The five stars is for the pizza and sweet heat wings! YUMMY! This is a pickup location with a small parking lot. You can call in your order or use their app/order online. Their pizza's are not the typical round pie, they're rectangular, taste great, look delicious and never disappoint! You get a nice crispy crust, the center dough is not too doughy, nicely charred pepperoni, their sauce is not overly sweet and the cheese is perfection. I order my wings extra crispy, they're always great, my own gripe is the price. I think their pizza and wings are the most expensive in the area. read more

I decided not to cook for lunch and pizza sounded great. I usually get the same order but decided to switch it up today. I got a medium cheese and pepperoni pizza with an order of fries. I ordered delivery since I was in a bunch of meetings today and didn't have time to pick it up. First off, delivery was great and got here on time which was great. The box had these cool Buffalo Pizza stickers that I love. So cool! The food was great! It had been awhile since I had Picasso's so it was good to see the quality was still there since last time. The pizza was cooked perfectly. Next time I might get the thicker crust but still good! The fries were great. Crispy and salty to complete the meal. The food here is great and I think this is a pizza that should be in anyone's takeout rotation. We will definitely be back for more! read more

See all

The he food is always consistent and cooked to perfection. I truly appreciate the chef that makes their pizzas. They are always done to perfection and not a lot of grease. Well done. The service is just as good if not better. You are greeted when you walk in the door and you do not wait too long for your order. The ambiance is wicked cool. It reminds me of the hen I was a kid in 90s. The nostalgia is real. I love it. read more

See all

Yo be completely fair here, the pizza was really good. And my pickup order was ready in 25 min at 530 on a Friday. However, A large cheese and pepperoni is almost $40. That is just unacceptable. It may (at most) cost $7 to make a pizza. And that's generous. It's good, but not worth that imo. But I won't knock them down a review because it was my decision in the end to buy there. You can travel up broadway 10 min and get a large cheese and Pepperoni for $24 at Carbones or Townline pizza. These prices need to be adjusted. Plus the parking lot sucks. (Lancaster) read more

First time ordering front Picasso's and we actually loved it. Crust has great crunch with a good chew, nice sweet sauce and plenty of it with perfect amount of cup & char pepperoni. read more

Picasso's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Pizzas the bomb it's not like any other pizza in town. The staff was nice I wish they had indoor seating tho.

I thought this pizza was delicious and only wish that there was a location closer to me. We live in Newfane, but I'd go as far as Amherst to pick up my food from here. The staff was friendly. They don't offer indoor seating, which was the only downfall. They have a small outdoor section. read more

The pizza was amazing. I ordered delivery said it had a hour delivery time. Got here in 10 minutes. Very good service. I would give this place 1 million stars that I could pizza with a tad cold. read more

Picasso's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

I typically don't love pizza that has alot of Italian spices, but I was pleasantly surprised how much I loved this pizza. We did order double cheese as we always do so I couldn't tell you how much is on a normal one lol There were tons of toppings on it! They do not skimp on them and they use fresh mushrooms, not the crap in the cans! The sizes are a little strange. Their large is the size of a sheet pizza! No complaints here though because that just means I get to eat more leftovers! read more

Picasso's Pizza - So many toppings on this HUGE large pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

The reason for my medium rating is because we do like their food but it is extremely over priced, at least with certain items you are able to get something free like a salad or fries but those have gotten smaller over the years. I have to say I have heard their gluten free pizza is pretty good for being gluten free. read more

See all

Decided to try Picasso's in Lancaster while entertaining family in from out of town before Bills' playoff game. First of all, the delivery was GREAT! The driver walked through the snow to get to the front door (didn't realize we had a side entrance). He was punctual, friendly and engaging! We ordered 3 large pizzas and some giant fingers. The food was spectacular. We are kind of pizza snobs, but these were great. Cooked to perfection! Many in our party said they were the best fingers they've ever had. Too bad there isn't a location in downtown Buffalo! read more

We personally have to be in the mood for Picasso's. So today, we decided to get a medium pizza combo with 10 wings and a small salad. My paper menu is old, I get it. But I had major sticker shock when I picked it up. Almost $50?!?!?! I asked the kid on register is that the combo price? And he said yes....it took $1 off. I can go to LaBellas and have a sit down for that price! It will be awhile before we come back and no wings!!!! That's crazy. read more

