Amazing bakery and sandwich shop. The portions are so generous. They have the best rainbow cookies. Sooooo good. read more

Paneantico Bakery - House salad with Grilled Chicken House and Pastrami, Swiss, Mustard on Brick oven bread - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best pastries around, always make a stop when we go through Brooklyn. Not to be missed. Cheesecakes are DIVINE.

Extremely good sandwiches. Great cakes, cookies and pastries. My only complaint when eating there is the service needs improvement. The waitresses always seem overwhelmed even when the place is not crowded. It could be due to lack of supervision but for such a good place the customers should receive better. read more

Late night snack craving for rainbow cookies, closest place to me that was open. Super yummy, can't complain! The cappuccino was pretty good too. My only complaint is the customer service was terrible. I wanted just rainbow cookies and a cappuccino so I ordered it standing up, wanted to sit down for a few minutes, so the lady told me I had to sit down and order... read more

Love this place for baked items - great donuts, pastries, and eclairs. I really love the simple elongated sugar donut - I think it has a special name, but I'm not sure. All I do is go there and point. And don't forget the chocolate bread - delicious! The service is friendly, fast, and efficient. I've been here 3 or 4 times and will probably go another 2-3 times before I go back to Oregon. If you are ever in Bay Ridge, don't miss going to Paneantico. read more

Every time I come here you'd think they were swamped with orders and people at the counter. LOL The waitress is always winded like she's juggling 8 tables alone. This use to be the spot. I dont know what happened. The coffee is not the same; it takes longer to drink. Its overly milked. I never thought someone could f*%k up eggs, but they sure can here. ‍ I left today hungry after they jacked up a regular coffee with milk order. Once I got my botched coffee order, I remembered, the last time I was here, they messed up my egg order. Stick to the counter stuff: muffins, pastries, bread, ready-cooked dishes. Sit down eating is a bust. read more

The food is great but the service is downright terrible. I have been here about a dozen times and have always enjoyed the food but it is like pulling teeth trying to get anything. Nobody greets you, seats you, or offers you a menu without an act of congress. I've been inside, on the patio, alone, or with a group, same experience every time. Order takeout unless you like feeling invisible. read more

Paneantico Bakery - Salad with chicken cutlet, cappuccino - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Magnificent food Magnificent deli people Magnificent counter girls Magnificent waitress service ! read more

After passing by this place 10+ times, I finally had the courage to try it for lunch. I ordered the (Ham, Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers). The order was huge for one person but absolutely delicious. Also ordered a hot chocolate, (I know simple) but it didn't taste ordinary. Everything was made with love, just wish there was more room on the table for my huge sandwich but thank you Paneantico! read more

Paneantico Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I love this little place, my husband and I went here today for breakfast and it was absolutely beautiful delicious. I don't like to have a BIG breakfast in the morning, just my coffee is fine, so I went for the croissant and cheese platter, it was great! It even comes with a tea cup full of blueberries, strawberries and raspberries. My hubby got the "Joes omelette" not sure what's in it, but he liked it. read more

See all

It makes me sad to give them 3 stars because they do have good food. Can't speak to the bakery part (too sweet for my palate). The outdoor seating is lovely especially with covid but everything they use is disposable from cutlery, water cups with lid and straw and even plastic containers for sauces. Why? When we are striving for renewable energy, zero waste etc to help our planet. It's not a future problem but a now problem. It makes no sense to use throwaways when dining in?! read more

Love the pastries! The salads hugeee even for a small. But service sucks! Been here multiple times. I'm allll about service. Was there on a Saturday which I've had the worse waitress out of all times. I basically served myself, while she watched. and saw her on the phone while I needed her to check out. Oh and that "service fee" Is credit card fee which is extremely unreasonable. My bill was $32. And the fee was $1 and change. read more

Service is terrible. I don't understand why they have table service if it's faster to just grab what you need and sit down. I waited 10 minutes for someone to come bring a different dressing(I was waiting at the counter!). This isn't about their food-they do have fantastic Italian pastries. Service is really lacking. read more

I have been here many times and each and every time I come in the service is worse. We sat at our table for 25 mins nobody came over to us, no water, no menus, no acknowledgement. We motioned to one of the workers and asked if we could have a waitress come over and give us menus he nodded his head and we waited 10 more mins and then decided to just leave. The only reason I keep coming back here is because the food is really good but this time was just so ridiculous we left. read more

