I like their crispy crust and fast service. Pricing is ok since the slices are big. Heads up, not all slices are priced the same. Don't forget to get a stamp card, your 13th slice if free with the card filled out. Service is good 95% of the time, but if they are busy you should double check your order or risk getting over charged with extra slices. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Slice of the Day (2018 menu) - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I love trying a new restaurant and finding it lives up to the hype. Stellar pizza and service; delivered earlier than expected and the pizza crust was insanely good. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - 11 inch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

I'm a regular but wow... time to experiment with other places. Prices went WAY UP! Delivery charge alone is 7 bucks. That's not including tip or the added cost of the items. Their pizza is great but the huge jump in pricing leaves me feeling undervalued as a customer. At the very least it's motivation to find yummy food elsewhere. A fair increase is understandable but this leaves a bad taste. read more

I have ordered from here for maybe 15+ years. I didn't appreciate the woman on the phone trying to make me feel guilty for a tip. I ordered 2 bottles of wine and a small salad and live less than a mile away. If I ordered pizza I would have tipped more.. I figured $7 was good enough without her snide comment. I've always had a pleasant experience.. I guess I can just make my own small salad and buy my own wine in the future. I also know other great pizza options in my area. read more

Easily one of the best pizza joints in Seattle, and it's right down the street from my job. Easy to order a slice in advance for pickup, and you really can't beat their caesar salad with the Macrina croutons. I always get extra croutons. The people are always nice and chipper, too. read more

The service here is great. The cashier was super helpful and even gave us a free drink! We ordered the Spicy Chicken Pizza. The pizza style here is thin, and it wasn't too bad. It lacked a little garlic and sauce. Although the pizza was decent, we got food poising. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Spicy Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I love their food but this Covid policy is bs! They have 20 employees 2' apart in a 15' x 15' space and they treat the customers like dogs and make them wait outside 1 customer at a time. No I think I'll take my money somewhere that actually cares about their customers and isn't an embodiment of Hypocrisy. read more

I'm not always in the mood for pizza, but if someone mentions Pagliacci, I'm definitely not one to pass that up! So Pagliacci Pizza is pretty common in the Seattle area, with sites all over the place. I love how I can order items at any of their locations and expect it to taste the same. Also, they offer seasonal pizzas and gelatos. Recently I noted an asparagus/prosciutto pie, which I did not partake, but doesn't it sound delicious? Now if you are a frequent pie-er, you'll get emails and updates on those offerings. Also, I am a huge, huge fan of the Pagliaccio salad: "Green leaf lettuce tossed with garbanzo beans, diced red peppers, kasseri cheese, salami, red onions and Dijon vinaigrette"?! YES, PLEASE! I'm a carnivore at heart, but that salad is sooo good; crisp and refreshing, and with just enough saltiness to keep you wanting more! I forgot to mention the awesome soda options! It's kind of high tech for me, I'm a total OG tech tart, so anything with touch screens and too many options kind of scares me away. I let my hubby play with the soda machine (he likes playing with buttons anyway) and order whatever. But they offer plain soda and soda with fruit flavoring, zero/low calorie sodas, etc... Now about the location on Stone. It is tiny...and parking is a pill!!! They have "parking" if you can call it that, but it can only accommodate 4 cars at the most. There is bicycle parking, if that's your mode of transportation, and there are bus stops along Stone. So, although the Pagliacci location on Stone is not my first choice, in a pinch, it satisfies just fine. read more

Always good pizza! Yes, it is pricey for a whole pie, but I think it's worth it. My favorites are the Italiano (roasted garlic and spinach) and the prosciutto and fig (though unfortunately, they don't have that all the time). Their delivery guys have always been friendly and courteous. They are definitely my go-to pizza delivery place in Seattle. read more

Ok pizza. But not worth the price of $33 for a 13 inch pie. For that price I expect a wood fired oven pie with imported Italian ingredients baked by a gentleman or gentlewoman from the old country donning a tomato stained tank top undershirt. Instead I was treated to a valley girl taking my order and a 'za arriving without a single napkin. read more

They put a ton of salt on my pizza and forgot to put on basil. Worst margherita pizza I've ever had.

one word: awfful $45 of dog food!!! pagliacci is not performing this is my second order in 30-days that tastes like $;&)# buyer beware pizza is a commodity and there are many pizza restaurants to choose. read more

Pizza was great!!! They use that brick oven which is key!! The closest thing to NY pizza I've found since living in WA. All other pizzerias could learn a thing or two from this place. Keep it up and see you soon. Came in again today 7/27/18. Pizza is amazing. I'm all about cheese pizza. This place never disappoints. Friendly staff. Just updated it from 4 to 5 stars. read more

A tad overrated by locals in my opinion. Had a lot of meat on the pizza and it tasty a tad undercooked.

