I was in Brooklyn during a brutal 17-degree weekend and waiting to check into my apartment hotel when we met an older Puerto Rican couple from Florida who had grown up in the area and were back visiting home. They told us we HAD to try Paneantico. Ended up being one of the best recommendations of the entire trip. Walking in on a Friday morning felt like stepping into a true neighborhood staple. The seating is tight and crowded, warm, lively, and homely. Union guys coming in and out, locals drinking coffee, and the whole place had that authentic old-school Brooklyn energy you hope to stumble into while traveling. Our waitress was amazing and honestly added so much to the experience. Super friendly, attentive, and had a heavy Brooklyn accent that somehow made the morning even better. We ordered hot oatmeal with fresh fruit and hot cocoa for the little one and she loved it. I got the grilled chicken, portobella, and fresh mozzarella hero with a cappuccino and a cannoli. Everything was fantastic, but the absolute star was their signature balsamic glaze that comes with the sandwich. Seriously unforgettable. It was so good that before flying back home, I came back one more time just to grab a slice of cheesecake and an Italian hero for the plane ride. Love when a place wasn't even part of the itinerary but somehow becomes one of the defining experiences of the trip. Can't wait to come back. read more

Paneantico Bakery - B77. Grilled Chicken Sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Some of the worst service on the planet. It's so bizarre. The place is empty and they'll just leave you sitting there on your thumbs. I think the average IQ in this place is about 69 read more

Good atmosphere, great staff, and great food. This is the trifecta when you are at the heart of Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. It appears to be a bakery, but the breads they bake turn into incredible sandwiches. The price is not too bad, but the sandwiches are huge. I ordered a ham sandwich with mozzarella and sundried tomato. I drew the short end of the stick that day when they told me the focaccia was sold out, but they had ciabatta. It took a while for the sandwich to come out, but it was worth it. You can definitely portion this into two separate meals if you are not a big eater. The bread was toasty and fresh, and the ham and mozzarella were nicely portioned and paired with the tomatoes and balsamic vinegar. Good sandwich for a fair price. Sounds about Bay Ridge. read more

Paneantico Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I remember when Paneantico first opened--hard to believe it's been about 20 years. Now, visiting from out of town, we knew we had to go back. It was absolutely worth the trip: incredible food, warm service, and that same bustling ambiance I've always loved. read more

See all

I love the Prosciutto sandwich here! Bagels are also very tasty. I'm always here for a quick bite during the weekdays or lazy brunch on the weekends. Looking forward to try the cannoli and variety of cakes my next visit. read more

Old-school Italian charm right in Bay Ridge Peaneantico Bakery gives all the cozy café vibes -- great service, delicious food, and even better prices. Lunch for two under $40? Proof you don't need to spend a lot for a solid meal. read more

Been back a couple times for both breakfast and lunch and this place is just as great as it was when I first started coming here. The breakfast platters here are massive enough to put you in a food coma while not being crazy expensive. The hero's are also top notch. Recently I went with the #B122 which was fried eggplant, fresh mozz, and roasted red peppers. You absolutely have to add balsamic glaze to make it complete and with the multiple bread choices you have I suggest you go with their brick oven hero bread. 10/10. Have to mention the coffee is good here too. Their brewed coffee is strong without it being bitter and works well with everything they sell here. You might run into Nonna who comes out of the kitchen every once in a while. Eat here! read more

Paneantico Bakery - B122. Fried Eggplant Sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I ordered a vegan version of a sandwich, they had an option to "make it vegan" my sandwich arrived FULL of meat! When I called the excuse was that they had no option to make my sandwich vegan, however, instead of calling me to tell me this, they sent me a sandwich full of meat and cheese. They said I could speak to a manager and put me on hold and I got hung up on. This is not a way to run a business. This was clearly their fault and not mine. read more

Paneantico Bakery - This is a full on meat sandwich when it's SUPPOSED to be vegan - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

It says "bakery" so you probably were like me and thought "yay, cookies!" No no. Do what they did and think outside of that. Pasta salad? Straight up hot food? Over 100 sandwich options?! Call in and order that sandwich in advance. That way, you go in, grab your sandwich, run home, and inhale that sandwich. And did I know balsamic glaze goes on all sandwiches? I do now. Paneantico taught me that. That's why they give you balsamic with every sandwich. You don't have to ask for it, it's their way of saying "trust us". Made to order. So good. You can't mess up a sandwich; only make it better. It's gonna take me a while to get to all these sandwiches but I'll try. Wish me luck. read more

Paneantico Bakery - N6O. Ham, Smoked Mozzareila, Artichokes, Extrabalsamic Napoliton Sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Absolutely delicious! The creamy grilled chicken Caesar salad was incredibly fresh -- crisp romaine, perfectly grilled chicken, and a rich, tangy dressing that tied it all together. Every bite was full of flavor. I'll definitely be back for more! And let me get started on the cakes. Servers were amazing and helpful read more

