I really don't know how this spot doesn't have a higher rating. Very well may be my favorite Buffalo-style pizza. Love the thick crust (has a bit of a garlicky flavor), sweeter sauce, and not overly-cheesy. They have the craziest concoctions, like a stinger sub made that uses two pep slices instead of a roll. Genius! I do love their hot bbq sauce for fingers when in a sub, but alone, it is a bit too sweet. I do wish they made their own blue cheese - Macy's can you consider doing this? You know you'd be great at it! read more

See all

Ordered large pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms. No pepperoni. Duh. Look like it got tossed aside as everything shifted to one side. One and done, never going back. What a waste of money. Taste was fair at best. Very disappointing. Save your time and money and go to Mattia's for quality pizza that will have the toppings and taste better. read more

A couple of weeks ago we ordered and paid for a large pizza. Received a small pizza! Told we would have credit for a large pizza on our phone number. Went to pick up "replacement pizza" today and told credit expired! No pizza again. Never get our business again. read more

Its been a few years since we've been here. For Super bowl weekend, we decided to get some pizza and wings, one more time for the season. Upon looking at various deals online, we decided to order it online and pick it up. As has happened many times in the past, parking was challenging, but it made sense as it was right before the Super Bowl. The pizza was good, and we also ordered hot BBQ chicken fingers. I am a HUGE FAN of the hot BBQ sauce. I'm not sure if I will go back for the pizza, but I definitely will order their fingers with the hot BBQ sauce. While ordering, I was surprised with the abundant variety of sauces we could've picked from. read more

Macy's Place - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Visiting the area from South Carolina doing a wing crawl. Also trying out other Buffalo foods like WNY pizza. Got a slice of pepperoni. I am being generous giving this place 3 stars. Average at best. Nothing special. Dough was good. It's a walk in type place so easy to get a slice and go. Not too busy when we arrived, so quiet. read more

See all

Macys used to be our go to every weekend for a really long time. I'm not sure what's happened over the last few months but every single time, I've been disappointed. And reading reviews, I wouldn't dare try to complain. The quality seems to have drastically declined. The breads changed, it's harder, smaller. The sub ingredients are bare and whether it's steak base for chicken based - it's been dry. Any wing flavors that are charred after being fried, are so dry you could choke. Pizza slices are so dried out the cheese is hard. Even worse when the order is wrong. This place went from being the best, most favorable and sloppy - to disgusting, bland and dry. Can you please go back to whatever you were doing 6 months ago? read more

This was my second pizza from Macy's. The first time I received it they under cooked it. They credited me for that pizza and I got a new one. That was very classy. This pizza was much better. Cooked well. The sauce is on the sweet side, dough is pretty thick, good pepperoni but only because I asked for it well done. Overall, it's a fine pizza. Nothing to write home about. read more

Macy's Place - Macys small Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Had to try a Buffalo Style pizza and I travel a lot and I try to get a pizza at each area I visit. I ordered a small pepperoni pizza and had it delivered via Uber. While acceptable, it really isn't too taste. Crust was kind of soft and floppy, good cheese and pepperoni, but the sauce was so sweet, not to my tastes. It's not a bad pizza but it's not for me. read more

The first time we came here we received awful service, but this last time we went it was so good. Where been here a few times since they are 3 minutes from our house and I feel like they have greatly improved. Their food is very inconsistent, that's my only complaint. read more

I literally thought the food was a joke! How could you even serve this? The white pizza was the absolute world's worst! Extremely thick and no flavor! Cheap garbage! The garlic parm wings. Right in the garbage! The ham sub??? Seriously? C'mon! Never again! I wouldn't feed this to a dying dog! Definitely not Buffalo pizza! 10 thumbs down! read more

Stopped by and put in an order for a basic cheese/ pepperoni pizza. Interior front counter area was clean and service was fast and friendly. Kitchen area, all the tiles were yellow from what I'm sure is years of use / pizza oven heat, fryers etc. Pizza was pretty average though. Unfortunately there aren't too many fantastic words for describing pizza. Nothin I'd travel out of the way for. Lovejoy pizza, Carbones, Great Lakes, Macy's... all kind of on the same level. read more

Small local spot- finally got around to getting there. Service was great- of course, they were all former students mine! :) Had one of their daily slices- pep/saus/hot peppers. It was great- not a ton of sauce, crisp crust. Space was clean. Small parking lot. read more

