Someone in the kitchen was having a rough Valentines . Tried to order a heart-shaped pizza during the Valentine's special. Got a very unappetizing blob instead. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - "Heart-Shaped Pizza" - Pizza Near Me - Oak Harbor, Washington

See all

More toppings! Here's a pic of my supposedly supreme pizza! As soon as I can get past this filter lol. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oak Harbor, Washington

Extra sauce butter chicken pizza is really good for the people who like Indian flavor. Epic pizza is a good choice for me and I think it's great for the people that like cheese and hate traditional crust pizza. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Butter chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oak Harbor, Washington

This location sticks out from the average Papa John's. My wife went there in high winds and her pizza literally blew away and they sent her on her way with a fresh one. The service and kindness the employees showed was awesome and sets the bar high for other pizza joints on the island. The pizza was hot and tasted great, can't ask for much more than that. Will be a repeat customer when those pizza cravings hit. read more

Great pizza. Only issue was Grub Hub delivered to the wrong house... Luckily I have honest neighbors that delivered my $100 order to my door. read more

We were glad they had finally brought Papa Johns to Mt. Vernon so we ordered a couple pizzas through the app. When partner went to pick the pizzas up they told him I had not ordered anything there! I checked the app, it showed I HAD ordered, paid and picked it up. I checked my bank account and they had already took the money out of my account. I called the manager and he looked for my order and could not find it but instead of offering to make it right, he told me I had to call the corporation to TRY and get my money back. Apparently my order went to Lake Stevens and was picked up by someone but still, no money or pizza. We won't order on line from them again, not sure we will even pick one up. I like their pizza but am very disappointed with how they handled their mistake. I guess I really want to tell people to be careful about ordering on line from them. Thank you for reading this and I hope no one gets treated this way! read more

Absolutely disgusting. The person who took my order was unpleasant and argued with me about what toppings i want. Then she put the wrong sauce on, and burnt the crust. Would never go back. Little ceasers is in same parking lot. Its a lot cheaper, tastes better, and you dont have to deal with that horrible girl. read more

We order from this Papa John's often. Have not had a bad experience. Love it that they deliver. Prices are very reasonable. Staff is friendly. Fresh ingredients every time. Garlic knots are addictive! read more

If you enjoy the affects of severe food poisoning, do order the pepperoni & meatball pizza!

This is LITERALLY the first time but still...WTF oakharbor?!!! Bubbles the size of the slice? Should have only paid for 6/8th. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oak Harbor, Washington

DO NOT USE THE GRUB HUB ON YELP - absolute nightmare. Used it for the first time and it took forever to load, then announced my food was ready. Not only was it not ready, it didn't exist - staff told me it's a 3rd party that charges a large fee ( was not aware) and they never get the orders. Called the Grub hub customer service and sat on hold for 20 minutes due to a high volume of calls (I'll bet!), they said a refund would be in 3 to 5 days. I told the staff while I was waiting for my real order, the guy told me good luck with that - great. read more

Awesome customer service. Above and beyond to fix a simple mistake. Will come back for sure.

Worst pizza EVER!!! Tried it for a second time to give them the benefit of the doubt, unfortunately they failed once again. The pizza was absolutely repulsive super thin on one side, super burnt, super greasy, I'm so sick I'm about to puke. Amen.. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Disgusting ,burnt, greasy ,thin, Papa John's Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Oak Harbor, Washington

I have never been a fan of Papa John's pizza because the crust has ALWAYS been burnt. However, while visiting my Dad on the island and staying at a local hotel - my daughter and I were hungry and she found this Papa John's very near to where we were staying - and they delivered. Ordered the Hawaiian BBQ Pizza - and it came within a very reasonable time and was the hottest delivered pizza I've ever had. It was great because ... 1. the crust was NOT burnt; 2. perfect amount of BBQ sauce to topping ratio 3. pizza was hot and fresh 4. delivery person was pleasant While I probably won't order from Papa John's in my local area - if I am ever back up on Whidbey in the Oak Harbor area - I wouldn't hesitate to order pizza from here. read more

Like 6 olives on my pizza, and garlic knots are burnt. Really super disappointed. Really had a craving. read more

For spending $79 on a order you would think you would not have to wait 2 plus hours on a pizza. Really??

This store is fast, convenient and the pizzas are great. We always ask for thin crusts- never been disappointed here!