See all

Consistently Outstanding - Our Go-To for Every Holiday! We've been using Paneantico to cater our Christmas, Easter and special celebrations for years, and I can honestly say they never disappoint. Their food is consistently delicious, beautifully presented, and made with such care -- The team at Paneantico always goes above and beyond to make sure everything is perfect. From the ease of ordering to their reliable service and warm, friendly staff, they make hosting stress-free -- which means we actually get to enjoy the holidays with our family. Whether it's their incredible pastries, savory appetizers, or full holiday meals, the quality is unmatched. We wouldn't trust anyone else with our most special gatherings. Thank you, Paneantico, for helping make our holidays so memorable year after year -- your dedication and excellence show in everything you do! read more

Paneantico Bakery - St. Joseph's Pastry are always a favorite! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The coffee was burned. The service was awful and the omelette was so over cooked it was like eating rubber. The poor waitress ran so ragged the entire time. Maybe hire more front of the house staff and hire a cook that can cook eggs properly. Worst meal and service I've had in years. read more

Amazing sandwiches and bakery. A true bay ridge staple and those in the neighborhood know of their quality

Paneantico is my haven. So many options for desserts, but their menu for food is just as good. I love coming here with my family for lunch. Or stopping by to grab some sweet treats for my coffee at home. read more

Paneantico Bakery - Dessert and pastries - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Service is always great. We don't understand how they only have a 3.5 rating- this is one of our favorite bakeries in Brooklyn- definitely 5 stars. Their food is delicious- from breakfast pastries and sandwich items, lunch sandwiches or pizza- everything is delicious. Parking isn't easy but it's worth the hassle. read more

I hold steady on the platform from my previous review, about the food served being delicious, however, I've knocked one star off due to the horrible service. Granted, they do get busy sometimes; I've seen the ladies behind the counter juggle three, four customers at a time without breaking a sweat. However... We went there today for a late lunch (2:15pm) to dine al fresco. There were plenty of tables to choose from, both inside and out (a lull in the day). We alerted a waitress that we were there for patronage, and we had a seat. The waitress came out with menus and silverware, and gave us some time. Then some more time. Then... some more time.... At 2:35pm, twenty minutes after being handed menus, and no one had stopped by the table to even take our "drink order", let alone "meal order". We really wanted to eat one of their sandwiches, so we were trying to be as patient as possible. We said "Five more minutes - If she doesn't come by within five minutes, let's go.". Five minutes came and went, so we packed up and left. My man alerted the waitress that he didn't appreciate being ignored, and we took off. Again, fantastic food but their wait staff needs either better training or better supervision. We waited 25 minutes to try to place an order. I'm not so sure we'll be going back. That's what "take out" is for, right? read more

Paneantico Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Horrible got the wrong item, charged for a broken item that was stale really!!! Used to be very good not sure what happened

This bakery is a true gem. The kind where you point and keep adding more and more into your box, yet the bill never breaks the bank. This Italian bakery spoke my language- and I only got to the sweets and not even the savories yet. Can't wait to return! I got all my usuals - cannoli, pignola cookies, something difficult to pronounce, the crisp butter cookies with sprinkles, and more. There was a green muffin I threw in there too at the last minute. The rainbow cookies were incredible. I noticed they also have a rainbow cookie cheesecake which I would like to try next time. Watching my kind server pull out each item behind the counter, ending with pulling string from a spool to tie around my box - a labor of love. Thank you, Paneantico! read more

See all

Paneantico is a neighborhood staple. Classic Italian baked goods, sandwiches and coffees. There's a large selection of everything. This place is always packed with locals. I love coming here for cookie platters for parties and it's a good place to pick up premade pizza dough. The chai latte are some of the best I've had in the neighborhood. I find the pastries to be more on the bready side than flaky. The outdoor dining area does have wait service so you can sit outside and avoid the line. Indoors the place is always packed and I find service to be a bit slow. There always seems to be people here day and night so it's a great meeting spot. read more

See all

I took my husband and my family for breakfast at Paneantico this morning and the husband made an observation on how light the coffee was, and instead of the waitress saying, "how can I help you or would you like your coffee darker?, she stated in her loud voice for everyone to hear and gesturing with her hands in our faces" I don't make the coffee, I just serve it" What terrible customer service!! After telling the manager that the waitress needed to work on her delivery, he said, "she has 15 tables to serve, citing with her and not even apologizing for the bad moment with had! This is not how you talk to a customer that's bringing money your business!! There are plenty of restaurants to go to in Bayridge! You lost a loyal customer!!! read more

