Fun and lovely atmosphere, New Orleans decor, went on a Sunday for brunch/lunch. There was plenty…read moreof seating, service was great, and a huge menu selection and variety to choose from. My friend and I split the fish tacos and breakfast burrito (meat on the side), and waiter was accommodating. The portion sizes are good for the price! One downside for the rice and beans - rice flavor was good but there was a crunch (rice was maybe over cooked / cooked inconsistently). Friends enjoyed the snapper and seafood pasta!

We came in just before kitchen close (9pm) and were seated right away. Unfortunately, it look about…read more10 minutes to get service. While slightly annoying, we were mostly just concerned that the kitchen was going to close on us. Luckily, it didn't, and when we did flag a server down she was super friendly and apologetic and the service was very attentive from there forward. They even comped us a desert for the wait! Over all the meal was delicious. My wife loves the blackened snapper and I tried the po boy this time. I think it could use a little more fish or less bread, but overall the seasoning was solid and the fish was flaky and delicious. We will be back!

Tonight we enjoyed the Commodore Cares Friday Night Fish Fry. This evening the chosen charity was…read moreThe Food Pantry of Waukesha County. $3 of each dinner was donated here, which I really appreciate. Other evenings throughout Lent will support different organizations. For $30 we enjoyed a wide-ranging buffet which included clam chowder, salad, potato pancakes, fish tenders, small red potatoes, pearl carrots, and a variety of desserts. We took our time and enjoyed each course, and also the ability to have easy conversations in a nicely quiet room. The Old Fashioned drinks were done well, and the entire evening was very nice. The fish buffet was held upstairs with a beautiful view of Nagawicka Lake. The tables are spaced apart nicely and the service was attentive. There is an elevator for those who need accessibility, as well as restrooms that are spacious for wheelchair access. There is plenty of parking.

While the location and ambiance of your restaurant remain undeniably beautiful, I regret to say…read morethat the overall experience fell far short of the standard one would expect at your price point, particularly for a dish presented as a signature item. We ordered the Beef Wellington for two, priced at $180. Unfortunately, it was one of the most disappointing renditions I have ever been served in an upscale establishment: * The beef fillet was cooked well-done throughout, with no trace of the requested (and customary) medium-rare centre. * The mushroom duxelles layer was wet and under-seasoned. * The puff pastry was completely soggy on the bottom and lacked any crispness; it essentially acted only as a vehicle to soak up excess sauce rather than providing texture and structure. * Overall presentation and execution made the dish feel more like a reheated, mass-produced item than a freshly prepared, premium offering.

My last experience here was great, I got the prime rib sandwich, and it was delicious. I'm not a…read morefan of all their dishes. So I was happy that I found what I liked. I mainly go here because it's got a great atmosphere and I like to support small businesses. The service is pretty good. They have a large parking lot. Nice place for small or large groups.

Had a large reservation here last night for a gathering, my boyfriend and i arrived last of the…read moregroup at about 6pm and there was actually no where to park! We were pretty late due to the fact that there were zero spots available. I definitely feel like this is a common theme in the restaurant industry; over booking reservations, over seating walk-in tables . Service wise, food came pretty fast! I ordered the Caprese pizza and it was okay! I also had a glass of wine that unfortunately was never offered to be refilled. The restrooms were clean and well kept! Overall I probably wont be coming back here in my free time, this place was way too busy for my taste.

Yum! My friend recommended this place and based on the reviews and pictures I was excited to try!…read moreWe had made a reservation, though when we arrived around 5:30 on a Saturday night, there were a good amount of tables available. By time we left there was a line at the door. The restaurant is intimate feeling and the low light created the perfect cozy feeling. There are good variety of table sizes for all types of groups, and outdoor seating for those warmer days and nights. Looking around as we were deciding on what to order, everything that was being delivered to tables around us, looked delicious! I ordered the Tortelloni Della campagna, an amazing mushroom filled pasta dish. Everything was so good and the perfect serving size. There are plenty of options of wine to go with your pasta dish. I am excited to come back and try more!

Nice little spot in Downtown Delavan. The restaurant is small, but cozy and the decor brought me…read moreright back to Italy! Tried the 3 for $35 weeknight special, which included an appetizer, entree and dessert. My bruschetta appetizer was fresh and loaded with plenty of tomato. Loved the pesto on top. For the entree, I went with their famous Rigatoni Bolognese, and it mostly lived up to the hype. For dessert, I had to try the creme brulee. It was carmalized nicely and the custard was delicious, but it could have benefited from some additional fruit toppings or something else to push it above ordinary. All in all, it was a fun night with friendly service and some pretty tasty classic Italian dishes.

Loved the patio & lake views - gorgeous! Our waitress was great. Very attentive & gave us lots of…read moretips & opinions. We really liked the Brussels sprout appetizer... SO GOOD. highly recommend trying that!

