Great little shop just down the street from house. Love their Pizza Subs (probably the best I've ever had) and Chicken Finger Subs!!!

Great consistent quality pizza! I have also tried their Hawaiian and pickle pizza and they were both tasty! Been getting pizza here for many years. read more

Top 5 worst pizza I've ever had. Good wings but the the pizzas is absolutely horrible. Whole family hated it

update Oct 2024 visited recently, and Pizza is way better have not tried any of the subs yet, but the pizza is definitely better. We will be returning in the future added back to my list of pizza places. read more

My third stop in my quest to find my favorite Buffalo pizza. The main thing I love about Buffalo pizza is that cup and char pepperoni. So, I ordered my usual double pepperoni pizza well done. When I arrived they gave me a pepperoni pizza with double cheese. DEFINITELY not what I ordered. The first slice I tried took about three quarters of the slice before I found a pepperoni. Very disappointing. The sauce is nice and robust but it overpowered the flavor of the pepperoni. Overall, this was a disappointing experience. Perhaps I'll try it again in hopes that they get the order right. Oh well, on to the next... read more

Deniro's Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Service wasn't great- they lost part of my order. I also called ahead to speak with the manager due to concerns with my daughter's food allergies (PN and tn). I was shocked when I walked in to pickup our order to find they serve ice cream with one of her allergens that I specifically asked about. It was in a separate cooler but the risk of cross contamination may not be safe for all allergen families. Not sure we will be coming back. read more

Definitely my go to place for pizza! Delicious dough, with their consistent sauce is some of the reasons why. Love it when the pepperonis curl up with that char. read more

So we tried Deniro's twice for regular cheese and pepperoni pizza and didn't like it at all BUT we tried them again for a specialty pizza and wow, that was delicious! There's a big divide there between regular and speciality pizza. I absolutely recommend them if you want something different. We had The Godfather today and it was perfect! It's a little pricier than others but they have specials certain days of the week! read more

Deniro's Pizzeria - Godfather - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

ordered several times and food has always been good. Last time the wings were really small. Guess that's the way they came in. Usually nice size. Wiil definitely order again. read more

Food is really good and great customer service as well. We once had an issue with an order and they went above and beyond to make up for it!

The fortnite burgers werent that good, but a pretty decent mug supply. Was pretty suprised to see glizzy juice from ohio as well.

Pizza was good! My grand daughter had her 8th birthday party at "Get Air Trampoline Park". The facility does not offer up in house made food. Pizza and boneless wings were ordered and delivered via Deniro's. I cannot comment on the pseudo wings however I thought the pizza was damn tasty! Sweeter sauce, as I prefer. Maybe at some point I will try out the actual brick and mortar, but for now I am happy. Simple things. read more

The good: - close to my office - amaaaazing pizza rolls (seriously addictive) The bad: - prices are pretty laughable for most items... especially considering that there are several other pizza places in the area - I called ahead for the pizza rolls and was told it would be 20 minutes. I was already nearby, however, so I got there in less than 10 and sat in my car for another couple of minutes because there didn't seem to be any place to sit and wait inside. When I went in, the guy at the counter was very nice and when I said I knew I was early, he said "oh don't worry, they take like 3 minutes." He then went in the back and picked up a bag that was already sitting there. I got back to the office only a few minutes later and the rolls were just warm enough to not be disappointing. If I had actually arrived at the time they quoted, the would definitely have been cold. That just seems like bad customer service... and they could use all the help they could get by the looks of other yelp reviews! I will be back for more pizza rolls but honestly everything else seems so overpriced I won't likely be trying anything else. And I will make a point not to listen to the quoted time! read more

Super disappointed. We discovered their antipasto salad earlier this year and it would come in a pizza box. Tonight we were entertaining and called to ask which size was which in pizza box sizing because we couldn't remember which size would fit our party. We went to pick it up and it was so n a salad bowl. They said they just changed the size this weekend. Gee thanks a lot! $18 for a salad bowl full of mostly lettuce with meat sprinkled on top. If you are going to change the size, be honest when people ask it's size. And if you are going to serve it at 1/3 of the size you did yesterday you should charge 1/3 the price. Not good business. Sorry guys you just lost customers. As a side note, the last food we got before this incident, my boyfriend went to pick up our food and a delivery driver was arguing with a manager (or some person in authority) right at the front counter. Made for a very uncomfortable wait for food plus not professional to argue about business in front of customers. read more

