Moving to Angola, on closing day we picked up pizza from Maria's. We are used to Vin Louie in Hamburg. BOY HOWDY ! Large cheese and half pepperoni was perfectly baked with a not too sweet sauce and had a very fresh tasting crust. Even though they were very busy, the pie was ready to pick up at quoted time . So glad we tried it! 10/10 would recommend . read more

My wife called to order a pizza and recieved one of the RUDEST, UNPROFESSIONAL, ABRASIVE, and DISMISSIVE customer service experiences of her life. It made her so upset, we had to cancel our order worried the pizza would be spit on. Based on the quality of the employee, this was 100% a legitimate concern. All my wife did was ask for extra sauce on the pizza and was told "I don't have time for that", when she insisted, the kid said, "it tastes the same." The whole interaction was rude and disrespectful. Absolutely reprehensible and vile interaction. Low class. We live in WNY...there are PLENTY of options for amazing pizza. If you experience something like this it taints it forever. If you want to order pizza the way you like it and like having a good experience, GO ELSEWHERE. NOTE: The manager or owner, some kinder woman answered the phone when I called to cancel our order and she was very apologetic...But the experience was jarring and no corrective action was taken to make a wrong right. What Maria's needs is a close evaluation of how their employees are treating people. read more

Ordered C&P Pizza and Bucket of wings. Receipt also said same. Called because no Pepperoni. Girl said we did not order Pepperoni.Offered to make new . We Declined. All 8BC were smashed and opened all in bag. Started to eat wings...Raw and slimy. Called back and she was very nasty. Her statement was.."I offered a new pizza ,do you need anything else?" Yeah I do, a refund or credit. $80 in the garbage!!! Will never go back. 2/2 times order was wrong,or raw... read more

Don't serve dry wings...my sauce is nuked. Bit in to a wing and tasted the crunch of wing that's been sitting under the heat lamp most of the evening. Wack experience read more

Maria's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Angola, New York

We always have to stop in for a slice or two, or a whole pizza to take home for leftovers when we're in town. I used to live in Angola and it was a weekly staple in our house. read more

best pizza I have ever had. we get mush bacon and onions. Never had better sauce, service is fast. wish they delivered 12 miles away. but it is worth the trip to pick it up. read more

Great food and service, I would highly recommend. It was good before but It's better since they reopened.

Been eating at Maria's for well over 30 years and they have the most consistent great tasting pizza you will find. Highly recommend!

Pizza is good! One of the few places where you can pick up a slice or a whole pie. Consistent quality.

I've gone here time and time again, and i don't know why i keep returning. Older lady at the front counter- stop eating and drinking between customers. Try actually getting the costumers food out within 45 mins for once. Don't know if the lady on the ovens is the owner or not, but allowing such poor customer service during peak times is so outrageous. Phone will ring 6/7 times before anyone picks it up. Also- stop handing me parts of my order before it's all finished, i don't want cold food. highly suggest getting some new employees. read more

We ordered the sheet pan pizza and it was delicious. Also, the chicken wings were superb!

I really love there pizza but poor customer service the blonde women who takes the in store orders is rude always has an attitude and never smiles at anyone read more

This is hands down the best pizza going! The crust is thicker but that's what I prefer... crispy cup and char pepperoni! The perfect amount of cheese.. it covers the crust perfectly! I totally recommend! The staff is great! They are so hard working... this place is always busy! Lori and Jess have been here forever! They are great to see when you walk in! read more

The great town of Evans debate: Which pizza place is the best? Maria's is the kind of place you go to drown your sorrows in a Buffalo style slice and Blue Cheese. Tiny pepperoni are baked to a crisp, and turned into mini grease cups. If you have high cholesterol, avoid this at all costs...but dang, it tastes so good. You can grab 2 slices, a 20oz soda, and a side of blue cheese for under $7 at lunch. read more

Maria's Pizza - 2 slice lunch - Pizza Near Me - Angola, New York

My favorite pizza place ever! I have been coming here for a long time and the pizza is always so consistent and obviously delicious. I always choose to dine in because there's just something about pizza fresh out of the oven and also because it's so far away from my house I wouldn't have the patience to wait until I got home to eat it. I've tried the subs and most of the apps as well and have never had anything bad. read more

