My go to anytime I want a good pie. I'm not sure why they have low ratings, b/c this location is consistently the best. When I moved, I was informed my only option was the University Dist branch, which was over-rated and very hit or miss. I was happy to return to Stone when the other closed. And a former hospital employee, thought the same of the Cap Hill branches. Both were freq overly greasy. The chain as a whole is popular for a reason. Their toppings are locally artisanal, fresh, and I love a REAL bread crust. I do enjoy the biscuit variation from time to time. But I can't stand Pizza Hut for many reasons, the top of the list being their crust. (If you eat there, you should really research their PCB ratings-200% over the toxic limit). My neighbors in the bldg ALL use this branch now b/c of me. You're welcome, Stone Way. My faves are a routine rotation of The Brooklyn Bridge, Pesto Primo, The Veggie, and Chicken Spinach (whatever it's called). But their seasonals are awesome too, my faves being the meatball & banana peppers, and pear/gorgonzola. I have recently been getting their calzones, minus the ricotta. Also love the biscuit bread sticks, Nona's pasta, and their gelato. I appreciate the variety of their drinks as well. And the cookies are very good. Make an gelato sammich w them. Whenever i've had any issues, these guys are super helpful to rectify and will either re-deliver or send a gift card. I have also received entire orders that were comped as birthday or customer appreciation. Their phone staff is by and large cheerful, helpful in their recommendations, and patient w picky orders & substitutions. Their drivers are the nicest & most considerate too. I've tried to tip the kitchen staff, but they don't accommodate that for delivery. So share the love if you eat there in person. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Brooklyn Bridge, extra sauce, minus onions and kalamata olives instead of the usual black ones. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Walked here and the place was modern nice n clean. We were greeted by a very nice gentleman. I like how you can order here by the slice if your not in the mood for a whole pizza. Picked the chicken BBQ flavor. Me and the rest ordered the same. We weren't big fans of it because we didnt know it had jalapeños and it was over powering the pizza. They should of named or put a sign that there was jalapeños because it was really spicy. We all agree. Pizza was okay... read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Front at night - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Always hits the spot! Staff were sweet despite it being late at night. Came out pretty fast read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

pagliacci locations have degrees-- this location is of the lowest of degree. didn't give me half of what i ask/paid/tipped for. slow as well. just nonsense. place use to be legit... exactly why i stopped going here. read more

Yummy local chain that was a great choice for a variety of dietary restrictions. All the pies were tasty, and held up well to our party on the water. Thanks! read more

I just ordered the Autumn Harvest Pizza I got a burnt mess. Their prices keep going up as their quality completely crashes. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - This looks nothing like the website photo. I've been a customer for years but this is the 2nd time I've gotten a burnt mess. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

This place is a great spot to grab a slice or a whole pie for the squad! I really appreciate their menu and the pizza is good. I love coming here with friends and it's my go-to when I need to order a whole pie for an event. read more

Dudes! Paying a s!it ton for good pizza. It should have arrived 15 minutes ago, which means IT WILL BE COLD. This happens literally 50% of the time. read more

This is my fav pizza in Seattle. They are a great company with a great product. The community is lucky to have em!

I've put this off for months, but after a recent delivery I feel compelled to update my review. I've been a Pagliacci fan and regular customer for many years, the Stone Way location in particular. Pagliacci remains great in many ways. Kind and personable delivery folks, excellent selection of wine and beer, tasty caesar salad, delicious gelato. Quick, reliable, and professional. What's making me reconsider ordering from them in the future is their pizza. The sauce, cheese, and topping remain solid, but what's up with the crust? My last 4 or so pizzas, ordered over the course of maybe 6 or 12 months, have had such a thin, soggy, sad crust. And what's a pizza place without good pizza crust? :( read more

