Based on taste and service alone, 5 stars. But wow are the prices out of whack! When you charge more for a Sprinkles, Kara's and Gigi's cupcake for half the size, I can't get behind that no matter much of a cupcake freak I am. We split a pumpkin spice and buckeye, both of which were SO good and we discussed getting 4 to go but in the end we just couldn't justify paying that much for the size we got. If someone were to argue it's because some of them are filled which is why $3.25 and $3.50, we've paid $3 for filled cupcakes at high end cupcake boutiques in big cities for much bigger cupcakes. If they adjusted the prices, we'd be back but until they do, we've got other options. read more

The owner was not too friendly and I was visiting from out of town with nieces and nephews. They were excited to choose the cupcakes but the service wasn't so great. The cupcakes were expensive and tasted ok. The kids were happy. read more

Our CupCakery - Got an assortment. Forgot to take the picture before we all started digging in. - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Strawberry, lemon and red velvet cupcakes, oh my! No. Seriously. Oh. My. Can someone bring me a dozen, split between those 3 flavors.... right now? Thanks. Also, the make-your-own cupcake bar is adorable. A quaint addition to the already quaint Historic Dublin. read more

Today I picked up a dozen cupcakes to take home for a family dinner to help celebrate my nieces 7th birthday. When I advised my family we would all need to try each of the flavors they grabbed their own cupcakes and ran to opposite corners of the house (we never were very good at sharing). I managed to tackle most of them without breaking any skin with the fork I was waving and did get a little taste of each. Here are the results: (Cake flavor/icing flavor) Chocolate/Chocolate: You could literally smell the chocolate frosting emanating from the box before opening it. The cake was moist and flavorful and the chocolate icing was the best I have ever had. It had a lot of chocolate flavor instead of just being sugary sweet. Dark chocolate/white icing: This was better than the regular chocolate cake because it was less sweet which complemented the white icing well. Almond/vanilla: The almond flavor was strong and a little unexpected but it was delish. Red Velvet/Cream Cheese: The flavor of the cake was subtle but in my opinion better than most red velvet I have had. Red Velvet/Chocolate: perhaps I am just a purist but I don't think this combo worked. Stramberry/Vanilla: Strawberry flavor was excellent - did not taste fake at all- very fresh and subtle. One of my favorites. Lemon/Vanilla: This was by far my favorite. I love lemon to begin with so this is not a big surprise. This cupcake alone would bring me back to the cupcakery. The best part was that my niece loved trying all the different flavors and based on her reaction I am pretty sure I have a mini yelp monster in the making. After finishing the cupcakes she wrote down each flavor and rated the each with check marks and X's for different components. I met Linda the owner and it was clear she takes pride in her products and reputation. My only complaint is that I did mention I found out about the CupCakery on Yelp and she did not offer 2 free cupcakes (since I ordered 12) I was unaware of this deal until I signed on today but perhaps she just forgot? Either way, at $24 it was well worth the price for 12 gourmet cupcakes. As some of the others have stated, there is also a cute little area where you can decorate your own cupcake. This would definitely be fun for kids. Last words: I need to update my Yelp profile "Last meal" to include one of the lemon cupcakes. read more

There is a reason they have such a great reputation. Our wedding cake looked fabulous but more importantly was delicious! They were flexible when we had to postpone twice due to COVID and their pricing is competitive. They delivered and set up the cake on time and I cannot wait to order future cakes. read more

While visiting family in Dublin, OH we went to see the sights in town. This really is a lovely quaint area. And while walking around we came upon this bakery that makes great cupcakes. I had a chocolate cake with chocolate icing of course. The cupcake was very fresh and the icing was not that over sweet type. There was enough frosting on the top to go with every bite. Other places only give you a dollop. And I could have had them changed the flavor of the icing if I decided I wanted a different flavor. But the thing that really stands out is they have a make your own cupcake section for kids. I thought well who would go for this? And then an adorable little girl walked in with her parents and started making her selections from the toppings section. Then she could put which ever icing color she wanted on the cupcake (with some help from Dad) and then the toppings go on. So I'm thinking okay, but this is just small fry. And the next thing you know the teens have arrived from after school and start in making THEIR own cupcakes. I learned that they also make wonderful cakes to order. Too bad I wasn't in town long enough to try them out. This place is located right opposite Donato's pizza on the main drag. So you can have dinner and dessert. If you go please tell them the folks from Pennsylvania sent you. Oh and cupcakes are $2.00 each. I thought that was a bargain especially compared to the places here in Pennsylvania. read more

Just to tell a little story. My sons both wanted a Minecraft themed cake...not the easiest thing in the world, because you can't get those at the usual cake places. So we went to Our CupCakery, which we have used several times before. Apparently, there was some confusion about our order when we first made it. But the owner made sure to fix the problem, and she did a fantastic job with the cake. The cake looked fantastic, tasted great, and my boys were excited beyond belief. So despite the intial mistake, I give a high recommendation for this bakery. I really appreciate people that can accept something was wrong, and make sure they get it right. Two thumbs up. read more

Could not have had a better experience with this locally owned business. I found this place because of a friend and let me tell you how incredibly awesome it is! It has such charm with the old building it is in and everything you could hope for! A cute seating area and even a cupcake bar, where you can design your own! I can't wait to come here to pick up some more for my sister's wedding shower in August! read more

Our CupCakery - Chocolate cupcake with ganache filling and peanut butter icing... Heavenly! - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Really good cupcakes ... really, really, really overpriced. The place is touristy, run-down. The people inside are all nice. They have horrible hours of operations. A touristy area and they're not open at night and not on Sundays! read more

I had been wanting to go here for awhile but the opening times really cut it close coming from Columbus after work. Well I rusehd and was hoping for a good selection and they had all flavors left. I got one of each and not wanting to be piggy, I decided that a mini would be enough. I like how they only put one of each out so they stay fresh but I had to wait half an hour for them to frost 6 minis for me. A bit long but they did do a very nice job and all kinds of details on them which I was not expecting. I was however shocked how small the box was she brought out and had to open to check that all 6 were really in there. 1.75 for a mini and 2.50 for a large which still isnt really large, your average cupcake is more like their big size at 3.50 which is what they had displayed. They really are bite sized and a tiny bite at that, for me almost too small to actually judge the flavor. They were fresh and soft, the different flavors did not really come out and the frosting was neither bad nor really special. Since I was waiting I did frost a sugar cookie at the cupcake bar out of sheer boredom and wanting to see how all the frostings taste since only vanilla and chocolate is available for the ready made ones. So I tried Key lime, lemon, strawberry, caramel, peanut butter and BUBBLE GUM each on an end of the cookie and they all tasted pretty fake. Not horrible but not great, the bar really is just for kids, if I go back I would try their specialty ones with fillings to get a real taste. read more

Our CupCakery - minis from our cupcakery - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Pretty tasty! I really liked the orange creamsicle cupcake. I didn't use the cupcake bar, but I'm sure kids would be all over that! read more

See all

Cupcakes were moist. A little expensive for the size. Staff was friendly and iced cupcakes right in front of us. Nice touch. read more