See all

Ok they are trying to improve their system . Someone is paying attention . Food can be good to great depending . Congratulations

Today we waited 30 min to get a wrong order. Don't worry because they didn't forget to charge us for it. Place is turning into an absolute dump. read more

The food is excellent but the system in place to pick up pre-order is ridiculous. You shouldn't have to wait in line 15 minutes or more to pick up a sandwich that was ordered 20 minutes ago. The sandwich just sits there for how long while you wait behind people picking out cookies. So stooooooopid! Dumb dumb dumb. read more

Great Bay Ridge sandwich shop and pastries too! Corner location with seating outside. Large menu for lunch and many variations salad and Italian hero's hot and cold. Sandwich can be made on different types of bread and also available to go. read more

Paneantico Bakery - Arugula Salad and Fried Chicken Cutlet, Fried Chicken, Mozzarella, Fried Eggplant (Brick Oven) - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Overall HORRIBLE service, I waited in line as directed to place an order and as I came up to the window several people cam up in front saying they had to pick up, but the person earlier was directed to the rear of the line. When I asked to speak to a manager some snippy tean said she was the manager, but doubtful. When asked to speak to the owner they simply applied Not here. Well I was going to place an order for my office staff, but rather chose to leave and never return to this HORRID place. read more

Panentico is my favorite sandwich place! My absolute favorite is the mozzarella and prosciutto sandwich. I could eat this sandwich everyday! I love that they give you this amazing balsamic sauce on the side to deep your sandwich. But even thought I love the food here so much the service sucks!! terrible waitress, it looks like they do not know what they are doing, and they take forever to take the orders. I would give the food 5 stars but the service needs to improve. I was waiting for a table for almost 30 minutes that I got up and left. I was so angry that I did not get to eat my sandwich that day! read more

Paneantico Bakery - Mozzarella and Prosciutto, Mozzarella (Brick Oven) - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have to say how disappointed I am. We went for dinner and there were only 4 tables there and the server was so obsessed with her cell phone. We waited so long to have our order taken. I eventually went to the counter to complete my own order. There were 6 people all together behind the counter and they were more concerned with talkiNg with Each other than their jobs. In addition to all that, the food was so dry. I'm so disappointed. read more

Great place for good sandwiches and fresh baked goods. One negative is it's always crowded so try to go on off hours. read more

Paneantico Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Delicious coffee and the sandwiches is to die for.. the pastries is always fresh . Love this place

Not just a bakery but also great food! Their house salad, their eggplant parm, their bread- gluttony at its best! It's also has a great family and neighborhood vibe as they have been around forever. Def worth stopping by, you won't regret it read more

I ordered a sandwich. The guy making the sandwich was wearing gloves, he was in the middle of preparing the sandwich when he dropped his cellphone, picked it up from the floor, did not changed his gloves and kept on making the sandwich. Should I have said something? Yes! but It was late, and I was tired, so I didn't want to get into it; But still, the costumer should not have to be in that situation. I would not order sandwiches here if I were you. read more

Their sandwiches are amazing. It's always super busy (for good reason!) and space is limited but when I'm in good company I don't mind. Be prepared to wait for things. Staff seems a bit overwhelmed at times. There is no organization you just kind of sit down and hope for the best. Sometimes I feel like they should do away with wait service altogether and make it a grab and go joint. That brick oven bread and homemade balsamic though... 4 stars because of food quality, friendly though not very attentive service, and you know what you get when you come here so if you expect something else...fuggedaboutit! read more