Ordered the Diavola and it was fell short of my expectations for its price of $25.92 for an 11" which is very small. Picked up the pizza and it was floppy. Even the $1 pizzas I get in NYC don't flop like that. I can get 26 of those which taste way better as well. Also calling in to place an order is weird, it goes to a corporate office, not the actual location and they have you provide your credit card details over the phone, um no thank you, very strange how the location/chain doesn't have their own phone. The staff that took my order in person seemed very uninterested in his job, sort of destroyed my mood for that night as I walked and no greeting or a simple "hi welcome" would suffice as well. I went to a different place in the area and got a full greeting so can't be the location. Overall for $26, you're better off going to a different place unlesss you really want pizza in Seattle for some reason. read more

We ALWAYS get our pizzas and large salads at Pagliacci on Lake City Way. Our call-in order and pick-up time are accurate and pies are fresh and delicious. read more

Not the Pagliacci I remember. Ordered two 13". They weren't the thin chewy kind of crust we're accustomed to when you buy a slice. The crusts were thick and crunchy. The toppings were sparse and not very flavorful. The crusts tasted like they were mass produced and sold in the freezer at Costco. The staff didn't seem too energetic to get things done. Took forever. We won't be coming back. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Should have gone to Costco. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I feel sad that Pagliacci has fallen so low I lived on lower Queen Anne Hill in the early 90s and often ordered Kidd valley and Pagliacci were the best. So difficult to order now, a $25 dollar pizza is $50 before tip, and it takes forever, as it is a call center, Sorry goodbye to an old friend, never again! read more

Another Seattle Icon and my personal favorite pizza place. On a Friday Ill pop in for a slice on occasion just to get that Friday feeling. Last night we were adventurous and tried the meatball primo and a large Paggliaccio Salad. I cant wait to have this salad again or maybe try to make something similar, I cant stop thinking about it. .. maybe this is true love. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza box art - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Pagliacci Pizza is the best pizza in town. What makes them exceptional is their caring and passionate staff. I am beyond thrilled that they now have plant-based options. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Vegan meat and vegan cheese finally!!! - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I've loved Pagliacci for decades I would look forward to it every time i visited the PNW. I am here in Seattle for work for the first time since 2019 so I had to stop by my old standby today in 2023. They used to make a perfect pizza, delicious pesto salad. Sadly the pesto salad was discontinued, much to my dismay, and the pizza tasted like mass produced pizza served at lunch in am elementary school. I ordered a medium cheese with a can of coke and paid $26, which is way overpriced. It was such an utter disappointment. read more

Love the product, love that they have their own delivery service. Easy website to navigate. All in all good. Cons, this $7.00 delivery fee plus tip in an already expensive pizza- small pizza, salad.. Fee, taxes, tip $55- yikes. Won't order as often. read more

Ordered a margherita pizza, got pagliacci version of "margherita pizza". Crust tastes over cooked. Was also treated very poorly For as expensive as this pizza was, it's not worth it read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

We had never been to Pagliacci. But the new one opened in Eastgate, so we thought we'd try it. It was awful pizza! The dough wasn't done. The cheese on the Hawaiian was nasty. The pineapple on the Hawaiian was sour. I couldn't even finish eating it. My suggestion is that you stick with any other pizza place read more

