Wanted to try out a new Pizza delivery spot! Came highly recommended, So, it was different must use slice app. I ordered the large cheese and pep Half with mushrooms and onions, extra sauce. I received a large cheese and one item mushroom? With onions and extra sauce. Very good hot, ooey, gooey, tasty, delivered early, excellent driver, very courteous, BUT! Not exactly what I ordered I will give them another shot because it was so good but the big money IS in the details. Pepperoni would've been good! read more

Ordered on Halloween night for the first time. Quoted 25-30 minutes and the pizza and wings were ready when I arrived. The service was amazing, they literally carried it to my car! Now to the food. Excellent sauce for the cheese and pepperoni, perfectly baked. Taco pizza was outstanding, plenty of meat! And the wings were crispy and the bbq on the pit would rate up there with La Nova. Will absolutely go back! read more

See all

Best pizza in Buffalo. Delivery is quick and easy. Always my go to. They deliver downtown, and it's always hot.

Imagine staring at a wall for hours. Your stomach growls. You stumble to the fridge and find nothing inside. You pull your phone out and nothings open at 1am. But all of a sudden you see Emergency Pizza pop up... the stars align and the hunger pains slowly fade away. Food was average, but perfect for a late night meal. Service was fine. Inside was a bit unsanitary. Overall, a pleasant experience. read more

Ordered a sheet pizza one very busy night at the hospital- it truly was a pizza emergency! It was hot and everything a pizza should be. Delivery was fast and seamless. read more

See all

Ordered dinner for the family. Got a shrimp dinner, fish dinner n a cheeseburger. Normally their food is very good especially their ribs. Tonight the cheeseburger was dripping w mayo. Absolutely disgusting. The fish dinner is so small, my husband was so disappointed at the size. Will not order fish unless its Friday anymore. Would normally give them a 4.5 out 5 stars but that burger was nothing to admire. read more

Emergency Pizza - Would u like a burger w ur mayo - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Ordered pizza online for delivery. Delivery person called me on my cell and said they were not able to bring pizza upstairs. They had to leave it at the front desk. Told her I was in my PJs and I would be right down. NO PIZZA at the desk Called the restaurant and the man that answered the phone asked the delivery person where they took it. I heard him tell her that it was farther down the street from the Hyatt. He kept telling me to go to the desk and get it. I told him that it was not here but I would check again then call him back. After calling the hotel desk where I AM staying the hotel person called around to the other hotels on road. It was left at the wrong hotel I called the restaurant back. The same rude man answered and he was insisting that I go to the hotel desk and get it. That it was there. Yes it was delivered but to the wrong address. No telling how many people opened up my food and possibly touched it. I asked him to make me another pizza and have it delivered to me at my correct location. Told me that he could/would not do that. That it was my fault because I didn't answer the phone. Welcome to the 21st century guy. Everything is logged and tracked but it was MY fault not theirs. He said he would send the delivery person to pick it up and then drop it off at the front desk of my hotel. Delivery person called again and said that they dropped off the food at the front desk. My COLD pizza was delivered to proper hotel. No plates or napkins as requested It a real shame because I spent $42 on 1 pizza, fees, tip and delivery that I was not going to eat and the restaurant would not even consider making any attempt to make good on the error. read more

Got pretty bad food poisoning from here and ended up in the emergency room. I was barely breathing and puking for 8 straight hours. I thought I was having a heart attack. Even if it was a one time thing I wouldn't risk it for below average pizza anyways. Avoid it read more

I recently had the opportunity to have my first pizza from Emergency Pizza. Great experience. Prompt, friendly service. The pizza was one of the best ones I've had in a long time. Tasty, prepared ideally. Crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings were all outstanding. Cost effective. I will be a repeat customer. read more

I've ordered from Emergency 20+ times in the past 3 months. Usually after 10pm and sometimes after 1am. I love that they are open later than any other pizza joint in the city. I always do take out, never delivery. Usually place my order thru the Slice app. With that being stated, I can honestly say, I do NOT understand the bad reviews on here. Maybe the owner is a little too authentic, old-school Italian for some, but I take that as a positive any day... This place has given me consistent and delicious food on every single order... there are not many Buffalo pizzerias I would say that about, let alone in the middle of the night. Excellent pizza, awesome chicken finger subs. Everything is great that I've tried. A+ from me, F*** the haters. Emergency is the spot. read more