See all

Delicious assortments of sandwich creations along with interior design and radio choice. NOTE: 3.5 stars review (see service*) Paneantico is a good spot to get a sandwich fix. The menu is huge! Two pages (long in height, short in width) of sandwiches in small font (less than times new roman 12?). All with the choice of either brick oven, Neapolitan, soft, fiber hero. Seated ourselves and the waitress comes after a decent wait for our drinks. When she delivered the waters, she tossed the straws on the table. Okay... shrugged it off. Then came our sandwiches and they looked great. Plus they didn't take too long to arrive. -- Ordered the: pastrami with mustard, swiss on oven toasted bread: real nice dose of mustard. May not be to some people's liking, but my friend appreciated it. Really neat sandwich to hold onto and tasty. The bread was great, crunchy exterior with a soft interior. salami with arugula, provolone, roasted peppers on fiber bread: felt dry because of the bread, but a nice dose of olive oil did the trick. Roasted peppers with the salami were a tasteful combination and the arugula was a refreshing crunch in each bite. grilled chicken with mozzarella, roasted peppers on soft bread: nice hefty slices of mozzarella to go with the peppers. Chicken was a little dry, but it wasn't too noticeable with the other ingredients. Very filling because of the chicken. The soft bread took some time to chew through, so heads up for those who have braces or a soft jaw like me. I think this sandwich with brick oven bread would've been a phenomenal combination. Overall, best choice of the dine in. *Now, the largest gripe that knocks off the star, service. Our waitress came by once when we were 80% done to ask how our food was. Not attentive to my table at all. Instead, she stayed in the back with her colleagues and chatted it up. Then, she assumed we were done so she delivers our bill. Didn't ask if we wanted additional drinks or whatever. Luckily we were done and ready to leave; risky assumption there. Visibly left my card with the bill towards the aisle waiting for her to take it, she takes about 10 minutes to come through. Really poor service compared to the attentive waitress to the table in front of us. If you're yearning for a good sandwich fix, this is a good choice. Tasty and large in size. Mostly $10+, but you get your money's worth with the quality of sandwiches and bread selection. However, note that service maybe dreadful. Really hope you luck out with the waitress and my experience of their service is better next time around. Shame the service trashes the beautiful and tasty sandwiches, tsk tsk tsk. read more

See all

So sad to update my prior review but my experience there was nothing like I've had before. Long story short (and it was LONG) - stopped in, girl at counter said seat yourself, we sat ourselves and the frazzled waitress didn't stop by once in the 10-15 mins we were there. I went inside and asked same girl at counter for a menu, she gave me one and said waitress would be right there. 15 minutes later, no waitress, we went inside and ordered to go. 20 minutes later we had our food. 15 minutes later we got home, opened the sandwiches and they were not even CLOSE to what we ordered. Called paneantico, asked them to deliver a corrected order, they said no delivery boy. Asked for a refund, they gave me the manager who said we had to bring the sandwiches back in for a refund. LOL seriously at this business tactic. We walked them back because why waste $30 on an order we weren't planning on eating. The young girl at the counter was sweet and polite, but the poor, poor soul of a manager with a scowl on his face was not so much. They proceeded to take the sandwiches from us and put them to the side before refunding our card. I hope they didn't reuse the sandwiches or take them home with them. I licked the inside! Haha just kidding, but how funny would it have been if I did??? As we were walking out, other male employee mocked us by repeating "have a nice night" until we were out of ear shot. Real mature, guy. Anyway, this turned out to be a longer story than intended. Do yourself a favor and take advantage of the many other options in bay ridge with decent human beings working there. Wishing you guys better luck! read more

Sunday brunch! It's so nice to sit outside on a beautiful sunny day. Big portions on their platters. Got the omelete with spinach mushroom and cheese.....did they make it with like 4 eggs?! Thing was like a monster, also came with a huge stash of fries, and a whole bagel! The almond latte was good, but the flower they made didnt not look too appealing HAHA. After the meal, went inside and walked through a mile long showcase of desserts, pastries and bread, I left with my tummy full and my trunk full, LOL. read more

Paneantico Bakery - Kids were hungry! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Went for lunch Sunday outdoor service was horrible, service forgot to put in order then after 40 min of waiting only omelet came out with order of bacon , not very good! ! Also guy makin the food is always angry ! It use to be a great spot but I wouldn't recommend it! read more

