5 star service and ambiance! Went this afternoon for lunch .... Everything on the menu is homemade . Like an Italian style deli . My chicken parm sandwich was delicious and flavorful . Everyone else at the table liked their food as well . I would like to see a specials menu as their actual menu is pretty limited . Overall, this is a great addition to East Aurora for a nice meal ! read more

See all

Friendly service in a small comfortable setting. The flat bread and my sandwich was delicious!

We had a great time at Marta's. After hearing positive things about them, we made a point of stopping there when in town. They did an amazing job refurbishing the building with an old world European feel. The staff was extremely friendly and welcoming and helped us to choose our lunch picks. We tried a bowl of their in-house chicken noodle and the soup of the day, zucchini. Both were fantastic, but we both agreed that the zucchini soup was the winner there. We split one of their Caesar salads and the Trinity sandwich. We enjoyed them both and had enough left over for lunch the next day. They also have a nice selections of beer and ciders on tap! There were a lot of more items on the menu we are excited to try when we go back. read more

See all

This place does not have off street parking so leave time to find a spot but once you are inside the ambience will be all worth it. The walls are moody and have many interesting items to look at, items for sale, and menus to read. Many of the sandwiches have a pistachio sauce that is amazing and the meats are sliced super thin. It's truly an amazing combo. The salad croutons were just so fresh and we also got a flatbread not pictured that was quite good. read more

Marta's Market - Ceasar salad and some sparkling wine - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - East Aurora, New York

See all

We are always looking for new places to try and after consulting Yelp and looking for local places that we would pass by on our drive home we settled on Marta's. If you blink, you'll drive right by it but I'm glad we didn't. Be aware there's no parking lot so you need to find a place on the street, which was no problem at all because it is just outside the main drag of downtown East Aurora, but still on Main Street. It is a small unassuming space very open but with a bar that has about six seats available and the rest of the space is two and four tops. Very bright inside with a very eclectic assortment of decorations. As soon as we walked in, we were greeted asked if we wanted to sit at the bar or a table and we chose the bar. Immediately upon sitting, the bartender greeted us, handed us a menu gave us just enough time in space to Peru's the menu before taking our drink orders. Several local beers and insiders to choose from they appear on a large board behind the bar area, as does the menu showing an assortment of sandwiches and Panini. The theme is definitely Italian. We were advised that the soup of the day was a zucchini bisque. I am not normally a soup person, but it was a very cold day and I love zucchini so I had to try it. I don't eat red meat and often have a hard time with selections in sandwich places. But at Marta's, I have the opposite issue. Too many choices! I was still deciding when the soup came out. It was piping, hot and delicious not too salty not too bland. The zucchini definitely was the star of the show, but it was thickened with potato and and topped with a crème fraîche and EVOO. I had a cup of it, but honestly could have had a bowl it was that good. Meanwhile, the bartender continued to check in on us. He was very friendly and very knowledgeable. We could see right into the kitchen, which was small and cramped, but had two cooks and it was very clean, which is always a big plus in my book has been decided on the chicken Parm sandwich, which I wasn't too sure was the right choice for him. How wrong I was. Not only did it look delicious, but it must've tasted delicious because he ate the entire thing, which is very rare for him. I can't remember the name of the sandwich I ate, but it was a chicken cutlet with a very fresh and zesty lemony aïoli and arugula. How could I go wrong? Honestly, I could have had any number of things on the menu and been very happy. The roles were amazing. I specifically asked about them and were told that they ordered them from a place in New York City. I wish I could buy the bread around here, but maybe I don't because I would probably gain 100 pounds. While we seated, someone came in and placed an order to go, I got the impression they were a regular based on the interaction I observed, which is another good sign when you have repeat customers. We will definitely be part of the repeat customer crowd. There were a lot of other options on that menu. I have to work through if you're looking for a place that has a nice vibe not too loud that you can hear the conversation you're trying to have with your dining partner, doesn't have a ton of people inside, and offers up fresh, innovative, and delicious food at really a fair price give Marta's a try. read more

See all

As a sandwich lover, this place is a must. I ordered the Vivani, which had chicken cutlets and a fresh lemon aioli. That citrus flavor took this sandwich to the next level. My friend enjoyed the Franca, which looked almost too pretty to eat. Our server, Syd, recommended adding a balsamic drizzle, which completed that caprese feel. Would definitely stop here again, because the food and service were superb. Not to mention, East Aurora is such a cute town. Sitting out on the front patio is perfect for people watching on Main Street. read more

See all

Anywhere with a delicious hot chicken cutlet sandwich and Caesar salad is getting 5 stars from me. They had a perfect sized menu and it was hard to decide which sandwich to choose from they all sounded delicious. The "Mike the Bike" was the perfect amount of spicy but paired well with a Caesar salad. I will be back to try one of everything Service was friendly and prompt. Restaurant is small and quaint but perfect for a lunch or intimate dinner read more

Marta's Market - Mike the Bike - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - East Aurora, New York

