We were craving authentic NY style pizza, but live in Cleveland so we researched places a few hours away and landed in Brooklyns Finest. A 3 hour drive and so worth it! I think we tried almost every flavor, but the standouts were the Buffalo Chicken - which I would never order but it was so incredibly good and the crust is perfection. The White Pizza with the ricotta was amazing, the Pepperoni was small and crisp and so tasty and the Margarita pizza had crushed tomatoes on it which was a first but so good. I think we got 10 slices, and ended up getting 2 more slices of the Buffalo Chicken to take home - yes we ate pizza for 3 days and so worth it lol. It heated up perfectly in the oven for 10 minutes and tasted just as good as it did at the restaurant. So worth 6 hours of driving. read more

Traditional NY Pizza, in all ways! In an assuming plaza, it has the nostalgic pizza place feel - with a Buffalo Bills twist. When you first enter, there is a phenomenal selection of specialty pies, and all are included in their two slice & soda special for $9. They offer both fountain sodas and a generous selection of refrigerated drink options also. Once you order, there is a back dining room with several different size tables, but all with Bills chairs, which is a neat trend we loved seeing in this area, despite being from Florida. The man who greeted us was kind helpful and I was impressed with the pizza options. We ordered: - Buffalo Chicken: had a really good flavor & was my favorite! - BBQ Chicken: my son loved it - Margerhita: also had a good flavor - Pickle: the best we've had by far - Beef Pattie: looks like a Jamaican one but isn't spicy and had a very strange almost veal or lamb taste. Overall the flavors of the pizzas were really very good, but unfortunately every slice was so overcooked and burnt that it quickly overtook the great flavor of each bite. Now, the thing is, everyone likes different kinds of pizza, and apparently Brooklyn style isn't necessarily our jam, but for something we really don't like (black crust), it was still very good and we would highly recommend it to people who like more cooked pizza. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Buffalo Chic, BBQ Chic, Margherita, Pickle & Beef Pattie - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Very pleased with the quality, price and taste of this pizza. It isn't like your typical Buffalo style pizza. I like that it is a different alternative to the local pizza restaurants. The owner is always very pleasant. read more

Brooklyn's finest pizza is an understatement. Their pizza is the best pizza I have ever had in my life. My boyfriend brings me here every Friday. We get mushroom pepperoni, onion, and pepper. read more

Lots of options for slices. They heat it up for you so that it's so hot and the crust is perfectly crunchy and crispy. Pizza was really good and I especially liked the crust. Enjoyed the seasoning they had on the table. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Cheese slice, crispy and delicious - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

We saw all the highly rated reviews here so we Postmated dinner. We were underwhelmed by all of the things we tried: Side of meatballs - 2 mass produced salisbury steak tasting, surely from a bag of frozen, filler ingredient filled bouncy textured balls in sauce w/cheese Lasagna pizza - good crust & plops of ricotta. But bland sauce & the meat chunks were more of the mass produced tasting, filler ingredient filled bouncy-textured stuff from a bag of frozen. Arancini parmesan - this had so much potential. Sadly it was yet more mass produced tasting, filler ingredient filled bouncy-textured bits & peas in the center of soggy rice balls, topped with sauce & cheese. Maybe I'm in the minority bc given the reviews, I guess people like that frozen fake meatball stuff. I just wish I had known prior to ordering bc I expected actual meat with no added texturized ingredient bounce. Packaging was secure & food arrived hot. So they got that going for them. read more

See all

Authentic NY-style pizza according to my husband (born and raised in New York)! We absolutely love it here. Our go-to order is cheese and pepperoni, plus the buffalo chicken rolls -- my personal favorite. Tonight we switched it up with BBQ chicken and garlic basil pizzas, and both were amazing! The owner always greets my husband by name since he's there so often picking up our orders, and the staff is always friendly and quick. The first time I went, the owner even gave me a free pizza because he thought he overcooked the first one -- but honestly, it was perfect! We haven't tried the pasta yet, but the pizza alone keeps us coming back. Highly recommend any of their pies! read more

The struggle is real for NYC pizza in the Buffalo area....this place is legit. Including fresh mozz. It's a bit of a drive from my hotel but stopped here during a work trip last month. The slices don't wilt either. I have tried w Buffalo style pizza...It's just not my jam. I grew up in CT w New Haven and New York styles...mixed in w Greek pizza. Brooklyn's finest will be my go to when I'm out here for work and I get the hankrin'. read more

Just moved to town and have quickly learned everyone has a strong option of best pizza spots. Brooklyn's is right down the street from us so we stopped in one evening. My husband & I both grabbed 2 slices and they were fantastic. Crust was perfect, not soggy in the middle, nice proportion of sauce and toppings. Staff was very nice. Will absolutely be back. read more

