is thin, you can eat more slices than you may expect, so plan accordingly. I had thought we had too much pizza, but there were only a few slices left at the end. I had no complaints about the pizza, and I enjoyed the slices I ate. I would give Just Pizza another try in the future. The gluten-free pizza went over well, although I did not try a slice for comparison. Delivery was one time, not bad for a Sunday at lunch time. Overall a good experience. read more

Gross Poor cooking skills had raw chicken fingers on my sub now I'm sick get in line if you want to be a real cook read more

Just Pizza - Someone wanna explain to me why my sub has raw chicken fingers on it? This is literally disgusting. - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

A wonderful service, from my first call to enquire about a large order for a party, great help in getting the most cost effective number of slices, all the way to the punctual delivery of ten delicious pizzas. So many of my friends asked me where they came from I hope you get some new customers! I'm definitely recommending to everyone. read more

Just ordered through DoorDash and while it took a little longer that was expected because the Bills Game was starting at 5 pm and I placed the order at 4:15. I ordered a single order of Blackberry BBQ wings and a 1/2 baked cheese sub with onions pickles and cucumbers, comes with lettuce and tomatoes. The wings were great! The blue cheese has no flavor, I believe you're stretching it too far, completely bland. The sub, while I asked for it baked wasn't even close to toasty at all and the sub oil was straight up oil, yuck, the cukes were 3 chunks not slices, I think they tossed the lettuce at it from across the room there was nothing on it, 1 pickle and A sad tomato I almost couldn't find. Busy or not have some quality control, glad I paid to have to doctor it up to make it taste like anything and toast the soggy roll myself. Good thing the wings were great along with fresh carrots and celery or the stars would be less. Haven't had their pizza but I'm Leary, if you can ruin a sandwich not sure about pizza. BUT THE WINGS ROCKED. read more

Just Pizza - Wings do not come in this container. Sorry ate a few... - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Some of the worse wings in wny . I do not recommend them at all . Why is this place called just pizza if they sale other food items ? That is a total mind freak . Pizza overpriced like the gas at the pump . You guys should rebrand as not only pizza but an assortment of low quality foods for an extensive price ! You guys do have the best celery and carrots in buffalo . I'll give you that ! Blue cheese sucks !!!! read more

This kid named Noah smelled but pizza was good. Loved it very fresh and it smelled great like cheese.

I don't know why I keep trying to go and give them a chance and every time I go I'm unhappy. This time I ordered pizza and wings, the wings were absolutely terrible. I ordered my wings extra crispy extra saucy and they were still soggy... And no I didn't drive far to get back home with them. I think the quality in general has been falling off but this location is definitely the worst one I've been to, it's just the one that's closest to home so I keep trying to give them the benefit of the doubt. No more tries, I'm done. I'm already mad I wasted $27 there last night. This is what I get for being too lazy to drive to Lackawanna and go to Bella. read more

Visiting some friends in Buffalo over the last weekend...while mulling over take-out dinner options one night...I said I wanted to get some real NY thin crust pizza. They said okay well you also have to try Buffalo Wings. I said I am not a fan of Buffalo Wings. They said you haven't tried ours here in Buffalo. I said I didn't know Buffalo have wings! Actually, NO I really didn't. I'm no Jessica. Brunette all the way here. But I did try the wings...which out here also come mixed with little mini drumsticks (seriously, are these specially-bred mini-chickens for this very purpose?) which I liked better...more meaty. I loved these wings!!! Our California version of Buffalo Wings are pretty sucky compared to the real deal over here in Buffalo. Lots of spicy wings...yummy bleu cheese dipping sauce. Dip, chew, dip, chew. That was mostly how it went. Their pizza is pretty fab too. They'll do thicker or thin crust. They have some CRAZY topping options...they advertise something like 75 varieties. We tried a few options that sounded good, but the plain ole cheese was the winner in my book. Ate more than a few slices of that one. They'll cut it regular triangle or square. Who thought of square? It's weird. Don't get square. Too bad we don't have a fab pizza and wings place here in SF Bay. Darn anorexic California mini-chickens. read more

I really enjoyed their pizza and french fries...decent prices and fast delivery. Would go back again!