Just had one of the best pepperoni pizza I had in years!! Not greasy, and the marinara sauce has a secret taste that I can't put my finger on, but I love it! read more

I think when reviewing a franchise the most important factor would be that it upholds the standards you expect from that franchise. There is absolutely nothing wrong with this Papa John's, it has the quality I expect from the franchise. With that being said, I usually grade franchises on a 1 to 3 star scale with the exception of sit down restaurants. Papa John's has great pizza, and if you utilize the website you can build your pizza and place the order entirely online. If you like Papa John's pizza you will not be dissapointed! read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Papa John's, Oak Harbor WA. - Pizza Near Me - Oak Harbor, Washington

My wife and I have had Papa johns pizza in the past, then we moved to a new area where there was no Papa John's. We were excited when they opened here. Last night we had pizza delivered and were never more disappointed. The crust was huge around the edge and took up over a third of the pizza. Had a lot of sauce but very little of anything else. Even my 15 year old daughter who loves pizza took 2 bites, then made a PBJ for dinner. Strongly recommend that don't waste your money or time. read more

They have decided to use Door Dash without informing the customers At Oak Harbor WA. Door Dash after 80 minutes still no delivery. Called had to cancel order got refund from nice staff. Sure hope their corporate goes back to local delivery drivers. I give tips straight to driver so door dash never would take my order. $60 they lost plus tip which would have helped local area. read more

I was a fan of Papa Johns until I went in to the Oak Harbor location about a week ago. I went up to the register and the girl who noticed me was too busy texting on her phone. She then signaled to another worker to come help me and he then signaled to her to come help me. It went back and forth until he finally came to help. He seemed busier than she did at the time, so I made more sense for her to help me. She was literally just standing there texting and decided that she didn't want to come assist us. When the guy finally came over he was great, but I had already decided that I wasn't going to be purchasing from them that night... or ever again. Very disappointed in the service. read more

I'd give them 0 stars if I could. The people who work here are extremely rude, absolutely no customer service. Love papa Johns pizza but it isn't worth the frustration of dealing with these employees. read more

Of all the major pizza chains on the Island (i.e. Pizza Hut, Dominos, Little Caesar's, etc.), Papa John's is our family's personal favorite. Their dough always tastes fresh, and they aren't skimpy with their cheese and meat toppings. We typically use their one-topping carryout special to get a pizza to split on busy weekday evenings. Online ordering makes it really easy! read more

I just went in and asked if I could buy two sides of bacon for my little kiddos the teenager working ask his manager and they said no. And I asked really you can't just sell me a little bit of bacon the answer was no. read more

Worst pizza around. Sauce is much too sugary and meats did not seem fresh. The NFL could have done much better. Free pizza? Overcharged.

"I ate it I'll rate it.", best pizza chain in town. Fresh mushrooms not canned. Best sauce wish they sold spaghetti sauce. Delivery to Base and in town to edges. More of a chewy tug at crust and a Tad browned on edges.never soggy on bottom. Real cheese and great Canadian bacon. They have PLATES and napkins and garlic butter sauces or parmigiana or hot peppers for delivery.GREAT place. Tell em how you want it and they will do it. Extra cheese or extra sauce or light pepperoni or cooked a bit more well done. That one they can do if their not to busy. A machine runs the pizzas through.best Root Beer. read more

I really enjoy the staff here, also when I order delivery I'm not waiting an hour like most other pizza joints and I love that my pizza is still hot when I get it delivered, that's a bonus, jet jalapeños and bacon it's the best. read more

We ordered delivery tonight and the driver showed up only to go next door. I went to grab chairs in the other room on belief that the driver would figure out they went to the wrong house, but low and behold they returned to their car and as I returned to the front room, they were driving off. Our house is clearly marked. I am sure our contact info was on the boxes, yet no attempt was made to contact us for clarification of address. Our dinner was over 30 minutes late, which was pre-ordered over three hours prior. We had to go to the store to talk with staff to get answers and a driver to return delivery. Our address was clearly marked on the box and it was still light outside. read more

Between the gooey dough and the strange consistency of the cheese (it was just a slimy clotted glub that oozed off the slice before you could even bite it) the pizza was just a slimy mass. But the sauce tastes like a super sugary ketchup, so who would want to eat it anyway? Disgusting. read more

Pizza is not great. Its better than others in our local community. We had chose not to order papa johns anymore, but tonight we figured we could try again. Our pizza was 15 min past the estimated time given, the driver went to the wrong house at first and finally the order was incorrect. Wont order again. read more

This place is horrible! I ordered from them and got charged 2 times! I called the store and they were so rude. Told them i got charged two times they put me on hold in mid sentence. Took the manager 5 mins to take me off hold. Then he his talking to someone elses while im on the phone trying to caculate my total several times! I keep asking what he was doing and no response! After 10 mins of him trying to add up my total which wouldn't be $47! I got mad and tried asking what they are doing? Why know one is talking to me about it they are talking among themselves? I Continued To said that this is horrible customer Service. In mid sentence i was put on hold while i was still talking. They finally take me off hold after another 5 mins to tell me they can't do anything. And give me there helpline number! Why they didn't give me that at the begining is baffling! I asked them for there suprvisers number to be put on hold agian for another 4 minutes. They take me off hold to tell me they can not give me supervisers number that i just have to call help line! When i get off phone with the store its already been 30 minutes! I call helpline lady was nice understanded my fusteration. But has to call store to make sure she got totals right. Takes me off hold to put me back then tells me she needs to call store agian to see if manager will allow a refund! Why couldn't he offer me the refund when i called them instead for being so rude! This was a hour process to be told i have to file a compliant to wait 24 to 48 hours for the money they took out twice! I will never order from papa johns ever again!! read more