Used to be good, but now they're price gouging. Yes, I know inflation has been high but prices have gone up about 1/3 in the last 3 years - almost twice the rate of inflation in Seattle. They've raised prices for a delivered pizza about 15% in less than a year. Just not worth it. read more

WTF? Aren't you supposed to let me know that my pizza is being delivered? You put it on the wet ground! ITS RAINING! A delivery fee and a 20% tip and a $30 small pizza, this is how you do business? Good luck with that read more

Ordered pizza from pagliacci. We tried the Verde Primo and regular margarita pizza. Both pizzas were quite nice but I thought they were very expensive for what you get. What was particularly frustrating was that I could not order all this online. There is no way to order online from this restaurant, their website prompts you to call.I found this particularly annoying, specially because I had to be on the phone for 20 excruciating minutes spelling my name and card number letter by letter and digit by digit when there was a party going on at my place! They have got to make this easier. read more

Love their pizza! Roman holiday is sooooo good! Always get half of that and then something else. The crust is so chewy and yummy. Idk it's just my go to pizza these days and always super friendly! read more

This company is a joke! You're almost paying $50 bucks for a 13 in pizza! It is 100% not worth that price. I cannot bring myself to ever eat there again. Some major price gouging for subpar pizza. Shame on the owners. read more

Stumbled upon this place through the wonderful world of Yelp. This place was located just one block of where we were staying when visiting Seattle. Location was very convenient, in walking distance and open later than other restaurants that were around. When we walked in there was only one person sitting inside, and I thought to myself maybe it is just a slow night. We were greeted upon entry and the guy at the counter was very helpful and patient when we were ordering. I had asked him for a few recommendations and he even offered to split the pizza into two different types. We ended up getting the pesto pizza on half and a meat lover (can't remember the name) on the other half. We got a medium and split it between three people. It was perfect. My absolute favorite is thin crust, which is what they have here! The sauce wasn't too overwhelming so you could taste all of the toppings they put on top. Yummy! If you're a fan of pesto or are a vegetarian, you'll love this one! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Half meat and half pesto - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

not a good place to order from ! when I order dinner tonight they had a tracker but when it was in order being prepared it just disappeared and there have been no phone calls to my phone ! I got no delivery but I still have the charge on my card showing ! I'm of course going to be disputing it now with my card company and that is all a hassle in itself . thanks lame pizza place that btw the food sucks anyways read more

The food is good if you can find the checkout button on the website. It takes 20-30 mins every time trying find it. Ive never seen such poorly desgined website. read more

Pagliacci is an amazing restaurant company to do catering business with. I had to cater an event with a short turn around time. Their customer service was superb! They were so polite and helpful. I had to change my order a few times and they were very accommodating. The food arrived on time. Their pizzas were delicious!! There was plenty of food at our party and everyone enjoyed having leftovers to take home. read more

I ordered the Pagliaccio salad and asked for extra dressing and it was basically mush. 75% of it was dressing. You think they'd know better than making it a mush? Waste of money. Also not the best quality over all. read more

Average pizza, overly oily, inconsistent crust, sour sauce. They serve slices which is not easy to find in Seattle, but this is hardly Italian or NYC pizza. read more

Longtime customer, first time reviewing. Just wanted to thank Pagliacci for saving dinner tonight! When I was ordering delivery I asked about the seasonal pies. That potato rosemary sounded great! Unfortunately the rep didn't say anything about chicken and I was so tired and hungry I forgot to ask, and I'm vegetarian. Needless to say I was disappointed when my pizza arrived and I couldn't eat it! I was prepared to order, and pay, for another, but Pagliacci was kind enough to fix it and not charge me again! Not that they had to try to keep my business, but now, this relationship is solidified and I'm a customer for life! Also, that gluten free crust, just, thank you!!! read more

I ordered a pizza last Sunday and someone at Pagliacci used my debit card to rack up nearly $700 in charges that Monday and Tuesday. If you want your identity stolen, just order from Pagliacci. Oh, btw, they skimp so much on toppings you'll pay a fortune for what amounts to a cheese pizza. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - I picked through the pizza and found this many toppings. That's before an employee used my debit card to steal almost $700. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Stopped in pretty late on Wednesday evening and just had to write this review- the dude who helped me (younger dude with tattoos) was so nice and knowledge! Another worker (female) was also so nice! Pizza and salad were on point! read more

