Bella Pizza has amazing food, always happy with their pizza whether it's a whole pie or a single slice. They never disappoint!

Bella has good pizza and subs. I also like their onion rings. Counter service is fast and friendly. There are many tables to serve a busy lunch crowd. Ambiance is typical pizza place for casual dining. read more

Service was quick when we ordered, we also ordered another time and the delivery driver was great. The pepperoni pizza is what we got both times and have been very satisfied! Never dinned in the restaurant, but carry out and delivery both were great. read more

The hours are ridiculous. Who closes at 9 on a Saturday ? The food isn't nearly as good as it used to be and the prices are just criminal.

Food was absolutely amazing! We are picky eaters and it did not disappoint. Everyone was super friendly too! It's probably the best pizza I've had in a very long time. Affordable too! We bought one of the family meals and added onion rings and a sub and it was still around $53 for a family of 6. We will be back! read more

Always great pizza and breadsticks. Food is ready and fresh when you order. Worth the trip to Boston!

Can't say enough about this place!! The pizza is tasty and consistent every time. We usually order it "well done" for a really nice finish on the bottom crust. Perfect! Keep it up, guys! read more

I often get pizza and wings from here and they're pretty consistent. This is takeout, mind you, but still. My inlaws live in Boston and when my husband and I come to visit, Bella is often called. I've never had an issue here. We just ordered here today and everything was yummy as per usual. I got a gluten free pizza as I unfortunately have an allergy. It's thin crust, but the sauce, cheese, and toppings are all on point. I got bacon and banana peppers as my toppings this tome and everything melyed just the way I like it. We also ordered medium and barbecue chicken wings for my family. Unfortunately, the bbq wings were too spicy for me, which is usually not the case. It's the only inconsistency I've ever noticed. However, the medium wings were flavorful and crispy...just how I like them! I suggest this pizza parlor the next time you're in Boston. It's food is good and the prices are reasonable. Plus, they're quick to get your order ready...what's not to like? read more

The pizza was absolutely delicious!! I just moved down here, after living downtown, and have been looking for the right spot. Looking forward to coming back soon. read more

This pizza is always cooked a perfection. The service there is great, always friendly and if you don't wanna go anywhere, you just wanna stay there and eat they have that too inside or out definitely heading back there for more pizza. read more

Order is never right foods on the poor side delivery takes forever one thing after another do not recommend at all, gave them various chances to correct... ordered a few times always the same read more

Really enjoyed the pizza here. It was thick and big and was all buffalo pizza style with the little grease pot pepperonis. Yum. Even had red pepper flakes and Parmesan cheese to sprinkle on the slice which is not always available at a pizza place. The folks next to us ordered fried dough with powdered sugar all over it. The lady compared it to a funnel cake at the Erie County Fair. Looked really good. The menu includes pizza, various wing flavors, subs and other stuff. It is clean including the bathroom and was priced just right. read more

Bella Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, New York

self proclaimed pizza snob from buffalo now living in nyc. this is hands down the best pizza in the southtowns - and the instagram account @sexyslices (dedicated to reviewing buffalo pies) would also agree. ignore the negative reviews here and order!!! if you are picky about your pizza (light sauce, well done, etc.) - just make that request when ordering and they will accommodate! the stuffed banana pepper pizza is out of this world - i order it without the red sauce (see photo). i've never introduced it to anyone who hasn't also fallen in love. seriously the best. i can't attest to delivery but have ordered takeout from here at least 100 times and have never had a bad experience or my order wrong. great customer service and the food is always hot and ready for pick up in a very timely manner - even on football sundays. read more

