Never ever a bad experience with this place. I order from them regularly. The food is always fresh and good, delivered timely. Great selection of menu items. Best sandwiches in Long Island !!!! Always my number one go to spot . They're number one in the game and I put that on everything , this is the place you wanna be when you looking for a good meal So many options to choose from, so there's something here for everyone. Great option for the heavy, carby cravings as almost everything is very greasy. Their Shrimp parm hero with vodka sauce is a classic. Be prepared to feel full after! Great deli, fast service, prices aren't too bad either for a giant hero. Great spot, great food, great service. Stop sleeping on this joint my friends. read more

I got the phil special (roast beef on garlic bread). It was ok (definitely not garlicky enough). Fries were great. Also got 1/2 lemonade and 1/2 iced tea to quench my thirst and it did just that. My sister in law got a greek omelette. It didn't look like anything special. read more

Came here based on really good reviews for this place ! We we're starving and ready for lunch. The menu was very extensive with lots of choices from burgers to wraps to Paninis. It was very hard to choose just one ! I got a sandwich that was like a chicken parmesan. It had beaded chicken, cheese and I ordered side of fries to go with them. My chicken was a little dry but had really good flavors. The fries were perfection ! Perfectly crispy and seasoned very well. My family got a variety of wraps and sandwiches and they enjoyed their meals as well. My husband got a free cookie too when he didn't have have a dollar on him so they just gave it to him free of charge! Great people + great food :) read more

See all

First time trying this place and gotta say it was pretty good. They offer a wide variety of food including breakfast, burgers, salads, amd a ton of diffenent yummy wraps, paninis, amd heros. We got two wraps and split them which was plenty of food considering all the portions are large. The five-o wrap was a pretty good riblet wrap. However there was a ton of bbq sauce on there and you couldnt taste anything else in the wrap. The second wrap we got was the big john which was very fatty but good. Chicken was cooked very nice and the gravy and fries added a nice flavor. Staff was friendly and place offered alot of nice sides as well if you wanted. read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Big john wrap - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

Decided to try out this place today. Wait time was a bit long and the food was certainly not worth the wait. I ordered the Buffalo stuffed flatbread with a side of regular fries. This was the soggiest food I had ever been served. Fries were ice cold and the sandwich was drenched in way too much sauce. Absolutely disgusting. I only went because the food looked delicious on their Instagram page, but never again, take your business elsewhere. read more

The food tastes decent but nothing great. The size of the wrap was so small ,had almost nothing in it and costs over $12. We encountered the rudest worker who I think was the owner . I am not sure why you would want to be nasty to your customers. I asked a question about our order and he replied with an attitude problem. I would never go back. There are so many better places to choose from. read more

Everything is always so fresh and delicious! We order Pantano's weekly and are always more than satisfied! The staff is always very friendly! read more

No frills, but all possible options type of deli. We came here just looking for a quick lunch and I was kind of taken aback by how many options they had for both sandwiches and sides. You can't have beer with your lunch, but that's the only downside I was able to find. Parking was a breeze because it's located in a shopping mall area and the employees were super friendly. I would absolutely come back here if I were in the area. read more

Yesterday I ordered 3 Penne Alla vodka. The one I ordered was with chicken cutlet and the others were with grilled chicken and onions. My gf and her sister were disappointed with their pasta because it was lacking flavor and overcooked according to them. My pasta with the cutlet on the other hand was good and I really enjoyed it. Today a guy from the restaurant which I'm assuming is the owner calls my gf to confront her about the 1 star review that HER SISTER left yesterday and was accusing us of bashing his restaurant's food! Very professional, right? One time my gf had ordered pasta because it's the only thing we order from here and the pasta lacked vodka sauce and was undercooked or so we picked it up 40 minutes later like the owner states with a very nice attitude that he has. My gf never gave this restaurant a 1 star review until now and so am I. Despite this man giving us attitude in the past... we were still ordering food here. He was going on a rant about the 1 star review. Listen man... everyone has the right to their opinions. If my gf's sister was unhappy with the pasta, you should've responded to her review and ask if you can do anything to satisfy her need like a professional does. He made himself look bad, not only did you NOT satisfy your customers, you didn't handle the situation properly afterwards either! Calling my gf and then yelling and going on a rant about how you think we're trying to make your business look bad??? You officially lost ME as a customer as well. Good luck to your business. Plus...From other reviews that I've read from this restaurant not satisfying other customers ... the man CLEARLY has issues admitting to his errors and harassing people who give him bad reviews. Do better for you and your restaurant's sake! I regret wasting my money at this restaurant. read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Penne Alla Vodka - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

My coworkers order from here time to time and I decided to come here on a lunch break with my fiancé. The menu is pretty extensive from breakfast items, salads, apps, sandwiches, paninis and wraps just to name a few things. I decided to go for the Max wrap in a whole wheat wrap with a side of seasoned fries. The Max wrap was like an eggplant parm in a wrap. It had thin sliced and fried eggplant with melted fresh mozzarella in a pink creamy tomato sauce. The seasoned fries were a great compliment to the wrap. They were nice and crispy and the seasoning was on point. We ordered a medium size and it was a good amount to share between the two of us. There is a small eating area with tables and a side bartop to eat at in the front. Also there is plenty of parking as it is located inside a shopping center. read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Seasoned fries (medium size) with the Max wrap - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

The best sandwiches ever. Freshly cooked food. Very clean place. Love the roast beef!!!!

