Being a Buffalonian, I enjoy a chicken finger pizza from time to time. I'm happy to say, Joey's Pizza cooks up a surprisingly good one! On a Saturday, I called around 4:50pm and placed my pick-up order with a friendly woman. At the end, she asked me to give them 30 minutes. A little over 30 minutes later, I pulled into the small parking lot. I easily found an open spot, walked in, paid, and was driving home in less than two minutes. The gentleman working the counter was friendly as well. So I think you can guess what I ordered for dinner: A small (12", 8 slice) chicken finger pizza with medium sauce on the chicken fingers. When I first opened the box, I'll admit, I wasn't overly impressed - The chicken finger distribution was a bit uneven and it looked like it could've used a couple more minutes to bake. This is a situation though where looks are deceiving - Joey's Pizza's version was excellent! The dough undercarriage was perfectly baked - Firm, able to hold whatever's laid on top, but somehow, still felt soft, while the crust had the perfect softness:crispy ratio. The bleu cheese base wasn't laid on too heavy but the flavor still came through and tasted great. On top of that was PLENTY of mozzarella cheese and BIG, diced chicken fingers. I've had a few chicken finger pizzas in my time, but for some reason, these chicken fingers were a step above - I don't know if it was the medium sauce or maybe it was how they were cooked as they had an awesome crispy exterior, but put simply, the fingers were perfect. If you've had as many chicken finger pizzas as I have, you'll know they can sit a bit "heavy" and leave you thirsty - Joey's Pizza's version didn't sit "heavy" in my stomach, I am pleasantly surprised. As for how thirsty I was after - I've had plenty of other pizzas leave me parched, but this pizza, another pleasant surprise. As for the price, for the quality ingredients and the amount of food, this was pretty reasonable I thought. Joey's Pizza has been a favorite of mine, and my family, for a few years now. Friendly staff, reasonable wait times, quality ingredients, and great pizza. I'm glad I finally had Joey's Pizza's chicken finger pizza; I look forward to coming back! read more

See all

Fish Fry season is upon us so let us dive into the first review of the season! This time I tried a new spot. Joey's introduced a fish fry this year and since they are my go-to pizza spot, I had to give it a try. We ordered take out and it was like waiting for Christmas on the first Fish Fry Friday of the year. It arrived very hot still and it looked great. The fish was a good size, it came with a lot of fries, a large slice of rye bread and a side of tartar sauce. It also came with two small side cups of mac salad and coleslaw. My only complaint is that I wish the sides were bigger. They were delicious and I needed a few more bites. The fish was crispy and had a great flavor. The fries from Joey's are always great too. I was very happy we started the season off with such a great spot. Fish fry season is competitive but I'd definitely come back for another one soon! read more

See all

I was happy to see Brandon G.'s review for Joey's new Lent season fish fry. Everyone loves Joey's!! My husband works in the area, so he grabbed one on the way home. It definitely did not disappoint! The fish is huge, with a nice crunchy batter that didn't sog even on the car ride home. They give you a ton of fries. The mac salad and coleslaw are homemade and perfect, the portions of them are small but there is sooo much food overall that you can't complain. They even make their own delicious tartar sauce!! I hope they bring their fish fry back next year, it's a good one! read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Fish Fry Season 2026! - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

Great pizza with Monday specials!!!! They actually have different specials every day of the day of the week. The workers are friendly the food is constantly perfect which keeps me coming back. Eat on drive through and DoorDash is all available read more

Rays place in Canandaigua is excellent. Place was packed but we were instantly showed to our table. This place is huge , decorated with nostalgia artifacts. Many that I remember from my childhood. Waiterers and waitresses tag team. One brought us our coffee. The other took our order. And another brought it to our table. We were there for breakfast and we're not disappointed at all. Portions were huge and cooked exactly to our liking. Mom had a huge Belgian waffle and I had the 2 eggs, bacon , home fries and toast. I have never had home fries that big but they were delicious. We barely ate anything the rest of the day. 5+ stars for this place. Can't wait to go there the next time we're in Canandaigua!! read more

Pizza is fantastic! Wings were very good as well. The cup and char pepperoni and the cheese... the cheese was awesome.