I ordered a pizza , salad and a 6 pack of soda and was told it would be delivered by 9pm. its now 11:15 . nothing . to call ,text, email call nothing. i tried to call back and got a machine that said they are closed and hang up. i checked my account and I've been charged . but no meal and to late to get anything else. i used to work for Pagliacci and never had anything like this happen . their customer service has taken a huge nosedive . for $60 pizza i expect a little more then to just get burned and go hungry . don't get delivery if you want your meal. read more

Pretty good pizza. Hey it's a Seattle institution right? My review is for the very loud talking manager holding new employee orientation in the dining room. His voice filled the whole room and was kind of annoying. Note to said manager who's "big on cleaning" every table around me had crumbs on it and the condiment shakers need some love. read more

For $18 the veggie pizza I ordered was not good. I have tasted better. I make good ones at home. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

The best pizza I have had in awhile! Highly recommend! Pizza was fresh and yummy! You will not be disappointed

Your crust is great. The sauce needs a lot of work. Your Caesar is uninspired. We're from Michigan and lived in Chicago (so both Chicago and Detroit style run in our blood) for many years. If everything else goes wrong, nail the sauce, that's noteworthy. $30 for a pie? We gave you a try. We appreciate what you do for your employees. And fully support your business model. Rethink your sauce, apply it more liberally, and you have a repeat customer. read more

Best pizza in Seattle. Hands down. Ordering is such a total breeze over the phone, it might be the best part. They also have a digital option. The Seasonals are Always delicious and unique. Local gelato, beer and wine, nice delivery-people. Pagliacci is a Pacific Northwest staple. read more

I'm from New York and this is the only pizza I frequently eat unless I'm ordering very late night I'll settle for anything available for delivery. It's extremely expensive but in my opinion worth it to throw down the extra money for a real pizza. People are always trying to tell me to try this place or that place and I just don't bother anymore. Pagliacci has my order down hot as the usual in their database. Customer service is phenomenal. If you're ordering for delivery, ask for extra condiments otherwise they'll gyp you. Oh and their hours are quite limiting. read more

Don't laugh, but the Paggliaci salad is pretty darn good. Yes, pizzas is yummy too. Try their seasonal specials.

Staff likes to loudly talk about you as if you aren't there or cannot hear them. Will never return. read more

With all due respect to Ian S., I don't understand what the problem is. The Pagliacci empire operates with an almost Orwellian efficiency and reach. If you're a repeat customer like us, they caller ID you to pull up your entire life's pizza-ordering record. They know what you like to order, they know where you live, they know your credit card number--it's all a little spooky. Even the freakin' canned recording that answers when operators are busy--even "she" knows if you're a repeat customer and greets you accordingly ("Oh, you know the drill--as one of our valuable customers etc..."). As far as I know, the only result of all this detailed knowledge has been reliably consistent pizza always delivered almost exactly 35 minutes after I call. And we're persnickety orderers. For example, tonight's order consisted of the following: 1) a small pepperoni pizza with no sauce (for younger kid) 2) a large pizza with 2.1) no sauce and pepperoni on one half (for older kid) 2.2) chopped tomatoes on the other half (because I miss the sauce but the older kid doesn't like it when it bleeds onto his half) 2.3) a little cup of pesto on the side (again, for me because the older kid doesn't like it bleeding onto his side). (It's not for nothing that my list of kid eats is called "This Is Why We Can Never Go Someplace Nice.") I was even embarrassed to give such a high-maintenance order, but the person on the phone didn't even blink. (Well, she might have blinked, but I didn't hear it.) Once, they overcooked one of our pizzas, and when we called to tell them, they sent over another one, free of charge. So honestly, I can't complain about these guys. The only thing that keeps them from five stars is that the pizza itself isn't the ne plus ultra of pizza, but what do you expect with delivery food? Piecora's (http://www.yelp.com/biz/2-u9Duo9s9tuuM7H8gl4gg), Tutta Bella (the Columbia City one, http://www.yelp.com/biz/TrGbVh2q5LmLnaPyVUEUIA -- we'll talk about the Wallingford one some other time), and Serious Pie (http://www.yelp.com/biz/-FOAQv22SXtSBs7nptI3UA) don't deliver, so we go with Pagliacci. Beats the hell out of Domino's. read more

1st order, paid for extra cheese, got no extra cheese. 2nd order, got margarita pizza, was missing cheese on almost 3 slices. 3rd order, got veggie pizza. Arrived so spongy soggy gross. As though someone spilled water on the pizza before boxing. Don't order delivery from Stone Way. I suppose if you're in the restaurant you can send a bad pizza back right away. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Was so soggy the crust was flaccid and spongy. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Madness Ensues, Money was Lost..I ordered from Pagliacci....My salad they tossed!!! I don't like this Pizza! read more