I got the eggplant ricotta, and it was phenomenal. They give you a ton of eggplant and it's not covered in breading. Their sauce is delicious. I didn't want pasta so they replaced it with delicious steamed broccoli. If I could choose 10, I'd give this place a 10 out of 10! Definitely go! read more

We were there to celebrate my Mom's 96th birthday and there were 14 of us. We were made to feel very welcome and our server Beatrice was fun, friendly and efficient. The restaurant is clean and nice looking. A very extensive menu with reasonable prices. Their bread and dipping oil is so good! I ordered the chicken Francese which came with spaghetti and my husband got the ziti with meat sauce. Both were delicious! This restaurant is great for large or small groups and should not be overlooked. read more

See all

With fast and friendly service I received my pizza and wings order.The BBQ wings were rotund, hot and delish.My peppers and cheese pizza was hot with the right amount of sauce and cheese, amazing. They also offer lots of pasta dishes on the menu for take out or inside dinning, plus a bar area to grab a cocktail. Plenty of parking in their lot. read more

See all

With speedy service and a smile I received my order. I ordered BBQ wings that were plump and very tasty.My pizza was cheese and peppers , it was hot with the right amount of cheeseyness and so delish.Dine in or take out with plenty of parking in their lot.Also a bar to come in and grab a beer, wine or cocktail. read more

See all

The portions are getting smaller than the one pictured here. I forgot to take a picture! If you come at 8:30 be prepared for the staff to be sweeping the floor around you and get ready to close. So if you want to enjoy a later dinner go somewhere else! read more

57ninety Restaurant - Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Depew, New York

The place is really nice and the staff super friendly. Service is a little slow but the food is super good. My friends who I went with called to make sure they had gluten free pasta at least and they told her yes. We got there and I told the waitress I had to eat gluten free as I am Celiac and get super sick and asked about the gluten free pasta. And she was like I am not sure we have let me go see if I can find some. She walked away and my friends were like we will leave if not. They did have it and the food was amazing!!!! My friends loved their food, the table next to us was raving about theirs and so everyone around was happy. They portions are big so u will have leftovers. Or share with someone! Go enjoy the food!!! read more

I love this recent find! The food is not only delicious, but the portions are huge! They are very creative in their menu and creations! Here is a photo of a flight of yummy specialty cocktails. All were great! read more

57ninety Restaurant - 1) TOASTED ALMOND 2) SPICED APPLE CIDER MARGARITA 3) VANILLA CINNAMON MAPLE WHISKEY SOUR and 4) CRANBERRY PALOMA - Italian Near Me - Depew, New York

Food and service was excellent! Too bad prices on specials menu didn't reflect actual prices charged! For example - margarita flight on menu$17.95. On bill $22.95 read more

Heard of this place from a coworker. Driven past it many times and didnt notice it. They've only been open a few months. Sign on the door says they're now serving lunches, open at 11am on Wed, Thur, and Fri. Very comfortable clean dining area. Many menu options. Our food was delicious, and service was also. Prices were reasonable and portions were good. Stuffed banana peppers, Gnocci Oliveri, and Baked Ziti. We will definitely be frequenting this place in the near future. read more

See all

The service was excellent and the food was so delicious. This will be on our regular rotation for restaurants! They even had gluten free options available! read more

The food was delicious and service great. I had the best cannoli that I have ever had! It was absolutely amazing. The peanut butter chocolate cannoli. All homemade in house. read more

We were seated upon arrival, our very friendly waitress greeted us with a warm smile, took our drink order & gave us our menus along with the specials of the night. I had the manicotti, which was the best I've ever had, my husband had the Joey sandwich which he said rivaled his grandmother's! We will definitely be going back. read more

Lots of choices on the menu. Friendly staff. Awesome Sangria.Large portions. Took home enough for another meal of chicken parm.