I really hate to give this review because I come to this location usually twice a month for pizza because it's amazing. Yesterday was my birthday and everyone wanted wings. So I spent 40$ on wings on top of 40$ worth of pizza. I honestly have to say they were the worst wings I've ever had. They were soo dry no one could even chew the meat. I was truly disappointed and discussed. Had to throw them all in the garbage because they were literally un edible.. read more

So I ordered a chicken finger sub for a romantic dinner with my girlfriend to share. I'm not gonna lie money is pretty tight so I had to borrow 20 bucks from my mom and thought we could split it with some bbq chips (from walmart). At first everything was really good. Then i started to get the runs. And let me tell you baby- after the thunder comes the storm. My girlfriend had it worse and I almost broke up with her. It was so disgusting she is lucky I have no job, have acne, and am overweight cause when I get my shit together I am leaving!! I will never forget that!! Waste of 20 bucks Thank u Picasso. You ruined women. read more

Always a good pizza! They have great wings as well as subs with homemade bread! Really good food.

I think I just had my all-time favorite Buffalo food experience here. I've known for a decade Picasso's has my favorite Buffalo style pizza, and after doing some research on Reddit I realized they might have the best Chicken Finger Subs in Buffalo too. So I tried it out: extra hot, lettuce, tomato, onion, cheese, and blue cheese. It might have been the best Chicken Finger sub I've ever had. I also got a slice of pepperoni pizza and of course it was amazing. The peps and edges had a perfect amount of char, and no one does pizza seasoning better than Picasso's. Every time I come back to Buffalo I obviously have to get a CFS and some pizza, and even though this location is a little out of the way, I'm probably going to be heading here every Buffalo visit. read more

Picasso's has perfected pizza. The perfect balance of crust, sauce and cheese! The charred pepperoni is always my favorite. The service is always wonderful! Definitely recommend Picasso's! read more

Picasso's is my fave spot in Buffalo for pizza and wings- it's a sweeter sauce which I like and Buffalo style thick crust. You can grab a whole party pizza (pictured) or a lunch deal with a slice and drink. They also sprinkle Parmesan cheese on top which really seals the deal for me, like magical fairy dust that adds a flavorful explosion in your mouth. Tip: I also always order plain wings with sauce on the side and they end up being crispier. Sometimes however the pizza is a miss and can be doughy but still remains my fave pizza read more

Picasso's Pizza - Party pizza half cheese/half mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Just as awesome as the Lancaster location! Consistency is key and they definitely have it!

Food is always great, service always friendly. Only issue is parking but it works out.

I am a fan of Picassos pizza and others that taste similar like Santoras and Bocces. We ordered a sheet pizza with half pepperoni and the other half white. Both were delicious. Lots of tomato and onion on the white side and a good amount of pepperoni on there other. I'm excited to eat the leftovers tomorrow! read more

Picasso's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Very good pizza. The wings are a hit or miss. The last time I ordered wings. They were pretty dry with the bare minimum sauce. Their subs have always been good. read more

I love their pizza hands down the best in the area. I get it half baked to have for later. Large sheet. Cheese and Pep for the win. Consistent and really good. Never had a issue with staff, everyone was nice. read more

Just got pizza nothing but grease. To thin on one side other side you was Thicker. This pizzia sucked

ordered a chicken finger sub and it was soo greasy the paper was falling apart from all the grease. The sandwich was a mess i tried to eat it had a few bites , the chicken was super stringy with those weird hard parts. Was sick all the next day and not to mention the subs $20 threw the rest out. read more

Solid and consistent Buffalo style pizza spot. Mostly take out / delivery and this location is extremely busy. Recommend getting the pizza well done here or the crust can be too doughy and some of the pepperoni (they are generous) that's not exposed for the char will be undercooked. Watch yourself in the odd shaped parking lot - there's a slight hill and you have cars constantly coming in and out along with the busy delivery guys. read more

Picasso's Pizza - Party Pizza - Half Pepperoni Half Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Called for delivery this place is 7 miles from me mind you and will not deliver. Not only location that won't deliver pizza is great but apparently won't try to make a buck past 7 miles. I'd rather get food at a dive bar just for lack of hustle. read more