Joey's offers good stuff. From Buffalo style pizza, subs and wings, through salads and even wraps. Their traditional cup and char pepperoni pizza is one of the best I tried. I'm not even trying to be nice. That's true. We recently ordered a large Three Cheese Steak specialty pizza with our choice of banana peppers. It was a birthday celebration, and we decided to get on a wild side. It was uber delicious! Even the onion, which was in a generous amount, was unusually mild with a slight crunch, oh! Delectable! Plus, Joey's pizza dough is always perfectly crispy on the outside, chewy and pleasantly fluffy on the inside. Pure heaven. Their pizza is dangerous. It's easy to forget how many pieces you've already eaten. However, for a special occasion, I'd like something more thoughtfully prepared. For example, some of us commented that the ingredients weren't evenly distributed. This didn't bother me, as I preferred pieces with the least amount of meat, but still. I remember being dissatisfied when our one topping mushroom pizza had the same issue in the past. I believe not everyone has a problem with that, but we do. We also got Assorted Cold Sub and Antipasto Salad. Everything tasted fresh and flavorful. Joe's is worth trying. People have loved Joe's for over a half century already. I know, it sounds serious, but this place is not a joke :). Cheers to that and the next fifty years. read more

See all

Joeys pizza! One of my favorite pizza places since I was old enough to remember. While I no longer live in the neighborhood, I always look forward to Joeys pizza when I do come out this way. Their pizza is so cheesy and always loaded with pepperoni. The guys working are also friendly and service is quick. During our most recent visit on a Friday night, we stopped in just to get two slices to go and were in and out in just a few minutes. Highly recommend! read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

Ordered a large cheese pizza for dinner. Very pleased with the quality and taste. Good value for the money. Pizzeria is always busy. read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

It's been a long time since I've had Joeys and I've been missing out! The Vincenzo pizza was amazing and I wish I would have ordered a large! We tried that , a small cheese and pep with 10 wing combo, and a side of fries and all were top tier! The wings were perfectly crispy, and large in size , the fries were also crispy and had really good flavor. Our order was ready in 25 min and we got there a little later but everything was kept warm and delicious. The staff was always friendly and that was the same great service this time around. Great place! read more

See all

The service was friendly and fast and the product was chefs kiss! The sauce had such a nice flavor, not sweet, not over powering... perfect amount on my pizza... there was also the perfect amount of cheese for me! I'm a cheese lover and love a generous portion of cheese without having to order extra! I also ordered a single order of wings, crispy and saucy and they were excellent as well... big and juicy wings, covered with sauce... yum! I will come back read more

See all

You can always count on Joey's pizza to come through for you! After an exhausting day of home remodel, nothing better than a beer and a great meat lovers pizza! Friendly service and cute little take out place with plenty of parking. read more

See all

We love Joey's pizza, so we were excited to stop by for a small pie and wings. We went to the George Urban location because I grew up a few streets away and and stopped in to say hi to my parents! Now I'm actually closer to the Broadway location. Both are excellent, with fresh ingredients and wonderful service. The wings we ordered were honey mustard and hot sauce. They dont have it listed but they will mix the two together and i highly recommend it. The small pizza had pepperoni, mushroom, jalapeños and hot cherry peppers. We like spice! Great crust, sweet and herby sauce, quality cheese, and tasty, fresh toppings. read more

See all

Pizza is outstanding every time we've had it. Delicious! But we Always ask for crispy chicken wings and they are never done . Always snap back & end up throwing them out. :-( read more

Service is always good here, the guys are friendly and also really quick with cashing you out. Also nice on the phone when taking orders. The pizza itself is usually pretty consistent. Today's pizza was a little dry and overcooked but nothing beats the taste of their cheese. The crust is also really good, not sure how it's prepared or seasoned but it's like buttery and crispy on the bottom- really good. Overall Joeys is a solid choice for Buffalo pizza read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

My husband and myself picked up pizza and chicken fingers from Joey's during the Yelp event night and it was honestly one of the best pizzas I have ever had! In Buffalo there's tons of options for great pizza and joeys truly knows how to make a great pizza! The chicken fingers and fries were cooked great as well and the fries were perfectly cooked and so crispy! I will definitely order from joeys again! read more

See all

Don't let this tiny building fool you. They put out some real good 'zah. Perfected Buffalo crust and not overly cheesy. Also tried their chicken cordon bleu sub. I recommend ordering it with blue cheese and the fingers tossed in hot bbq. FYI - their hot bbq is definitely more sweet than spicy. This is a satisfying sub with the layers of fingers, ham, cheese, and veg. All and all, adding this spot to my "Great Buffalo Pizzas" list. read more

You know it's good when your family only leaves you once slice for leftovers. A few hours old and still yummy! read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Seriously delicious food. This is what Buffalo pizza should taste like. The small was just right for 2 people if you're curious. It was ready on time didn't have to wait. The turkey sub had plenty of meat as well. I definitely will try them again. Thanks! read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Turkey Sub - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Stopped in here to buy a large pizza and 20 wings to take to the guys working down the street at Walczak's. Just my way of saying thank you for helping me and my student when we dumped our motorcycles in front of their shop during rush hour *facepalm emoji* But the order smelled so good when we picked it up and were driving it down the road, we came back and got lunch after delivering lunch to the guys. We split a small pizza and 10 wings, and ate inside at one of the adorable little bistro tables. Super cute. I hadn't been here in quite a while so I'm glad I chose Joey's for our thank you to the guys up the road. Thanks, Joey's!! That pizza and wings hit the spot! read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