Went there for the 1st time yesterday on a recommendation. Had the X-large cheese pizza and 20 wing deal. Didn't try the wings but the pizza was amazing!!! read more

Holy crap this place was great and I never knew they existed! The Jamaican patty was awesome and the pizza and garlic knots even better. The staff were so friendly and welcoming and had a passion for their food. We tried the knots Buffalo chicken pizza slice and regular cheese pizza. My buddy also got the BBQ chicken pizza and really enjoyed it. Plenty of parking in the Plaza and tables to sit and eat in if you want to. This is Brooklyn and new York style pizza large thins slices and they were fantastic! Can't wait to come back again! read more

See all

Good price amazing ingredients, cannot beat the fresh daily made pizza along with fresh ingredients and good workers read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Best Sicilian pizza I ever did have !!!! - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Beef sausage? Where in hell have you ever heard of an Italian pizzeria New York style serving beef sausage on sausage pizza? So we left- again- and now we are on the third search to try to find pizza in Western New York today. read more

The quest for the Best NY style pizza in WNY is over. BROOKLYN'S FINEST is the winner. They beat Ferros (Josh Allen's pick and my own), also in West Seneca. Both feature the required thin crust, but BF's has a slight crisp which is something Brookyn pizzas particularly feature. They really got it on the sauce and their cheese seems a cut above. It's worth a longer drive. read more

Fellow pizza lover & critic who just realized I haven't reviewed my FAVORITE pizza spot in Buffalo...NY style pizza prepared by fellow East New Yorkers... thin, crunchy, as it should be.. with just the right amount of cheese. It's a family owned business with a location in Niagara Falls as well and when I tell you, these 2 are your go tos in the area, you won't find better pizza,wings, service or the feeling of a real NY pizza shop. (Hole in the wall with awesome food) it's the Brooklyn wayyy :] read more

I heard that the pizza was pretty good, but when I got their the help was super rude. I just walked out. Find a different pizza place there are around 25K in the Buffalo area. The owner was so rude I bet he can't help himself with a snarky response on Yelp. Let's see. read more

I was told about this place, he told me the NYC thing crust pizza was awesome. He was right. Just had a slice of mushroom and pepperoni It was excellent, the sauce was perfect, thin slice high quality pepperoni and dough lightly toasted enough for the crunch. Many, variety and even have Sicilian slices. Lots of cold pop. read more

I'll start off the review by noting that we paid $13.58 for 2 slices...damn near $7 a slice (kinda ridiculous to me) mainly because it was not filling at all and lacked flavor. My gf got the margherita slice, I got the bbq chicken slice. The place was clean and was well kept. But simply not worth the money unless you're getting a plain cheese whole pie with their coupon then..maybe. Service was good, straight to business but overall for NY style I would hit ferros or Gino and joes. Better quality, cheaper prices. read more

Former New Yorker, Buffalo transplant here. Ordered the grandma pie, half cheese, half pepp and it was as good as any square slice you'd get down in the City. Reheated on the pizza stone on 500 degrees for about 2 min and it came out perfect! Well deserved "well done" for some great pie. read more

It was set up just like a NYC pizza place. Multiple pies cooked and for sale by the slice. Thin crust, big circle pepperoni, and huge sized slices. The real bonus is not only does it look the part, IT TASTES THE PART! Everyone knows that smells and tastes are strongly tied to memories. The taste and smell brought me back to my days of getting pizza at the corner and Church Ave and Coney Island Ave. AUTHENTIC & DELICIOUS read more

See all

Pizza here is great if you're craving a taste of NYC! Lots of options for slices if you go inside. Perfect thin crust, not too tough but a nice crisp. Friendly employees. Has some booths to dine in if you'd like but nothing fancy. Great place for any pizza lover. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Bbq chicken slice - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

I am absolutely in love with the chicken fingers. They are so well made in every way possible. The pizza is outstanding as well. The employees definitely put pride in their work/cooking. I have now become addicted to the chicken fingers and pizza and refuse to go anywhere else.. Thank you guys for making such amazing food. read more

Their Steak & cheese sub is delicious. It is a true steak sanmich. It is different from other places. They do not put ltm on it. The Margherita pizza is the BOMB MUST TRY! Sweet sauce a little pizzazzz pepperoni & we get mushrooms on ours. I never try and add to much to the specialty pizza's because they are already done just right. Trust the CHEF's here they know what they are doing. The inside has the basic sit and go type set up nothing fancy but just what you need to have slice or two and drink for lunch. If you do not give this place a try you are missing out. read more

Overall really good thin crust pizza. Many of the other dishes are really great. Garlic knots are fantastic. Wings are good. I had the chicken French, but I found that a little bland and the garlic cheese bread was eh. People working there are great with good service. Overall a place I will frequent often. read more