This is a place that is always pushing the boundaries of what pizza can be. They do this for likes and notoriety. I find it gimmicky and sad. It doesn't matter though because when you make the best straight and normal pizza in Buffalo, a place that loves pizza more than anywhere else, you can do what you want. Macy's has the best straight and normal pizza in Buffalo and they're fun and creative. Get over it. read more

Macy's Place - Macy's Straight and Normal Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

10/10 approved by the whole family. great prices, great quality, and super efficient packaging. always a good experience ordering from here. might have to ask for an extra box next time though :D read more

Macy's Place - Sheet Cheese & 1 Topping Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Macy's place is known for their over the top creative pizza's. I'm an old school type of guy, so anything other than pepperoni is to exotic for me. But I was quite pleased with my order. I will come again Pizza- (pep/cheese) sauce is the sweet kind, which I really like. Cheese is the thicker type, and not the stringy bite and pull cheese. But that was fine Wings-(hot) I am not a hot type of guy. But these wings were amazing. The heat was all from the spices they use. I'm not sure if it was a dry rub but it wasn't saucy. But I love how these wings came out read more

Macy's Place - Bbq wings - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Great pizzas. I have ordered from the Kenmore location as well and love trying new kinds when I have out of town friends visit. read more

See all

Oh. My. Goodness. I've been wanting to try this pizzeria for about two years because I've heard the most incredible things about this spot. I am so glad that we finally tried it out!! We ordered the large Spicy Square Boi pizza. It's a pie made with pepperoni, jalapeño, pecorino, Mikes Hot Honey, red sauce and mozzarella.... The flavors combined were literally unlike anything I've ever tasted before. This pizza is not for those who can't stand the heat because every bite brings the spice. However, the crust is coated with honey that makes your fingers so sticky and the sweet with the spice is amazing. I will say the parking lot is tiny and I had to park on a side street and double park - but it was totally worth the trouble. My husband and I demolished this pizza over the last two days and there was no crumb left behind. read more

Macy's Place - Spicy Square Boi Pizza (large) - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

4/5 for this pizza place. I order something pretty basic just to give it a try- cheese and pepperoni and medium wings. Overall it was really good and I would come back to try something a little more fun! This place does have a lot of unique combinations and flavors of the items on their menu. It's really a fun spot and the staff were nice. read more

Macy's Place - Half Sheet - cheese and pep - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Every single time we order from Macy's we are impressed and never disappointed. Our favorite topping is kielbasa. But lately we have been ordering sausage and cheese. The only downside..... parking Can't wait for Clarence to open up since it's a twenty minute drive the for us. read more

Ok nobody mentioned they're take out and delivery only? Come on Yelp Elite Squad! Drove from Dunkirk - that's OK we caught a beautiful sunset on an otherwise too windy day. Will update after we get to taste!!! read more

Macy's Place - Pickup here! - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I want to like this place. but I have yet to have a single good experience. the first time I ordered delivery, it just didn't show up. we waited an hour and a half before the order was suddenly cancelled by the store with no call or reason. then, when I wanted to give them a second chance I ordered a Caprese. the wrong pizza arrived. it was a white pizza with onions. I hate onions so I had a replacement pizza ordered. a different looking pizza arrived, something that looks more like a caprese- except it had onions all over it and white sauce. WHO PUTS ONIONS AND WHITE SAUCE ON A CAPRESE PIZZA? a caprese pizza is red sauce, tomatoes, basil, and fresh mozzarella. The description of the pizza says literally nothing about onions. so, the first time I ordered we wasted over an hour and a half waiting for dinner for a 90$ order, then the second time I ordered I payed 42$ for two pizzas I don't want. read more

I have had Macy's a handful of times in the last few years and was particularly pumped to hear About their clearance location, as they previously weren't able to deliver to my location and driving there during the dinner rush was unpleasant. I was, like many people I assume, drawn in by their cheeky Instagram captions and the incredible photos of their pizzas. They regularly have new ideas and flavors that they offer for a limited time and sometimes they make the permanent menu. I want to love my orders. Multiple times I've ordered the chicken and waffle pizza which tastes absolutely delicious on the first day but is lacking as a leftover. Maybe I just haven't mastered heating it up in a way that will restore its luster. Having said that, I ordered a Maui Waui for myself today. The flavor of the toppings was great, but when combined with the sweet tomato sauce, it was not tolerable. Otherwise the pizza was extremely soft as if it wasn't cooked all the way, (I would prefer a crispy crust) but the toppings were sometimes pretty crispy. Finally, I did find it difficult to find other pizzas I'd be interested in as many of their pizzas have some spicy elements- hot sauces, jalapeños, etc. or a large amount of fried toppings- chicken tenders, Dino nuggets, pizza logs, crab Rangoon, fries, pizza pockets, mozzarella sticks, etc. the pizzas themselves however are unique and creative. I wouldn't say that there's much of an ambiance in the Cheektowaga location because it's just a takeout joint. The service that I've received there wasn't incredible or friendly but I know they're extremely busy. Overall, this is probably the best place to get hangover or 420 friendly food, but I will have to be in a very particular mood to try an order from them again. read more