I'm always a fan of Picasso's, but I didn't know this location had a small eat-in area. It was great to stop in for lunch over the holidays and hang out with family and eat some comfort food. The lunch specials here are a steal - what they serve as one piece of pizza our entire table viewed as two slices so we definitely ordered too much. That being said - the pizza and chicken wings/fingers made great leftovers! There's a small tv in the area which was a bit loud, but that didn't affect our meal too much. Service was so fast and friendly, I'll always continue to order delivery for dinner, but now I know onsite lunch is an option maybe next time I'll stop in again! read more

Ordered food at 8:05 and was told it was be ready by 8:35, I arrived at 8:38 and they told me "the pizza would be ready in 10 minutes" after 15 minutes of waiting the pizza was FINALLY put in the oven. It was a bunch of kids working with no management to supervise. 0/10 - would not recommend read more

Why have spaghetti on the menu if you don't serve it? I ordered a spaghetti parm, and that's not what was delivered, it was penne pasta with a watery sauce. Upon calling the location to tell them I received the wrong order, I was told that is their spaghetti--UHMM, no it's not. I asked why I wasn't told they don't use spaghetti noodles when I placed the order, my answer........"oh well, that's what we use". $15.80 for watery sauce on penne noodles, that's outrageous. To top it off, there's a picture of very saucy spaghetti on their dinner menu page. read more

Picasso's pizza are my favorite. But this location really stinks. Chicken toppings were overdone and pizza was really chewy. This Picasso is nothing in comparison to other Picasso's. I am never going back to this location.. Picasso at West Seneca location is the best! read more

See all

Thanks to breaking the company safety record we got to order a ton of pizza from here last night and celebrate. The delivery driver was fast and friendly and loaded all the pizzas right inside for us. Since we did order take out I don't have much to say regarding the experience other then the actual pizza itself, but that's whats important anyways. When I opened the first box which was a chicken pizza, my mouth watered a little bit. The pizzas are made just right! The dough is thick, the chunks of chicken are quite large, and it had plenty of cheese on it. The same could be said about the pepperoni slice that I tried. Overall, this place definitely holds its own on being a great pizza place in Lancaster, I will definitely be ordering some more in the future! read more

Picasso's Pizza - Chicken Pizza, mmmmmm. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Is thee pizza great? yes, it's excellent Buffalo style pizza, the wings are great too. The main problem problem is when you look at the price. A cheese pep with +1 topping cost me $42! That is by far the most I have ever paid for a pie, save some money and get a comparable slice anywhere else in the area. read more

ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING!!! DONT ORDER FROM HERE! Pizza and wings were soaked in grease!!! Completely inedible! Asked for a refund and was told they don't refund. I dont want a credit to here because it was the worst pizza and wings. Horrible customer service as well. Manager was rude and short with me. Pizza also had barely any sauce on it and cheese was unevenly thrown on there. Tossed it all! Transit location is great this one is awful and staff is rude. read more

Picasso's Pizza - three fried chicken nuggies on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Ordered a chicken finger sub from this place and when I picked it up the grease was soaked through the wrapper and the sleeve. Opened it up and the roll was absolutely SOAKED with grease. I'm not exaggerating, inside and out like they dipped the whole sub in the fryer. I was starving so I ate it anyway (it was nasty) ended up with the worst heartburn and stomach ache of my life and had the shits all weekend and couldn't eat. Absolutely ruined my whole weekend and paid $20 to do it. F this place in the A. read more

Pizza is consistently made the same way whenever we order it and it's delicious! The owner is there almost every time I've been there, working amongst his employees. Employees are very friendly. It's my family's first choice for pizza. read more

Precovid, picassos was a favorite. Last year had several thin, terrible pizzas. Ok covid over, gave it another try and equally disappointed. Crust was thick the remainder so thin it was hard to pick up and toppings again were burnt steak bits on the stinger. Really wanted it to be good:( read more

Picasso's Pizza - Stinger pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Placed an order for dinner for the family. Was told 1 hour for delivery. Waited almost 2 hours and no delivery. Called to see where my order was...and they didn't even have it. Wasted two hours waiting for someone's mistake!!!​ read more

They messed up my order but IMMEDIATELY threw in another batch of fingers and an extra breadstick...SO KIND AND COURTEOUS and willing to make it right. EXTREMELY adorable young man working, great customer service, HIGHLY RECOMMEND. read more

I'm a fan of this pizza place! They have multiple choices and great options. We have ordered sheet pizza for groups and regular pizza with our favorite toppings. Picasso's is extremely consistent and I enjoy their crust. Price can be more expensive but otherwise it is a great option! read more