Cancel

Open app

Search

Muscarella's Pizzeria

4.1 (20 reviews)
Closed 1:00 pm - 8:30 PM
Updated 1 month ago

Order Muscarella's Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery

Muscarella's Pizzeria Photos

Business Info

MUSCARELLA'S PIZZERIA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Good for kids
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

More like Muscarella's Pizzeria

Recommended Reviews - Muscarella's Pizzeria

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Two slices for $9
Lauren S.

Small little place next door to the express Tops. Pizza is decent, it's not the best nor the worst in the area. If you like burnt (charbroiled) pepperoni, it might be a great place for you. Personally, I hate any of my food burnt. It's nearly $9 for two slices which is insane. I can get two slices for half that price at Pizza Heist down the road. Their cloves subs are pretty packed of meat though so those are with the high pricing. I don't like the hot sauce they use for the chicken finger subs though. Overall it's not a place that I would stop for a quick lunch but I do appreciate that they are on all of the regular delivery apps - UberEATS, GrubHub, etc.

Cheese and pepperoni
Shannon R.

My husband and I did a Lancaster/Depew pizza tasting review on YouTube a few years ago (we were bored and heck, we like pizza). We wish Muscarellas would've been in the area back then because now the review feels incomplete. I rate my pizzerias based on dough texture, cheese taste, sauce,- sweet or bitter, and pepperoni spiciness and style. The dough at Muscarellas has a great chew, good salt ratio, and crunch. The cheese is tasty, sauce has a sweeter vibe, and the pepperoni is cup-style and charred perfectly. I seriously love how the round pizza is cut in a square shape. I love the crust (dipped in pretty much anything), and this maximizes the crust to middle-piece ratio. We will return!

2 slices cheese and pepperoni. Not good

See all

3 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 7
Thanks 3
Love this 2
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

The last pizza we ordered was delicious! Good service. The antipasta salad is the best around and very cheap for what you get.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 1

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Charlie M.

Charlie M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Charlie M.

Charlie M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Dave S.
1
19
13

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Outstanding pizza and chicken tenders. Pizza was cooked perfectly! Very friendly staff as well!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Amazing pizza such a nice family that owns it good prices definitely will be going back a lot! My new fav spot

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Pizza was very good but kinda pricey.but will be ordering from there again. Highly recommend.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

The pizza was very good and service excellent. Can't wait to try their subs. A few more words. Lol

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Muscarella's Pizzeria

Review Highlights - Muscarella's Pizzeria

I feel their pizza is cooked better than Leo's.

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Off the Wall Sandwich - Costanzo breakfast sandwich

Off the Wall Sandwich

3.9(107 reviews)
10.2 mi
$$

A new location and a new look. Off The Wall Sandwich is a sparkling clean and colorful restaurant…read more With vibrant wall art, and striking lighting, the interior has an energetic vibe. This is a busy spot for classic American favorites: burgers, sandwiches and wings. From my previous experience, I knew it's worth checking the menu beforehand. For someone who is trying to make healthier choices, but not salad, this might be a good idea. I remember the last time I had the Classic Grilled Cheese Melt. This time, to avoid beef, bacon, or fried chicken, I decided to substitute a burger with grilled chicken breast for an additional $1. The Frenchie was my choice. I asked for the included Bison dip on the side and added Grilled Cremini Mushrooms for another $1. I simply couldn't find any ready-made combinations that suited my taste. All the burgers, melts and sandwiches come with your choice of fries or tater tots. We waited longer than expected for our food. The restaurant started filling up after we arrived. There were a lot of takeout orders while the dinner rush was starting. They should have a parallel system in the kitchen to keep the dining room moving at its own pace. Anyway, my sandwich was good. The chicken was perfectly grilled. The mushrooms and onions were flavorful, and the provolone cheese was melted and delicious. It's good that I asked to have the Bison dip on the side. We enjoyed the mountain of fries and onion rings (we really liked the breading on the onion rings). The Mac and Cheese was basic, but classic and very tasty. Unfortunately, our feedback on the Steak Hoagie was not so good. It wasn't as expected - a juicy, Buffalo-style, meat and cheese sub. My partner said that too much spice rub made the sandwich salty and dry. It wasn't the experience of dripping, shaved steak covered with lots of melted cheese, grilled peppers and onions. There was none of it. It was dry, smallish and disappointing. Our server Kimora took good care of us. She was smiling, and made our stay very pleasant.