I loooove ordering pizza from here when we're in the area. They have such unique combinations and my favorites have lots of pickles on them. read more

Macy's Place - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Let me start with some positives. The pizzas and food here is great. We love the two tone pepperoni pizza and all of the Instagram pizzas are delicious. Different but delicious. We most recently tried the Nashville Hot Chicken pizza and it was amazing!! The only reason it's a 3 star review really comes down to service. Whether you order for pick up or delivery, it's never been ready or delivered on time. Granted, it's always busy in there but someday it'll hopefully be done sooner rather than waiting an additional 15-20 minutes for the food. read more

Macy's Place - Nashville Hot Chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

This review is for 2 separate occasions. 1st: 24K Gold slice 8/10. had macaroni and cheese, and chicken fingers. It was huge and really really good! I think it could have used some more cheese sauce or some cheese that's a little creamier on the bottom, since a lot of the cheese on the top was a tad crispy from baking. The bites with the more creamy scoops of Mac and cheese were the best. The chicken finger was cooked crispy and delicious. 2nd: Ordered delivery to work. My coworker and I both wanted to try the chicken burrata slice, but they gave us both a cheese and pepperoni instead? Upset because we paid the difference for the gourmet slice, and they gave us a regular slice instead.... That being said, the regular cheese and pepperoni pizza was still good 9/10. I like the sweeter sauce. The only thing is that the pepperonis were so spicy for me, I either needed blue cheese to eat them with or else I couldn't eat them. See my older review for their calzone below! read more

Macy's Place - Calzone with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Went from being one of the best pizza places in Buffalo to a "not again." So much good pizza in Buffalo there's no need to waste your time or money here. Pizza was cold and soggy, wings the same. Maybe it's better as take out, but do not in any way get it delivered and expect to be happy. Macys went from the top on my pizza list to just a cool Instagram account. Hope they sort it out. I now know the reason why Domino's and Little Cesars exist, better pizza at 1/4 the price. read more

If you love all different kinds of pizza, this is a place to go and different types of subs. They got a huge menu. The prices are a little bit overpriced, but the food is amazing hundred percent recommend and will go to from now on. read more

Updating my review as today was the first time ordering one of the crazy "Instagram" pizzas. After dreaming of this pizza forever and putting it off for whatever reason today we finally ordered takeout online. I got a small Lala land (chicken finger, burrata, waffle fries) pizza, and my husband got the Maui wowie - I cant speak for that one but I did post a photo. The Lala land was so good definitely worth the hype. The pizzas are on the higher end of pricing but you have to think how many toppings, how many styles and the effort they have to put into these so this is a special treat for us. Ordering was easy, the order was ready when we got it no issues at all. read more

See all

One of our fav pizza spots in Buffalo. Have ordered several times and it is always good.

Extremely slow delivery service. And do not serve the public equally. Incredibly disappointed

Was eager to try the very expensive & unique "instagram pizza", offered as a limited edition on a rolling basis...we chose two pizzas for takeout. Both pizzas were unique & had delicious flavor, however like many other customers. our order wasn't ready on time or even a few minutes after we were told they would be ready. We were also disappointed that the advertised items were not included (no sesame seed crust, no green onions) & the pizza we ordered 1/2 jalapeños was ruined for one person in our party who can not tolerate their heat because there were jalapeños hidden throughout the pizza. Our 9 year old dining companion notes his personal cheese pizza was also spicy, which was quite surprising. read more

Macy's Place - Instagram pizza with kimchi & pork. Sadly, they neglected to include the advertised sesame seed crust & green onions - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

The pizza was good but a little bit too thick for me. Lots of cheese and pepperoni helped though.