Went in on a Thursday for a birthday. Table for 4, which, considering both my sister and I work in the service industry, a 4 top is easy work. Service was horrible. Server makes it over to the table after sitting for a minute or two, takes drink orders, drops them and asks if we need time. We did, and it literally took upwards of 10 minutes for her to finally come back. Bread didn't hit the table until about 30 minutes later and about 5-10 minutes before entrees, and was dropped by another server. It was nowhere near busy. She drops entrees and disappears again. Like saw her all of 3 times the entire night. Food was okay, but we will never be returning. read more

The food has changed dramatically since 2024. I ordered the beloved baked ziti I got before, that was amazing. Well, today was a massive disappointment. The ziti I ordered was penne. The melted mozzarella was leathery. The meat sauce I decided to treat myself to, was tasteless, watery, and the meat sauce aspect was chunks of bland hamburger. I was locked forward to this baked ziti all day. And now I'm left with a foil tin of what will probably be tossed. And I when I went in to pick up my order, the restaurant was empty. At 5:30pm. read more

57ninety Restaurant - Huge chunks of hamburger placed on top of the noodles. - Italian Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

My third time going back to this resturant and let me tell you it does not disappoint. The food is awesome here. The spaghetti is always cooked to perfection. My go to place for Italian food. Keep up the good work. read more

57ninety Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Depew, New York

Service is on point. Food is delicious, have had a few of the dishes, never a disappointment. Family owned and operated, support local, eat local! read more

This place was recommended to me as having a great chicken parm. I've heard that before and walked in skeptical. Skeptical no longer I finally found that home run of a chicken parm. The perfect ratio of sauce to cheese. My mouth is watering just typing this review. The staff was friendly and genuine. I will be back hundreds of times. read more

My wife and I dine out several nights a week. We have a few staples we go on a regular basis but also like to try places we haven't been too. Tonight was an excellent choice of an Italian restaurant. Driven by a number of times and decided this was our choice!! The food was excellent as well as the atmosphere! Staff were accommodating and friendly! Prices were very reasonable as well as the pricing on bottles of wine!! My wife had the baked lasagna, a very large portion smothered in cheese. She loved it!! Took 2/3s home! I had the spaghetti with meat sauce. My test for a good Italian restaurant is this dish!! The sauce had a touch of sweetness and delicious chunks of beef !! The pasta was al dente! A definite home run!! It made the grade!! Had a side of meatballs, big as a softball and tender as could be! 57Nintey will become a regular place to have dinner, whether just the 2 of us or bring all the family up!! Shout out to Jake, the bartender, nice to meet you, catch you soon!! Pat & Linda read more

57ninety Restaurant - Dinner at the bar!! - Italian Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

Excellent food and service!! Will come back for sure!! Great pasta and gnocchi was excellent

Nice remodel from the old restaurant. Fresh bread and dipping oil was very good. I had a trio of Italian dishes. It was delicious. My wife enjoyed her chicken Parmesan. Service was quick. Looking forward to going again. read more

Food was great, and fairly priced. However, our sever was rude, unpleasant and not willing to help. Not once did we get checked up on to see if we needed refills or anything. Also, over head the nearing table complain about cold food and we saw her visibly annoyed and shaking her head as she walked away. Wasn't even too busy either read more

This place is excellent. The food is delicious. I would highly recommend going here for a nice dinner. Reasonable prices and friendly staff and is very clean inside. read more

My co workers and I have decided to have a dinner club where once a month we try somewhere local no chain restaurants. We went last night and there were 7 of us. We were seated right away. Our server was awesome! We the table had stuffed mushrooms, veal parm, spaghetti parm, the dominator sandwich, 2 had the 57ninety sandwich, the gnocchi oliveri, and the bleu cheese gnocchi. The food was amazing! Everyone really enjoyed it. We said we might need to go back to try other things. read more

We had a party of five and all of us ordered different items there was not a complaint food was delicious but more importantly the wait staff was exceptional! I will definitely be back! read more

ordered a pizza and the bottom was burnt black! showed it to the waitress and she says that is how they cook them. I could taste the burnt crust when I ate it. I will not be returning! I was never even offered a new pizza. read more

Love their food. The meatballs are terrific and their sauce is my local favorite. We usually order out and they are great every time.