Ordered custom ommlette platter (9$) and ham egg and cheese sandwich ($5). But I was missing my home fries so I called. He said he never charged me for home fries, so I asked how my ommlette came out to be $9.81, when the custom ommlette is only $5.99 with 2 free toppings. I requested bacon ($1.50) and ham ($1.50) as the 2 free toppings SPECIFICALLY. AND THEN I ADDED MUSHROOM, PEPPER, AND CHEDDAR CHEESE WHICH WAS AROUND $1.50 ISH EXTRA TOTAL. Then he said the two free topping price was applied onto pepper and mushroom BLATANTLY instead of the bacon and ham I requested for. I was so shocked how they just managed to bs their way into charging me more by extra $3.80 and do nothing about my missing home fries. Unreal treatment to the customers. read more

I've been wanting to try here for a long time. I got the famous Gabby wrap and it was great! Definitely one of the places that actually fits the Instagram hype. The staff was nice and wore masks and gloves. Definitely will be back! read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - The Gabby ( Top 5 Seller ) - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

I gave 2 stars because they have been good in the past but to pass this off as a roast beef hero is sad. read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Where's the beef??!! - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Love their food here for lunch. The wraps and paninis are delicious. Highly recommend this spot.

The service here is friendly and efficient, with staff members who genuinely care about making your meal enjoyable. They are quick to accommodate special requests and provide helpful recommendations. read more

I love Pantano's Eatery breakfast, Lunch or taking food home for dinner is amazing each time The sandwiches are fresh and they make anything you may want to eat I had the most amazing Roast Beef sandwich today it was the best Thank you to the wonderful staff and owner always smiling and happy to see you Thank you again, Joyce Friiedman read more

Been coming here for years and always happy with anything that I got. I'm currently on the Teriyaki Rice wrap kick, get it a few times a week and is always delicious. I suggest adding some cheddar cheese to the wrap!! Recently we had Pantanos cater my brothers graduation party and everything was so delicious! We love love I mean love this place read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - The delicious Teriyaki chicken wrap and I add cheddar to it. Omg!!! - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

My husband and I went to Pantano's for lunch today. The owner was so helpful as it was our first time there. We decided on salami with cheese, lettuce and tomato. The sandwich was filled with meat. We will definitely be going back to try more things off the menu. read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

No value for the money. Over priced. I paid $8 for a sad BLT. For $8 i expected more? Seemed like they were cheap on all the ingredients that make a BLT, even the mayo **i gave an additional star as Pantano's reached out to fix the situation. I also added a photo of the receipt to show the charge of 7.99 for the BLT. read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Classic BLT Sandwich - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

Amazing food. And great service. Get the griller with chipotle. The best lunch. read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Warps & Everything Wraps! This spot is official if u looking to stuff your stomach w/ delicious wrap creations! This is da spot! The menu can be super overwhelming, SoOo much toO choice from! Take your time, no one is rushing you.. There is a Daily lunch specials menu also. The portions are huge & good.. it's one of those meals that doesn't leaving wanting more. It's as satisfying as it looks! The spot has limited seating located inside a shopping center w/ plenty of parking. Grab & Go kind of spot! FYI: 10% off entire meal! With yelp "Check-in" Restrooms available on premises! read more

I use this place regularly for catering for work lunches and accounts in the area. I usually pick up my orders but they have delivery. Nice selection from hot to cold dishes, beverages up the whazzoo, salads, sandwiches, pasta and everything in between. All items made fresh daily, made to order and you can dine in or take out. Competitive prices, friendly staff and convenient location. Parking lot can be a little hairy so take caution when driving around. read more

Don't hesitate to call Pantano's to cater your next event. This is my 2nd time having a party catered by them and once again the food was amazing and price was fair. I know if I order from them the food will always be good! read more