I stopped into this place because it right down the street from me. The first time my husband and I grabbed 2 slices to go and it was so delicious. A little greasy but nonetheless, delicious. I went in again today and the young woman at the counter was so friendly. They had some specialty slices. I tried the "Walter White" and it had sausage, spinach, salami, and Barada cheese. It was so good. Next in my list is to to order a whole pizza next time and try their wings! read more

Macy's Place - two slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Kings of social media, maybe the best in the pizza game. Have had pizza and wings several times from here, some great, some mediocre. Severe consistency problems here. Seem to take way too many orders, and then tell people their food won't be ready for 40-60 min as quoted, even on pre orders. Service is a big factor for me since Buffalo has so much good food and I would give it a 1/5 here. Wings have been above average and are the star of the show. Recommend hot honey glaze and hot honey mustard. The chicken finger burrata is a must get if you come. It is a nice touch you can pick the sauce that goes on it. Really good Monday pizza and wing special is worth checking out. Would eat again if someone ordered it and brought it to me but I will not be making the trip myself. read more

See all

So many pizza options it's crazy!! always delicious never any problems one of my fave pizza spots love trying a new pizza each time we order! read more

See all

Well .... I allowed the teen to select the restaurant we would patronize for our big night in and he chose Pizza and wings from Macy's Place. Having junk food wasn't my idea of fun ..but I have been letting him choose every other week so he feels included ... One of our favorite spots has been closed and he had been wanting to try this place so we went with a large pie with double pepperoni and a double order of wings with garlic parm and a spicy cajun Well I must say I thoroughly enjoyed the food. They have a simple online order process and they text you when your order is ready. We arrived and the parking lot was practically full. While sitting in the car several people pulled up and seemingly had a smooth pick up process. The gentleman approached my truck and asked my name and brought our order and a menu and sat it in the back of the truck. He was VERY courageous We got the pizza home and it was still hot. We are a family that likes our wings extra crispy and not drenched in sauce. We ordered and they accommodated well ... they also cut a hole in the top of the container to keep the steam from making the chicken soggy (amazing how many people don't get that) The pizza was great! The sauce a bit sweeter than I am used to but good. The wings were just the way I liked them in texture and flavor. They did have larger wings, which I personally don't like (I know , I know) but yeah ...well ... I can be a bit anal with my preferences. But all in all it was a good experience read more

Macy's Place - Pizza and Cajun wings - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Buff-a-WHOA This is the pizza PIZZA you need in buffalo. This is the spicy HEAT you need in your life. This is the cheesy CREATIVITY you can be blessed with if you get your butt down to Macy's Place (or let them bring it to you with delivery ) Macy's place has absolutely BOOMED in the last few months especially after taking the W in the Sexy slices best pizza competition last year. First off, Macy's online ordering is super easy and makes getting your food so eaSy! Pictures to help you decide too which I definitely need to make these life changing decisions.... Prices on par with the amazing food you get.... and good sizing and quality too! We ordered a sativa (instagram pizza) and a cheese pizza with broccoli + 20 hot honey wings The Sativa: great crust and LOADED with chic iken ginger strips, curly Q fries, jalapeños, cheese, and all the bbq sauces... I AM SWEATING JUST TYPING THIS The Cheese (+ broccoli): same great crust, lots of cheese, really stupid good broccoli with MORE cheddar cheese and parm. Tastes like a cheesy broccoli casserole on a pizza... plus some veg for the morals of eating a veggie lol The wings: SAUCY goodness right here, if you don't like sauce leave right now... thiqqqq, sweet, and spicy, a slow burn on the tongue with loads of flavour. Small to medium in a size but not greasy and good meat to skin ratio and perfectly cooked! I WILL be back for more of the instagram pizza styles, I need more over the top pizza like this in my life. Well done! read more

See all

Best nashville hot wings I've ever had. Crispy and saucy and an amazing flavor. Addictive. Like other reviews, you often have to wait for your order is the reason for 4 stars. read more

Macy's Place - Super saucy and crispy nashville hot wings - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Definitely need more help in there and people that can actually READ/UNDERSTAND what customers order . It shouldn't be a problem fixing the problem after waiting almost 2 hours ! The food is good but I will not be going there anymore .... and the one older lady needs to work on her customer service skills and know how to talk to customers ! read more

The last 3 times I have ordered from here the pizza has been grossly undercooked. To the point where it was falling apart and not edible. The dough was extremely underdone to where it didn't even look or taste like it was cooked at all. The wings were also extremely dissappointing this time around. Very thin with barely any meat on the bones. Both of those items for nearly $45 is outrageous for the quality. I used to love macys but the quality just hasn't been there lately and think they have finally lost my business unfortunately. read more