Great service and amazing friday fish fry. I've had their nachos before too, which were also good…read more But this is going to have to be my new fish fry spot! Cole slaw and potato pancakes were both delicious

This was our first time at Red Circle Inn and it was awesome !!! It all started and ended with our…read morewonderful server, Austin. He is one of the best we have ever had. He was very pleasant, knowledgeable and great with his attention to us. Great recommendations for drinks and wine. He paced our meal very well. The Shrimp appetizer "Special" was very good along with their house made Sauce and the French Onion soup was great, with plenty of onions and a wonderful broth.For our meals I had the "Overnight" Prime rib and it was delicious as was my wife's Salmon. The kitchen was great in their presentation and flavors. They even "split" my Cesar salad w/o being asked to, as we had told Austin we were probably going to share it.. To top off our meal we had their Schaum torte and it was the best we ever had. The meringue was perfectly done and not too hard, just practically melt in your mouth... The whole staff paid attention to the tables and dirty dishes did not stay on the table very long. It was a totally wonderful night out and we plan to return soon and of course we will request to have Austin as our server. Thank you Red Circle Inn ! ! ! Read less

First time here except for a fundraiser last year. We wanted to find out which of the previous…read morereviews was true. A Tuesday night with a 6:00pm reservation, we were greeted by a smiling young lady who made sure our visit started off right; coats stored, did we want a drink in the bar first, would we like a wine menu? All great questions. We were seated at a small table for two, which at first look seemed uncomfortable, but it was just fine. We had Old Fashioneds and were given a relish platter, which was mostly olives and a few small crackers with a spread, all very supper club traditional. We then ordered the Exotic Mushrooms, where the crispy ciabatta toast was a nice combination for this unusual appetizer. It was a big order, so we actually took some home. The House Signature Overnight Prime Rib was our choice with mashed potatoes and horseradish sauce on the side. These were done to perfection (medium rare) and a good size. My only changes would be a little less au jus with the Prime Rib. It was swimming on the plate and looked a bit overwhelming. Our server was Christine M., and to say she made our meal wonderful from start to finish is an understatement. She obviously enjoys her job and knows how to make everyone feel welcome, which goes a long way towards a great meal. As we asked questions, she gently directed us to the best options, and her knowledge and attention to detail made our choices easy. Red Circle Inn did well when they hired her. As a surprise treat, I got a birthday ice cream sundae, which was delicious! Rich ice cream with just the right amount of whipped cream, chocolate, and sprinkles on top. Thank you for this treat! After this visit, I hope to return soon. The pricing was appropriate, and we left with enough food for another meal another day. Thank you, Christine! We always appreciate being treated well by a knowledgeable and friendly server. You made our evening.

Went for their Sunday Brunch and was delighted! You can either do à la carte brunch/lunch or all…read moreyou can eat. Our table decided to do all you can eat. We got started off with fruit and bagels and lox with pastries. Then we got served the mains, eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, potatoes, and everything was so well seasoned and delicious. Then you have the option of going to the buffet for pasta, omelettes, waffles or dessert. Food was great, service was great and we had a really nice table by the window which looked out over the lake. I love the inside with all the decor, it's all so fun to look at. Will hopefully be back soon!

Mothers day Seated 40 mins late ... waited another 15 mins for coffee and water ... eggs were dried…read moreout ... lamb over done ... roast beef average ... waffles and dessert were outstanding Making a mothr wait almost an hour past reservation ... on Mothers day .. whem we were seated ... there were multiple open tables ... and most of the buffet items were average at best

My wife and I love to come here for the amazing steaks. I think they're better by far than the…read morefamous Milwaukee steak chain that start with a B. That said, stay for the dessert! The cookie and ice cream treat is truly indescribably delicious! A WOW!

Pros: -Great steaks…read more-Good ambiance -Service has always been excellent -Steaks have always been cooked correctly as ordered Cons: -Tables are packed pretty close together -Can be loud in the main dining room This is probably a 4.5 star review as opposed to a 4 star, but I rounded down based on a couple of places that are truly 5 star compared to Palmer's. Great place for a special occasion, but they don't hit it out of the ballpark every time...maybe 4 out of 5 (hence 4 stars). The food at Palmer's has always been very good. My wife and I have only ever had steak here as entrees. My go to is a med-rare ribeye and my wife always goes with a mid-well filet butterflied (I know, I know...shaking my head as I type that). They also have a really good tomato and fresh mozzarella salad that is a great starter (the balsamic is what makes it stand out). Service here is pretty spot on the majority of the time and all of the people that we have interacted with have been friendly. It can get relatively loud if you are sitting in the main dining room area, and this is where we have always been seated.

Ended up here when our fish fry place was too busy. What a gem! It's a small plate, tiny old world…read moretavern with trendy updates. Very pleased with the vibe and appreciative of the gorgeous Christmas decor that was still up. All of our food was delicious and plentiful but the stars were the spinach risotto, creamy and slightly but perfectly al dente. The beer cheese soup was tangy and delicious but the chocolate Guinness peanut butter cake!!OMG I'm still thinking about it! Background music was wonderful, service was friendly and efficient. Will definitely be back.

Menu is amazing, I'm wishing I lived closer and could try it all. I really enjoyed the Brie…read moreappetizer and the key lime pie!