Disappointing Experience - Not Worth the Hype
I had high hopes for Phyllis after reading great reviews on Yelp, but unfortunately, our experience fell far short of expectations. My wife and I chose this place for a Valentine's Day weekend date, and let's just say we left with the firm decision to never return.
Upon arrival, we were greeted and seated quickly, which was a good start. Our waiter brought water and gave us time to look over the menu. So far, so good. However, things quickly took a turn.
When my wife asked about mocktails, she was simply told no--despite the restaurant having a full bar. The waiter said they had Fanta orange as a choice if she wanted that instead lol. There was no offer to make a non-alcoholic version of an existing drink or even a suggestion for an alternative. It was an immediate red flag for the level of service we were about to receive.
Then came my ordering experience, which was frustrating beyond belief. I initially wanted the catfish and grits--they were out of catfish. No problem, I'll go with the steak--they were out of steak. Okay, let me try the biscuits--no biscuits. Fine, how about the cornbread? No cornbread either.
At this point, I asked the waiter, what do you actually have? He suggested the lobster plate, but I don't like lobster. By this time, the lack of communication and preparation was incredibly frustrating. A restaurant being out of a couple of items is understandable, but this was a significant portion of the menu, and no one informed us before we sat down.
Feeling forced into a choice, I ended up ordering the chicken and waffle, the same as my wife--something we never do as foodies who love trying different dishes. This was not a meal we were excited about but rather a reluctant last resort with the lack of available menu options.
When our chicken and waffles arrived, I have to admit--the waffle was really good. This was the one highlight of the evening. The chicken wings were cooked well, fresh, and hot, with a solid seasoning blend. However, they were almost on the verge of being too salty, just stopping short of being overwhelming. I'd rate the wings a 3.5/5 for that reason. The presentation was nice, too--the food was served on fine china, which gave the impression that they cared about the dining experience.
But then, in a moment that perfectly summed up the night, the server handed us plastic utensils to eat with. Yes, after presenting our food on elegant white plates, we were given the kind of cutlery you'd expect at a backyard cookout. My wife couldn't help but ask the server why they'd go through the trouble of using fancy dishware only to pair it with plastic utensils. His response? He didn't have time to wash the silverware because he was the only one working--just him and the cook.
At this point, nothing surprised us anymore. We just nodded and moved on, realizing there was no point in arguing over an experience that was already beyond saving. If this is the level of service and preparation that Phyllis finds acceptable, then it's clear we're just not their target customers.
I genuinely wanted to love this place, but it was disappointing from start to finish. Marietta has way too many solid restaurants to justify coming back here. Final rating: 1/5. Definitely won't return. Id also be more understanding if they were packed. There were only 2 other tables in the entire place.
(They also have a loyalty program that states - "Spend $1000 and get $10 off your next online order ) No further commentary lol read more