I work just around the corner from here and am always game to try a new Pizza Place. I am a huge fan of Buffalo Style Pizza but NY Pizza also hits the spot ( basically I'm a huge Pizza Fan !!! :) ) Selection was good, Service was friendly enough. I tried the Pepperoni and Banana Pepper and also the BBQ Chicken. Pepperoni was tasty, BBQ Chicken didn't pop and was a touch on the bland side but I'd still stop by here again and try some of their other selection. Small seating area with tables and chairs for Dine in. Overall a solid addition to the WNY Pizza Scene. read more

If you're craving New York City pizza, this is a place to go. Amazing customer service amazing food highly recommend

I was born in Brooklyn, and I know GREAT PIZZA!! THIS PIZZA is Legit!! BEST OF THE BEST!! Buffalo is not known for their Pizza, but Brooklyn Finest! Puts them on the PIZZA MAP!! read more

Pizza is so good! just like NYC, and NJ, Way better than the pizza in Buffalo, service is great and the people are very nice and generous. I recommend this place to anyone who is looking for thin crust, New Jersey style pizza. read more

We ordered a stuffed steak pizza, not knowing what it was and we were pleasantly surprised. Delicious, cheese sandwich steak with thin sliced mushroom, and sweet green pepper mixed into a creamy cheese , thin filling. Delightful! Will be ordering it again soon! read more

I'm thrilled that I finally a pizza with phenomenal sauce and NYC style thin crust ... By far the best pizza in WNY. If you like the conveyer belt thick crust with Ketchup sauce don't bother stopping here. This place is legit. We also ordered Aracini Parmigiana and it was spectacular. Best sauce around and the rice balls were made like gramma would make them. Filled with peas beef and mozzarella. .... Incredible find I feel like I won lotto finding this place. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Aracini parmasian (Rice Balls) - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

Great service and great food! Ordering by the slice made it quick and we got to try a variety of flavors. Also got a salad that came with amazing garlic knot rolls. Tried the wings too and they were awesome. read more

We tried Brooklyn's finest pizza for the first time tonight as it is new to the area and we always like to give new places a shot! We got the cheese pizza and it was absolutely delicious! The dough was thin and had a nice crisp to it while the crust was fluffy inside with a really nice flavor. The amounts of cheese and sauce were perfectly balanced (which is actually a hard thing to find around here)! Both were also very tasty! I especially loved their tomato sauce, it was just a very lovely fresh tomato flavor without that harsh tinniness you sometimes get. And as good as the pizza was the rice ball parmigiana was the real star tonight! I love arancini so when I saw a "rice ball parmigiana" under appetizers I assumed that's what it was but it was quite different and in the greatest way! It was essentially all the flavors of an arancini but as a parmigiana meal. The depth of flavor in this dish was just absolutely spectacular and we devoured the whole thing! That is definitely going to become my regular here. I totally recommend stopping in for some great eats at this place! I hope they stick around! read more

See all

literally so flippin delicious. perfectly crisp bottom, has an amazing fold when folding and has tons of flavor. for sure a homemade sauce. super clean, and the staff was kind and super fast!!! sooo good. read more

born and raise jersey girl living full time in buffalo for 11 years now. my aunt told me about this place and now this is day number two of getting pizza for dinner !!!! THE BEST NYC/NJ PIZZA IVE EVER HAD IN MY LIFE !!!!! omfg. the crunky crispy bites. EVERY BITES WERE AMAZING. OMG. everyone neeeds to try them!!!! 100/10 read more

I've picked up here three times already. The pizza is thin NY style like I like and is delicious. Wings get home and they're still crispy like I like. Not sure how that happens because usually once you close the lid on the box they go soggy. Owners are a hard working family. Can't say enough good things about this new pizza shop. It's been fantastic three times in a row and I expect it to be great next time also. A great addition around here for pizza! Certainly my new go to. They're doing an awesome job with great tasty food. Sam actually called me after my last pick up to make sure the food was delicious. It sure as hell was and what a nice touch from an owner. read more

everyone that works here is so unbelievably friendly and the food is phenomenal. I've tried almost all of their pizzas and I have yet to find one I didn't like. Subs and wraps are great too. read more

Been waiting 17 years to get pizza in Buffalo that reminded me of pizza from NYC. This place is good, damn good. I'll be back again and again and again. Can't wait to try the other stuff on the menu. read more

The workers were pleasant and kind. The food was great! Inside was clean as well. I placed a schedule order, and it was prompt and right on time! read more

Great NY style pizza! Service is awesome! You can tell the owners take pride in their food! Welcome to WNY. read more

I ordered my 2nd pizza from here and it was just as delicious as the first! I am so happy to have REAL NYC style pizza here, FINALLY!!! Thank you! Everything was on point! read more