Really good food and fairly priced too. Dig the eggplant parm, especially when you add ricotta to it. Also, the Big C salad (basically a chicken caesar) is huge and outstanding. read more

The service was fast and incredible, waitresses were extremely kind and helpful, the food was AMAZING. The restaurant was quiet and calm. Everything seemed super clean and well kept up. I have no complaints! Will definitely be returning! read more

See all

We were headed to a different restaurant that we heard of and saw this on the way and decided to stop! Hard to find the entrance at first, but it did not disappoint! So good! We ended up with a ton of leftovers! Meatballs in the meatball flight are huge! And tasty. The chicken/eggplant/ham dish I got was tasty and great flavor and came with a huge bowl of spaghetti we took home also. Joey roll was huge! Brought back college memories for us. Stuffed peppers were good and house bread was warm, fresh and tasty. Price was nice as well. The waitstaff were down to earth and friendly. Cocktails were strong. Best sangria around so far. We will be back. read more

Ordered lasagna tasted delicious. Only i thing wrong it's served all spread out on the plate look like soup. Not served like a straight up pie . Should be stacked.i will go again but won't order lasagna. Service was good .. read more

Had a very nice meal last Saturday. Food, Service, and ambiance were top notch. Thank you to your staff.

If you are looking for great, homemade Italian food, then look no further at the new restaurant 57 Ninety is a great place to get it. My husband and I stopped to check out the newly opened restaurant and were glad we did. I ordered the ravioli alfredo and he ordered the manicotti - both were fantastic. We loved the warm, Italian bread served immediately to us. There was so much food that we ended up taking half of it home. We had to try their fresh-piped cannoli and it was fantastic - crunchy on the outside and an unbelievable filling on the inside. The prices were reasonable and the staff was so friendly. We will be back for sure! read more

Service was friendly. The chicken franchise was horrible. They were random pieces of chicken. Tasted like butter chicken very little sauce. And ice cold. The side of pasta was hot and good. Parking was easy and the place is clean. Don't think I'll give it another try on chicken. read more

I use to order here all the time food was amazing when it was the old name we decided to try them today since it's new owner boy was that a mistake the chicken frances was absolutely disgusting no flavor chicken was all soggy and disgusting they definitely need to less on how to make the sauce with butter and lemon and the noodles came with the red sauce instead of the butter lemon sauce like at any other normal italian restaurant my wife's ravioli had mushrooms in it and we asked for no mushrooms but clearly attention to detail is not one of their expertise when I called to complain I asked for a manager a teenage girl that appear to be 12 13 max when I picked up food started to interrogate me why do u want a manager what's wrong with the order lol then she told another women there's a guy calling asking for a manager, and I don't know why he won't tell me clearly I just told her, but she doesn't have any integrity so she would rather lie teenage boy took the order and also cashed me out he also looks 13-14 years old Then the women who says she is the manager starts to argue with me and tell me i'm lying and she made the food and I am wrong and nobody told her not to put mushrooms and the chicken Française made correctly when it wasn't my wife was like sending her pictures at that point I wasn't disgusted with her attitude and the way she was handling a valid complaint this place is a joke and won't last long having teenagers running the place and arguing with customers read more

57ninety Restaurant - chicken française - Italian Near Me - Depew, New York

The food was excellent. The sauce is sweet, the meatballs are homemade. We also had pizza. The pizza was fresh, excellent. You could tell everything was made with quality ingredients. Oh yes, the home baked bread was served piping hot with butter. You must try this place. read more

Went to celebrate a birthday dinner with my kids and grandchildren. Heard the great reviews of this restaurant. Food was just okay. I ordered the chicken marsala which was absolutely terrible. Looked like microwaved thick chicken breasts with a weird orange sauce and only a few muchrooms. Didn't want to complain and dampen our family celebration. We won't be going back. read more