Our CupCakery - Snores cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

This is a fun little cupcake joint. My husband and I wander in every time we're in downtown Dublin, because they have great flavors. Try the lemon with raspberry filling and vanilla buttercream - it's yummy! The "decorate your own cupcake" bar is great for my kids. I'm personally not a fan, because I am a purist: I like my cupcakes with just cake / filling / frosting. But the kids like to put a bunch of candy on them, so whatever makes them happy. It's a small area (maybe 6 feet long) with some frosting bags and about 10 or 15 types of candy and sprinkles. I've always had great service when I've been in. Take the time to talk to the ladies in the store - they're really interesting and very helpful. I could see how some folks might think them "snooty", but the reality is that they let their delicious cupcakes speak for themselves. They don't try to sell me extra cakes, or to push the day-old stuff on me as a "special". Everything is fresh, they take great pride in giving you a superior product, and they really do try to get you in and out quickly. I didn't give this bakery five stars because of the location and the hours. As mentioned in a few other reviews, parking and traffic is a challenge. You'll have that in the Historic District, but it really does hurt this otherwise great bakery. The other challenge, and one that bears mention from those of us that have a more-than-full-time job ... the hours. The only time that I can get in to pick up some delicious cupcakes is on Saturday, and if I have things to do with my kids, I may not make it in before they close. If they were open an evening or two a week, that would rock. Especially since Jeni's is right across the street, and is open late every night (and on Sunday) for my sweet fix. read more

A beautiful little store in downtown old Dublin right in walking distance of other great shops and places to eat in Dublin eat at mezzo grab some desert at this awesome cup cake shop filled right in front in a perfect little box. Hand stuffed with your favorite filling I had the raspberry lemon it was flavorful and fresh an awesome shop for that sweet tooth or early morning craving stop by! And see for your self read more

Our CupCakery - The inside of the building - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

I love this place they have so many options as far as flavors and cakes or cupcakes. Also they are very tasty, my daughters can't get enough. I highly recommend them!!! read more

We were so thrilled with our experience with Our Cupcakery. I can't imagine using another company for all future events! We had another vendor in mind for our wedding but they dropped off the Earth a month before the wedding. I am so thankful I stumbled upon Our Cupcakery's website! I saw all of the options and reasonable prices and they were able to set up an appointment immediately. I was so impressed by the customer service we received and it wasn't difficult to pick out our best options. We were less picky about color matching (it is over rated, pick the flavors you love and worry less about colors) but they were so great about making sure it fit what we wanted and were willing to do anything we needed. They then came and set everything up with our cake topper and a few decorations. I greatly appreciate the attention to detail. Our cake was GORGEOUS on top of the cupcake tiers. I can't thank them enough and also can't wait to use them for our other big life events!!! Side note - I see a lot of comments about the price and the size of the space. The price is NOT unreasonable when you realize the quality of product and ability to build your favorite cupcake. Yes, the building is smaller than today's standards but it is a HISTORICAL building and absolutely beautiful. Their prices are plainly posted on their website for any questions but they are some of the better prices I have seen in the city (and trust me, I do my research). read more

We used Our Cupcakery" for our wedding. We did not want a traditional cake, but instead did a cup cake tree. We got chocolate cake, cream cheese w/mini chocolate chip filling and chocolate butter cream icing. The cupcakes were *delicious* and our guests just raved about that. I would highly recommend Our Cupcakery! read more

Our CupCakery made a cake for our wedding on May 5, 2018. When my then-fiance and I had our first consultation, we not only tasted the different cake flavors and frostings, we browsed through photos of cakes the bakery had made previously. Laura was very terrific and helped us narrow down what we wanted. We wanted a simple, yet delicious cake. We selected a lemon cake with raspberry filling and vanilla buttercream frosting. We had her add small red rosettes on the cake as well for a little pop of color and elegance. The price was reasonable and we liked using a local vendor. The cake was at the reception venue as promised and was absolutely beautiful and delicious. We are looking forward to eating the free anniversary cake that was provided. We highly recommend this bakery. read more

These cupcakes are mediocre at best. Nothing against the place, and the woman who helped us out was perfectly nice, but they just aren't worth the calories. The icing is just like you'd find at a supermarket bakery, gritty with sugar and greasy. The cake is dry and the flavors are artificial tasting. We tried 6 different flavors, so this review isn't based on just one cupcake. If you want the best cake in Columbus go to The Suisse Shop and try the vanilla cake with buttercream icing! It's amazing! read more

Great baked goods!!! Just took a cake pop class and the instructor was phenomenal! Showed us step by step how to make them, gave us some tips and tricks. Tons of choices for dipping and sprinkles. Had a great time. Can't wait for the parent child class on May! read more