Now I see both ends of the Chicago vs. New York pizza war. Being a born and raised Chicagoan (I'm talking city folks, not the burbs.) I've have always been biased towards New York style pizza. Simply because I really didn't try any before I paid a visit to NYC about a year and a half ago. Tried Patsy's and it was delicious. Now I've had a chance to try some other pizzas that New York has to offer at a small (but chain store) pizza joint called Just Pizza up in West Seneca. My girlfriend and I had a simple pepperoni thin crust pie. Good lord was it tasty! The crisp of the crust when you bite into it was simply out of control. They have different varieties of pies, I believe the next time I visit I'm going to try that Three Cheese Steak pizza. Game on Just Pizza, game......on. read more

Pretty decent pizza from here. We ordered in tonight, this location has a deal with a large pizza and 20 wings after 4pm on a Monday it's only 23$ , which I think is a steal. We have ordered from them before and they are kind of pricy for pizza and wings around this area. Wings are delicious with plenty of sauce options to choose from. read more

Ordered food online around 8:30 pm, they close at 10 pm . I received my order confirmation and when I went to pick it up they couldn't find it. The female working the counter said someone cancelled it because they weren't getting a lot of orders. The guys in the back didn't feel like working clearly , lazy approach to business. Must be Nice to make enough money to not care to work anymore for the night having an hour and a half still to go in your shift. read more

Worst pizza ever........I ordered a pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms and green olives, you couldn't see anything but olives, they skimped on the pepperoni and mushrooms. I love green olives but this was over kill and overpriced. read more

I eat A LOT of pizza over the course of a year. I eat Just Pizza once a year, Valentine's day. They cook up a heart shaped pizza my wife and I have grown rather fond of every February 14th. Other than that I could do without Just Pizza. It's Just Ok Pizza. In their favor, they do offer a variety of doughs and pizza wing varieties are vast as well. Our last order left us with the wrong order of wings that were also soggy and cold. Long story short, need pizza? JUST go somewhere else. It's Valentine's Day? JUST get a heart shaped pizza from here. read more

I ordered a cheeseburger sub and taco fries from the Center Rd location. I have to say that it was that blandest and worse thing I've eaten in quite awhile. I just moved into the neighborhood and thought I would try them out. I don't think I will try this again. read more

As far as local pizza places go, this is one of the most consistent and tastiest. There are so many varieties to try and each one of them has been great. My personal favorite is Laura's Old Fashioned pizza. It features a sweeter sauce, thick old fashioned pepperoni and caramelized onions. If you're in the area and craving some pizza, give them a try. read more

Just Pizza - Waiting for pizza man - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

We used to really like Just Pizza and ordered often from here. The quality (like a lot of places it seems) has gone down hill over the years. Today we placed an order $39 for a medium pizza and double order of wings, is WAY TOO much considering how low their quality has gotten. On top of that, tonight we were given the wrong pizza not once, but TWICE. They were nice enough to have the 2nd delivered (we picked up the 1st one) but when they brought another wrong pizza my bf who was beyond hungry and frustrated (it had been over an hour since ordering at this point) just took it. It wasn't bad... but HOW do you get the order wrong TWICE? There was nothing complicated, we didn't ask for anything specially done and it is a pizza that is on their regular menu! Maybe we'll try again because we used to really like the specialty puzzas but when you're paying for food you didn't order and not getting what you actually wanted it's really disappointing and not worthwhile. read more

Have to say nothing great about this place. The way you treat customers and staff are what keep people coming time and time again. And if you treat them like crap they won't come back in. Staff is rude when picking up and There are a million places in town to order pizza and this will no longer be one of them. read more