Let me dig my self in PANTANOS!!!!!!!! Omg Omg cheat day out everyday, the have all kinds of varieties in sandwiches, wraps, salad, pasta, baked goods. Yummmmm! You name it, they have it. Perfect for cravings, stuffiness and food coma! Hahaha and if you want to be more in the health side they have a food coma for that too, you can create your own as well. Am just going stuff my self every time I'll be here.... been honest. How can you say no to fresh food, made on the spot for your satisfaction. They are a small spot clean and on point. My new favorite place. The owner is really accommodating and welcoming, together with his staff it makes the place so cozy and even comfortable with kids. ++++. You should deft try if around the area, I was going to wait to write the review but I know I need to spread the word and I can't hold my self. Lol really enjoy!!!! read more

See all

Yummy...my wife and I ordered chicken sandwiches yesterday for delivery and and a kids Mac n Cheese. She said it was the best wrap she has had. I was shocked, she doesn't usually like wraps that I order. read more

Way Too Overpriced! I paid $20 for a wrap and 4 piece chicken tenders! I was supposed to get a pasta salad on the side with my sandwich and when I left the store, the gentleman that took care of me never bothered to check to see if everything was inside. Quickly rushed my order without any utensils. However, I did get the Megan (or Melissa wrap, forgot what it was called) and it was very delicious. If you're a chicken parm guy and you're into mac and cheese with vodka sauce, this is your go to. I'd go back but proceed with caution because your wallet will pay a hefty fee! read more

Great good! Small inside and hurried but we were able to get a table and enjoyed our sandwiches!

I visited Pantano's Eatery because it was a place that was convenient for me to take out. I ordered the Chicken Vodka Hero and the portion was huge! Tasted great and would recommend to any locals nearby looking for a place to order take out from. read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Chicken Vodka Hero - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

Food is excellent and service was very good. Staff is helpful and courteous, menu also has great variety. Definitely will be returning. read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - Menu boards - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

This place is what cheat day dreams are made of. It's sick, and I love it. My husband and I split two sandwiches. We got the *crazy rich* which has chicken cutlet, cheddar, bacon, (switched up the ranch for RUSSIAN), and french fries....all smooshed up in a wrap. Also, *the gabby* wrap which had chicken cutlet, mac n cheese, bacon, and mozz sticks. Just as incredible as it sounds, melty, just over indulgent goodness. Dreaming of it now.......As crazy as these wraps are, I saw a normal human ordering what looked like a healthy and delicious salad. Plus there are so many choices, you can get a regular sandwich too. Huge parking lot. Took a bit of time for the wraps to come, but it was worth it as they were h o t and f r e s h !!! read more

See all

Pantanos is my go to. Obsessed with their Hungry man hero. All their lunch sandwiches are incredible too. Today I'll try their pancakes. Besides the occasionally lightly over toasted bread this restaurant is FIRE. Try the ice tea and lemonade. Oh. And super fast delivery. Those pancakes are here I gotta run. Edit: pancakes are dope. read more

I'm new to the area and tried this place for lunch. Every that I have purchased so far has been very tasty and just the way I like it. Service is always excellent! Only gave 4 stars because I haven't tried everything as of yet. read more

Place is a joke. Overpriced skimpy sandwiches. The owner writes fake reviews to boost his business. He also posts on the Facebook group DINE LI, pretending to be a customer and raving about the food. Tool read more

Always an excellent sandwich. I recently ordered for a large group and everyone loved lunch!

Pantano's is truly one of my favorite quick stops for lunch while working my shift in the plaza. Always makes food on point and always ready to serve with whatever we need. Even catering!! The service is A+ and the gentlemen who work there are so sweet. Thanks for all you do!! read more

Ordered and got my wrap in probably a little over 5 mins. The guys working behind the counter were very nice. I ordered the Rob wrap: buffalo chicken, fresh mozzarella, jalapeños and lettuce. It came with blue cheese too, but I asked for it without it. The buffalo chicken in the wrap was really delicious, just the right amount of sauce. The spice level of the wrap was probably medium, not really spicy, but enjoyable. Since the wrap was hot the lettuce got soft, and I don't really like hot lettuce. So next time I would definitely ask for the wrap without it. But it was still very tasty. I'm definitely going to come back, they have some other wraps and paninis i want to try! read more

Pantano's Deli Plainview - The rob wrap no bleu cheese - Italian Near Me - Plainview, New York

John Luca and the Entire Pantanos team are amazing! Go out of their way to provide great service and the food is Amazing! You truly get your moneys worth. read more

I love this place. I order from here all the time. Very reasonable price for good tasting food. They have a lot to choose from as well. They have a broad menu and you can tell they've taken time to prefect it because some of their sandwich options, you wouldn't think go well together but they do. I get the Spicy Mellisa quite often and it's always great. Lately, I've been ordering egg sandwiches to try and eat healthier and I miss the items that I used to try. I order from this place usually twice a week. I recommend you do as well. read more

Food was amazing and presentation was even better!!! An absolute pleasure to work with for our corporate catering !!