The owner of this place may not be the most courteous person on the phone. However, the food is phenomenal. The portions are Grande. The menu is extensive the hours are late. And he does a lot for the Alcoholics Anonymous community. Supplying Pizza numerous times a week for a local Alcoholics Anonymous support group Which is phenomenal. And it's free. read more

Because one never knows when an emergency will strike, Emergency Pizza is here for us all. A mainstay in South Buffalo, a friend from the First Ward told me that, "When the bars close and you're really messed up, this is the place to be." A tiny hole in the wall on Seneca Street, I tried some wings and pizza as I was truly having a middle of the day capital E mergency and was not disappointed. The Emergency passed once I bit into the pizza with those lovely greasy little pepperoni cups that seem to be unique to Buffalo. Day or night Emergency Pizza is there for you. read more

Emergency Pizza - Forget urgent care...come here Instead. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

This supreme pizza really hit the spot at our hotel room after a long ride on our Can Am Spyder, on our return trip from Quebec, Canada to Des Moines, Iowa. My boyfriend and I agree it was the best pizza we have ever had, and the two of us have been all over the US from coast to coast and north to south! Our only regret is we couldn't eat it all and had no way to take it with us! Emergency Pizza rocks! read more

Emergency Pizza - a pizza in a box with a pizza cutter - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

The restaurant is very dirty. Pizza was Salty and terrible. I wouldn't recommend this pizza to anyone. I'm surprised they are still in business. I assume it's for the late hours. Pizza doesn't have to taste good for the drunks at 3 am. Don't do it. There's much better options with a cleaner staff and building close by. read more

Cute little place, great pizza, good service! Very quick turn around time, but no seating. Open late, so highly recommend!

Dear Yelp: Emergency pizza did not meet the implied expectation inherent of their name. We had an emergency. A pizza emergency. They were closed and we had to look elsewhere for a solution. Which was also unsatisfactory as it resulted in a $70 two pizza, 1 hour approach from a competitor. - Dr Chapman, PhD read more

One of the few spots left in my immediate vicinity in South Buffalo to try, I was pretty happy with how things turned out. First when I went to pick up the order it was $30.40 for their Large Pie and double order of wings special. Its a pretty average price, but I handed the guy $40 and he gave me a $10 back saying close enough. Not a big deal but it definitely had me start with a positive view of the place. It's nice to know they are not penny pinching, because who wants that with their restaurant. The pizza was good. Its a typical Buffalo style in terms of dough and cheese thickness. The sauce isn't to sweet like some places use. And pepperoni weren't to spicy which my kids sometimes complain about. I really liked the crust on this one too. The wings were not anything mind blowing, but were decent. I get half hot and half plain always and the hot were still good and crispy when I picked them up. Hate it when my wings get soggy, but these did not. All in all its not anything that different from many other places in my area, which is lucky to have a bunch of great places like this. read more

Emergency Pizza is nothing but a disgusting man's way of threatening and sexually assaulting a customer who trusted in their company through this scary time in our country I ordered dinner actually two steak Hoagies with extra cheese deluxe when is it came to my house it was absolutely awful there is no cheese I'm either a sandwich the hoagie with peppers was supposed to be only light sweet peppers with extra cheese when I called 2 correct the matter the owner literally got on the phone and told me he does not care what I put in my mouth or my family's that's our doing it when I asked why he was speaking to me like that he told me sure he'll replace the order making sure that there's extra cheese and extra special sauce on it I cannot believe what a disgrace of a person or business he is running please do not trust this company explicitly saying he does not give a care in the world about his product nor the quality or how it affects people this came directly from the owner himself being derogatory in sexual manner telling me he would put a special sauce just for me on there read more