Called on Thursday 4/28/22 asking to do a preorder for a birthday party delivery. Was told by a young woman that it wasn't a big order and that I could just order it on the same day. Called today, Saturday 4/30/22 at 10:08am to place an order for delivery. Ordered two sheet pizzas, a bucket of wings and two gluten free pizzas to be delivered for a birthday party at 1pm. Confirmed everything over the phone, was told 1pm for delivery wouldn't be an issue. Paid the total bill and a $10 tip for delivery driver in advance. In total a $170 bill. 1pm comes along and no food. No biggie, it's lunch hour on a Saturday and figured they were busy. At 1:10pm, I called to see if everything was okay and/or if the driver was lost considering the location. Was told by a man over the phone that the original person (young woman) who took my order wrote it down as a carry out and that our order was still in the pizzeria. He stated he could get the pizza in a car immediately and drop it off. Figured that's okay, wasn't his mistake. Being just a 10min drive, I asked if it would be easier if I just picked it up myself. He stated no, because he would be leaving immediately. I said no problem and considered the issue rectified. Once again this is a 10min trip. 1:30pm comes along (20min after our phone call) and still no food. So I call again. They said they would call the driver and get back to me. I said okay no problem. Once again this was for a toddler's birthday party. At this point there's crying and parents are all upset and hungry. The last straw was calling at 1:37pm to ask if he was lost, and as soon as the man heard my voice on the phone he hung up. Every phone call was placed on speaker, my husband and other adults in the room were furious. My husband left and went into the pizzeria (at that time it was 1:50pm) for a full refund and to speak to a manager. To his surprise all of our food was still sitting there in the pizzeria. It was never on any delivery car in those last 40min like the person stated. He said the mans voice at the desk sounded like the person we had been speaking to over the phone for the last hour but the man denied it and denied hanging up on us. Instead of a full or partial refund, the most they claimed to be able to do was give us a $25 gift card, a gift certificate for a free pizza, and refunded us the $10 delivery tip. But that is not enough. We will never go there again, so the gift card and certificate was pointless. My husband didn't think it fixed anything, but when you have a 3 year old crying at her own birthday party because she's starving, at that point you just want to get the food and get out of there. Once the food was finally there, it was cold. We had to warm it up ourselves and even then it was disgusting. And the wings were incorrect (we ordered medium and hot, we received plain and medium). This was by far the worst customer service I've ever experienced. The most disrespectful thing in my opinion, is that I gave them the option for me to pick it up myself when I first called at 1:11pm. This could have been fixed from the first phone call. Such a disappointment. Now they have lost 30 customers considering everyone at that party used to go there, but after this mishap everyone is disgusted. read more

Eh. Not horrible but won't be my favorite either. Why, why whyyyyyyy does any self respecting pizza place cut a round pizza into squares? It does nothing but wreck the entire pizza! I now know you can request it to be cut traditionally into triangles but I certainly didn't realize that beforehand. Plus not to be a drama queen but I think that turned me off to this pizza to begin with. Anyway ordered a large with honey sesame crust--which was a nice change from the "plain" crust had everywhere else...I found the sauce to be on the bland side-possibly needing more oregano or spices in general....The chicken wings however were great! ( go figure!)...they are on the small side which meant they were actually crispy! Something that almost never happens anymore because most places now use those gigantic flabby wings....these wings had a very delicious flavor, and are now at the top of my chicken wing list. I would make sure to eat the leftover pizza quicker next time though, for some reason the crust became like concrete after being wrapped up in the fridge for a few days. read more

I love their NY style pizza, but I think it's disgraceful that they charge $19 for a c&p pizza that has 1/2 the crust as a regular pizza. I also ordered a grilled chicken Caesar salad that came with way more croutons than there was lettuce...not to mention a boatload of tomatoes! Tomatoes don't belong on a Caesar salad. I probably won't be ordering from here again....way too expensive for pizza. read more

absolutely disgusting inside!!! spiders crawling everyone and the employees do not wear mask which is pretty gross!! food was good just not the service read more