Came here after seeing someone post on Instagram about it . I'm in the area all the time so now I'm excited that I found this place too. Came here specifically for the house salad and it did not disappoint. Came in on a Thursday evening, there were a few people, but it definitely wasn't busy. Placed my order and bought several additional items unplanned. There were definitely no mistakes made here. Everything was fresh and delicious. The staff was friendly and helpful. We all even laughed a little. The large salad ended up being huge so there was plenty leftover. The ambience in this place gives deli/bakery Italian style. You can sit down and eat there if you need to, but for the most part, I think people take their food to go. I will absolutely be back and who knows maybe next time I'll venture into the rest of the menu. I highly recommend you stopping by checking it out for yourself. read more

I always order delivery from here for lunch. Their house salad with grilled chicken is so fresh and delicious! The balsamic glaze they give you also just makes the salad so yummy. The house salad has roasted peppers, eggplant, mozzarella, cucumbers, tomatoes, and greens. Super healthy option for lunch and they are always on time with delivery! read more

This place is fantastic, from their Antipasto to their pastries! Every year for the Super Bowl I order a 4ft chicken cutlet fresh mozzarella with roasted peppers. They never disappoint. read more

Paneantico Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I used to rave about the pastries and cookies here, so great. Yesterday my husband went in to buy pignoli cookies, they were charging $40.00 a pound, so he bought a half pound. However, when we got them home, they were stale. The service was always great here., but no more cookies for us, The atmosphere was always pleasant and a bust atmosphere, ambiance. read more

We stop in here often on Saturday mornings to pick up some pastries and other sweet treats, although we have yet to dine in (definitely on our list though!). I love that there is outside seating as an option and I think it would be perfect for when we bring our kids. The bakery is on the corner and provides so much to see for my boys. The bakery is small but well maintained and everyone seems really nice. On our last visit, we spent under $22 for a large lobster tail, 2 large cannolis (1 regular and 1 chocolate), a slice of Oreo cheesecake and a slice of the strawberry shortcake. I thought the prices are fair, and we've yet to dislike anything we've ordered. My husband also loves the blueberry cheesecake from past visits as well. Looking forward to dining in sometime soon! read more

Perfectly alright Italian pastries. The Pasticiotti/less likely a pasta croce was unique as they have one not just with the usual citron/ricotta but also with chocolate. The texture inside was more like jello but it was still tasty so no real complaints. Their lobster tail was alright. A bit thick. Dough was similarly a bit thick for the fruit tart. Coffee had a fun container for it to be served in. My pastry was around a 3.5, the rest were a 3/upper 2. Rating makes sense here. read more

See all

I stopped by this neighborhood staple for a cake for my Christmas Eve dinner party. It was packed full of customers ordering food for the holiday. It was so busy and there was only take-out for the holidays. I bought a 5-inch chocolate black out cake. I charged the $27 to my credit card. Perfectly delicious! The cake was moist and chocolatey.The chocolate pudding filling was yummy. The dark chocolate icing surrounding the cake added another fun dimension to all that chocolate! read more

Paneantico Bakery - Chocolate Black-out cake a la mode! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Oh Bay Ridge, what happened to you? What happened to your delicious Italian cuisine? What happened to that taste from generations of old? What happened to genuine service? Smiling cashiers? What happened to naturally delicious food? What happened to people allowing you to try before you buy? Unfortunately this is a bakery I will not be returning to, because what really happened, was a lack of love in the pastries. Everything was stodgy and claggy. There is no love. Just distribute and go. That is what happened to you Bay Ridge, and if you are too narcissistic to see that, then I am done with you. read more

Everything is great,I know it's a very broad statement, but in this case it is true. The food is traditional and done to a turn. The only thing I would suggest, try to control yourself or you won't fit through the door on the way out! Although the quarters a tight service is great. The ambiance is Cozy, Friendly and Warm. The Proprietors are always welcoming and always open to suggestions ‼ read more

The quality of this place fell off a cliff from what it used to be. The food is horrible, ingredients were not fresh, the service was bad and the staff was rude. It's a shame because this place used to be really, really good. There are way too many bakeries and sandwich places in Bay Ridge to go here. Avoid!! read more

Review based on my indoor dining experience. Went in with my family in the afternoon. I saw some delicious looking pizzas I wanted to try out and was on line while my family sat down. After waiting for my turn, I told the employee working the counter I would like to get some pizzas. She asked if it was to go or for indoors and I told her indoors. She refused to take my order and told me a waitress would come over, even after waiting long in line. We probably waited 15 minutes without anyone acknowledging us or asking if we needed help. After waiting so long, we left angry and will never come back here again. read more