We were craving some pizza today and heard good things about Pagliacci's so decided to give it a shot. I don't think they have a private parking lot (if they did I missed it) so decided to park across the street at the 7/11. Residential parking within the block is available as well. I called in for pick up and it was ready in 15 minutes which was amazing cause we were getting hangry. My favorite part about Pagliacci's is the thickness, it's a nice thin New York style pizza. I'm personally not a fan of deep dish cause it's too much breading for me. Their crust was a nice fluffy and chewy texture which I really enjoyed. Personally for our margarita pizza, I would have liked a stronger mozzarella taste. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - a dog holding a basketball - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Some Best Things about Pagliacci Pizza: (1) the gluten free crust is crunchy and crispety and seems to be better all the time. It reheats very well, too. (2) We like the seasonals. We like getting a gluten-free pizza (available in 11" only, I think) that is half-and-half, so we can get two seasonals on one pizza. In our house of two getting-elderly, moderately-foodie souls the one pizza is fully satisfactory and gelato or sorget is Meal Elevation to the Max. (3) They have the seasonals on the "slice" bar three days a week, just where I can reward myself for the arduous trip down to the coffee shop ( . . . three doors north of the Pagliacci's storefront . . . ) with a restorative slice of each seasonal. (4) We find that one gluten-free pizza with 1/2-and-1/2 of the two seasonals; a large Pagliacci salad with the garbanzo beans and all; and a pint of gelato or sorbet (also has seasonals!) makes a welcome fill-you-right-up treat after a weekend-long work party or a friends-and-family Mandalorian watch party. The quality and creativity of the Pagliacci's pizza is unrivaled. They're more expensive than pizza from the larger chains, but then they're not in the same market, so to speak. They have wild-foraged mushrooms (morels! great googly moogly, the morels!) and Iserno chicken sausage; they have Mama Lil's peppers. They have white pizza as well as red pizza. None of the guests we've ever fed on a Pagliacci pizza has not gone back for seconds. I'm writing about the Pagliacci's Pizza on the corner of E Miller and 10th Ave E (north Capital Hill). We've lived here from before there was a Pagliacci's (grin). Try a Pagliacci pizza! They're good! read more

Making pizza the old fashion way! Tasty and relatively inexpensive. Hot so watch the roof or ceiling of your mouth. Friendly and clean. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza throwing in real-time. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I get Pagliacci often. It's usually great! But tonight I got the Brooklyn Bridge (which I have had before) and I decided to have a slice while I waited for the bus. I am glad I did because I found that the pizza was really soggy. More than halfway up each slice it was wet and gross. I took it back and showed it to them and they said that it was because they were using mushrooms from a different supplier temporarily. I didn't ask then, but I am wondering why they would use them if they know it makes the pizzas soggy. They could just be out of mushrooms for a while. They gave me half off a new pizza and I got Hawaiian thinking that with less toppings, it would be less likely to be soggy. Well, the Hawaiian was still a bit soggy. While at the bus stop, I pulled the pieces off the cardboard that is there to absorb, flipped it over, and put the pieces on it again. This worked pretty well. When I got home I put a couple pieces in the oven to dry them up the rest of the way. I hope this new problem was a one (or two) time thing! The second pizza did seem to have a lot of extra cheese (maybe he way trying to be nice?) but the issue could be easily solved by weighing toppings. I will try them again, but I will also always be sure to check it before I go! read more

Great Pizza ! Excellent place to spend lunch and dinner time. Good music, good people ! Highly recommended.... read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza !!! I don't remember the name, BUT WAS DELICIOUS !!!! - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I order from Pagliacci on Bel-Red Road at least twice a month, if not more. I have never had a bad experience, even when I have randomly walked in to order a slice. The calzones are to die for, and I am an Italian American who knows what a good calzone should be. They know what they're doing, and they do it well. Their slices are enormous and their toppings are other-worldly. Their delivery drivers are courteous, quick, and thoughtful and well-deserving of a good tip. You know you're ordering from the right place when the staff obviously enjoys their work and creates such works of art. I cannot extoll the virtues of this place enough. read more

Don't deliver a slice of pizza to a hotel that is 2 blocks away that is cold and looks like it has been lying around all day and charge like it's a whole pie. read more

Expensive but delicious! Busy place and good delivery options. Small inside space but it works. Overall friendly service from their staff.