Bella Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Boston, New York

See all

My husband abs I LOVE Bella pizza. We have been busy and exhausted lately and decided to get Pizza abs actually have it delivered this time. We were told it would be about 45 minutes. We had paid over the phone to minimize contact based on the coronavirus pandemic. We were busy at home waiting for our pizza and realized it had been an hour and we don't have our pizza yet. So we called to find out if they were lost and what was going on and it turned out they left our pizza on the ground near the door 30 minutes ago. They said she knocked and left the pizza. So, the driver didnt like wait to see if someone came to get the pizza before we left... they didn't call our cell phone numbwr that was provided when we ordered... they didn't knock and wait to see us through the glass and then go away.. like many different options were available, but they just left the pizza on the ground. My husband was very upset and called back asking for a hot pizza and they said they just closed for the night, so they would just give us a credit and we could get a hot delivered pizza next time we wanted one. Okay. Still annoying, but it's fine. We warmed up our pizza. So we call back a week later looking to have the same exact pizza delivered. I explain that there should be a credit on the account and the person on the other line says no, we own an extra $5 for delivery. I was frustrated and said, that was not the case, the issue was with the delivery so that should have been included. They say okay and get our delivery out to us. Then the driver is in the driveway with our hot pizza and is refusing to give it to us until we settle up for the delivery fee. I could not believe it. Out pizza is sitting in this car getting cold and we are fighting over the same $5 I already had words about earlier. She called us and we protested the $5 and then she had to call the manager of the store. Ugh!! Eventually we got our pizza, but the fact that they were supposed to right a wrong this way was like this was frustrating. We've probably ordered Pizza 10 times since then and unfortunately have not wanted to order Bella because of the frustration. We've actually paid more money for more expensive pizza that we like less because of it. That's my story, I hope they can readjust some of their service policies especially in such a saturated mArket. read more

I'll sum it up for you, the food sucked, fam got sick from the pizza, rude staff. Boston Hills location.

So I ordered a Meatball Pizza for pick up. Was ready when promised. Cashed out and took it home. Upon opening the box found quite a dissapointment. Hardly any meat on this pie. See posted pic. Keep in mind the meat you see are not whole meatballs. Just sections of meatballs. Kids and I ate the pizza cuz we were starving and didn't feel like driving back there. Last time for me at Bella Boston read more

Bella Pizza - a pizza box on a table - Pizza Near Me - Boston, New York

See all

Eh, not what it used to be. Ordered a sickly looking pepperoni pizza, now we're all throwing up. Never again.

Last week I came into Bella's Pizza Boston to pick up my wife's pizza, and I was greeted terribly by one of your workers. I didn't get her name but she had choppy black curly hair, a nose piercing, and big eyelashes. When pulling out my credit card, she mumbled under her breath "slow old hag" and then ripped the card out of my hand. She didn't say anything else to me, other than handing me the food and scoffing. I understand she may have had a rough day but I felt very violated in the moment. read more

I love their pizza but unfortunately won't order anymore because Shawn from the Boston Bella is the absolute rudest. Who hangs up purposely on a customer?? Then when they call back has another worker laugh at them?? Or when a fish fry is delivered with no fish, makes them wait an hour and a half for it? There's too much more to write. I hope Dave Everhart knows that Shawn is losing him customers that ordered weekly or more faithfully for over 10 years. We spent a lot of money there. I guess that's why the parking lot is not full anymore. read more

While this location of Bella Pizza used to be one of our preferred options, at this point I couldn't be more disappointed. In a time where prices are high and food costs are high the least that can be provided is good customer service. When we called to place our food order the person on the other end of the phone was less then helpful. They where unresponsive after we placed the order for the first item and then continued to be silent on the phone. One of the subs was not correct and the food overall was lack luster compared to what it used to be. What happen to the Bella we used to know? read more

My friend recommended this place we decided to give it a try. We ordered a large pizza with 20 mild Buffalo chicken wings. I have to say the pizza just cooked perfectly right! Crispy on the edge and sauce deliciously yum.Wings cooked perfectly crispy outside.Inside of the wings are a bit over cooked. Not much taste inside of the meat though. For the pizza and wings I would say better than most of other restaurants.Highly recommend. Worth a drive friends. read more

Completely disappointed. I ordered a large cheese & pepperoni pizza with an additional mushrooms and anchovies on half. No mushrooms, a few anchovies on three slices. I called to alert them of the mistake. They did promise $10 off my next order, but the damage was already done...supper was ruined. $22 for this awful pizza. read more

Bella Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, New York

Ordered a sheet pizza and medium wings for a get together. It was ready on time and cooked perfectly. A little too saucy for my taste but our guests enjoyed it. read more