This was my first visit here. I was really drawn in by the decor, it's got a cool vibe, especially…read moreif you like graffiti like I do. The staff were super nice, which always makes a difference. The food wasn't mind-blowing, but it was solid. I had the Nashville hot chicken sandwich, it was good, even if it's not the top contender for the best. The tater tots were a highlight, and I loved the habanero dipping sauce the server picked out for me. Would I go out of my way for it? Probably not. If I'm nearby, I'd absolutely stop in again to try something else on the menu, which has some great looking options.

Photos
Off the Wall Sandwich
Off the Wall Sandwich
Off the Wall Sandwich

See all

Chris' NY Sandwich Co - Cajun Chicken Salad Croissant, $12.95. :-) Big guy!

Chris' NY Sandwich Co

4.0(159 reviews)
10.1 miDowntown
$$

Chris's is still fantastic...the prices have increased, just like everywhere else. But this is one…read moreof those places where I feel ok paying a lot right now because the quality is there and the sandwiches are big. I'm not sure how long I'll feel that way though! :-) I try to get something different each time we go. This time I got the turkey jalapeno club. Along with the side of fries we shared, it was enough for two meals. It was really delicious!! They roast the turkey breast themselves and the jalapeno bread is out of this world. I would definitely get this again. Matt got the jalapeno cheeseburger, which had two thick beef patties side by side on the jalapeno bread...at $18.95 it was actually a pretty good deal. He's ordered this before and loves it. He especially likes the fried jalapenos they add. The fries are house made and delicious. One order is enough for two. We'll definitely be back!

Got take out for a work lunch. When first looking at the menu the prices were a little shocking,…read morebut when we got the food and saw the sizes it made sense. I had an assorted on sour dough. It was delicious and had plenty of meat. Coworker had the steak sandwich and was happy with it. Another had the fish taco and it was huge, more like a fish burrito and was even large to be considered a burrito.

Photos
Chris' NY Sandwich Co - We have been here over an hour.  Restaurant pretty much empty now.

We have been here over an hour. Restaurant pretty much empty now.

Chris' NY Sandwich Co - Steak Sandwich

Steak Sandwich

Chris' NY Sandwich Co - Jalapeno turkey club with a side order of house made fries. Big sandwich and enough fries for two. Sooo good!

See all

Jalapeno turkey club with a side order of house made fries. Big sandwich and enough fries for two. Sooo good!

The Deli - The Lucy - the homemade nduja spread was layered on thick and gave a nice kick to the sandwich. Proven - The Deli makes baseball better.

The Deli

4.9(69 reviews)
8.4 mi

A place where they know you by name and every sandwich is made fresh to order. The quality is truly…read moreuntouchable. I also love the specialty goods they carry in the store -- they make it easy to pair a sandwich run with a thoughtful gift (a gift card is always a win!). Stopped in on a Tuesday around 5 and ordered three sandwiches for my friends and me. I'm proud to say I'm just three sandwiches away from trying everything on the menu! My favorites so far are the muffaletta, the Young Turk, and the All-American. Highly recommend for a quick, delicious meal.

Amazing amazing! The food here is always fresh and I've never had a bad experience. Great variety…read moreof subs, chili, soup du jour, pizzas, and desserts. Great customer service and they will customize every sub or pizza the way you want. They use top line Boar's Head meats and freshly delivered sub rolls, homemade spreads and dressings. Homemade soups and chili are always so good. Can be pricey but you get what you pay for. Parking is ample and they have a few tables inside for seating with simple ambience and decor. There is a cooler with self-serve drinks and desserts. Meatball sub is so good (homemade meatballs of course), and the homemade olive spread on the muffaletta hits the spot, New Orleans style! Pizzas are fresh and tasty also with fresh made dough and ingredients. Call ahead so everything is ready when you get there!