Our CupCakery - Bakeries Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

So I was very excited to take my son here for his birthday. He LOVES cupcakes.. So, I take him in to pick out his cupcake and the woman who came to the counter was kinda rude. " What do you want".. I responded " Well, today is my sons 4th birthday and he would like to pick out a cupcake" Her response " OK, well.. which one does he want?" Not the response I was looking for but at that point I just wanted to get his cupcake. He picked out strawberry and I got a red velvet. We went into the other room they have on the side to enjoy the cupcakes. Disappointing to say the LEAST! they were dry and had almost no real flavor.. I expected more for how much $$ they are Overall I was very underwhelmed. I could have went to Kroger bakery and probably got better service and better cupcakes at a cheaper price.. **This is my 2nd attempt here. I got my husband's 30th birthday cake here before. It was NOT what I asked for decoration wise but it was too late to change so i let it go. but they charged $90 for a 10' round! All they did was use blue frosting and a #30 on top.. SO overpriced and totally not worth it.. I tried to give them the benefit of the doubt and go again for my son's birthday cupcake.. Use you $$$ elsewhere. read more

Ok first things first the cupcakes were very good but not 20 dollars for eight good. Decent service but not outstanding. Very tight space wise. I would go again but not before I check out a few of the other local cup cakeries read more

When my boyfriend got a new job over the summer, I wanted to do something special for him. We found out in the mid-afternoon, but I thought I would call around to some bakeries to see what they could do figuring it would be really too short of notice to get any custom work done. I called Our CupCakery, and they were extremely helpful and great to work with. Not only did they do a small, custom special order for me (3 cupcakes with the flavors and colors I asked for, and lettering and a logo too), but they did it in about 3 hours AND stayed open a little later for me to come pick my cupcakes up after work! Great prices too (all of that for only $9!) Thanks so much! Plus, they are right across the street from Jeni's, so I was able to drop by and pick up my boyfriend's favorite ice cream as well! (not that that has to do with the review, but it was pretty convenient!) read more

Quality, quality, quality! The exact word that comes to mind when I think about this gem of a bakery. Not only did the cake I ordered turn out beautiful, but the service I received when going in was a treat! Linda was so helpful with figuring out the exact style I wanted for the cake and made it happen. Not only did the finished product look stunning, but it tasted heavenly as well! Wonderful staff, amazing baked goods..not much more you can ask from such a charming little bakery. I will absolutely recommend this place, as well as patronize it whenever I need a beautiful & quality dessert made again. Love it! read more

New to the area and tried our cupcakery for the first time today. Fantastic cupcake selection and competitively priced! The cookies and cream one is amazing. And the triple chocolate filled cupcake is probably the best cupcake I've ever had! The icing is to die for. Oh and the service was excellent. The young lady working explained their entire menu to me upon learning I was new to the shop. Great local business! read more

We had a hard time finding parking and ended up walking about a block to get there. Not really that big of a deal. Went in and the lady behind the counter was a little on the snooty side. Kind of made me, my fiancee, and my friend feel not welcome. We got 4 cupcakes to try. We were tasting them as a prospective wedding cake flavor. As wedding cake flavors they were lacking. As regular cupcakes they were decent. Not worth the $4 each but decent. read more

They probably taste delicious, but I was underwhelmed by the finished product. When you spend $18 for 6 cupcakes, they should LOOK SPECIAL... again they probably taste good, but to me, presentation is everything. I wanted thick frosting and cute sprinkles, but it looks like I could have done the decorating myself. Next time I will plan ahead and go with the place next to my home where they taste and LOOK great! For $18 it really does have to be both. Sorry Cupcakery, but I will pass. read more

Great cupcakes! Moist cake, a little too much icing, exactly what you want in a cupcake (says the chubby girl). I needed a box of pretty confections to take to a party. They were a hit. read more