I just ordered a sheet pizza and they sent it to the wrong address and refused to refund it or send a new pizza. They actually were extremely disrespectful and until i threatened legal action they werent going to rectify the situation. Shame on you! Dagostinos for life!!! read more

I had not been to this place in years and happened to be in the area the other day so I grabbed a slice. I am glad I only grabbed one slices though, because I forgot how heavy the pizza here actually is. There's enough cheese on this pizza to choke a small horse. Just make sure you are ready for a nap afterwards or you don't have to do much at work for the rest of your day, because this pizza will put you down. I would certainly recommend stopping by for a quick slice or maybe even two if you feel like doing nothing the rest of the day. Still one of my favorite lesser known pizza spots in the area. read more

This place simply rocks!! Garlic Parmesan wings crispy are off the hook!! The Pizza is just as good, it is definitely no disappointment. I will not get my pizza anywhere else if I am at home. If you ever want pizza and wings I would not pass this place by!!! read more

Deniro's Pizzeria - two slices of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Their taco pizza is so awesome and is the benchmark for me that any other pizzeria has to comply with. Ordered the white pizza tonight and it is one of the best! This is a quality place that serves up awesome pizzas!! read more

Order at noon online for a 5pm pick up and as I stand here at 5:20 the order is still not ready. I purposely ordered online as it is Halloween. read more

The chicken finger sub was really good. It came fast and just the way I ordered it. I be nervous to order out when I can't pick it up because I don't like it soggy or sitting but it came fast and was perfect. read more

See all

Honestly never ordering from here again. Each and everytime i order something from here its always messed up one way or another. The Food is nowhere good enough to justify messing up the order whether it be missing pizza toppings to unwanted toppings on a sub. Unfair to customer to have to arrive home to find there food is not what they wanted just to have to call and complain to be offered to remake it. no1s got time for that shit so i wouldnt waste your time here go elsewhere. read more

So far I've ordered here twice and ordered subs. Each time was delicious and on time. No complaints so far. Want to try the wings and pizza soon read more

This used to be a great place to pick up our local pizza and wings. It WAS reasonably priced for a decent meal. $29.99 for a large pizza and 20 wings. Apparently their prices have changed, A LOT, because we just called to order our usual, and the total was $42.99. I understand that tax was added to this, but their prices went up by $10.00??? I can see raising by a dollar or two, but $10 is ridiculous! A 33% increase? No way is that inflation. Besides, I checked into LaNova, which is the number 1 rated pizza place in the area, and they are cheaper than Dineros! Sorry Dineros, I will NOT be ordering from you anymore. $$$$ read more

Late night pizza and wings craving? Deniro's will hit the spot! The hot buffalo wings and delicious sheet pizza were great. They have great pizza/wings combos and plenty of unique pizza topping options. Friendly staff at this pick-up/delivery pizza joint in suburban Buffalo. Great experience overall. read more

Had good food. Staff tends to make mistakes with orders so it's advised to check order prior to leaving. New menu & price increase Dec 2017. $10 increase on speciality pizzas & $2-$3 increase on all other items. The increase isn't justifiable based on other pizza establishments & owner gets offensive when asked about pricing. Needless to say I'll be looking for another place to get my pizza from. read more

We ordered a personal sized pizza and chicken finger meal at lunchtime this week. The order was easy to place, it was ready on time and pickup was fast and efficient. The meals were hot and delicious. We really enjoyed them. read more

This is my absolute favorite place to grab a pizza and sub!!! The portion size for a slice is like getting two for one! Pepperoni is spicy but so delicious. They really take note of anything you say and make it specifically to that order. Staff is always accommodating. The food always tastes amazing and of high quality meats, not anything crappy. I highly recommend looking over the menu and going in for a slice of pizza for your lunch break! Nothing bad to say, ever. Also, these other reviews make it seem like an argument is something out of the ordinary, or mistakes are the worst.. things happen and people aren't perfect I'm sure if they made a mistake the food still was great. And the argument, you happened to catch them on an off day...relax people read more