Maria's Pizza - Pizza with pepperoni / half sausage and onion - Pizza Near Me - Angola, New York

See all

Stick to the two slice special. This place isn't the prettiest inside or out, but the pizza and the special you can't beat! It was a bit more greasy than the other places around Buffalo, but tasty nonetheless and a classic of Angola. read more

The BEST pizza in Angola!!! There sause is sweet!!! Love there food!! The only place our family orders pizza from!! Thank you Maria's for the best pizza in town read more

This place has gotten to be the worst Pizza I have ever eaten. The Pizza Hut in Derby and the stuff you buy at Tops taste better than what Maria's is serving. Their pizza sauce is bland and tasteless. Their peperoni on the pepperoni pizza is non existent, and then add to that its burnt cups. I guess you can say the pepperoni pizza is Cheese with Pepperoni oil smothered on top of it. Also this was the only pizza I have ever eaten where there would be oil running down my arms when I eat it. Its super disgusting. I'm not sure why or how everyone is giving this place high ratings? Its probably because they haven't tasted anything better. Or let alone why are they so busy? From what I notice people don't like to drive places here. So I guess people settle for what they think is great pizza. Honestly go else where. I drive from Derby, NY to Imperial Pizza in South Buffalo if i want some damn good Pizza, and their reviews confirm that. read more

Went into the pizzeria with no expectations based on previous reviews. We had a group of 7 and were the only occupants of the dining area. Service was very good for our purposes as having the pizza and wings just set out on another table and allowing us to serve ourselves was what we wanted. Requests for any additional items ie: more blue cheese, additional napkins etc. were responded to quickly. So while maybe not a traditional dining out experience, it was good for a group of friends or family just wanting to hang out together. Food was good. Tables and chairs *anchored* so we could not all sit together but that was fine too as we just moved around sitting with one group and then with another. So overall a good place for the our purpose. read more

My friends who were staying in Angola wanted to get food at somewhere close, and this was what they decided on. Let me be clear: this place is a total dump. I wouldn't voluntarily dine in here again. It's hot, dirty, and oily. There are a few tables inside for eating at, but it is definitely lacking in atmosphere. The pizza on the other hand was pretty decent. The crust was chewy and cooked well, the cheese was decent, and the sauce wasn't as sickly sweet as I feared it would be. They also use the small style of pepperoni, in case that is useful to know. So yeah, for takeout or delivery, this place ain't bad. To eat in? Nope. read more

Still popular for the two-slice and a soda lunch deal for $5, but I've stopped eating here after getting sick. The pizza dough is, well, doughy and I do like that from time to time, but after the past couple of years the pizza has gotten waaaaaay to greasy. I mean it's terribly greasy. Wings are average and the subs are not bad at all. I've ordered a number of both hot and cold subs and the only dud was the veal parm. That was flat-out terrible. Food joints are limited right in Angola so that has a lot to do with why people still go here. Tredo's opened up in the last year - I wonder if they are taking any business away from Maria's. Go if you must, but there are better options for pizza in the area if that's what you are after. read more

The pizza is just OK. the staff, however, is a gang of women forever complaining. terrible phone service, awfully late delivery and their suicide sauce is bland. Not a whole lot of options in Angola though. (Oh, and the place was FULL of flies... in OCTOBER) read more

I wish I could give a zero star review!!! On Friday, June 15th I called Marias at 11:30 am to order a large order for a pickup at 6:00 pm. The girl I spoke with on the phone repeated my order back to me, I double checked to confirm the order would be ready at 6:00 pm. When my husband went to pick up the order, they didn't have it! There was no record of the order?!?! I had 25 people at my house waiting for pizza and wings! I called several times trying to speak with an owner or manager, and still have not been called back or gotten through to someone in charge. If you want your order made correctly or your order at all don't go to Maria's! read more

Great pizza as always! Definitely worth the stop! I grew up with this pizza and I always love going here! Nice people! The inside needs remodeling, but if you can get past that like I do it's amazing!!! The best deal is the 2 pizzas and a drink for about $5! Never judge a book by its cover! What you get is sometimes the best you can find! read more

I grew up in this area and now live in South Florida. This is still the best pizza I have ever had! They may need a deep cleaning and a slight remodeling, but you don't go there for the look of the place! I cant wait until my next trip to Buffalo! I dream about this pizza! I have not been here in years! I hope that the pizza has not fallen off. read more