I do not recommend this bakery as the owner has shown a complete lack of responsibility and regard to customer service. Long story short - they blew the surprise for our gender reveal party by telling me what color the cake would be after repeatedly reminding them to not mention it to me. After the error they didn't feel it required anything more than a $5 discount to correct. I ordered a small 8" cake for our Gender Reveal party. I discussed the specifics with Linda, the owner. From the start I felt that she had a condescending attitude and was not altogether pleasant to correspond with, however I proceeded. I had specifically stated to her on the phone and email, "I do NOT know the gender so please do not include any info of that in emails, on receipt, or outside of box or outside of cake." The fact that I did NOT know the gender ahead of time was also reiterated when I put Linda on the phone with my doctors office, who privately told her what the gender was, so it was to remain a surprise for me and the rest of the party. When confirming the details via email, Linda responded back with: "Here is your new total. You requested pink for the batter color." In shock, I responded that I hope she meant "pink OR blue". I expressed my frustration as the gender had been revealed to me by what was confirmed as the cake color. To be paying a premium for something so special and have that moment of revelation and joy be taken away is extremely disappointing. I​ said I hoped​ we c​ould​ come to a resolution​ and that this ha​d​ become a very frustrating experience. I told Linda that ​I ​hoped to avoid conflict and disappointment​, and asked for reassurance that there would be resolution ​in terms of customer satisfaction and me ultimately feeling ​​more positive about the situation. ​Linda's response was: "​Our daughter recently learned the gender of her baby when the technician referred to "her" during the ultrasound appointment. We know how special that information is and wouldn't intentionally impact the surprise but sometimes mistakes happen. We make many gender reveal desserts. I'm sorry if information may have inadvertently been communicated to you in one of our many emails. Our goal is make the best possible desserts as possible but sometimes we do make human errors. We'd like to offer you the colored batter fee for free." I thought that attempting to minimize the situation by comparing this to her daughter was a poor attempt at an excuse. Considering her family had a similar experience, I would have thought that Linda's reaction to making this mistake herself would have been a little more regretful than "mistakes happen". I completely understand that this was human error and not intentional. However, the the total for this cake was $50.50, and the charge for the colored batter was $5. The resolution that she offered for this mistake was $5 off a $50 cake and a half-hearted apology that sounded like a dismissive excuse. This is completely unacceptable. Luckily, Linda had not taken the 50% nonrefundable deposit yet so I was able to cancel the order. I am not one to believe that the customer is always right in every situation. However, if this was my business, I would have gone above and beyond to make sure that the customer walked away as happy as possible. Instead, Linda let me walk out the door, with the gender reveal surprise ruined. Had her reaction been one of genuine apology and regret, and an offer of a more substantial discount than $5 off, I would have been able to look past the mistake. I ended up ordering a cake from Market District for $18.95. I had a great customer service experience, saved money, and was not charged a non-refundable deposit to place the order. I wish I would have gone to them in the first place and had the experience that I expected. Linda's response and reaction was irresponsible and unprofessional, and I would not recommend anyone to give their business to this (over-priced) bakery. read more

Adorable little shop in the middle of old Dublin. As I entered the shop it smelled so heavenly. Warm and welcoming feeling. Had the cutest little cupcake display and many cupcakes to choose from. The cupcakes tasted delicious! Especially the s'more cupcakes! Savored every bite! :) staff is friendly. And the location of the place is perfect for a little stroll outside. Overall I loved it and will be coming back!:) read more

I agree with the commnet about the Orange Dreamcycle. It's awesome. I visted the very cute store and the staff was super friendly. Their vanilla butter cream icing is to dye for!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

The staff was very friendly and not pushy- the cupcakes were delicious and the icing was amazing. I will definitely be back!