Can't put my disappointment into enough words. Tonight me and wife didn't feel like cooking dinner. We decided to order pizza. I called Bella's and ordered a sheet cheese and pepperoni. The pizza that they gave my family to eat was disgusting. Old, definitely not fresh out of your oven. I called to complain to the manager. He try's to tell me over the phone that the pizza he served my family is fresh... you know how many pizzas I ate in my life?? That is not fresh out of an oven. That pathetic that you would even server that to someone. Offer me a credited account?? No thank you. I will Gladly take my business else where read more

Absolutely disappointe. The pizza was gross and that's being polit. I ordered a sheet pizza at 5pm. Was there to pick it up by 5:25pm. Got home to a pizza that is at least 6 hours old. Barely room temperature you can tell it's been in the warmer all afternoon. disgusting.... read more

This is usually are go to spot because we're out in the Boston area . Seems to be extremely inconsistent lately . We asked for a pizza well done because normally their pizza is a little undercooked in my opinion . I had burnt pizza last night and chicken wings for 48$ . I understand chicken wings are extremely expensive lately , but I don't understand why a 1 topping large pizza is 25$ . I don't see the value in ordering from here anymore. I will be ordering from elsewhere for awhile . Maybe their short staffed or something. I'm pretty disappointed. I will probably be driving to the village of Hamburg for takeout . read more

New to the area and have been trying to support local businesses. We saw that the store closes at 9PM and called at 8:20 to order takeout. The phone rang three times and then a girl picked up the phone and said, "Sorry we're closed." And then immediately hung up. It was extraordinarily rude and poor customer service. I hope the owner reads this and gives that employee a refresher on how to answer a phone. Maybe she needs to find a different job if she can't comprehend basic customer service skills. I'm turned off and won't try again. read more

If you like your pizza way over sauced, soggy & literally RAW dough... this is your place. This was truly the worst pizza I ever had. I couldn't even eat the slice. For the money you pay here , you should get fully cooked pizzas. I'm so disappointed. Actually, we had a sheet from Bella's a few weeks ago & we thought pizza wasn't all that good, but this one today was down right gross!!!! read more

Bella Pizza - Pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Boston, New York

We haven't had pizza from them in a while and figured we would give it another try. We ordered a large Cheese and Pepperoni pizza for take out $16.30. Upon coming home and opening the box to our surprise- where's the pepperoni? Very disappointed, this is more like a $8 pizza I could buy at Walmart and re-heat. come on Bella you can do way better.. We should have went to Brunners. read more

Bella Pizza - PIzza with LITTLE Pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Boston, New York

Amazing pizza in the Boston Hills.. we've been back several times and haven't been disappointed ever!!!

This was our second visit here for breakfast. I couldn't decide between the homemade hash plate or the biscuits and gravy on the first visit and went with the biscuits which was a great choice. However, I've been thinking about the homemade hash all week and decided to pay a return visit today to try it. Once again I made a great choice. Now I'm anticipating the next visit when I sample the garbage plate. Service is friendly and efficient. This has become our go-to place for breakfast. read more

Bella Pizza - 1st visit. Reviewing our waitress Sheryl in action. So far so good - Pizza Near Me - Boston, New York

Visited last night 8/21/23 about 7:30 pm. BIG MISTAKE!! 2 of us Had a few slices of pizza and 2 drinks. $24.00 OUCH. Pizza was very well done. Cheese was burned, pepperoni was burned and the crust was dry and hard. Should have sent it back. Ate about half of a slice and threw the rest out. We ate on the patio which was our 2nd mistake. The perimeter of the patio was completely overgrown with at least 2 foot weeds. Probably hasn't been attended to all Summer. Not very inviting or welcoming. I called the manager, Mike, just to let him know, rather than flaming him on here, and unsurprisingly he had plenty of excuses. He even said he would pay me to come and pull the weeds. What a complete asshole! Looking at the place and ordering sub-standard food there, his attitude was not surprising. This is your manager? Needless to say, I'll never set foot into that place again. I wouldn't let this guy manage a paper route!! I had to give 1 star they won't allow NONE! NO STARS FOR THIS PLACE!! read more

LOVE Bella Pizza, the pizza deserves 5 stars! Boston location is the best, clean and comfortable. However, would it kill the girls working the counter to smile?!? Or better yet say thank you?? Customer service is extremely important in my book and these ladies were lacking...maybe they hated working together? Regardless ladies, smile back at your customers and tips would be left. read more