Great food and nice people, never had a problem with this place until today when I walked in and saw about it 10 people working up front and making food without masks or gloves while handing over food. Very irresponsible during a worldwide pandemic. Please be better and protect yourselves and your costumers!!! read more

These guys are open the latest of any pizza place in Buffalo as far as I know. The food is always good. Nothing to special, but perfect late at night. The guys behind the counter are usually friendly and I've never been disappointed in a meal. Glad to have Emergency near by. read more

Emergency Pizza - a car with a smiley face painted on it - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Wow I call up for a delivery n ask for curly fries they give me stake fries then I call up n tell them why I got stake fries Brian tells me I'm not going through this right now n hangs up on me very rude pretty much tells me it doesn't matter what I ordered they give what they want I come there every other day n spend 40 dollars or more well they just lost our business n then calls me back to tell me I don't know what I'm talking about I tell him I'm gonna write a bad review n he tells me he doesn't care n then hangs up again on me the worst service I ever had read more

Food is ok. owner is rude. Staff needs to talk to people nicer. Prices are comparable

We called late and this was the only place open. The food was okay, but the person I spoke to on the phone was so very rude. Yelling at the person they were speaking to and calling him kid. Very rude and would not order from there again. read more

Great food, great owner, fast and friendly service. Open late which is nice working 2nd shift.

First time I tried honey mustard wings and they are GREAT!! Crispy and hot. Pizza had plenty of cheese and crisp dough. Cant wait to try other food! read more

Great food. excellent service.friendly staff.I was just there today.ordered a couple pies. They were busy so we had to wait 10 minutes. Not only did the guy carry the food to the car. He also gave us a couple 2 litres of pop for the wait. I also heard the owner is a veteran and gives free pizza to other veterans on the 4th of july and veterans day. read more

Ordered a sub from right down the street at midnight and was charged $25 for a $9 sub will not order from there anymore i flatly refuse to pay that amount for a sub when i could of called another place and only paid $10-15 read more

Emergency pizza is great...the food is great the people are always nice to me my order is always right and on time unlike wiseguys pizza which for me is the complete opposite. Our weekly order is the mini pack and once in a blue moon steak subs never had a problem there ...thanx emergency pizza for the great service read more

I've seen quite a couple online complaints about customer service at Emergency... and let me just say that's definitely not the experience I've had tonight. First off, hallelujah I have finally found a *local* late night pizza joint. Anyway, my brother, father, and I walked into the pizza place about 12:15AM. We probably ordered the food (a calzone and a slice) about five minutes later and were told twenty minute wait - no big deal. About 12:50, we still hadn't gotten our food and at this point we're obviously very restless (pacing, looking into the kitchen). However, we're trying to be patient because truly an extra ten minute wait time still isn't even close to terrible service - but by the way the staff reacted to our "inconvenience" when they noticed you'd think they had committed a crime! Seriously, after many profuse apologies, refunding us nearly our entire order amount, a free 2ltr pop, and an extra calzone(!!!!)(I guess there was a mishap in the kitchen so they let us keep it) and slice, we left there at probably 1AM completely blown away at their kindness. They went above and beyond. I kept asking if they were sure, I couldn't believe it! Okay, but the food. Calzone was HUGE. Slices were of good size, too. Good bang for your buck. Everything tasted decent. Wasn't a huge fan of the red sauce but I'm extremely picky about red sauce so keep that in mind. Bottom line is that I really have to give major props to the staff tonight. Beyond amazed by how my family was treated. I'll definitely be back to try more food. read more

Emergency Pizza will save you at hours nobody else can touch! Plus, today while exiting the door with my delicious fish dinner, a wind blew it right out of my hands. I cleaned up the mess that was all over the sidewalk and went back inside to get a second fish dinner. The guy working there said, " I saw the whole thing and I'm makin you another one". How cool is that? read more

This was the first time I ordered from Emergency Pizza. It was the only place open near me. Most late night pizza places are sub par. The pizza at emergency pizza impressed me enough to call them back to say thank you and let them know how much I enjoyed their food. I would absolutely recommend their pizza! read more