They should rename this shitty city $eattle "the fake NYC wanna be" You wonder why you have the least stars out of any location. Maybe it's because of standards, of which you have so few. It's amazing the pizza is still ok, with the amount of grease and laziness that goes into it. Oh, and guess what, you have to pass at least TWO TIP SCREENS to order PICK UP? So basically, you are saying the customer needs to pay 27 dollars for a 13 inch pizza, drive over and pick it up, and then pay your teenage employees too, cause what, rent is high. I pay rent to you cheap fuck. SMH. Me: 3 stars Gordon Ramsey: 1 star read more

Pagliacci has one mainline. I called to see if I could catch a WSU game in town with my dying grandmother. The guy on the mainline was so rude. He didn't transfer me to the store either. There goes another gem. Pagliacci I was a loyal customer for yrs with my family. I will never go back. read more

Amazing pizza that was served so quickly! We were a table of 9, which can be a chaotic party- but the ordering process was so smooth. 3 pizzas were more than enough for our table, & they each tasted so delicious! The pepperoni & cheese were great, but TRY THE SPINACH CHICKEN! we also enjoyed the beautiful neighborhood view out the window. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

We ordered 1 pizza and they charge $5 delivery fee and that doesn't even go to the driver. For one 17 inch Pizza with 3 toppings, it was $42.00!!! 1 pizza for 42.00 is absurd, especially for a chain shop!! read more

I've seen Pagliacci all over Seattle but had never tried it despiste living here for a few years. They offer both individual slices and whole pies. The individual slices are large and cheaper than buying an entire pie, but still feel expensive. I believe it was ~$5/slice vs $20 for an 8 piece pie. Perhaps I am spoiled by New York $1 slices, but the price alone felt disappointing. The flavor was OK, nothing special. Due to the convenience, I'd say it's worth stopping in, but buy an entire pie. read more

See all

Walked in the grab a slice trying to find some decent pizza here in Seattle This was OK came in right in the open grab a slice of cheese cheese tasted good Sauces little bland the dough was Decent cook a little too much so is really dry but would get it again read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Had a half Agog Primo and half pepperoni pizza from here and it was delicious. Tasted extra good this time. This location usually seems to be pretty consistently early or at least time with their pickup orders. I think this pizza is better when cooked a little longer so the crust has a little crunch to it - sometimes it's a bit too doughy. Would like to see them experiment with more new pizza specials/toppings. read more

I cannot believe they charge 5 bucks for a slice of bland pizza sitting under light bulbs for hours. They put it in the oven to make it crispier, per our request, and asked for $10,25 for two slices of garbage. Very few choices for slices and vastly overrated because this city has few pizza venues that are notable. read more

Pagliacci was suggested to us on a rainy day in Seattle. This was our first time in the city and it seems to be a chain as I saw another location elsewhere. The pizza hits the spot with MANY different options that will make anyone happy. Instead of ordering a full pie to ourselves, we decided to grab some individual slices so that we can try more! From what I was told they usually have 2 of their uniquely flavored pizzas and then 1 staple such as pepperoni or cheese. I loved the everything slice I got and also a butternut squash slice! The pizza was a little greasy, but a few napkin blots and you are on your way to deliciousness. The servers were friendly and the establishment was clean with a lot of seating. They also have a stamp card for individual slices so that you can earn a free slice! - J read more

I'm a regular but wow... time to experiment with other places. Prices went WAY UP! Delivery charge alone is 7 bucks. That's not including tip or the added cost of the items. Their pizza is great but the huge jump in pricing leaves me feeling undervalued as a customer. At the very least it's motivation to find yummy food elsewhere. A fair increase is understandable but this leaves a bad taste. read more

Over priced reheated pizza. $4 for a slice of pizza? It was more worth $2-$2.50. I wouldn't be going back if I had a choice. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - $15 for 3 slices and a soda. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I like their crispy crust and fast service. Pricing is ok since the slices are big. Heads up, not all slices are priced the same. Don't forget to get a stamp card, your 13th slice if free with the card filled out. Service is good 95% of the time, but if they are busy you should double check your order or risk getting over charged with extra slices. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Slice of the Day (2018 menu) - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington