I'm new to the area and tried this place for lunch. Every that I have purchased so far has been very tasty and just the way I like it. Service is always excellent! Only gave 4 stars because I haven't tried everything as of yet. read more

Place is a joke. Overpriced skimpy sandwiches. The owner writes fake reviews to boost his business. He also posts on the Facebook group DINE LI, pretending to be a customer and raving about the food. Tool read more

Always an excellent sandwich. I recently ordered for a large group and everyone loved lunch!

Pantano's is truly one of my favorite quick stops for lunch while working my shift in the plaza. Always makes food on point and always ready to serve with whatever we need. Even catering!! The service is A+ and the gentlemen who work there are so sweet. Thanks for all you do!! read more

Best HEC and BEC on a roll sandwiches. ! We travel for them ! Also amazing crumb cake iced coffee. Delicious. Friendly staff.

John Luca and the Entire Pantanos team are amazing! Go out of their way to provide great service and the food is Amazing! You truly get your moneys worth. read more

I've only ever eaten egg sandwiches from Pantano's (which are great) but I've been eyeing this wrap for quite some time. Tonight I gave into my buffalo chicken craving and decided to go for it. Buffalo chicken, Mac and cheese, waffle fries, and spicy ranch all in one wrap. Where can you go wrong. It was delicious! I ordered online and it was ready when I got there. Both employees I interacted with (I did not get their names) were friendly and welcoming. I will definitely be returning to try another wrap soon. read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - The Spicy Melissa ( Top 5 Seller ) - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Delis are pretty common on long island so much like pizza places on the island they really have to bring it, but sadly Pantanos doesn't bring it. Go to any of the other 50 deli or deli esque places in 10 mile radius. read more

A deli is a deli is a deli is a deli - well, you get the idea. Pantano's Eatery - Plainview, NY In the adjacent shopping center across from Bed Bath and Beyond. Seems this place has been here for 6 years. The outside is nice enough. They even have a small table and chairs outside. The windows have hand painted designs of a Snowman and red bows. We ordered Beef Barley soup and Cream of Potato soup along with a hero sandwich dubbed Michelangelo which listed Corned beef (or was that pastrami) and sauerkraut. The bread was toasted and there was eat on in with maybe a tablespoon of kraut. I asked for more and the server gave me a little cup of cold juicy kraut. I asked him about the soups. They are canned. They add small bits of fatty beef to the Beef Barley and call it home made. Then they put the serving in a huge coffee cup. The amount is easily big enough for two people to eat. They do provide individually packed crackers and individual small salt and pepper packs from the back near the napkins. Yelp*ers - note- that there is a 10% discount for first time check in. It has a timer on it that clicks down from 3 or 4 minutes. Also note that Soda and drinks at 2.50 a pop, are not included in that, and, that you must pay cash to be able to get any discount applied. So, for 2 soups, 2 sodas, a hero sandwich and the so said discount of $2.71- the bill came out to $24.18. Ah but so nice, on the bottom of the receipt it notes: Thank you for your patronage! Have a wonderful day and hope to see you back soon! Oh, and on the bottom, it notes, We Cater for All Occasions! (see pix*) read more

See all

Food was amazing and presentation was even better!!! An absolute pleasure to work with for our corporate catering !!

My husband and I LOVE Pantano's! Look no further for delicious sandwiches and salads, the BEST iced coffee on LI, and great Italian-style desserts. I ordered Pantano's for my sister and her healthcare team (She is a PA); they really went above and beyond to keep them nourished and ready to take on this virus. We are originally from New York, but recently moved to South Carolina - boy do we wish Pantano's would open here! There is a similar NY-style deli near by, but it does not even compare to the unique family-style that Pantano's deli has. Support local, family businesses! Especially during this time. Cheers! read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - An image of some of the sandwiches delivered. - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Thank goodness my brother lives in Hicksville! Even better, thank goodness his friends like to eat. My brother was asking around at work where he can find a good sandwich and long behold he was attacked with recommendations to try "Pantano's Eatery" at the Plainview Shopping Centre. He tried it and than recommend it to me. I guess word of mouth is great advertising. You shouldn't wait long to find parking, the lot is huge so it's a breeze. Looking at the building from the outside, you can tell this establishment means business. Going inside, the place looked modern and fresh. It was very clean and organized and that made my decision to stay and eat warranted. At the counter, the staff wasn't all to friendly. But they did take my order and than instructed me to have a seat. I made a quick run to one of a few chairs with cushion. My bottom thanked me while I waited for my meal. A lot of patrons walked in, received the food and left. Finally they called my name. I acknowledged I was there and they brought my meal to me. I finally had my wrap. I couldn't wait to try it. I was not disappointed. The chicken was breaded and had a tenderness to it that worked on the wrap. The bacon was crisp and crunchy. The Mozzarella stick was warm and gooey and the Mac and cheese was okay. This place is definitely on top with wraps. I definitely need to come and try more options. My only issue is I don't know what item to try next. Maybe it's best if I chose alphabetical read more

See all

10 stars if it was an option! We order from this place almost everyday and they never disappoint! Breakfast and lunch are always a go to for us and they deliver in record timing with no problems. If you're in the area definitely give them a try, its worth it! - The Staff at Perfect Pharmacy :) read more

Always warm and delicious, Pantanos is my go to lunch spot, since I work in the area. Occasionally I get ln early and have a nice breakfast. Luka is super friendly and always willing to take what you want! read more

I've been coming here for 10 years and have never been disappointed. The coffee is my favorite! They have thee best wraps and breakfast. I got all my coworkers at Lucid hooked on Pantano's read more

This place truly deserves more attention. Stopped by today and the food is amazing, staff is extremely friendly. I live in Staten Island and take the trip down often to grab Pantano's and it truly never ever disappoints. This is my go to spot always. Thanks guys! read more

I walked in, said give me your best wrap and after eating half I was like....Whoa, this tastes AMAZING! Not low on the calories, however the Food Comfort satisfaction rating far outweighed the calories. Well done. ER read more

Been coming here for years and always delicious! I usually get the Nico wrap but everything I've gotten there has always been good. The Nico wrap is for sure the Fire Pick for me. Staff is always friendly and store is very clean. The owner is an awesome guy and we always talk stocks. Actually made about 7k from some of his suggestions. Can't go wrong, eat delicious food and made money at the same time. It's a win win!!! read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - The Cathy Panini- chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato, American cheese, Russia/1,000 island Dressing - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Taking my Pantano's back to San Diego because it is THAT GOOD. The chicken parm wrap double-fried has become my new favorite, but everything on the menu (especially the penne a la vodka and homemade spinach dip) are out of this world. Favorite place to visit when i'm in Plainview! Highly recommend!!!! read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Taking my Pantano's back to San Diego! - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

This place is incredible. Me and my best friend come here once a week for lunch/breakfast. The guys behind the scenes are always the sweetest and kindest. The food is fantastic. A+ read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Crumb cake coffee. And bacon egg and cheese! - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Warning Yelpers!! The cashback offer DOES NOT work here. I unlocked the 15% off offer and it does not work!! In addition, Pantano charged me a 5% credit card fee. Yelp and Pantano refused to refund me the 20%. I will NEVER return to Pantano's because of this. read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Sneak in a service charge by posting this on a register thats not in use. - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

So I was in Modells getting some items and over heard some employees talking about how delicious their lunch was, I asked what place they got the food from since we needed to get lunch. We are so glad we came here, everything we got was so delicious. My friend got the Big John, my sister got the Megan and I got the Gabby!! Everyone there was friendly and store is very clean. It's new go to spot especially that I learned they delivery and serve breakfast all day long!! Take my word for it you need to try Pantano's. FYI kind of hard to find the store since all the stores look the same but it's between Denny's Kids and GNC read more

I ordered in from here with a few people. We got 2 taco salads, a Caesar salad, chicken fingers and a spinach dip appetizer. The chicken fingers were your typical diner food kids meal and tasted fine. The Caesar salad was doused in dressing and the lettuce was mostly wilted. The taco salads did not look appetizing at all. Someone basically threw some brown lettuce and wilted tomatoes into a tin with a heaping amount of overcooked chop meat. The result was a greasy mess that no one would be proud of. The spinach dip appetizer was the worst part of the meal. If it wasn't floating in a pool of oil, it may have been tasty. I was able to spoon out over 1/4 cup of oil off the top of it. Never again. read more

See all

I normally do not write reviews, however, Pantanos is a place that deserves the appraise. I ordered a chicken cutlet sandwich and eggs. The chicken was of stellar quality, the chicken melted in my mouth. You can tell the chicken was made from scratch and not frozen. The eggs were also fantastic. The owner of this place is also super friendly and takes pride in customer satisfaction. I highly recommend ordering at pantanos! read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

Nice little lunch spot in a strip mall with a big parking lot. Brought home two wraps for about $10 each- the big john and the spicy melissa. I preferred the spicy melissa (buff chicken, spicy ranch, fries, mac n cheese) to the big john (chicken, fries, gravy, mozzarella) which was still good but got a little dry by the time I came home (but I imagine it would be great for dine-in). Would definitely come back for the spicy melissa or to try other wraps. read more

The food here is great, I have been coming here a long time and the staff is very friendly. All my friends enjoy the food and like to come here. Deliveries are fast and always on time. read more

Absolutely delicious! Found this place on a whim and AM I GLAD I DID! If you're in the area definitely stop here!

Where do I even begin? I am a frequent customer and their sandwiches are out of this world!!! The spicy Melissa gets me every time after a bad day, in need of some comfort food. All the 3 best comfort items in one dish - buff chicken, mac&cheese, and fries! The employees are so cordial too and never make you wait dreadfully long. If you are in the area I highly recommend giving it a try! read more

Went here for lunch while visiting Long Island. Ended up getting a Burnside sandwich (chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella, honey mustard). It was delicious. The chicken cutlet is top-notch. It came with a side pasta salad. Also got an iced coffee, half regular half crumb cake. Needless to say, it was perfect. Won't hesitate to go back. They have a ton of sandwiches on the board that I'd love to try. Lastly, the customer service here is really amazing. Really nice people! read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Burnside with a side pasta salad - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

So I usually go to Pantano's in Uniondale and was expecting the level of food quality of that location and yeah, that's not what I got. This location isn't great. Located in a DISASTER of a parking lot (not their fault), the menu is tiny compared to Uniondale and the food isn't really great. Food was bland and tasteless. Service sucked. Restaurant wasn't super clean. Ate there and almost all the tables were dirty. I got a wrap that was far from being worth $12. Just wasn't impressed at all. Wouldn't return to this location. read more

Food is GREAT here. However, I cannot rate more than because of a shady business practice. This place charges 4% to use a credit card, and bills it's menu prices as "cash incentive price" . Me I highly doubt 4% is the processing fee assessed by the credit card companies for this business to accept payment, so this restaurant is essentially profiting on a service not provided by themselves. Bring cash if you want to eat here. read more

It's a regular stop for me. The coffee is delicious. The staff is super nice and the sandwiches are delicious. The Anderson is one of my favorites for lunch. For breakfast everything's been pretty good. Love me a good sausage egg and cheese and they don't disappoint. Their bagels, when you ask for them toasted, are fantastic. Try a BLT with mayo on a toasted bagel, it's delicious!!! Come here once a day at least, and even more than once a day on multiple occasions. Their salads and pasta dishes are pretty satisfying too. read more

Their food is ok, but nothing very memorable for the price. I've mostly ordered sandwiches from here. The price is not bad for the portion you get but the quality wasn't that great and I wondered if it was worth paying more than I would at Subway for the same amount of sandwich. I ordered a pasta from here once and it was not so good. The shrimp that came with the pasta was actually cooked well. However, the pasta and the sauce tasted like something you get from a middle school cafeteria. Very bland, very generic. The pasta was way too mushy. Overall, the food wasn't absolutely terrible but the existence of other quality lunch options in the area makes this place less appealing. The service is fine, never had a problem with placing long orders for an office lunch. I wouldn't order from here again if I had other options. read more

I've gotten sandwiches from here a few times now, and am always very pleased with what I get. I've had both paninis and regular sandwiches, as well as the spicy fries (which i highly recommend)! Ever since I first tried the spicy fries, I won't get a sandwich without ordering these too-very tasty! I do wish they had a few more simpler options on the menu. They have lots of interesting combinations, but not too many that I personally prefer. Overall though, I think this is a great lunch spot if you live in the area! read more

I found this little spot through groupon. I thought it would be a diner type of a place but it isn't and it is more like a deli. A big NO in my book are places that change their prices from their menu and doesn't inform their customers of their new prices. A 2 dollar increase is significant enough to notify the customer of the price difference. Becareful and definitely price check before ordering. The food isn't bad and above average. If you are looking for a quick bite this is a great place and nothing fancy. read more

See all

The staff is very friendly and the food is very good. You can call ahead and your take out bye waiting for you

The grilled cheese is unmatched from pantanos ! Always greeted with friendly and fast service. Would absolutely recommend

This is a deli located across from Dr. Pardeshi's psychiatric outpatient office we medical students go for learning on our suny rotations. By the way, he is excellent! This deli has all the favorites. Tuna, egg, and chicken salads together with creative sides like bow tie pasta and even excellent rice pudding. Snapple iced teas are there, even peach! My egg salad was super creamy and the rice pudding was extra thick and cinnamony (this is a new adjective by the way!)! So if you want a real deli NYC experience, make sure to come! read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Fresh standard deli fare! Snapple, egg salad, and actually incredible rice pudding! - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Overall a very good local spot with pretty good food. Most of the things I've tried from here taste good, but sometimes service is lacking, slow delivery, mistakes on items, etc, but they always make it right. Not perfect, but for a place that makes so many different items, you'd be hard pressed to find something significantly better. read more

Nice deli sandwich plenty of stuff inside. Fast service. Nice decor for a deli though