Love love love Our Cupcakery. Their cakes/cupcakes are amazing! The people are so friendly and easy to work with. I have used them for a number of events for over 6 years and have never once been disappointed. The build your own cupcake bar may seem a bit pricey; but when you look at all of the ingredients you just used, the price makes perfect sense. My friends and I have started getting the cherry chip cake for each other for all of our birthdays - it is soooooooo good. Parking leaves something to be desired; but, that's just the trouble with that particular area. read more

Yum! They did our wedding cake, which was AMAZING. We had 130 guests, an open bar, a buffet, and 150 slices of cake and NONE left over. Everyone raved about our cake. Since then, it's our go-to staple if we ever need cake or cupcakes. Everything is simply delicious. The cake/cupcakes always have such an amazing flavor with so many options and always so fresh and moist. I may pay a bit more, but it's worth every penny. I won't go anywhere else now! read more

Our Cupcakery has never, ever disappointed. After the tough task of sampling bakeries the area, I think it has the best cupcakes in Columbus. Linda, the owner, is wonderful and so helpful. Always a pleasure. She made the cupcakes for our wedding, and people are still raving about them. The cupcakes are delicious and moist and the icing is smooth, never too sweet. I love all the flavors, but highly recommend the red velvet, almond and chocolate. You can't go wrong! read more

From the first bite I knew this was everything I want in a cupcake---moist and flavorful! It's as simple as that! The store itself is playful and welcoming. The staff is friendly and helpful. They were also very informative about how to store the cupcakes while traveling. We ordered a mixed selection of the regular sized cupcakes. Some with fillings and some without. I'm a sucker for red velvet so it was definitely my favorite. But all the cakes were a delight! read more

From the cupcake tasting to the day-of wedding cupcakes - Our Cupcakery was such a breeze to work with and everyone commented on how yummy the cupcakes were. My mom ordered a dozen extra just so she could take them home to enjoy for the days following our wedding. The wedding cake design was simple but they made my vision come true and everything was truly amazing. We will be coming back for more! read more

So I went back this place, since I loved it soooo much! I placed an order on the phone for the bite size platter, and then when I went there at the time they told me to show up, they claimed to say we never called, I told them the entire conversation, and they still said they can not find the order. So they said they can do another order but it wont be ready for another 3 hours, plus since they can't find the order, they will charge 5 dollars more since the order is placed less then 48 hours, ( mind you, I called 48 hours before to place the order in the first place). then after coming there they said oooo we found your order?!?!??! what the heck. then after all that trouble they only just refunded the five dollars, which I shouldn't have paid in the first place. then I understood the platter would be mix of mini-cupcakes, and some other treats... but I didn't think it would be that few of cupcakes, plus they put some candy in there that you can buy from anywhere! Don't get me wrong, their cupcakes are still super delicious, but I thought the service was bad. I mean you would think they would be a tad more apologetic, and at least give us a free cupcake, or something, when they realized they made the mistake. I am really sad with this experience! I would say, the cupcakes are still fantastic, but I don't think I will be placing an advanced order again with them. read more

We have made a point of coming to this bakery to support local businesses and because of their vegan offerings. Like others, we also think the cupcake are overpriced but were willing to deal with that to be able to offer our son with an egg allergy the same treats as the other kids. After our last visit, we will not be returning - after explaining multiple times and making a special order due to the allergy, one of the cupcakes had icing that included egg (which we only discovered after his reaction and our subsequent follow-up). We just cannot trust that this would not re-occur in the future. read more

The most thoughtful Christmas gift Ihave ever received came from Our CupCakery. My fiancée took the recipe for my favorite cookie/cake/petifours,( really there is no way to categorize this delicious confection) and had them especially made for me. The recipe takes about ten hours if you attempt to make them at home! Our CupCakery made them in time for Christmas and the first bite brought me right back to my childhood, they tasted just as I remembered and hoped they would, layers of cake soaked and flavored with almond and apricot encased in a delicious layer of fine chocolate. So, if you are looking for a sweet treat that you can't seem find in any bakery or food store have them custom made and you wont be disappointed. Our CupCakery knows how to bake! read more