In my opinion, they have the best pizza around! I order from there all of the time! Subs are good. I like the variety of things they offer on their menu! read more

I generally try and give positve reviews. I would have given one star but the guy at the counter was nice. BBQ Chicken Finger Sub - it was too soggy to eat. I was there to pick it up as soon as it was done and drive it home two minutes away so its not like it was sitting long. 1/2 Stinger Pizza - the steak they used was chunky and grizzly. A stuffed Buffalo Pepper - it was a battered pepper basically. The inside was full of Buffalo Wing Dip. The concept was cool but the batter was luke warm and soggy so it just didnt work. I may potentially go back and try for pizza but tonights experience wasnt all that great. read more

Your delivery time stinks. You say deliver within the hour and it's one hour and 30 mins and counting. I was told the delivery had to go to deliver at a school. Seriously? read more

While in Buffalo for business, I didn't know much about the area. My GPS pointed me in the direction of Deniro's. I ordered white pizza and Honey Garlic boneless wings. They were okay, but honestly could have been better. The wings, especially. They weren't crispy enough, and the pizza crust was way too thick. I might give them another shot in the future. read more

Foods decent but when they tell you delivery within the hour and it's two hours plus to deliver right down the street, that's garbage. It'll be Johnny's next time for sure. read more

All in all, meh pizza. Nice and cheap prices; $9 for a 1 topping large pizza., but it's not really all that special. It tastes almost as good as microwave pizza. The saver is their crust. It's actually tasty. read more

I'm what you might call a chicken wing enthusiast with a minor in hot sauces. I've eaten wings practically every week (sometimes twice a week if someone else was buying) since I was 17, and I...haven't been 17 for quite awhile. That said, Deniro's 'Inferno' wings are no joke. On a scale of Frank's Red Hot being 1 and Duff's 'Suicide' wings being a 10, Deniro's 'Inferno' wings are a 15. If you haven't been cross-training for these wings for the better part of your life, don't order them to win a bet or to look tough in front of your friends. They're really flavorful but they pack a serious wallop, too. Deniro's wing size is above par, their pricing was in the 'to be expected' neighborhood ($18 for a double, $27 for a triple), and the warning in the menu description was not kidding. I don't resort to blue cheese except for emergency scenarios, and this was one of those scenarios. Their blue cheese is pretty good. It doused some of the flames, and I've got nobody to blame but myself. If you punish your taste buds on the regular and you can appreciate good flavor paired with volcanic heat, try them out. I've had their deep-fried stuffed Hungarian peppers (to die for) and a few of their specialty pizzas in the past which were pretty spectacular. In a town lousy with pizzerias, they're worth ordering from. When my body's recovered from Deniro's 'Inferno', I will definitely order again! read more

Instead of going out to get something to eat, I decided to order a pizza while I'm staying in Buffalo for my company training. The hotel stated that this was the best pizza place near here. So, I ordered some food and it was just ok. I would probably never order from there again as long as I am here but it hit the spot at the moment. read more

I use these guys for takeout / catering for so many parties. Anyone can sling a decent pizza together, but some specialty pizzas and a killer antipasto, that's special. I have never had a complaint and could personally eat from here daily. The service is good as well as the food. I'll get food here any chance I get. read more

HUGE fan of their pizza! The spices in their sauce is what does it for me! Crisp dough on the bottom with a chewy layer before you get to the awesome sauce and cheese... yummm read more

I'm in from Michigan on Business. I was hoping for an infamous "NY Style" pizza. Deniro's pie was a bit too thick to be the pizza I was looking for. However the pepperoni's had a wonderful curl to them coupled with a nice crispy outer edge.I It was a bit spicier than other pizza's I've had. It's very greasy, though that isn't always a bad thing. I got a large with cheese and pepperoni with a 20oz drink and it was 20.00. It seems I am still on my quest and sadly Deniro's is out of the running. read more

This place is great!! Used GrubHub for the first time and got screwed. I'm a big fan of this food. I'm never gonna use GrubHub again for delivery since the food here is the best. read more

New to this town and seeking a great steak and cheese sub. This is not the place. The steak was chunked and yes I asked for mayo and oil but it was drowning in mayo. I took one bite and threw it out. read more