I've had Joey's twice now and its pretty good. Food doesn't take long and was ready as promised when ordering. Staff was cool. I got a steak pizza recently and it was very good. It had a good amount of meat on it and lots of crispy onions. I've had their wings before which were pretty good, but for some reason had way too much sauce on them. I dont think thats the norm though, Ill havevto try then again soon. I day give this place a try if your around the area. read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Small steam pizza - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

6/2026 I have the pleasure of patronizing Joeys for many many years. What I have found is I always come back to them. I have learned stay associated with the winning team. From the good folks that work and work very hard, from the supreme sauce on the pies, that is always just right. Sauce is key to the entire pie. Served with ample amounts of ingredients. The wings are huge and always done right. I have had a few subs and no complaints. They offer deals during the week, which is always welcome to anyone that want s to get a great deal at a great price. Over all I am a pizza lover and yes between the wings and the pies I am a very satisfied customer over the years. Continued success to the crew that work there. Support local ownership always. read more

They were very friendly once I entered and it was very clean. I ordered double wings double extra crispy and they were perfect. It's also hard to find a place that makes them crispy and saucy but theirs were perfect, well done boys! I also ordered a joey's deluxe sub with double sausage and that was a 10 too. Plenty of meat, toasted, and great flavor. All was very reasonably priced too. Will be going back often. read more

I just tried to order a pizza and they denied me cause IDK bullshit!! I order and get delivered 1 to 2 pizzas a week now I'll never order again FUCKYOU!!!!! read more

My 500th review On my visit for my Elite perk, I decided to order a mini tuna sub. The sub was made by the hardworking owner himself, which made me feel special. I need something for lunch, consistent, quality, average pricing, decent size sub. The sub came with tomato and lettuce, and was asked on other selection of condiements for mayo, onion and oil which was appericated. Not all pizza places will always remember to ask. Thanks for speedy service, and great food. read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

Went to Joeys for the Yelp opportunity. Never been, and I was very impressed by the worker. It was a little confusing arriving there, and accidentally walked into the kitchen at first. The place was nice. Only a couple tables, which is fine, because I was driving back to work. Server was helpful and very kind, he even sent me out with a pile of napkins; very kind. I ordered cheese & pep slices, and they were fine. While it had some zest to it, there was a certain flavoring to it that was missing. I was less thrilled that when I arrived at my destination to eat, most of the napkins were used to soak up the puddled grease - a far greater level than I am used to, with pizza I usually order. The pizza tasted good enough, it just was not anything that I would rush to get again. read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

This place serves the best pizza I've had in a long time, with a perfectly cooked crust, the best sauce in town, and well-balanced toppings. Their turkey submarine sandwich is also excellent, making this place a true gem. read more

I have been patronizing this establishment for 30 years going back to the days when Vinney owned it. Once he sold the place it went down in my opinion, but I continued to patronize it. Sometimes the food was great and sometimes it was just ok. Tonight was different. IT WAS SHAMEFULL. I ordered a small cheese and pepperoni WELL DONE. It was disgusting!!! It was like mushy cheese on a large taco shell. Totally uncooked, smothered in cheese with exactly 7 pieces of pepperoni. It was not even cut. It was gross. You guys should be ashamed of yourself for serving such crap. I threw the entire thing in the garbage. You just lost a customer of 30 years. HORRIBLE!!!! read more

I was pleasantly surprised by Joeys! We grabbed two slices of cheese & pepperoni pizza and some bbq boneless wings. The pizza was pretty good! It had the cup and char pepperonis and the sauce to cheese ratio was good. I typically Ike my crust on the softer side but I would get pizza from them again. The boneless wings were good too, but I could have done with a little more sauce. Overall though, the food was good, the staff we friendly and the prices were definitely reasonable. There's a few things I'd try again and I'd recommend going there. read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - BBQ boneless wings - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

After a long day of shoveling snow and fighting the cold, I was in the mood for a hot slice of pizza. Best decision of the day. It was great that I didn't have to wait forever for someone to take my order. I noticed the cleanliness of this pizzeria and I can safely say it was certainly kept up. ( my number one pet peeve for all restaurants) Joeys is a small place but has accommodations if you do have to wait for your order to be ready. The pizza was delicious! Not to saucy and not too dry. It has a generous balance of cheese and pepperoni. Made my day. I won't hesitate to come back and order more. read more