I've been coming here for years! The food here is great. The service, not so much. Their slogan should be: Come for lunch, stay (for an extra hour) as you try and flag down your server for the check. Let's start with the food: Breakfast: I can't imagine why people would ever opt for the diner, Bridgeview for breakfast. Paneantico offers 'real' eggs for breakfast - whether it's in an omelette of your choice, or in a sandwich - paired with bacon or italian sausage. The downside to breakfast, however, is that management must only get 10 croissants delivered each morning - because it's almost funny to ask for one after 9AM. Same goes for english muffins. We usually go through a song and dance with the waitress: "I'll have a bacon egg and cheese on a croissant" "Oh, we just ran out of croissants" "Ok, can I have that on an english muffin?" "Ok let me check......oh, we ran out of english muffins..." ". . . Ok....uhhh....a roll?" If you're just looking to nibble on something, their blueberry crumb muffins are to die for. This must be where the hashtag nomnomnom originated from. Lunch: Probably what they're most known for, their huge sandwiches will fill up just about anyone. A large menu filled with italian delights. Eventually, you'll be able to memorize and order the Letter and Number next to your shortlist of favorites. N93 for the win. The hero the sandwiches usually come on is pretty hard to bite into, so unless you enjoy cutting the roof of your mouth, ask for a soft roll - just as yummy, and you won't leave bleeding. Coffee & Dessert Pastries are amazing. Despite the vast selection, Sfogliatella and american cheesecake are our personal go-tos. Their cookies are also top-notch and will please any household family gathering. Although they may get overlooked, try the lemon raspberry cookies (buried in the back) - if you're in to lemon. Their regular raspberry cookies are the bomb too. When it comes to cappuccinos, Paneantico remains supreme and untouchable. Always super tasty, with enveloping, fluffy milk and a nice dash of cinnamon. Their iced coffee is a staple in the summer as well. The downfall: The Ambiance and Service: This place is loud - and really packs 'em in here, and always has a line for pastries or sandwiches to go. Which means if you're at one of the tables hugging the in-store line, you WILL get banged into, hovered over and generally, just feel claustrophobic by the entire Bay Ridge population waiting for cookies. If you get any other table inside the place, be prepared to get to know everything about your neighboring diners, as you will be sitting on top of them (no space between tables). During the summer, outside dining is quite lovely - now that they finally cleaned up that sewer and sinkhole. How people were able to eat sandwiches outdoors in the summer ingesting the scent of raw sewage is beyond me - but now that that's all cleared up, it's a great place to people and dog-watch in the warm weather. Finally, the service is why this place gets a 3 instead of 5 stars. Yes, it's that terrible. You will never...ever, see your waitress again upon delivery of your food - that is, if someone ever comes over to you with menus in the first place. There have been countless times that we've sat ourselves - waited, 10, 15, 20 minutes, and then just left. If you do get served, be prepared to wait an additional half hour (minimum) as you try and hunt down your server. They will usually hide in the back, and generally just try and run away if they see you wave for the check. This is especially true in the summer if you want to enjoy the outside seating. A tip, ask for your check once your food comes out - it may actually come to you by the time you're done eating! read more

Paneantico Bakery - Cappuccino's are untouchable! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

One of my all-time favorite places! Everything is so fresh, the BEST pastries in Brooklyn!

I moved out of Bay Ridge about 5 years ago, but when I knew I had to be in the area for the day- I knew I had to stop and get a chocolate croissant from Paneantico! It was even better then what I remember!!! I'm glad to see the quality of food is still amazing and the customer service is still exceptional!! read more

It kills me to give such a mediocre rating to a place that usually has delicious food and coffee. Their baked goods have no competition in bay ridge - but their service is horrendous. They mess up your orders (even if they aren't complicated) the wait time is mind boggling. Even if you call in to pick it up, add an extra twenty minutes to the time they give you. I have stood there for over twenty minutes waiting for a simple sandwich for take out.... they either need more staff or a better system of waiting on their customers. Every time I go in there during the evening my mind is blown by how incompetent and slow the service is. I feel like it's a prank and there is a hidden camera somewhere that is waiting to jump out and say it's a joke. Don't get me wrong the food is delicious. The bread is amazing and the baked goods are the best. That's why we keep going back and every time I fall for it! That's why it's always crowded and that's how it's such a booming business but they seriously need to work on their service. read more

I would stay away from this place if you watch prices on baked goods. I wanted to buy a lb of Pignoli Cookies that are expensive at $18.00 per lb. Not here... they are $28.00 a lb, more than a Ribeye Steak. A single sesame cookie was $4.00. I have had breakfast here and prices are reasonable. Baked goods are way over priced. read more

