Gabrielle's used to be my favorite place in the Village of Lancaster. I supported them constantly. They have wonderful gluten free baked goods, as well as great breakfast sandwiches with a gluten free roll, if one so chooses. I will discuss three different run ins with Gabrielle's. First one - I went there in January to grab some sweets for a little crafting party I was hosting. I ordered both gluten free items and non gluten free items. The woman working, who was new, proceeds to ask me if she can put the non gf and the gf in one container. I said absolutely not. How can you not be trained on this, or not know not to do that. Why would I be ordering gf items, if I'm going to agree to put them in the same container. It defeats the purpose. Second time - Valentine's Day. My husband and I had a tradition of going to support Gabrielle's on Valentine's Day because they offered different gf items and a romantic atmosphere. This was our third time attending since living in the village. We arrived right when they opened, and they weren't opened yet, which was fine. When the owner unlocked the door, she wasn't very friendly. I let it slide, and continued to choose to visit Gabrielle's because I loved the baked goods and breakfast sandwiches. Third time - I stopped in on my way to an event to get a breakfast sandwich. It was about 10 minutes after they opened on a Saturday. It was quite busy there. There were roughly 2 or 3 tables occupied throughout my half hour stay.  Most notably there was a mom and daughter there. I'll get back to that in a minute. When I arrived, I was the only one at the counter. The same girl from the first not great encounter was making coffee behind the counter. That is fine. What wasn't fine, was that she didn't acknowledge me at all and I waited there awkwardly to put my order in for a good 5 minutes. Weird, that you wouldn't say, "Hi, it will just be a minute, as I'm working on another order,"  or something like that. The owner also came out of the kitchen during this time and took several Door Dash orders, but also didn't acknowledge me standing there. All I needed was a Hi, I'll be right with you. Something. I felt like a ghost. Fast forward, woman takes my order. It is for a gluten free breakfast sandwich. I sit down and wait. I wait for a solid half hour for my breakfast sandwich to be complete. During this time, the mother and daughter duo go up to the counter and say that they told the woman when they ordered that they needed to get everything by 9am, and it was 9am, and they still hadn't gotten their sandwiches yet. Why does it take a half hour to make 2 breakfast sandwiches?! They finally get their order and leave. The woman goes from the kitchen to the counter and is yelling to the owner, "If they wanted their food faster, they should have went to Tim Hortons." There was me and about 2 other tables present for that. I thought that statement was absolutely horrific and disgusting. Everyone who came through Gabrielle's and who goes to Gabriele's chooses to spend their money locally. To help a local family and support their business. To say that in front of customers, is abhorrent. I finally got my breakfast sandwich and left. I ruminated this for a while and decided against posting this review and emailing them directly about how this comment was unwarranted and not ok and the employee should be reprimanded. I received no reply back. This happened in February and it is now May. I have not received any acknowledgement regarding that my comment was received. I can only take it as the owner and employees don't care. Thus, I'm posting my review.   Not to mention that they claim to sell fresh bread on Saturdays, and there were a couple customers who arrived asking to purchase the fresh bread, and were told it was still rising and would be ready around 1 pm or so. What?! You would think they would be more in a hurry to get their bread out on a Saturday morning. That is when people want to eat fresh bread. It breaks my heart that I can't support this business anymore because the baked goods are so delicious, but I'm going to support other local businesses that value their customer base and are happy that the customers who walk through their doors want to support local. read more

We were shopping in Lancaster and needed a quick snack/coffee break. Luckily Gabrielle's was still open and we popped in quick to grab something as we checked out all of the shops on Main Street. It was a busy Saturday so there were a few people in front of us. We decided to get some things out of the pastry case and a couple chai lattes to go. Unfortunately for us with it being later in the day, the last of some of the items we wanted got taken before us but we ended up getting a slice of pumpkin roll, a cider donut, and a slice of carrot cake. The desserts were all so good. The cream cheese frosting was made perfectly and the cider donut had such a great flavor to it. The only downside was the wait for the drinks. The drinks took about 15-20 minutes to get to us. They were short on staff it seemed like so no worries but we had finished our food and were waiting for the drinks still. This is a really cute little spot on Main Street and I would love to go check it out again and hopefully try a couple of the things we didn't have a chance to next time. read more

See all

Very cute bakery! Coffee and food were reasonably priced. The staff was very kind. I got the focaccia bread with eggs, cheese, sausage and bacon on top but it lacked a good amount of those ingredients and seemed more like just bread. Would try again another time but maybe order something different read more

See all

The first time I visited Gabrielle's, everything was so yummy I forgot to post a review. The staff are super friendly, the space is relaxing, and the baked goods are spectacular! read more

See all

What a cute little Bakery. I arrived at about 11:30am on a Sunday, parked on the street (parking limited), there were only a couple people in line before me, a few couples sitting down, maybe about eight small tables for optional seating but the place is very small, cozy feel. There were only three cinnamon rolls left... I was going to buy all three but then I overheard the little girl behind me say she wanted one so I only ordered two. Try a cinnamon roll, they're so yummy, cost about $5.75, a 16oz house coffee was $3.75. I ordered the two cinnamon rolls, a piece of a carrot cake (WOW), slice of a pumpkin roll and a large chocolate chip cookie. All equally delicious in their own right! They were packaged to go in a large cake box for me, which I appreciate so nothing got squished during the ride back home. In total I spent $29.50 and didn't feel bad about it, I needed some sugar in my life that was worth eating, I try not to eat carbs anymore as a personal diet preference and I feel amazing but if you're going to eat them, let them be worth every bite so you don't regret it. Anyway, I love this spot. I did attempt to chat it up with the woman taking my order, she was very nice. read more

New bakery/cafe located in the village of Lancaster, I couldn't wait to check it out! It's a small little place in the new builds on Main St. Parking is plentiful with some parking on the street and you can also park in the save-a-lot parking lot for a short walk. The inside is super cute and modern looking. Bright teal walls with a couple tables to sit at. There are a couple cookies/scones/baked goods to choose from. A few fancy coffees. Doesn't seem like a lot of selections but I truly love that they have evening hours since Lancaster usually shuts down by like 3pm. I had a peanut butter cookie (very basic but delicious!) And a chocolate chip cookie which had some kind of added spice to it... Maybe anise? Not sure... But it was a very welcome surprise, it was sooo good! Excited for this new addition to the village and can't wait to go back and try some more options! read more

Gabrielle's Bakery - Bakery hours September 2022 - Bakeries Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Excellent bakery - the beautiful breads and pastries are clearly made with love and skill, and very fresh. I am a baker myself and this place impressed me. Great coffee and lattes too! There are a few tables for indoor seating, not a large space, but very comfortable (and great air conditioning if you need an escape from a hot day). Staff is friendly and helpful. read more

10 out of 10; absolutely wonderful in every way. The cakes were outstanding and so beautifully decorated. They really added to the festivities of the occasion. Will definitely go back again. I highly recommend Gabrielle's Bakery! read more

Gabrielle's Bakery - Not only were these beautiful but they were absolutely delicious! - Bakeries Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Delicious pumpkin roll. Great staff. Everything made in house. Street parking. Will be back to try more of their baked goods!!

When driving around town today with my friend, we decided to stop into Gabrielle's Bakery because we had some time to kill, and boy am I sure glad we did. The bakery is a cute little cafe with seats and chalkboard menus. I got an apple crumb cake and maple blonde with an orange hibiscus iced tea since it was a hot day out. Just on the food alone, I would give it an 11/10. It was absolutely delicious. The customer service wasn't bad at all but nothing too special. I would definitely recommend this bakery to anyone driving around Lancaster on a nice afternoon liking for a sweet treat! read more

My favorite bakery! I always get sausage egg and cheese on a croissant and it's never short of amazing! I have tried many of the desserts (cinnamon roll, cake, pumpkin bread) and I have no complaints. The customer service is incredible and the employees are very kind. They always give my dog a treat when we stop on our morning walks. read more

We stopped in for the first time today and will definitely be coming back! The staff was very friendly and welcoming. Their breakfast sandwiches were delicious and the cinnamon rolls were to die for! We can't wait to go back and try more! read more

Had both a Birthday cake and Birthday cupcakes for recent birthdays. Everything was just as we order and quality and service was outstanding. Will definitely visit again when back in town to enjoy a coffee and a pastry. Thank You read more

Very nice atmosphere. Wonderful Joe. Delicious hot chocolate. Many many delicious treats. Taste the high quality ingredients used in them. Yummy yummy read more