Photos
The Deli - Not just a sandwich shop

Not just a sandwich shop

The Deli - I love that they always sneak in a Dum Dum

I love that they always sneak in a Dum Dum

The Deli - Valledolmo - I can't stop with their sandwiches

See all

Valledolmo - I can't stop with their sandwiches

Jessie’s Hidden Cafe & Eatery - Battered fish fry

Jessie’s Hidden Cafe & Eatery

4.7(3 reviews)
3.9 mi

I work at Appletree so I go here quite often and I have honestly never had a bad experience here…read more Everything is great from the food to the workers. They all seem to love working there and it shows. The restaurant itself is very cute and they often sell items from local vendors. You can't go wrong with any of the food. It can be a little pricey, but you get decent portions and I've never had anything bad there. A couple of my personal favorites: anything from the coffee area, their to go chicken salad box, tuna melt, amazing chicken fingers, and don't you dare leave without a s'mores cookie. Easily one of the best cookies I've ever had.

I just came back to an office in the business park a few weeks ago, after a 9 year hiatus…read more This little deli has changed names and owners since, but it's still set up the same- order over here, pay over there, and most things are made to order. I've been getting emails with specials from Jessie's, so I decided to stop in one day I didn't bring lunch. There was not much ready-to-eat food, so I grabbed a chicken salad with crasins from the cooler, which was pretty good on the go. Today I placed a mobile order for chicken cordon blue sandwich with fries, got a text when it was ready for pick up, about 20 minutes later. They use an app called Takeout Taxi that's similar to DoorDash, very convenient when you only have 30 minutes for lunch, but you can't order the specials on the app. You can call ahead too. It's nice to have a place inside the building to get good food.

Photos
Jessie’s Hidden Cafe & Eatery - Chicken cordon blue

Chicken cordon blue

Jessie’s Hidden Cafe & Eatery - Coffee area

See all

Coffee area

Dalfonso’s Italian Imports

Dalfonso’s Italian Imports

4.8(11 reviews)
10.2 miAllentown

The three of us enjoy this Italian food shop and cafe's neighborhood and also the Elmwood Village…read moreneighborhood when we visit Buffalo. This is a relatively new place on Allen Street. Two of us ordered a different pasta dish and they were great. One of us ordered a sandwich and it was phenomenal. Excellent cannoli and espresso. We told the staff we were visiting from across the river in Canada, which we do four or five times a year, and they were very friendly to us. Lots of products from Italy to buy, and we bought some dried pasta, extra virgin olive oil, and balsamic vinegar. A great choice for a delicious lunch. The decor is very cool.

An exceptional place with high quality options available. You can eat it in or take home. Plus…read morescores of products from Italy for sale, like olive oil, pasta, balsamic vinegar, canned Italian tuna fish, canned DOP tomatoes, cookies, fig and berry jams, etc. My fresh pasta was amazing. My friend's House Sandwich was huge and filled with salami, arugula, roasted red peppers, and house-made mozzarella. Another friend's fried mortadella sandwich was incredible. And the fourth person in our party had a huge bowl of delicious ham and bean soup made in-house. We all had excellent espresso and superb cannoli. I have to mention the beautiful decor, which is very Italian islands. The place is a real treasure. Friendly staff, too. Dalfonso's is at 162 Allen Street in Buffalo, N. Y.

Photos
Dalfonso’s Italian Imports - Items to purchase

Items to purchase

Dalfonso’s Italian Imports
Dalfonso’s Italian Imports - Dalfonso's Italian Imports. 162 Allen Street, Buffalo, New York.

See all

Dalfonso's Italian Imports. 162 Allen Street, Buffalo, New York.

Muscarella's Pizzeria - chicken_wings - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...