This place has gone down the tubes far as quality and consistency are concerned. The last order(actual last order) pizza was doughy and wings were rubbery even though we ordered extra crispy. When first opened was one of the best but new owners/management drove this place into the ground as far as we are concerned. We could walk there from our house but will go to Brunner's or drive into Hamburg before ever ordering from here again. Last order of large pie and double crappy wings ended up in the trash. Would not recommend to anyone! Multiple terrible food orders is why this is posted. read more

Pie crust is airy with a crispy outer...perfect for holding the generous toppings and the wings are to die for...Super fast carry out and reasonable price...Would like to see senior menu. read more

Just picked up my order of double wings, pizza, sub and bread sticks. The wings were supposed to come with a large blue cheese. I ordered two extra blue cheese, which I paid for. I received only the one blue cheese that comes with the wings. So disappointed as one blue cheese was not enough for six people! read more

Best cheeseburger subs we can find in the area! Order is always accurate and ready as promised.

I used to really like this place, but after my last few visits, I'm about to give it one last shot and move on to another pizza joint. Hot subs, to me, should have A toasted roll that might still be warm, not a roll that's soft and no where near warm. If I said- no tomatoes or lettuce, I'd hope not to get home and see that there's both. My husbands side of the chicken finger sub had one measly chicken finger. Sad for him- my side had just enough- but since I paid for the whole sub- I kinda wanted the whole thing to be good. The pizzas good, but they can't follow an order if their life depended on it. Update. Went back last night. Ordered wings extra crispy and hot. And an order of spinach bread. He wings were soggy- even though I got there before they were done- the spinach bread wasn't even ready- I had her take it off the bill. By the time that would have been ready the wings would be cold. I think I'm officially done with this place. :/ read more

Let me begin by stating, unequivocally, that pizza is my favorite food on planet Earth. My love for the pie borders on obsession. Whoops, my bad; The Pie. (Caps necessary for something as divine as pizza). For some glorious reason I can't explain, I have had an intense love affair with traditional pepperoni pizza since I was two. Can I get an Amen? All right, so having established that let me now offer my take on the food at Bella Pizza. In a nutshell, it's ALL good. By all, I mean the pizza, the wings, subs, and the numerous standard Italian dishes from spaghetti and meatballs to eggplant parmigiana. Since it's a pizzeria we are talking about, let me offer more specifics on their pies. For starters a pizza from Bella is your typical Buffalo pizza in terms of thickness. Think thicker than NYC but thinner than Chicago. The dough is fresh and cooked to just the right amount of doneness. In many years of ordering from Bella's, I have never once eaten a burned or raw crust. I realize sauce is a highly personal thing; some prefer sweet, others are into spicy. I like either option, and I tend to order accordion to my mood at the time. I can tell you Bella's sauce is tasty, and somewhere in the middle in terms of the sweet/spicy ratio. The toppings are generously provided, and yummy to boot. I'm not a huge fan of broccoli on pizza, but I do eat it from time to time when I'm trying to be more health conscious. Very often pizzerias will give you small, over cooked, mushy broccoli crowns. Not so at Bella's. If you are a fan of the "green pie," you simply MUST try a broccoli pizza from this place. As for my all-time favorite food, straight ol' pepperoni pizza, I can tell you it's simply heavenly here. The pepperoni is amply supplied, and it has a mouth-watering crispness and just the right amount of spice. Bella's offers both dine-in and take-out. Be advised, however, this is a very popular establishment. If you show up anywhere near the traditional dinner hour, you may have to wait before a seat opens up. But don't leave! Trust me, it will be worth the extra time. read more

I've been here a ton of times since they opened in Boston, and the Lackawanna one before that. The foods ALWAYS great, and if you have an issue, they make it right. I always get the pizza well done, and wings crispy, plus they have the best medium wings in Buffalo. The sauce just has good flavor to it. Also, get the breadsticks. I'm sure it's just their pizza dough cut into strips, but there's just something about them that make you wish you had ordered the 10 piece, and not just the 5 piece. The only issue i've ever had was when they forgot to split an order of wings into two sauces. They caught it before I did, and as I was calling them to just give them a heads up, in case it was the wrong order; the driver was knocking at my door with a new order of wings, and they said to keep both. read more