Came here for breakfast and was disappointed. I usually pick up cookies and pastries and have been for several years. I use to have an occasional meal. I really wanted to go to Pegasus diner on 86 st and 3 ave although they had a 25 minute wait. After this experience I should have waited there. Paneantico did a great job here expanding the outside seating. Everyone was nice no complaints. There were a few things that were just out of sorts. They used paper plates and plastic utensils. No plates or silverware. It's not very convenient to cut pancakes with a small plastic knife and fork. Oh yes the cups were plastic too:) Prices are reasonable although the breakfast menu lists Blueberry pancakes for $7.95 and we were charged $11.95. When we asked they showed us this little sticker on the front of the menu that said that due to COVID prices have changed. Some remain the same. They said they were waiting for updated menus??? So that means they can charge what ever they want? I am not one to quibble on price, it's the principle. I don't think the Department of Consumer Affairs would agree with that. The food was ok, ordered Blueberry pancakes you get 3 average size ones. No complaints. Ordered the Joe omelette which was just ok, it was not served hot. The presentation on a paper plate was horrible. See the photos. When I cool an omelette at home they look much better. Our waitress was nice, everything was clean. There are so many choices in Bay Ridge and I don't think I will be back for breakfast. Maybe cookies, desert to go or w sandwich. read more

Paneantico Bakery - Blueberry Pancakes - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This review is for the Too Good to Go bag.They should be ashamed. Almost closing time..lots of food left over.in the showcase. Got 4 bagels and a piece of dough pizza. Just awful!! Shameful!!! read more

The food is good but the attention that you get, when they get the order wrong and charge you for it is not good. This is the second time that I purchase a frittata with cheese and they charge me for the cheese and they don't put it. I call the place to asked for credit just for the cheese and I was told to bring the sandwich back to add the cheese when I was already driving to work. read more

Paneantico Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Exceptionally kind workers, delicious food and huge portions! My favorites are the blueberry cheesecake, grilled chicken Caesar salad and basically any sandwich off the menu! read more

Unpleasant, unwelcoming, no one makes eye contact, no good morning greetings or how may I help you. Enjoy.

Excellent coffee bar. Phenomenal pastries. The service is always great. I love this local treasure and highly recommend it.

Today is my mom's 35th birthday (for the 2nd time)! She absolutely loves Strawberry Shortcake! Normally, I get the 8-inch for her, but we were having lots of company to celebrate this milestone birthday. I pre-ordered yesterday for today. I asked for something that would feed 20 to 30 people, and the young lady behind the counter went and asked the baker for a recommendation. She was super sweet and helpful! She said the baker recommended a 14-inch cake. I'm thinking it's like a half pan size, so I'm like, ok, sounds good to me! My husband was running late to pick up, so I called in to let them know. They told me the price, and I was a little caught off guard. Normally, the 8-inch round is $25. They quoted me $85. I hung up, thought about it, and called back. I asked for the manager because I couldn't wrap my head around the price. I'm thinking it's like a 14 by 7 rectangle. I spoke to Stephanie, the manager, and she's trying to explain the pricing to me. I'm not getting it, so I asked her to send me a picture. She does, and I realize why the cake isn't like $50. This gargantuan beauty is AT LEAST the size of 4 of the mini cakes, so I'm actually getting a deal! Stephanie is patient with me all the way. She's wonderful! My husband brings the cake home, and everyone is like, "What the freak?!" But mom loved it, so now we told her she's gotta eat it for breakfast, lunch, and dinner for the next 3 days! I just wanted to thank you guys for this lovely creation. It was delicious and made mom so happy! I also want to thank the girls at the counter and Stephanie for being so sweet and patient! I definitely got my money's worth, haha! read more

Paneantico Bakery - 14x14inch Strawberry Shortcake - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

It is so funny that I just can't believe they do not make homemade roast beef instead of using deli roast beef while they have the steam table with all the pre-cook food displayed. I'm just very surprised they have not changed that if I wanted a deli roast beef I would've went to supermarket and got a sandwich, and usually I do go there for pastries, but one day last week for dessert while eating there with some friends, the chocolate cover cannoli cream was has stale as it was in the refrigerator for three weeks And I really don't understand about the service anymore. It used to be great now it stop and slow waiting for table service. read more

The specialty hero with steak, broccoli rabe, and mozzarella was ok. But the small indoor space feels warm and inviting. There are charming interactions between staff and customers all the time. And service for me was prompt and friendly. Now onto the food. The bread wasn't quite right. I preferred a crisper exterior and fluffier interior. The steak was 2 pieces of well-cooked, yet undersalted meat. The broccoli rabe seemed too bitter in comparison to the underflavored steak. There was a tiny cup of sauce, but i felt it lacked enough of a savory element. It reminded me of a smoky, slightly sweetened balsamic vinegar. My favorite part of the sandwich was the creamy mozzarella. Sad that this was so hyped up by sietsema from eater NY read more

Paneantico Bakery - Specialty hero with steak, broccoli rabe, and mozzarella - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York