Pizza is excellent but the interior looks like a dump, I'd advise that you order it to go if you want to enjoy it

The Pizza Was Really Good!!! The Crust Was Actual One Of The Best I've Had Outside Of My Family's 80 Year Old Recipe The Staff Was Nice Too read more

Have been ordering here for a long time, recently it's really fell off. Pizza is good but takes so long to get it that it's been cold when it got here (the last three times we ordered.) Today was 2hours, fries wilted, fingers cold as was the pizza... warning other folks who order when hungry. What ever you do DO NOT put the tip on ahead of delivery, apparently puts you on the pay no mind list. It's a shame because they used to be great. read more

My favorite pizza place. Whenever we are in town is a great excuse to get Marias, but driving 30 min would be way worth it! Always super satisfied with cheese and pepperoni with a side of blue cheese ! Consistant and reasonably priced. read more

This maybe the worst pizzeria I have even been to.its one of two pizza places in the area and I have just about nothing good to say about this place.god were to start most of the time when I would call nobody would answer that would he the first thing second pick up would take double the time they tell you for example they say 30 35 mins you wait 45 mins to pick your food up and you sit there for 30 more minutes waiting for your food this has happened more then once too.the service is horrible the girl who normally works the counter the dreadlocked girl with all the tats is probably the nastiest little girl I have ever had to deal with after waiting more then double the time for your food you would expect at the very least a sorry for the wait nope just a a dirty look as she throws your food down.oh also many times you go to order chicken wins and they just tell you we don't have any.what kind of pizza place is constantly out of chicken wings? The pizza is ok not great not bad, subs are gross. I have stopped calling them for food.if your in the area and want pizza call pats it's faster the place is actually clean unlike Maria's and the food is a lot better. I think the only reason this place is still open is the fact there's no option in the evens area for pizza.save your money and go anywhere else read more

This place I gave another chance to as it was one of my favorites, but lately the food SUCKS. My pizza when I picked up and got home had half cheese, other side was pretty bare, 10 mushrooms on if that and it was burnt. Called and complained but didn't seem to care. Ordered a taco mild today with sour cream, no salsa, came and it was hot, hamburger burnt, sour cream (think it was bad)and most of the taco was shell, what is happening to your restaurant?????? Will not be back, you lost a good customer. Did call and complained again. Sad because you guys were one of the best but not anymore, will be going to TREDOS instead. read more

There is no pizza in the world better than this pizza. The flavor pools of pepperoni, the perfect crust, the slightly sweet sauce. Any bad review of this pizza are just uncultured hipsters with no pizza class. read more

Good pizza if you like thick crust (although the crust was not cooked completely through). Very friendly service.

It's my Pizza Place, Best pizza in town. Yes, on occasion things get mixed up but they are so busy it's bound to happen. But 9 out 10 their 100% read more

yuk, i remember when they had great pizza. I have not been home in long time and i made the mistake of eating there. i can say next time i'm in derby i'll go to pasquale's read more

Found a piece of electrical tape in the crust!!! When we mentioned it to a member of our group, people began mentioning other things they found in their food from this specific location... bandaids, hair, etc! I'll never eat there again! Thoroughly disgusted! read more

Go-to place for pizza in the southtowns. I doubt you'll find better than this. The inside of the building is a bit unsightly, though. Worth it for the pizza. read more

This has always been my favorite pizza place. I currently live in PA but always order when I'm back in town!

Chicken finger pizza is good. Cheese & pep is decent but greasy. Service is a complete disaster. On a consistent basis, I call ahead, arrive to pick up my order 45 minutes later, then the workers scramble around for a few minutes trying to figure out where my order is. Then I'm almost always told that I'm too early and I need to wait another 30+ minutes (for a single large pizza). On multiple other occasions, nobody on staff had any recollection of even taking my order. Then, while I'm waiting, I observe the same thing happening to the next five people who walk in to pick up their orders. If this happened every once in a while, I wouldn't be writing this review, but the fact that it happens every single time I order here is inexcusable. This is for a basic pizza... I can't imagine what happens to anyone who attempts a larger order. read more

The pizza and wings are good. I wish I never went to pick up our food. The restaurant isn't what I expected. Doesn't give me a good feeling. It needs updates and a deep cleaning. read more