Paneantico Bakery - $4.00 cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Finally, I realized why service is slow, whether you take-out or dine-in. There is 1 cash register. I have shopped here and dined here a handful of times within the last decade. Tonight, I order a lobster-tail pastry to go. Another man is trying to change $1 for coins. There are a few ladies behind the counter. I say "hi ladies" hoping to get FAST service. I did, and the man mumbled something about my cutting him (in line). He did get there 1 second before me. I do dread patronizing this establishment JUST because of slow service. Guess I am used to the bakeries in Chinatown where patrons don't always know the concept of a LINE and the cashiers are QUICK to get you in & out of their business. read more

Where do you want to go? Well...I want to stay local but I want to try someplace new too. So we stumbled upon this all-in-one place. We started off with the Turkey, Mozzerella and Roasted Pepper on brick oven bread with a little bit of balsamic vinegar. Sure, the price isn't cheap but, man, this sandwich was H-U-G-E. The bread was slightly warm with a nice crunchy exterior. The balsamic vinegar that absorbed into the bread made this one finger lickin' good sandwich (I hear that the balsamic is their own secret recipe). Definitely one of the best sandwiches I've had as of late. I couldn't decide what to have for dessert so he said, why not a little of everything? We sampled the rainbow cookies, chocolate cheesecake, mini red velvet cupcake, strawberry shortcake and the napoleon. I also had a cup of cappuccino with skim milk. I am a girl who loves sweets but meh, I've had better. The only 'okay' desserts out of the batch were the strawberry shortcake and the napoleon. Service was helpful and quick. The decor is simple and casual. Definitely an unpretentious and inexpensive date spot. With so many choices of sandwiches on the menu, I will definitely be back to try the others. *Note: This is an averaged out 3 star review. The sandwich gets 4 stars but the desserts get 2.5 stars. Go for the sandwiches!!! read more

Paneantico Bakery - Turkey,mozzarella and roasted peppers on brick oven bread - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I got a NY-meets-Napoli cafe feel when I first walked into this place. That "this is one of those unique neighborhood gems" feeling came over me....like why didn't I know about this place before? Easy....I dont frequent Bay Ridge, especially 3rd Ave in the 90's....but I should....I'm jealous of all the good eats I'm seeing in this neighborhood! I ordered a cappucino here instead of going across the street to Starbucks...it was perfect..and Im picky. There was no line at the coffee counter, but everywhere else was bustling and busting at the seams with ravenous people. There's the long line at the decadent olde world style pastry counter....those cookies and cakes are so irresistible looking I had to.snag a tiramisu cheesecake for my friend's birthday celebration tomorrow night...and a cookie for now....yum! The antipasti, sandwich and decadent prepared food counter, further back had people in the line salivating...including me. So many gourmet italian delights, it's hard to narrow down what to eat! Everything looks so good. I saw lots of people ordering paninis, which looked fresh & delicious. Although it's really tight in there, people seem to take full advantage if the table service. Something about the atmosphere really transported me to Napoli! I love it! The tiramisu cheesecake was really good; the sweeter, italian-style cheesecake with the tiramisu added a little hint of tiramsu makes it special --it's not typical NY cheesecake at all though - much more of what I'd categorize as a gourmet italian bakery creation - and a good one. Paneantico is not just a wonderful neighborhood cafe/bakery/eatery, it's one of those mangeries that make Brooklyn great ....I'll definitely be stopping in anytime I am in Bay Ridge! read more

Paneantico Bakery - Tiramisu cheesecake for the Holidays - December 2011 - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Vibe- crazy at lunchtime Prices- good Bathrooms- Fail Service- good Food Great huge heros. I had the mozzarella, prosciutto and red peppers $12. Delicious. Can easily be shared by two people *Note pastries are horrible! Soggy cannoli shells, dried out napoleons, chalky chocolate cake WIGB? Yes, for hero's read more

Paneantico Bakery - Chicken - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Their bread is perfectly crusty, yet chewy. A hulking portion for a reasonable price. Chicken cutlet, house-made mozzarella, fresh vine tomato and arugula=masterpiece. Had to take the other half to go! Had a bite of the Fried eggplant, eggplant salad, roasted peppers and mozzarella as well and it was divine! Great Italian American food! read more

See all