Best chicken finger pizza I've ever had. They offer a red sauce base or a blue cheese base. I prefer the red. They do not skimp on the chicken fingers. This place delivers late and the service is quick and pleasant as well. Definitely a must try for good late night pizza. read more

The food is awesome, but the employees who answer the phone to take your order are extremely rude. Almost want to stop doing business with them. 9 out of 10 times your made to feel as you ruined the person's life by ordering. The 3 stars is for the good only. read more

These jerks charged me $39.58 for 2 large cheese and pepperoni pizzas?!!! This place is a rip off. If you have ever worked with pizza dough and you let it sit out too long it forms a crusty layer on the outside. Then when you cook this dough you can tell by looking at the bottom. Its all hard and nasty. They are serving food that needs to be discarded and to charge me $20 a pie, these people are out of there minds. Emergency Pizza needs to be shut down and thats an emergency! I am disappointed and i am very easy to please! read more

I ate less than half of a single slice of the pie. The dough was raw and too thick even though I requested a thinner, thin crust. The toppings were raw on one half and the cheese burnt on the other. I called back and requested that they remake the pizza. I explained that I had ordered and requested a thin crust, NY style pizza. I explained that the toppings were raw and the cheese burned. They said they would remake it... Which I give them credit for, however, the remade pizza was far worse than the original. Again the cheese was burned and the dough raw. There was no change in the crust. Once again I contacted them to say I was disappointed. They hung up on me three different occasions and I had to block my number before they answered my call. When I finally got on the phone with them again, I was told that they didn't know how to make a thin crust pizza and would be returning my money (thanks), and sending me the pie they had just made even though it wasn't right. I did get my money back, but when the delivery driver returned, it was with cash only. Not that I wanted to eat a raw dough, burnt crust pizza anyway. Do you? Emergency pizza is right... Order only in case of extreme starvation. Even then, I would want to eat anything else. There is always a better choice than this, anywhere else. read more

Worst ever, pizza acceptable hot. Tried to order and rude lady said "say louder I can't hear you". So I said my order louder and she hung up on me also won't answer my number now since I asked for the manager. This is the 3rd time it happened and I'm a local Buffalonian . Boycott this rude pizzeria. Don't buy this mediocre at best cheaply made pizza. If u need pizza that bad i have Pasquale's recipe -davidbstrats88@aol.com- best pizza ever , and I will FaceTime to make sure it's right and you get the right right ingredients cheep to read more

Emergency pizza is one of two places, that you get a Steak Hoagie Pizza, in this area. For you steak hoagie lovers you have to try this pizza. I always order a large and can only finish 2 slices. I am a big eater too. I freeze the rest for 3 other lunches. I am not kidding and when I talk about food, my friends listen. They call me for wants. They tell me I am right on. Plus this is only one of three reviews I gave 5 stars to. Now if that ain't saying something nothing is. Great job guys. read more

Buyers BEWARE!!! My wife and I ordered a pizza after our daughter went to bed..it was late as usual but they treated us like a drunk order, the lady who delivered our pizza was dressed in a apron which she was making food with which isn't sanitary. And our total bill was $6 more then what the menu said. According to the "manager" they charge a $4 deliver char (which isn't stated anywhere on there menu or online) and after 11pm they charge a xtra 4% meal tax because it's just so hard to make a pizza after then!! The food is okay but don't order anything fried like mushrooms, motz sticks, or pizza logs by the time they actually make it to your house it's cold, it's a convienent place when everything else is closed but they're SCAMMERS they're making money off people with family's and late night jobs while ripping off drunk kids in the mean time!! Masters pizza accommodates everyone in the south buffalo area go to them emergency pizza is just a living proof of showing the decline in not only Seneca street but he reputation of good food in our small town. NOT for nothing but the manager there is incompetent and had no care about happy customers or there experience read more

Food is good. Delivery is fast. Employees act as though they hate their lives. If you pick up your order, be prepared for the giant Donald Trump banner on the building. It might make you lose your appetite. read more

First time I ordered a pizza with credit card and my account got hacked with 2 on-line transactions the next day.