Cute little place that features Italian sandwiches. The place was clean and the staff very friendly. I had The Tony which was delicious. My wife had the chicken Parmesan which came out piping hot ( I hate places that serve that sandwich Luke warm or cold). She thought the cutlet was a little thin but the sandwich overall was good. I knocked off 1 star because of the price ($18) for just a sandwich. No chips or side salad. Overall very positive read more

Marta's Market - Chicken Parmigiana - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - East Aurora, New York

See all

Delicious sandwiches and a very cool atmosphere, however, it is a tiny space which leads to noise bouncing off the walls. Unsure if we were just there with a loud table next to us or if this is the case at all times (Only 5 people at the table near us though). The service was fantastic! I'd highly suggest trying out the "Mike the bike" sandwich as it was phenomenal. The waiter told us they'd be offering pasta soon as well. We will be back to try again! read more

See all

My fiance and I stopped for a second time to Marta's on a warm and sunny Saturday in October following the Roycroft festival. We were warmly greeted and chose to sit inside on this visit. We got cozy in our spot and enjoyed the sun streaming in through the large windows. We admired the wall of stuff. It osnarranged beautifully. I ordered the prosecco, which is on tap and it waa great. I also ordered the Sandro with gf bread. My fiance got a beer on draft and the mortadella. We also got 2 bags of chips. When I bit into the Sandro for the first time, I knew that this has been the sandwich I was craving all my life. It was delicious. This is the kind of sandwich you dream about. The spread on it really solidified those thoughts. Our server was delightful and expressed that they will be finding more gf items including beer and dough for the flatbreads. He was friendly. Check this place out! read more

See all

Stopped in to grab lunch to take home. The staff were super friendly and helpful. The restaurant itself was surprisingly small but cute. I ordered the Vivani. It had chicken cutlets, roasted peppers, a lemon sauce and mozzarella. It was sooo good!! Super filling and fresh. Will definitely be back :) read more

This place is so cozy! Nate and Jeremy made my sandwich experience such a fun time. Those dudes are goofballs, but in the best way! It's so fun to have a place where I can relax and have good conversations! read more

Greeted by a very pleasant young man, who seated us and took our order....came over twice to see if everything was good and if we needed anything else..very cozy vibe, the food was fresh and delicious..will definitely be back and will definitely recommend.. read more

Marta's market is amazing!! Located on Main Street, East Aurora, NY in between the West and East end, Marta's has the BEST Italian sandwiches and their version of pizza called a "pinsa" which has a dough made from ancient grains. My favorite pinsa is the Careen with sautéed onion and mushroom with goat cheese and ricotta. Can't go wrong with classics like the meatball sandwich or the chicken parm sandwich or Italian deli sandwich's with anything from prosciutto to mortadella. They're open for lunch and dinner most days. read more

Marta's Market - The Meatball sandwich and one of their craft beers on tap - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - East Aurora, New York

Amazing! Atmosphere is so cool, staff is incredible-knowledgeable, friendly and attentive. Our server Nate was a class act. Food was absolutely incredible. Highly recommend read more

The food is always super fresh and the service always makes me want to come back and try something new. The patio is very cute in the summer time read more

See all

10/10 meatball bomber!! The bread was crisp and airy and the meatballs were tender and delicious. A new favorite!

Marta's Market was this tiny cafe with the best food! The pizza was outstanding and the sandwiches so delicious. read more

Marta's Market - Vivani Chicken Cutlets, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella, Lemon Aioli, Seasoned Italian Roll - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - East Aurora, New York

See all

Ordered 4 sandwiches on Friday, the web site needs updating and that is the only bad thing I can say! We all loved what we ordered, delicious, fresh and the bread was outstanding! read more

Oh man this place hits it out of the park. Small, quaint, and with character that delivers incredible sandwich's and other great dishes. Their meatball sandwich is literally the best sandwich I have ever had. Nice selection of artisanal beers with great food and charm. But leave the pretentiousness outside, you're in E.A. read more

Absolutely go try this place. Sit at the bar and have a pizza or sit outside and watch the town. You can't go wrong either way read more

Marta's Market - Tony - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - East Aurora, New York

See all

sooo yummy!! get the Vivani sandwich it was delicious, and the servers were extremely nice and helpful!! 1000% recommend for a nice yummy lunch. read more

Unbelievable Italian sandwiches. I had the Tony and was NOT disappointed. The homemade mustard was a great compliment to the mortadella. I think they have some sort of vinaegrette on the arugula which cuts the richness of the rest of the sandwich. The bread is perfect and soft with a great ratio of meat:bread. Jeremy at the bar was super friendly too! We will absolutely be going back to try the other sandwiches and pizzas. read more

I had the Rita Pizza. Sauce was authentic/Italian. It was sooo good! Service was excellent as well.

The service was great. Everyone was very pleasant and helped with questions. It is very small inside but they make use of the space. The menu is limited but expanding. The beer and wine selection was sufficient. The food was filling but mostly because the majority of it was bread. We hand the Sandro and the Vivani. The sandwiches are pricey considering the small amount of meat and they do not come with any sides. Even chips would have been nice. I would recommend to give them a try for something different than the usual EA locations. But it's pricey. read more