See all

Sounds odd but this place just reeks Buffalo pizza spot. Big friendly dudes serving up delicious pies. I called and placed an order. I was told 20 minutes. Perfect since my ride from work would take exactly that long. Food was ready when I showed up. It also traveled well. This is exactly how I like my pizza. Thick gooey cheese and a tasty sauce with the beautiful curled 'ronis. I ordered a turkey club but the bacon was not there. Turkey sub was great. Nice thick real turkey. None of that cheap thin deli meat. And the wings were perfect. Saucey, slightly crispy exterior, and juicy inside. This would be my spot if I lived in the area. read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Turkey Sub, Two Slices, Medium Wings - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Great service and food. Everyone has always been friendly and outgoing. If you're in the area, give them a try.

Great pizza. Love the Garlic Parm wings. The employees are friendly and helpful. I need to add a few more words to satisfy Yelp

I recently visited Joey's for a Yelp event and also ordersome fries on the side. The staff was extremely friendly, the prices very very affordable, and the pizza was cheesier than normal. If you like Buffalo style pizza, this place is very much what you are looking for. I was a bigger of the french fries. For roughly $4.50, I received this large box of deliciously seasoned fries. They were enough to reheat and consume for 4 meals. I look forward to coming back and trying their wings, their offerings, and of course more of their fries. read more

See all

I've been a loyal customer for years. Well today I ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza and it was cold and tasted old. Very disappointed!!! It was terrible. read more

I love Joey's subs. Always so good and put together without making a mess. So many places just throw them together with too much condiments. Who wants a dissolving sub, am I right? read more

Stopped by after reading many positive reviews to try the pizza at Joeys. The staff was so friendly and helpful even to suggest other establishments that might offer food that would be worth trying. The building was very clean and the pizza was probably the best I have eaten since my last visit to Chicago. All the ingredients was fresh and the wait time was minimal. I would absolutely recommend their pizza (we ordered a meat lovers) to my friends. The crust alone was to die for. If I could give a 6th star, I would! read more

Ordered pizza, fingers and 2 subs, ready in the 25 minutes as stated. Pizza was nice, could have had a little more sauce, cup snd char pepperoni, chicken fingers are good quality chicken and cooked to perfection. Benny sub was so big, hubby could not finish it. The cold cuts on the subs are good quality also. Will definitely order again, every one was happy with their food. read more

Joey's Pizza Depew - Large double cheese double pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

This is a well-deserved review, and I couldn't wait to get to it. First, let me say I have been near this place MANY times and never tried the food. I was pleasantly surprised when I realized this was the place. This place is pretty small in a very small strip on George Urban. There is plenty of parking for the busy lot. The reception area is a bit conjestted when you have more than 6 people waiting at the counter. But it seems like a neighborhood favorite, and I was impressed to hear the gentleman who greeted me to refer to people by name. I walked into a pretty busy establishment, and I was greeted by who I think may have been the owner or a manager. He was pleasant and eager to assist me. I advised him that I was part of the Yelp Elite event, and he quickly obtained the sheets to verify my info. I also ordered a double order of garlic parm wings. I was very clear on how I liked them, and he listened and gave me a time to come back to pick up my order. By the time I walked back in, there was a pretty large crowd of people waiting to order or pick up. I was quickly acknowledged and given my order. Now to the good part. The FOOD THE PIZZA was pretty good. I have a teen who met me at the door and claimed a slice immediately. He isn't picky as most are ... but he did say it was pretty good. I am a tough sell ... I consider myself a pizza snob. I must say the crust was good. Not too thick, and the sauce had a sweetness without being too heavy. I usually prefer a double cheese, but the special was for a regular slice. The flavor was good, and there is nothing better than plenty of pepperoni with slightly burned edges. Now for the wings ... another thing I am a snob about. I don't like it when restaurants have those super huge wings. These were perfect, realistic, actually. They were cooked extra crispy as I asked, and that was very much appreciated. The flavor was on point, and they had a nice crunch .... awesome I am certain I will stop in again I will say the best part of this experience was customer service. Unfortunately, that seems to be a lost art lately. To have a positive experience and to see it extended to others is a real pleasure. read more

See all

This was the first time I've ordered from Joeys and I'm not impressed. They charged $23 for 10 chicken fingers. At first glance as you will See in the pictures they looked alright but when you moved the first two the rest were the size of boneless wings and there were only 10! I liked their fries but I won't be ordering again sadly. Hopefully I was the rare case but I doubt it. read more

See all